Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Systematic comparison of the quantization rules of hydrogenoid atoms in the Old Quantum, Schrödinger, Klein–Gordon, and Dirac theories, by means of a common set of three parameters

A. A. Levy

Published May 1, 1985• 8 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A set of three parameters λ, β, and δ related to energy E and angular momentum L were used to make the closest possible formal comparison between the five successive theories of the quantization of the energy levels of the hydrogenoid atoms. The expression of the quantization rules was made uniform and the differences between the theories were reduced to simple redefinitions of the parameters.

DOI
10.1119/1.14199

Related papers

Addendum to ‘‘Systematic comparison of the quantization rules of hydrogenoid atoms in the old quantum, Schrödinger, Klein–Gordon, and Dirac theories, by means of a common set of three parameters’’

A. A. Levy

American Journal of Physics•Jul 1, 1986•0 citations

Schrödinger Treatment of Hydrogen Atom

Dae Mann Kim

This chapter presents the quantum treatment of the hydrogen atom. The H-atom is the simplest atomic system, but the theory of H-atom contains the central core of quantum mechanics. Bohr's H-atom theory was the culmination of the old quantum theory, and the Schrödinger treatment of the H-atom demonstrated the versatility of his wave equation. Moreover, the theory is used as the general background for treating the multi-electron atoms and molecules. The topics included for discussion in this chapter are angular momentum, spherical harmonics, spatial quantization, atomic orbital, electron-proton interaction, quantized energy level and atomic spectroscopy, Doppler broadening, and so on. The angular momentum is a key ingredient of quantum mechanics.

Wiley eBooks•Feb 6, 2015•0 citations

Comments on Good’s proposal for new rules of quantization

Miguel Navarro

In a recent paper [J. Math. Phys. 35, 3333 (1994)] Good postulated new rules of quantization, one of the major features of which is that the quantum evolution of the wave function is always given by ordinary differential equations. In this paper we analyze the proposal in some detail and discuss its viability and its relationship with the standard quantum theory. As a byproduct, a simple derivation of the ‘‘mass spectrum’’ for the Klein–Gordon field is presented, but it is also shown that there is a complete additional spectrum of negative ‘‘masses.’’ Finally, two major reasons are presented against the viability of this alternative proposal: (a) It does not lead to the correct energy spectrum for the hydrogen atom. (b) For field models, the standard quantum theory cannot be recovered from this alternative description.

arXiv:hep-th/9503068•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 1995•8 citations

Guiding Principles

Anthony Duncan A, Michel Janssen B

Abstract The development of the complex of assumptions and methods now referred to as the “old quantum theory” mainly took place in the first five years following the introduction of the Bohr atomic model in 1913. Three guiding principles emerged that were used, sometimes in overlapping ways, to explain the flood of spectroscopic data that needed to be explained. First, quantization rules (or conditions) were proposed to single out the allowed orbital motions of electrons in atoms. These rules were derived in various forms by Planck, Sommerfeld, and Wilson, but were put into their most general form by Schwarzschild, who recognized the underlying principle as the quantization of the action variables of a multiply periodic classical system. Second, the special role of the action variables in quantization was given convincing support by the transfer of the adiabatic principle of mechanics to quantum theory (work primarily due to Paul Ehrenfest). Third, the correspondence principle, or statement of asymptotic coincidence of quantum and classical theory in the limit of large quantum numbers, originally introduced by Bohr in 1913 as a supporting argument for his quantization of angular momentum in his theory of the hydrogen atom, was extended by Bohr and Kramers to provide selection rules and approximate intensity predictions evening the regime low quantum numbers.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Aug 29, 2019•1 citation

Hydrogen and Hydrogenic Ions

Christopher W. Churchill

The energy structures and transition energies of single-electron atoms and ions are presented. Five Nobel Prizes in Physics were awarded for the theories discussed in this chapter. We first review the Bohr model, which was based on quantized angular momentum and classical circular orbits. The wave model of Schrödinger followed, in which spherical boundary conditions quantized polar and azimuthal standing waves. The energies were identical to Bohr’s, but transition selection rules dictated the change in angular momentum of the system during absorption and emission. Dirac incorporated electron spin and relativistic energies, resulting in energy shifts and fine structure splitting of the energy levels for non-zero angular momentum states. Feynman and Swinger incorporated quantization of the electric vector potential. This physics broke energy degeneracies in the Dirac model and correctly predicted the famous Lamb shift. In this chapter, each of these models are described in detail. The final full characterization of the energy levels and transitions are presented. The chapter ends with a discussion on isotope shifting and transitions to the continuum (ionization/recombination).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Dec 17, 2025•0 citations

The Bohr-Maxwell Description of the Hydrogen L-to-K Transition

Daniel Scretching

This paper develops and verifies a physics-first description of the hydrogen-atom transition from the L shell (n = 2) to the K shell (n = 1) by combining the historical Bohr model of atomic structure with classical Maxwell electrodynamics. Beginning with the Coulomb force, centripetal dynamics, and Bohr’s angular-momentum quantization condition, the analysis derives the allowed orbital radii, electron velocities, angular momenta, kinetic energies, electrostatic potential energies, and total bound-state energies of the hydrogen atom. For the n = 2 → n = 1 transition, the calculated energy difference is approximately 10.2 eV, corresponding through the Planck–Einstein relation ΔE = hν to a frequency of approximately 2.47 × 10¹⁵ Hz and a wavelength near 121.6 nm, consistent with the hydrogen Lyman-α transition. The emitted radiation is then examined through Maxwell’s equations and the vacuum constitutive relations. The resulting electromagnetic-wave description yields the transverse electric and magnetic fields together with the associated electromagnetic energy density, Poynting energy flux, momentum density, radiation pressure, and Maxwell stress tensor. In this way, the atomic energy difference obtained from the Bohr model is connected quantitatively to the classical propagation properties of the outgoing electromagnetic radiation. The derivation is mathematically consistent as a historical Bohr–Maxwell reconstruction, but it does not constitute a closed dynamical theory of spontaneous emission. The essential bridge between discrete atomic energy levels and the continuous Maxwell field is supplied by the quantum frequency condition ΔE = hν. Neither classical Maxwell electrodynamics nor Newtonian orbital mechanics independently derives this relation, and classical Maxwell theory does not by itself quantize the emitted radiation energy into individual photons. A complete treatment of spontaneous emission, transition probabilities, radiative lifetimes, and photon-field quantization requires quantum mechanics and ultimately quantum electrodynamics. Accordingly, the framework is presented as a verified correspondence between established limiting descriptions rather than as a replacement for Schrödinger wave mechanics, Dirac theory, or quantum electrodynamics. By clearly separating the atomic bound-state calculation, the quantum energy-frequency bridge, and the classical electromagnetic propagation problem, the analysis provides a rigorous conceptual and mathematical foundation for subsequent Maxwell–Schrödinger, Dirac–Maxwell, quantum-electrodynamic, Maxwell–Scretching, and Scretching Quantum Chain formulations of hydrogenic radiative transitions.

•Jul 16, 2026•0 citations
A set of three parameters λ, β, and δ related to energy E and angular momentum L were used to make the closest possible formal comparison between the five successive theories of the quantization of the energy levels of the hydrogenoid atoms. The expression of the quantization rules was made uniform and the differences between the theories were reduced to simple redefinitions of the parameters.
This chapter presents the quantum treatment of the hydrogen atom. The H-atom is the simplest atomic system, but the theory of H-atom contains the central core of quantum mechanics. Bohr's H-atom theory was the culmination of the old quantum theory, and the Schrödinger treatment of the H-atom demonstrated the versatility of his wave equation. Moreover, the theory is used as the general background for treating the multi-electron atoms and molecules. The topics included for discussion in this chapter are angular momentum, spherical harmonics, spatial quantization, atomic orbital, electron-proton interaction, quantized energy level and atomic spectroscopy, Doppler broadening, and so on. The angular momentum is a key ingredient of quantum mechanics.
In a recent paper [J. Math. Phys. 35, 3333 (1994)] Good postulated new rules of quantization, one of the major features of which is that the quantum evolution of the wave function is always given by ordinary differential equations. In this paper we analyze the proposal in some detail and discuss its viability and its relationship with the standard quantum theory. As a byproduct, a simple derivation of the ‘‘mass spectrum’’ for the Klein–Gordon field is presented, but it is also shown that there is a complete additional spectrum of negative ‘‘masses.’’ Finally, two major reasons are presented against the viability of this alternative proposal: (a) It does not lead to the correct energy spectrum for the hydrogen atom. (b) For field models, the standard quantum theory cannot be recovered from this alternative description.
Abstract The development of the complex of assumptions and methods now referred to as the “old quantum theory” mainly took place in the first five years following the introduction of the Bohr atomic model in 1913. Three guiding principles emerged that were used, sometimes in overlapping ways, to explain the flood of spectroscopic data that needed to be explained. First, quantization rules (or conditions) were proposed to single out the allowed orbital motions of electrons in atoms. These rules were derived in various forms by Planck, Sommerfeld, and Wilson, but were put into their most general form by Schwarzschild, who recognized the underlying principle as the quantization of the action variables of a multiply periodic classical system. Second, the special role of the action variables in quantization was given convincing support by the transfer of the adiabatic principle of mechanics to quantum theory (work primarily due to Paul Ehrenfest). Third, the correspondence principle, or statement of asymptotic coincidence of quantum and classical theory in the limit of large quantum numbers, originally introduced by Bohr in 1913 as a supporting argument for his quantization of angular momentum in his theory of the hydrogen atom, was extended by Bohr and Kramers to provide selection rules and approximate intensity predictions evening the regime low quantum numbers.
The energy structures and transition energies of single-electron atoms and ions are presented. Five Nobel Prizes in Physics were awarded for the theories discussed in this chapter. We first review the Bohr model, which was based on quantized angular momentum and classical circular orbits. The wave model of Schrödinger followed, in which spherical boundary conditions quantized polar and azimuthal standing waves. The energies were identical to Bohr’s, but transition selection rules dictated the change in angular momentum of the system during absorption and emission. Dirac incorporated electron spin and relativistic energies, resulting in energy shifts and fine structure splitting of the energy levels for non-zero angular momentum states. Feynman and Swinger incorporated quantization of the electric vector potential. This physics broke energy degeneracies in the Dirac model and correctly predicted the famous Lamb shift. In this chapter, each of these models are described in detail. The final full characterization of the energy levels and transitions are presented. The chapter ends with a discussion on isotope shifting and transitions to the continuum (ionization/recombination).
This paper develops and verifies a physics-first description of the hydrogen-atom transition from the L shell (n = 2) to the K shell (n = 1) by combining the historical Bohr model of atomic structure with classical Maxwell electrodynamics. Beginning with the Coulomb force, centripetal dynamics, and Bohr’s angular-momentum quantization condition, the analysis derives the allowed orbital radii, electron velocities, angular momenta, kinetic energies, electrostatic potential energies, and total bound-state energies of the hydrogen atom. For the n = 2 → n = 1 transition, the calculated energy difference is approximately 10.2 eV, corresponding through the Planck–Einstein relation ΔE = hν to a frequency of approximately 2.47 × 10¹⁵ Hz and a wavelength near 121.6 nm, consistent with the hydrogen Lyman-α transition. The emitted radiation is then examined through Maxwell’s equations and the vacuum constitutive relations. The resulting electromagnetic-wave description yields the transverse electric and magnetic fields together with the associated electromagnetic energy density, Poynting energy flux, momentum density, radiation pressure, and Maxwell stress tensor. In this way, the atomic energy difference obtained from the Bohr model is connected quantitatively to the classical propagation properties of the outgoing electromagnetic radiation. The derivation is mathematically consistent as a historical Bohr–Maxwell reconstruction, but it does not constitute a closed dynamical theory of spontaneous emission. The essential bridge between discrete atomic energy levels and the continuous Maxwell field is supplied by the quantum frequency condition ΔE = hν. Neither classical Maxwell electrodynamics nor Newtonian orbital mechanics independently derives this relation, and classical Maxwell theory does not by itself quantize the emitted radiation energy into individual photons. A complete treatment of spontaneous emission, transition probabilities, radiative lifetimes, and photon-field quantization requires quantum mechanics and ultimately quantum electrodynamics. Accordingly, the framework is presented as a verified correspondence between established limiting descriptions rather than as a replacement for Schrödinger wave mechanics, Dirac theory, or quantum electrodynamics. By clearly separating the atomic bound-state calculation, the quantum energy-frequency bridge, and the classical electromagnetic propagation problem, the analysis provides a rigorous conceptual and mathematical foundation for subsequent Maxwell–Schrödinger, Dirac–Maxwell, quantum-electrodynamic, Maxwell–Scretching, and Scretching Quantum Chain formulations of hydrogenic radiative transitions.