Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Traversal-Time Distribution and the Uncertainty Principle in Quantum Tunneling

H. A. Fertig

Published Nov 5, 1990• 118 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We derive the exact distribution of times spent in the classically forbidden region by a particle as it tunnels through a square barrier potential. We find that the integrated distribution has a simple interpretation. If one restricts the time spent in the barrier to be \ensuremath{\leqslant}\ensuremath{\tau}, then an effective uncertainty \ensuremath{\Delta}V is introduced in the barrier height, such that\ensuremath{\Delta}V\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremath{\simeq}1. This uncertainty leads to unusual interference effects in the distribution. These interference effects explain why the average speed of a particle traversing a very opaque barrier may exceed the speed of light. \textcopyright{} 1990 The American Physical Society

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.65.2321

Related papers

Path decomposition and the traversal-time distribution in quantum tunneling

H. A. Fertig

We define, using a path-integral method, an amplitude distribution for the traversal time of a particle tunneling through a barrier. We calculate this without approximation for the case of a square barrier potential. The form of the integrated distribution is shown to be determined by the uncertainty principle: if the particle is known to spend a time \ensuremath{\le}\ensuremath{\tau} inside the barrier, then an effective uncertainty \ensuremath{\Delta}V is introduced in the barrier height, such that \ensuremath{\Delta}V\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremath{\approxeq}\ensuremath{\Elzxh}. The distribution has a number of interesting properties: it is noisy at very short times, oscillates periodically at intermediate times, and saturates to a constant at long times. The first two properties arise as a result of resonances in the transmission amplitude, which play an important role in the distribution. The characteristic (median) time scale for the distribution is shown to be ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\tau}}}_{\mathit{Q}}$=2${\mathit{md}}^{2}$/\ensuremath{\Elzxh}. We show that this represents the average traversal time for particle energies that are close to the energy of the barrier height. For very opaque barriers, the oscillations have a very short period. We show that this can lead to anomalously short average traversal times, and resolves the outstanding problem that the average velocity of a tunneling particle may exceed the speed of light. For particles with energies above the height of the barrier (classical traversal), we find that the real part of the distribution is dominated by the classical path, and has a sharp peak around the classical traversal time. It is argued that the form of the distribution found in this work may be applied to general barrier shapes.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 15, 1993•32 citations

Path-Integral Resolution of the Tunneling-Time Controversy

Henrique Coelho Barbosa

The time a quantum particle spends traversing a classically forbidden region has resisted un-ambiguous definition since the earliest analyses of wave-packet tunneling, and the proliferation ofmutually incompatible “clocks”—the Wigner phase time, the Büttiker–Landauer traversal time, theLarmor time, and the path-integral complex time among them—has kept the question open fordecades. The controversy has been sharpened, not settled, by the advent of attosecond angular-streaking metrology, in which competing analyses of tunnel ionization continue to disagree over theexistence of a finite delay. Here we show that these rival definitions are not alternative answersto a single question but distinct cumulants of one traversal-time quasi-distribution, generated bythe exact rectangular-barrier transmission amplitude when the latter is promoted to a cumulantgenerating functional through a barrier-height counting field. The first cumulant unifies the Wignerphase time and the Larmor/Büttiker–Landauer time as the real and imaginary parts of a singlecomplex traversal time, recovering the celebrated Hartman saturation as the width-independentvalue ℏ/V0 of its real part. The second cumulant—which, to our knowledge, has not previouslybeen enlisted as a tunneling-time observable—yields a traversal-time variance that entirely evadesthe Hartman saturation and instead grows linearly with the barrier width d. The standard devia-tion of the tunneling time therefore scales as στ ∝ √d: rather than becoming superluminally sharpfor thick barriers, the tunneling time grows progressively more uncertain, in direct opposition tothe naive superluminal reading of the Hartman effect. This parameter-free scaling, independentof the O(1) coefficient that fixes its magnitude, constitutes a falsifiable prediction: attosecond an-gular streaking, which resolves the full arrival-time distribution of tunneled electrons rather thanmerely its centroid, should register a temporal spread broadening as √d even where the mean delaysaturates. We thereby recast a nearly century-old semantic dispute as a concrete experimentalquestion.

•Jul 7, 2026•0 citations

Quantum tunneling time: Insights from an exactly solvable model

Seyedmohammad Yusofsani, M. Kolesík

Quantum particles interacting with potential barriers are ubiquitous in physics, and the question of how much time they spend inside classically forbidden regions has attracted interest for many decades. Recent developments of new experimental techniques revived the issue and ignited a debate with often contradictory results. This motivates the present study of an exactly solvable model for quantum tunneling induced by a strong field. We show that the tunneling dynamics can depart significantly from the scenario in which the barrier-traversal time is zero or very small. However, our findings do not support the idea of a well-defined tunneling time either. Our numerically exact results should help in finding a consensus about this fundamental problem.

arXiv:2107.01737•Physical Review A•May 27, 2020•19 citations

Quantum interference and determination of the traversal time

D. Sokolovski, J. N. L. Connor

The tunneling-time problem is shown to be analogous to the interpretation of the two-slit interference experiment. A measurement assuming an arbitrarily small interaction between a particle and a clock is shown to contradict the uncertainty principle and leads to complex times. A real non-negative traversal time is obtained in a measurement which selects Feynman paths that spend in the barrier a known amount of time; this, however, strongly perturbs the tunneling. The Larmor clock demonstrates both types of behavior.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1993•77 citations

Semiclassical traversal time analysis of superluminal tunneling

D. Sokolovski, Y. Liu

In the limit $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\ensuremath{\Elzxh}}0,$ a tunneling particle can be shown to follow classical trajectories which experience in the classically forbidden region a deep well rather than a potential barrier and, therefore, spend a very small amount of time there. Such trajectories interfere destructively. While the tunneling rate is small, the tunneling itself is very fast.

Physical Review A•Dec 12, 2000•9 citations

ON THE PATH INTEGRAL APPROACH TO THE TUNNELING TIME

Thierry Martin

The path integral formulation of the traversal time in tunneling utilizes a restricted Feynman amplitude. We present a derivation based on the Fisher Lee formula to compute the average time and the integrated distribution for arbitrary potentials. The (complex) tunneling time can be expressed as a derivative with respect to a potential which surrounds the region over which the particle is “detected”, and a correspondence with other tunneling time scales which depend on energy derivatives of the transmission coefficient is found. A semiclassical treatment confirms that there are two time scales associated with this measurement procedure. The imaginary component is related to the multiple instanton bounces in the inverted potential. The issue of positive times is found to depend crucially on the behavior of the transmission coefficient for asymptotic limits of the measurement potential. The calculation of higher moments of the distribution allows to define a positive barrier interaction time, without appealing to any regularization procedure.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Dec 15, 1996•10 citations
We derive the exact distribution of times spent in the classically forbidden region by a particle as it tunnels through a square barrier potential. We find that the integrated distribution has a simple interpretation. If one restricts the time spent in the barrier to be \ensuremath{\leqslant}\ensuremath{\tau}, then an effective uncertainty \ensuremath{\Delta}V is introduced in the barrier height, such that\ensuremath{\Delta}V\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremath{\simeq}1. This uncertainty leads to unusual interference effects in the distribution. These interference effects explain why the average speed of a particle traversing a very opaque barrier may exceed the speed of light. \textcopyright{} 1990 The American Physical Society
We define, using a path-integral method, an amplitude distribution for the traversal time of a particle tunneling through a barrier. We calculate this without approximation for the case of a square barrier potential. The form of the integrated distribution is shown to be determined by the uncertainty principle: if the particle is known to spend a time \ensuremath{\le}\ensuremath{\tau} inside the barrier, then an effective uncertainty \ensuremath{\Delta}V is introduced in the barrier height, such that \ensuremath{\Delta}V\ensuremath{\tau}\ensuremath{\approxeq}\ensuremath{\Elzxh}. The distribution has a number of interesting properties: it is noisy at very short times, oscillates periodically at intermediate times, and saturates to a constant at long times. The first two properties arise as a result of resonances in the transmission amplitude, which play an important role in the distribution. The characteristic (median) time scale for the distribution is shown to be ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\tau}}}_{\mathit{Q}}$=2md2{\mathit{md}}^{2}md2/\ensuremath{\Elzxh}. We show that this represents the average traversal time for particle energies that are close to the energy of the barrier height. For very opaque barriers, the oscillations have a very short period. We show that this can lead to anomalously short average traversal times, and resolves the outstanding problem that the average velocity of a tunneling particle may exceed the speed of light. For particles with energies above the height of the barrier (classical traversal), we find that the real part of the distribution is dominated by the classical path, and has a sharp peak around the classical traversal time. It is argued that the form of the distribution found in this work may be applied to general barrier shapes.
The time a quantum particle spends traversing a classically forbidden region has resisted un-ambiguous definition since the earliest analyses of wave-packet tunneling, and the proliferation ofmutually incompatible “clocks”—the Wigner phase time, the Büttiker–Landauer traversal time, theLarmor time, and the path-integral complex time among them—has kept the question open fordecades. The controversy has been sharpened, not settled, by the advent of attosecond angular-streaking metrology, in which competing analyses of tunnel ionization continue to disagree over theexistence of a finite delay. Here we show that these rival definitions are not alternative answersto a single question but distinct cumulants of one traversal-time quasi-distribution, generated bythe exact rectangular-barrier transmission amplitude when the latter is promoted to a cumulantgenerating functional through a barrier-height counting field. The first cumulant unifies the Wignerphase time and the Larmor/Büttiker–Landauer time as the real and imaginary parts of a singlecomplex traversal time, recovering the celebrated Hartman saturation as the width-independentvalue ℏ/V0 of its real part. The second cumulant—which, to our knowledge, has not previouslybeen enlisted as a tunneling-time observable—yields a traversal-time variance that entirely evadesthe Hartman saturation and instead grows linearly with the barrier width d. The standard devia-tion of the tunneling time therefore scales as στ ∝ √d: rather than becoming superluminally sharpfor thick barriers, the tunneling time grows progressively more uncertain, in direct opposition tothe naive superluminal reading of the Hartman effect. This parameter-free scaling, independentof the O(1) coefficient that fixes its magnitude, constitutes a falsifiable prediction: attosecond an-gular streaking, which resolves the full arrival-time distribution of tunneled electrons rather thanmerely its centroid, should register a temporal spread broadening as √d even where the mean delaysaturates. We thereby recast a nearly century-old semantic dispute as a concrete experimentalquestion.
Quantum particles interacting with potential barriers are ubiquitous in physics, and the question of how much time they spend inside classically forbidden regions has attracted interest for many decades. Recent developments of new experimental techniques revived the issue and ignited a debate with often contradictory results. This motivates the present study of an exactly solvable model for quantum tunneling induced by a strong field. We show that the tunneling dynamics can depart significantly from the scenario in which the barrier-traversal time is zero or very small. However, our findings do not support the idea of a well-defined tunneling time either. Our numerically exact results should help in finding a consensus about this fundamental problem.
The tunneling-time problem is shown to be analogous to the interpretation of the two-slit interference experiment. A measurement assuming an arbitrarily small interaction between a particle and a clock is shown to contradict the uncertainty principle and leads to complex times. A real non-negative traversal time is obtained in a measurement which selects Feynman paths that spend in the barrier a known amount of time; this, however, strongly perturbs the tunneling. The Larmor clock demonstrates both types of behavior.
The path integral formulation of the traversal time in tunneling utilizes a restricted Feynman amplitude. We present a derivation based on the Fisher Lee formula to compute the average time and the integrated distribution for arbitrary potentials. The (complex) tunneling time can be expressed as a derivative with respect to a potential which surrounds the region over which the particle is “detected”, and a correspondence with other tunneling time scales which depend on energy derivatives of the transmission coefficient is found. A semiclassical treatment confirms that there are two time scales associated with this measurement procedure. The imaginary component is related to the multiple instanton bounces in the inverted potential. The issue of positive times is found to depend crucially on the behavior of the transmission coefficient for asymptotic limits of the measurement potential. The calculation of higher moments of the distribution allows to define a positive barrier interaction time, without appealing to any regularization procedure.