Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Nonrelativistic rotating charged sphere as a model for particle spin

Ralph H. Young

Published Jun 1, 1976• 12 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The rotating charged sphere is discussed as a model for particle spin. The nonrelativistic classical mechanics of the model shows a close analogy to the nonrelativistic (Pauli) quantum mechanics of spin. The spin contribution to the Hamiltonian operator, −γŝ⋅B (standard notation), represents the nonconstant part of the kinetic energy associated with spin. Variations of translational kinetic energy in an inhomogeneous static magnetic field are offset by variations of spin kinetic energy. The latter, along with the torque term responsible for them, cannot be overlooked without forfeiting conservation of energy.

DOI
10.1119/1.10383

Related papers

Spin–orbit coupling and the conservation of angular momentum

V Hnizdo

In nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, the total (i.e. orbital plus spin) angular momentum of a charged particle with spin that moves in a Coulomb plus spin–orbit-coupling potential is conserved. In a classical nonrelativistic treatment of this problem, in which the Lagrange equations determine the orbital motion and the Thomas equation yields the rate of change of the spin, the particle's total angular momentum in which the orbital angular momentum is defined in terms of the kinetic momentum is generally not conserved. However, a generalized total angular momentum, in which the orbital part is defined in terms of the canonical momentum, is conserved. This illustrates the fact that the quantum-mechanical operator of momentum corresponds to the canonical momentum of classical mechanics.

arXiv:1103.4092•European Journal of Physics•Feb 7, 2012•6 citations

Statistical approach to quantum mechanics II: Nonrelativistic spin

G. H. Goedecke

In this second paper in a series, we show that the the general statistical approach to nonrelativistic quantum mechanics developed in the first paper yields a representation of quantum spin and magnetic moments based on classical nonrelativistic spinning top models, using Euler angle coordinates. The models allow half-odd-integer spin and predict supraluminal speeds only for electrons and other leptons, which must be treated relativistically. The spin operators in the space-fixed frame satisfy the usual commutation rules, while those in the rotating body-fixed frame satisfy "left-handed" rules. The commutation rules are independent of the structure of the top, so all nonrelativistic rigidly rotating objects must have integer or odd-half-integer spin. Physical boundary conditions restrict all mixed spin states to involve only half-odd-integer or only integer spin eigenstates. For spin 1/2, the theory automatically yields a modified Pauli-Schrödinger equation. The Hamiltonian operator in this equation contains a rigid rotator term and a term involving the square of the magmetic field, as well as an interaction term having the usual form in spherically symmetric and some cylindrically symmetric models, valid for any magnetogyric ratio.

arXiv:1408.1721•Aug 7, 2014•1 citation

Spin 1/2

Gordon Baym

The Pauli spin matrices have many useful properties. The spin of a particle is a degree of freedom additional to the spatial degrees of freedom. It is independent of the spatial degrees of freedom in the sense that one can simultaneously specify the spin state and the spatial state of a particle. Non-relativistically one must use more indirect methods of observing the spin. Classically, a spinning distribution of charge will have a magnetic moment; quantum mechanical spinning particles also have magnetic moments associated with their spins, and one tries to observe these magnetic moments in experiments. Spins in magnetic fields have very interesting dynamical properties. The right side is just the torque exerted by a magnetic field on a magnetic moment. This equation says in operator language that the rate of change of the spin angular momentum is the applied torque.

CRC Press eBooks•Mar 5, 2018•0 citations

Dipole in a magnetic field, work, and quantum spin

Robert J. Deissler

The behavior of an atom in a nonuniform magnetic field is analyzed, as well as the motion of a classical magnetic dipole (a spinning charged ball) and a rotating charged ring. For the atom it is shown that, while the magnetic field does no work on the electron-orbital contribution to the magnetic moment (the source of translational kinetic energy being the internal energy of the atom), whether or not it does work on the electron-spin contribution to the magnetic moment depends on whether the electron has an intrinsic rotational kinetic energy associated with its spin. A rotational kinetic energy for the electron is shown to be consistent with the Dirac equation. If the electron does have a rotational kinetic energy, the acceleration of a silver atom in a Stern-Gerlach experiment or the emission of a photon from an electron spin flip can be explained without requiring the magnetic field to do work. For a constant magnetic field gradient along the z axis, it is found that the classical objects oscillate in simple harmonic motion along the z axis, the total kinetic energy -- translational plus rotational -- being a constant of the motion. For the charged ball, the change in rotational kinetic energy is associated only with a change in the precession frequency, the rotation rate about the figure axis remaining constant.

Physical Review E•Mar 21, 2008•10 citations

Kinematics and hydrodynamics of spinning particles

Erasmo Recami, Giovanni Salesi

In the first part (Secs. I and II) of this paper, starting from the Pauli current, we obtain the decomposition of the nonrelativistic field velocity into two orthogonal parts: (i) the ``classical'' part, that is, the velocity $\mathbf{w}=\mathbf{p}/m$ in the center of mass (c.m.), and (ii) the ``quantum'' part, that is, the velocity V of the motion of the c.m. frame (namely, the internal ``spin motion'' or Zitterbewegung). By inserting such a complete, composite expression of the velocity into the kinetic-energy term of the nonrelativistic classical (i.e., Newtonian) Lagrangian, we straightforwardly get the appearance of the so-called quantum potential associated, as it is known, with the Madelung fluid. This result provides further evidence of the possibility that the quantum behavior of microsystems is a direct consequence of the fundamental existence of spin. In the second part (Secs. III and IV), we fix our attention on the total velocity $\mathbf{v}=\mathbf{w}+\mathbf{V},$ now necessarily considering relativistic (classical) physics. We show that the proper time entering the definition of the four-velocity ${v}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ for spinning particles has to be the proper time \ensuremath{\tau} of the c.m. frame. Inserting the correct Lorentz factor into the definition of ${v}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ leads to completely different kinematical properties for ${v}^{2}.$ The important constraint ${p}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{v}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}=m,$ identically true for scalar particles but just assumed a priori in all previous spinning-particle theories, is herein derived in a self-consistent way.

arXiv:quant-ph/9607025•Physical Review A•Jan 1, 1998•68 citations

Speculation on the Role of Spin in Momentum Based Energy

Francesco R. Ruggeri

Physics is based on experimental observables. Some of these observables are functions of other observables. For example, mass is an observable associated with inertia or gravity and velocity is classically measured, but the product mov yields nonrelativistic momentum which may be measured independently through an impulse hit with a target. A further issue with measurement is the case of vectors. For a vector pointing in one direction, one may orient the z axis to lie along this direction. If one always does this, momentum appears as a scalar, but one has to continuously rotate the co-ordinate system to account for different orientations. In this note, we are interested in spin which is linked to a kind of rotation and so we focus on the momentum vector, but only consider a function of momentum which yields a linear E, free particle energy. Thus, for the Lorentz invariant: -EE + p dot p = -momo, we consider the nonrelativistic limit: E = p dot p /2mo. In quantum mechanics, a free particle is represented by the complex probability (wavefunction) exp(ip dot r).This function has physical implications as it manifests itself in n-slit interference experiments so it is physical (not a mathematical convenience), but at the same time is responsible for conservation of momentum in x,y,z because Integral dx exp(ip1x) exp(ip2x) = 0 if p1 is not equal to p2. A physical function (property) through orthogonality creates an important relationship, namely conservation of momentum. We suggest that a similar idea may be at work in a relationship linking a linear E (free particle energy) to a function of momentum. We start with a linear E related to a function of p and only focus on the p vector because if it is treated as a number, the co-ordinate axis must rotate to account for its orientation. We only consider a situation in which p(x), p(y) and p(z) behave in an independent manner in the function of p (i.e. in the same manner as p itself) and suggest that instead of using vector analysis, there should exist a physical co-ordinate axis for each projection p(x), p(y) and p(z) if they are independent. We argue that p dot p = p(x)p(x) + p(y)p(y)+p(z)p(z) does not contain cross terms such as p(x)p(y). This is a kind of orthogonality which we associate with a rotational kind of operator linked with the p(i) operator -id/dx(i). In other words, we seek: p vector = generalized number = p(x)sx+p(y)sy+p(z)sz, where s(i) are generalized numbers or matrices, so that when this multiplied by itself, it yields p dot p. It turns out that the s(i) are the 2x2 Pauli matrices. In the case of a photon, there is no nonrelativistic limit and a linear E equation related to p is: E= |p|c. This equation is not independent in p(x), p(y), p(z) i.e. one cannot write p(x)sx+p(y)sy+p(z)sz an obtain E = {p(x)sx+p(y)sy+p(z)sz} c. Thus we look for another equation containing a linear E and a function of p. In this case, we use energy and momentum densities as given by the continuity equation: d/dt partial energy density + d grad dot ElxB =0 where d is a constant and El and B electric and magnetic 3-vectors. As in the above analysis, one wishes to have a momentum operator linked with a kind of rotational operator which allows one to eliminate vector math and use generalized numbers. In such a case, grad in the continuity equation becomes the momentum vector and eijk (Levi-Civita symbol in the cross product) becomes the spin matrix. Thus in both cases, spin governs the form of the function containing momentum which yields a linear E. In other words, it is not momentum alone which yields the relationship between a linear E (free particle energy) and momentum.

•Sep 6, 2023•0 citations
The rotating charged sphere is discussed as a model for particle spin. The nonrelativistic classical mechanics of the model shows a close analogy to the nonrelativistic (Pauli) quantum mechanics of spin. The spin contribution to the Hamiltonian operator, −γŝ⋅B (standard notation), represents the nonconstant part of the kinetic energy associated with spin. Variations of translational kinetic energy in an inhomogeneous static magnetic field are offset by variations of spin kinetic energy. The latter, along with the torque term responsible for them, cannot be overlooked without forfeiting conservation of energy.
In nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, the total (i.e. orbital plus spin) angular momentum of a charged particle with spin that moves in a Coulomb plus spin–orbit-coupling potential is conserved. In a classical nonrelativistic treatment of this problem, in which the Lagrange equations determine the orbital motion and the Thomas equation yields the rate of change of the spin, the particle's total angular momentum in which the orbital angular momentum is defined in terms of the kinetic momentum is generally not conserved. However, a generalized total angular momentum, in which the orbital part is defined in terms of the canonical momentum, is conserved. This illustrates the fact that the quantum-mechanical operator of momentum corresponds to the canonical momentum of classical mechanics.
In this second paper in a series, we show that the the general statistical approach to nonrelativistic quantum mechanics developed in the first paper yields a representation of quantum spin and magnetic moments based on classical nonrelativistic spinning top models, using Euler angle coordinates. The models allow half-odd-integer spin and predict supraluminal speeds only for electrons and other leptons, which must be treated relativistically. The spin operators in the space-fixed frame satisfy the usual commutation rules, while those in the rotating body-fixed frame satisfy "left-handed" rules. The commutation rules are independent of the structure of the top, so all nonrelativistic rigidly rotating objects must have integer or odd-half-integer spin. Physical boundary conditions restrict all mixed spin states to involve only half-odd-integer or only integer spin eigenstates. For spin 1/2, the theory automatically yields a modified Pauli-Schrödinger equation. The Hamiltonian operator in this equation contains a rigid rotator term and a term involving the square of the magmetic field, as well as an interaction term having the usual form in spherically symmetric and some cylindrically symmetric models, valid for any magnetogyric ratio.
The Pauli spin matrices have many useful properties. The spin of a particle is a degree of freedom additional to the spatial degrees of freedom. It is independent of the spatial degrees of freedom in the sense that one can simultaneously specify the spin state and the spatial state of a particle. Non-relativistically one must use more indirect methods of observing the spin. Classically, a spinning distribution of charge will have a magnetic moment; quantum mechanical spinning particles also have magnetic moments associated with their spins, and one tries to observe these magnetic moments in experiments. Spins in magnetic fields have very interesting dynamical properties. The right side is just the torque exerted by a magnetic field on a magnetic moment. This equation says in operator language that the rate of change of the spin angular momentum is the applied torque.
The behavior of an atom in a nonuniform magnetic field is analyzed, as well as the motion of a classical magnetic dipole (a spinning charged ball) and a rotating charged ring. For the atom it is shown that, while the magnetic field does no work on the electron-orbital contribution to the magnetic moment (the source of translational kinetic energy being the internal energy of the atom), whether or not it does work on the electron-spin contribution to the magnetic moment depends on whether the electron has an intrinsic rotational kinetic energy associated with its spin. A rotational kinetic energy for the electron is shown to be consistent with the Dirac equation. If the electron does have a rotational kinetic energy, the acceleration of a silver atom in a Stern-Gerlach experiment or the emission of a photon from an electron spin flip can be explained without requiring the magnetic field to do work. For a constant magnetic field gradient along the z axis, it is found that the classical objects oscillate in simple harmonic motion along the z axis, the total kinetic energy -- translational plus rotational -- being a constant of the motion. For the charged ball, the change in rotational kinetic energy is associated only with a change in the precession frequency, the rotation rate about the figure axis remaining constant.
In the first part (Secs. I and II) of this paper, starting from the Pauli current, we obtain the decomposition of the nonrelativistic field velocity into two orthogonal parts: (i) the ``classical'' part, that is, the velocity w=p/m\mathbf{w}=\mathbf{p}/mw=p/m in the center of mass (c.m.), and (ii) the ``quantum'' part, that is, the velocity V of the motion of the c.m. frame (namely, the internal ``spin motion'' or Zitterbewegung). By inserting such a complete, composite expression of the velocity into the kinetic-energy term of the nonrelativistic classical (i.e., Newtonian) Lagrangian, we straightforwardly get the appearance of the so-called quantum potential associated, as it is known, with the Madelung fluid. This result provides further evidence of the possibility that the quantum behavior of microsystems is a direct consequence of the fundamental existence of spin. In the second part (Secs. III and IV), we fix our attention on the total velocity v=w+V,\mathbf{v}=\mathbf{w}+\mathbf{V},v=w+V, now necessarily considering relativistic (classical) physics. We show that the proper time entering the definition of the four-velocity ${v}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ for spinning particles has to be the proper time \ensuremath{\tau} of the c.m. frame. Inserting the correct Lorentz factor into the definition of ${v}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ leads to completely different kinematical properties for v2.{v}^{2}.v2. The important constraint ${p}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{v}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}=m,$ identically true for scalar particles but just assumed a priori in all previous spinning-particle theories, is herein derived in a self-consistent way.
Physics is based on experimental observables. Some of these observables are functions of other observables. For example, mass is an observable associated with inertia or gravity and velocity is classically measured, but the product mov yields nonrelativistic momentum which may be measured independently through an impulse hit with a target. A further issue with measurement is the case of vectors. For a vector pointing in one direction, one may orient the z axis to lie along this direction. If one always does this, momentum appears as a scalar, but one has to continuously rotate the co-ordinate system to account for different orientations. In this note, we are interested in spin which is linked to a kind of rotation and so we focus on the momentum vector, but only consider a function of momentum which yields a linear E, free particle energy. Thus, for the Lorentz invariant: -EE + p dot p = -momo, we consider the nonrelativistic limit: E = p dot p /2mo. In quantum mechanics, a free particle is represented by the complex probability (wavefunction) exp(ip dot r).This function has physical implications as it manifests itself in n-slit interference experiments so it is physical (not a mathematical convenience), but at the same time is responsible for conservation of momentum in x,y,z because Integral dx exp(ip1x) exp(ip2x) = 0 if p1 is not equal to p2. A physical function (property) through orthogonality creates an important relationship, namely conservation of momentum. We suggest that a similar idea may be at work in a relationship linking a linear E (free particle energy) to a function of momentum. We start with a linear E related to a function of p and only focus on the p vector because if it is treated as a number, the co-ordinate axis must rotate to account for its orientation. We only consider a situation in which p(x), p(y) and p(z) behave in an independent manner in the function of p (i.e. in the same manner as p itself) and suggest that instead of using vector analysis, there should exist a physical co-ordinate axis for each projection p(x), p(y) and p(z) if they are independent. We argue that p dot p = p(x)p(x) + p(y)p(y)+p(z)p(z) does not contain cross terms such as p(x)p(y). This is a kind of orthogonality which we associate with a rotational kind of operator linked with the p(i) operator -id/dx(i). In other words, we seek: p vector = generalized number = p(x)sx+p(y)sy+p(z)sz, where s(i) are generalized numbers or matrices, so that when this multiplied by itself, it yields p dot p. It turns out that the s(i) are the 2x2 Pauli matrices. In the case of a photon, there is no nonrelativistic limit and a linear E equation related to p is: E= |p|c. This equation is not independent in p(x), p(y), p(z) i.e. one cannot write p(x)sx+p(y)sy+p(z)sz an obtain E = {p(x)sx+p(y)sy+p(z)sz} c. Thus we look for another equation containing a linear E and a function of p. In this case, we use energy and momentum densities as given by the continuity equation: d/dt partial energy density + d grad dot ElxB =0 where d is a constant and El and B electric and magnetic 3-vectors. As in the above analysis, one wishes to have a momentum operator linked with a kind of rotational operator which allows one to eliminate vector math and use generalized numbers. In such a case, grad in the continuity equation becomes the momentum vector and eijk (Levi-Civita symbol in the cross product) becomes the spin matrix. Thus in both cases, spin governs the form of the function containing momentum which yields a linear E. In other words, it is not momentum alone which yields the relationship between a linear E (free particle energy) and momentum.