Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Clarification of the great ensemble

Edward H. Kerner

Published Oct 1, 1981• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The argument advanced by Farquhar purporting that the author's recently introduced great ensemble (which generalizes the usual grand ensemble to allow for uncertain speciation of particles) is only a derivative of the grand ensemble, is shown not to hold upon a more precise explication of the great ensemble, in particular, a clarification of a misleading example I had mentioned. The great ensemble then remains a novel ensemble, not obtainable from any grand ensemble, for describing systems with appreciable but uncertain speciation.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.24.2244

Related papers

Comment on “Typicality for Generalized Microcanonical Ensembles”

Dorje C. Brody

The validity of the so-called "typicality" argument for a generalised microcanonical ensemble proposed recently is examined.

arXiv:0803.1981•Physical Review Letters•Apr 10, 2008•4 citations

Coherent States in Superfluids: The Ideal Einstein-Bose Gas

James R. Johnston

It is argued that the grand canonical ensemble is not appropriate for describing local properties of a closed system when the system has off-diagonal long-range order over distances of the order of the dimensions of the system (e.g., when there is a condensation into a single-particle state). It is shown that the local dispersion in number in the condensed part of an ideal Einstein-Bose gas is “small” (appropriate to a Poisson distribution), contrary to the usual result obtained using the grand canonical ensemble. This leads to an approximation in which the condensed part of the system is represented locally by a coherent state. It is further argued that these considerations serve as a rationale for breaking gauge symmetry whereas the usual arguments (based on analogy with ferromagnetism) are not appropriate.

American Journal of Physics•Apr 1, 1970•17 citations

Some Consequences of a recent Approach towards Quantum Foundations

Inge Svein Helland

A recent approach towards the foundation of quantum mechanics is described in some detail. This requires some mathematics, but it is claimed that this approach is easier to understand than the usual formal quantum foundation. Several consequences of the theory are described, consequences that for example also lead to a simpler and deeper understanding of Quantum Decision Theory, which has bearings both on our daily decisions and on the decisions made by political leaders. Another consequence is in the form of arguments for the existence of God, a God that is perfectly rational and has infinite knowledge. To understand these consequences, it is not necessary to understand all the mathematics, but simply to appreciate the fact that the theory is derived from 6 postulates, postulates that can be interpreted in several different directions. Two of these postulates, when interpreted in a very general setting, form the basis for my theological arguments. Finally, it is a hope that by reading this article, and then further discussing the mentioned consequences with other people, one may contribute to a better understanding between groups of people, groups that partly may have their basis in different cultures. These cultures may be of many kinds, also based upon different scientific communities. Or upon different religious groups.

Dialogo•Jun 20, 2025•0 citations

A new approach for the justification of ensembles in quantum statistical mechanics ? II

Joel Keizer

Journal of Statistical Physics•Jan 1, 1970•0 citations

A general scheme for ensemble purification

Angelo Bassi, Giancarlo Ghirardi

We exhibit a general procedure to purify any given ensemble by identifying an appropriate interaction between the physical system S of the ensemble and the reference system K. We show that the interaction can be chosen in such a way to lead to a spatial separation of the pair S-K. As a consequence, one can use it to prepare at a distance different equivalent ensembles. The argument associates a physically precise procedure to the purely formal and fictitious process usually considered in the literature. We conclude with an illuminating example taken from quantum computational theory.

•Jun 26, 2002•10 citations

A new approach for the justification of ensembles in quantum statistical mechanics ? I

Joel Keizer

Journal of Statistical Physics•Jan 1, 1970•1 citation
The argument advanced by Farquhar purporting that the author's recently introduced great ensemble (which generalizes the usual grand ensemble to allow for uncertain speciation of particles) is only a derivative of the grand ensemble, is shown not to hold upon a more precise explication of the great ensemble, in particular, a clarification of a misleading example I had mentioned. The great ensemble then remains a novel ensemble, not obtainable from any grand ensemble, for describing systems with appreciable but uncertain speciation.
It is argued that the grand canonical ensemble is not appropriate for describing local properties of a closed system when the system has off-diagonal long-range order over distances of the order of the dimensions of the system (e.g., when there is a condensation into a single-particle state). It is shown that the local dispersion in number in the condensed part of an ideal Einstein-Bose gas is “small” (appropriate to a Poisson distribution), contrary to the usual result obtained using the grand canonical ensemble. This leads to an approximation in which the condensed part of the system is represented locally by a coherent state. It is further argued that these considerations serve as a rationale for breaking gauge symmetry whereas the usual arguments (based on analogy with ferromagnetism) are not appropriate.
A recent approach towards the foundation of quantum mechanics is described in some detail. This requires some mathematics, but it is claimed that this approach is easier to understand than the usual formal quantum foundation. Several consequences of the theory are described, consequences that for example also lead to a simpler and deeper understanding of Quantum Decision Theory, which has bearings both on our daily decisions and on the decisions made by political leaders. Another consequence is in the form of arguments for the existence of God, a God that is perfectly rational and has infinite knowledge. To understand these consequences, it is not necessary to understand all the mathematics, but simply to appreciate the fact that the theory is derived from 6 postulates, postulates that can be interpreted in several different directions. Two of these postulates, when interpreted in a very general setting, form the basis for my theological arguments. Finally, it is a hope that by reading this article, and then further discussing the mentioned consequences with other people, one may contribute to a better understanding between groups of people, groups that partly may have their basis in different cultures. These cultures may be of many kinds, also based upon different scientific communities. Or upon different religious groups.
We exhibit a general procedure to purify any given ensemble by identifying an appropriate interaction between the physical system S of the ensemble and the reference system K. We show that the interaction can be chosen in such a way to lead to a spatial separation of the pair S-K. As a consequence, one can use it to prepare at a distance different equivalent ensembles. The argument associates a physically precise procedure to the purely formal and fictitious process usually considered in the literature. We conclude with an illuminating example taken from quantum computational theory.