In this paper we would like to stress that, besides two commonly discussed conditions inducing violation of Bell's inequality—nonlocality and death of realism—there is the third condition having th ...
In this paper we would like to stress that, besides two commonly discussed conditions inducing violation of Bell’s inequality—nonlocality and death of realism—there is the third condition having the same consequence. This is the condition of probabilistic incompatibility (PI) of random variables—impossibility to realize them on a single probability space—“non‐Kolmogorovness.” This additional source of violation of Bell’s inequality should be taken into account. We remark that PI can be a consequence of nonlocality or impossibility to use the realistic model. However, PI is essentially more general condition. Random variables can be of the PI‐type even in absence of nonolocal effects.
The aim of this review (oriented to biologists looking for applications of QM) is to provide a detailed comparative analysis of classical (Kolmogorovian) and quantum (Dirac-von Neumann) models. We will stress differences in the definition of conditional probability and as a consequence in the structures of matrices of transition probabilities, especially the condition of double stochasticity which arises naturally in QM. One of the most fundamental differences between two models is deformation of the classical formula of total probability (FTP) which plays an important role in statistics and decision making. An additional term appears in the QM-version of FTP – so called interference term. Finally, we discuss Bell's inequality and show that the common viewpoint that its violation induces either nonlocality or "death of realism" has not been completely justified. For us it is merely a sign of non-Kolmogorovianity of probabilistic data collected in a few experiments with incompatible setups of measurement devices.
The main aim of this review is to show that the common conclusion that Bell's argument implies that any attempt to proceed beyond quantum mechanics induces a nonlocal model was not totally justified. Our analysis of Bell's argument demonstrates that violation of Bell's inequality implies neither "death of realism" nor nonlocality. This violation is just a sign of non-Kolmogorovness of statistical data - impossibility to put statistical data collected in a few different experiments (corresponding to incompatible settings of polarization beam splitters) in one probability space. This inequality was well known in theoretical probability since 19th century (from works of Boole). We couple non-Kolmogorovness of data with design of modern detectors of photons.