Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Quasiparticle-Conserving Hamiltonian for Interacting Electrons and Phonons

C. Alton Coulter, D. W. Howgate, R. A. Shatas

Published Dec 13, 1965• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Hamiltonian most often used to describe a system of electrons interacting with lattice vibrations has the asymmetry that the electrons are represented by the creation and annihilation operators which arise from quantum field theory whereas the lattice vibrations are represented by the one-particle ladder operators of the one-dimensional harmonic-oscillator problem. Although the equal spacing of the harmonic-oscillator energy levels and the commutation relations satisfied by the oscillator ladder operators have led to an interpretation of this formalism in terms of the "creation and annihilation" of phonons, the phonons thus defined are not the quasiparticles which are obtained by a field-theoretical formulation of the lattice Hamiltonian in the harmonic approximation. A Hamiltonian is derived in this paper in which both the electrons and the lattice (in the harmonic approximation) are represented in field-theoretical formalism. A lattice creation operator in this formulation actually creates a vibrational mode (in a given state) from the physical vacuum, in contrast to a ladder operator which merely generates transitions between two states of an already existing vibrational mode. As a consequence, the number operator for the lattice quasiparticles commutes with the Hamiltonian, a property which is useful in certain applications. It is shown that even though our Hamiltonian is formally different from the ordinary one, it yields equivalent results for the state vectors of physical interest.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.140.a2000

Related papers

Constants of motion in an interacting electron-lattice system

R. A. Shatas, C. Alton Coulter

The electron-lattice interaction term of the Bloch-FrÖhlich Hamiltonian, written in the occupation number representation, is bilinear in the electron creation and annihilation operators but linear in the phonon raising and lowering operators. This asymmetry leads to the non-commutability of the phonon number operator and the interaction term of the Hamiltonian. It is shown that by introducing a bilinear form for each phonon operator the commutability of these two terms can be achieved. Formally, the new lattice operators arise from the quantum field-theoretical treatment of the normal modes. Specifically, in the harmonic approximation and coordinate representation of the lattice Hamiltonian in phonon space, this is achieved by the replacement of wave functions by a coordinate-dependent operator field. One obtains then such a field for every normal mode of the lattice. The operator field expansion coefficients are the lattice vibrational mode creation and annihilation operators which appear only in a bilinear combination throughout the theory. To obtain an equivalence relation between the field-theoretical and wave-mechanical formulations, one requires that only one lattice quasiparticle per lattice vibrational mode be allowed. For this case, the relation between the lattice field operators and the conventional phonon operators assumes a simple form. Finally, the entire Bloch-FrÖhlich Hamiltonian is rewritten in terms of the new set of lattice operators and the conservation of the new lattice quasiparticles is demonstrated. Thus, both the number of electrons and the number of lattice quasiparticles are shown to be constants of motion of an interacting electron-lattice system.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jun 18, 2009•0 citations

Quantum Optics

We discussed quantum transitions between electron states due to a classical light field in Section 9.4. Similarly we could calculate electron scattering by classical vibrations of a crystal lattice using the matrix elements in terms of the vibrational amplitudes which we derived in the preceding section. However, it is often important to treat both the electrons and the fields quantum-mechanically. When the fields, or vibration amplitudes, are very large the quantum effects are not so important but they become essential when the fields are small. The treatment of electromagnetic waves and vibrational modes quantum-mechanically is called field theory and we now need to introduce the operators of field theory, both for these waves and modes, and for electrons. This formulation is often called second quantization . Their application in quantum optics is perhaps the most important for us, and the focus for this section of the book. However, it will be best to introduce the operators for electrons first, and to make the first application to phonons, quantized lattice vibrations. In principle we already have the basic results we need. We have treated the harmonic oscillator quantum-mechanically, and have indicated that all of the findings apply to vibrational modes and to optical excitations. However, in field theory we use only a part of what we developed, the fact that the momentum operator (h'/i)∂/∂x does not commute with the coordinate x (changing the order of the product of two "commuting operators" does not change the product). In this case, (h'/i)∂/∂x (xψ)= (h'/i)ψ + x(h'/i)∂ψ/∂x so interchanging (h'/i)∂/∂x and x leaves a remainder, h'/i. This turns out to be the feature essential to defining field-theoretical annihilation and creation operators for excitations and particles. This is closely related to the point we made in Section 1.1 that it is possible to develop quantum theory without the waves which we have used throughout. Since we can obtain all of the information about the eigenstates of a harmonic oscillator, and its coupling to external fields, from the corresponding commutation relation, we did not really need the waves. Heisenberg represented the observables by matrices, rather than operators on waves. They had the same commutation relations so they led to the same results. For most contemporary physicists and engineers, the procedure with waves is much more comfortable.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jul 1, 2000•0 citations

Ladder Operators

Massoud Kaviany

This appendix deals with the boson and fermion ladder operators (i.e., annihilation and creation operators). These operators are not only used to find, for example, the eigenspectrum of a the quantum harmonic oscillator (Section 2.6.4); they are also in the second quantization to deal with systems of identical particles, such as, bosons (symmetric particles, e.g., phonons and photons) and fermions (anti-symmetric particles, e.g., electrons). This appendix covers the basics of the second quantization (as compared to the first quantization, of which a brief description is also given here), including the Fock (number) states and the basic forms of the creation and annihilation operators and their commutators (or anti-commutators, in the case of fermion operators). Finally, the use of these operators in creating arbitrary states, the number operators, field operators, and non-interacting and interacting Hamiltonians are discussed.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 10, 2014•0 citations

One-dimensional harmonic oscillator hamiltonian and wave function with ionization energy

Andrew Das Arulsamy, Kurunathan Ratnavelu

Abstract. 1-dimensional hamiltonian with ionization energy (ξ) is shown to be exactly the same with the total energy from the standard harmonic oscillator hamiltonian, with the harmonic oscillator potential, mω 2 x 2 /2. Commutation relations for the ladder operators, energy at the n th state and the expectation value for the potential are analyzed and shown to be consistent with the principle of ξ. We also derive 1-dimensional wave functions for Dirac delta (−αδ(x)) potential and with V (x) = 0. Formal justifications are given as to why the total energy in ξ based Fermi-Dirac statistics is exactly the same with the standard Fermi-Dirac statistics. Energy levels and Bohr radius of a Hydrogen atom are also shown to be consistent with the ionization energy concept. This concept is also applied in a free Mn atom that represent a free many-electron atom. 1.

•Feb 27, 2007•0 citations

Towards a Quantum Many-Body Theory of Lattice Dynamics. I. Time-Dependent Hartree Approximation

Donald R. Fredkin, N. R. Werthamer

The phonon is discussed as an example of a collective mode which restores a symmetry property (in this case, translational invariance) to a system whose Hamiltonian is invariant under the symmetry operation, but in whose ground state the symmetry is broken. The crystal lattice is first studied within the time-independent Hartree approximation. It is then shown that allowing small time-dependent changes in the Hartree field generates an equation for the normal modes of vibration. The three k=0 modes with $\ensuremath{\omega}=0$ are shown to represent uniform translations of the solid, as expected. The $\mathbf{k}\ensuremath{\ne}0$ modes are analyzed to extract those three which may be identified as one-phonon modes, and the contribution of these modes to the free energy is computed. The recent theory of Brout is found to be equivalent to the Hartree approximation with the further assumption that the atoms are infinitely heavy. No restrictions are made here on the interatomic potential other than that a hard core is absent. The reduction of the present theory to well-known results in the case of harmonic forces is demonstrated. An extension to include hard cores, analogous to the Brueckner theory, is discussed.

Physical Review•May 31, 1965•78 citations

Quasiparticle Fock-space coupled-cluster theory

Leszek Z. Stolarczyk, Hendrik J. Monkhorst

The quasiparticle Fock-space coupled-cluster (QFSCC) theory, introduced by us in 1985, is described. This is a theory of many-electron systems which uses the second-quantisation formalism based on the algebraic approximation: one chooses a finite spin-orbital basis, and builds a fermionic Fock space to represent all possible antisymmetric electronic states of a given system. The algebraic machinery is provided by the algebra of linear operators acting in the Fock space, generated by the fermion (creation and annihilation) operators. The Fock-space Hamiltonian operator then determines the system's stationary states and their energies. Within the QFSCC theory, the Fock space and its operator algebra are subject to a unitary transformation which effectively changes electrons into some fermionic quasiparticles. A generalisation of the coupled-cluster method is achieved by enforcing the principle of quasiparticle-number conservation. The emerging quasiparticle model of many-electron systems offers useful physical insights and computational effectiveness. The QFSCC theory requires a substantial reformulation of the traditional second-quantisation language, by making full use of the algebraic properties of the Fock space and its operator algebra. In particular, the role of operators not conserving the number of electrons (or quasiparticles) is identified.

Molecular Physics•Oct 11, 2010•18 citations
The Hamiltonian most often used to describe a system of electrons interacting with lattice vibrations has the asymmetry that the electrons are represented by the creation and annihilation operators which arise from quantum field theory whereas the lattice vibrations are represented by the one-particle ladder operators of the one-dimensional harmonic-oscillator problem. Although the equal spacing of the harmonic-oscillator energy levels and the commutation relations satisfied by the oscillator ladder operators have led to an interpretation of this formalism in terms of the "creation and annihilation" of phonons, the phonons thus defined are not the quasiparticles which are obtained by a field-theoretical formulation of the lattice Hamiltonian in the harmonic approximation. A Hamiltonian is derived in this paper in which both the electrons and the lattice (in the harmonic approximation) are represented in field-theoretical formalism. A lattice creation operator in this formulation actually creates a vibrational mode (in a given state) from the physical vacuum, in contrast to a ladder operator which merely generates transitions between two states of an already existing vibrational mode. As a consequence, the number operator for the lattice quasiparticles commutes with the Hamiltonian, a property which is useful in certain applications. It is shown that even though our Hamiltonian is formally different from the ordinary one, it yields equivalent results for the state vectors of physical interest.
The electron-lattice interaction term of the Bloch-FrÖhlich Hamiltonian, written in the occupation number representation, is bilinear in the electron creation and annihilation operators but linear in the phonon raising and lowering operators. This asymmetry leads to the non-commutability of the phonon number operator and the interaction term of the Hamiltonian. It is shown that by introducing a bilinear form for each phonon operator the commutability of these two terms can be achieved. Formally, the new lattice operators arise from the quantum field-theoretical treatment of the normal modes. Specifically, in the harmonic approximation and coordinate representation of the lattice Hamiltonian in phonon space, this is achieved by the replacement of wave functions by a coordinate-dependent operator field. One obtains then such a field for every normal mode of the lattice. The operator field expansion coefficients are the lattice vibrational mode creation and annihilation operators which appear only in a bilinear combination throughout the theory. To obtain an equivalence relation between the field-theoretical and wave-mechanical formulations, one requires that only one lattice quasiparticle per lattice vibrational mode be allowed. For this case, the relation between the lattice field operators and the conventional phonon operators assumes a simple form. Finally, the entire Bloch-FrÖhlich Hamiltonian is rewritten in terms of the new set of lattice operators and the conservation of the new lattice quasiparticles is demonstrated. Thus, both the number of electrons and the number of lattice quasiparticles are shown to be constants of motion of an interacting electron-lattice system.
We discussed quantum transitions between electron states due to a classical light field in Section 9.4. Similarly we could calculate electron scattering by classical vibrations of a crystal lattice using the matrix elements in terms of the vibrational amplitudes which we derived in the preceding section. However, it is often important to treat both the electrons and the fields quantum-mechanically. When the fields, or vibration amplitudes, are very large the quantum effects are not so important but they become essential when the fields are small. The treatment of electromagnetic waves and vibrational modes quantum-mechanically is called field theory and we now need to introduce the operators of field theory, both for these waves and modes, and for electrons. This formulation is often called second quantization . Their application in quantum optics is perhaps the most important for us, and the focus for this section of the book. However, it will be best to introduce the operators for electrons first, and to make the first application to phonons, quantized lattice vibrations. In principle we already have the basic results we need. We have treated the harmonic oscillator quantum-mechanically, and have indicated that all of the findings apply to vibrational modes and to optical excitations. However, in field theory we use only a part of what we developed, the fact that the momentum operator (h'/i)∂/∂x does not commute with the coordinate x (changing the order of the product of two "commuting operators" does not change the product). In this case, (h'/i)∂/∂x (xψ)= (h'/i)ψ + x(h'/i)∂ψ/∂x so interchanging (h'/i)∂/∂x and x leaves a remainder, h'/i. This turns out to be the feature essential to defining field-theoretical annihilation and creation operators for excitations and particles. This is closely related to the point we made in Section 1.1 that it is possible to develop quantum theory without the waves which we have used throughout. Since we can obtain all of the information about the eigenstates of a harmonic oscillator, and its coupling to external fields, from the corresponding commutation relation, we did not really need the waves. Heisenberg represented the observables by matrices, rather than operators on waves. They had the same commutation relations so they led to the same results. For most contemporary physicists and engineers, the procedure with waves is much more comfortable.
This appendix deals with the boson and fermion ladder operators (i.e., annihilation and creation operators). These operators are not only used to find, for example, the eigenspectrum of a the quantum harmonic oscillator (Section 2.6.4); they are also in the second quantization to deal with systems of identical particles, such as, bosons (symmetric particles, e.g., phonons and photons) and fermions (anti-symmetric particles, e.g., electrons). This appendix covers the basics of the second quantization (as compared to the first quantization, of which a brief description is also given here), including the Fock (number) states and the basic forms of the creation and annihilation operators and their commutators (or anti-commutators, in the case of fermion operators). Finally, the use of these operators in creating arbitrary states, the number operators, field operators, and non-interacting and interacting Hamiltonians are discussed.
Abstract. 1-dimensional hamiltonian with ionization energy (ξ) is shown to be exactly the same with the total energy from the standard harmonic oscillator hamiltonian, with the harmonic oscillator potential, mω 2 x 2 /2. Commutation relations for the ladder operators, energy at the n th state and the expectation value for the potential are analyzed and shown to be consistent with the principle of ξ. We also derive 1-dimensional wave functions for Dirac delta (−αδ(x)) potential and with V (x) = 0. Formal justifications are given as to why the total energy in ξ based Fermi-Dirac statistics is exactly the same with the standard Fermi-Dirac statistics. Energy levels and Bohr radius of a Hydrogen atom are also shown to be consistent with the ionization energy concept. This concept is also applied in a free Mn atom that represent a free many-electron atom. 1.
The phonon is discussed as an example of a collective mode which restores a symmetry property (in this case, translational invariance) to a system whose Hamiltonian is invariant under the symmetry operation, but in whose ground state the symmetry is broken. The crystal lattice is first studied within the time-independent Hartree approximation. It is then shown that allowing small time-dependent changes in the Hartree field generates an equation for the normal modes of vibration. The three k=0 modes with $\ensuremath{\omega}=0$ are shown to represent uniform translations of the solid, as expected. The $\mathbf{k}\ensuremath{\ne}0$ modes are analyzed to extract those three which may be identified as one-phonon modes, and the contribution of these modes to the free energy is computed. The recent theory of Brout is found to be equivalent to the Hartree approximation with the further assumption that the atoms are infinitely heavy. No restrictions are made here on the interatomic potential other than that a hard core is absent. The reduction of the present theory to well-known results in the case of harmonic forces is demonstrated. An extension to include hard cores, analogous to the Brueckner theory, is discussed.
The quasiparticle Fock-space coupled-cluster (QFSCC) theory, introduced by us in 1985, is described. This is a theory of many-electron systems which uses the second-quantisation formalism based on the algebraic approximation: one chooses a finite spin-orbital basis, and builds a fermionic Fock space to represent all possible antisymmetric electronic states of a given system. The algebraic machinery is provided by the algebra of linear operators acting in the Fock space, generated by the fermion (creation and annihilation) operators. The Fock-space Hamiltonian operator then determines the system's stationary states and their energies. Within the QFSCC theory, the Fock space and its operator algebra are subject to a unitary transformation which effectively changes electrons into some fermionic quasiparticles. A generalisation of the coupled-cluster method is achieved by enforcing the principle of quasiparticle-number conservation. The emerging quasiparticle model of many-electron systems offers useful physical insights and computational effectiveness. The QFSCC theory requires a substantial reformulation of the traditional second-quantisation language, by making full use of the algebraic properties of the Fock space and its operator algebra. In particular, the role of operators not conserving the number of electrons (or quasiparticles) is identified.