Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Science Education

Early theories on the nature of heat and light

Ned D. Heindel, Nancy C. Warner

Published Mar 1, 1969• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Though no simple picture has been invented affording a mechanical model of a light ray, by combining the notions of waves and particles a logically consistent theory has been devised which seems essentially capable of accounting for the properties of light as we know them. Radio rays, heat rays, visible and ultra‐violet light, X‐rays, gamma rays and cosmic rays all are thus different varieties of light. We find from our experiments on diffraction and interference that light consists of waves. The photoelectric effect and the scattering of X‐rays give equally convincing reasons for believing that light consists of particles. For centuries it has been supposed that the two conceptions are contradictory. Goaded on, however, by obstinate experiments we seem to have found a way out. We continue to think of light propagated as electromagnetic waves; but whenever the light does something, it does it as photons. In reply to our question, what is light, the answer seems to come, waves and particles, light is both.

DOI
10.1002/sce.3730530210

Related papers

Electromagnetic Radiation — A Particle

Edward K. Yeargers

Having just described electromagnetic radiation as a wave, it may seem a bit peculiar to embark on a particle description of that radiation. Perhaps it will help to recall from Chapter 2 that our perception of something depends in part on the means we use to perceive it and that we used a specific experiment (interference) to define the wave property. There is no reason to believe that one human-invented experiment is the only one that can be used to describe electromagnetic radiation. In fact, the Einstein photoelectric effect, described next, is consistent with light being a particle.

CRC Press eBooks•Jan 18, 2018•0 citations

What is light?

Have you ever tried to define light? If so, your definition is probably related to vision, the ability to see things. The Merriam-Webster English dictionary defines light as “something that makes vision possible”. However, the definition of the “nature of light” is a complex term already discussed by philosophers of Ancient Greece. In the 17th century, the debate on the matter focused on whether light was a particle or a wave, based on the different properties of light that had been gradually discovered over time. Isaac Newton (1642−1727) was a defender of the corpuscular theory of light, which considered light to be formed by particles, i.e., small pieces of matter, like dust or grains of sand. He was the author of Opticks (1706), the front cover of which appears in Fig. 1.1. Christian Huygens (1629–1695), on the other hand, supported the theory that light is a wave. These are two completely different definitions of the same physical concept. A range of experiments were developed to attempt to clarify this dilemma, but it was only until 1900 when Max Planck (1858-1947) introduced the basis of a theory that would go on to revolutionize scientific thinking, marking the beginning of modern physics: quantum theory. Developed during the 20th century thanks to advances made by scientists such as Niels Bohr, Born, Heisenberg, Schrödinger, Pauli, Dirac, Einstein or de Broglie, quantum theory clarified that light is neither a particle nor a wave, but that it has a dual nature: it behaves like a wave as it spreads but like a particle in its interactions with matter. In this book, we will specify where necessary whether light behaves as a particle or as a wave, although in most cases we refer to rays of light, which always represent the direction of propagation of light.

SPIE eBooks•May 6, 2021•0 citations

RADIO WAVES AS A STREAM OF PARTICLES IN VIBRATIONAL STATE

Я. М. Грохольський, B. A. Sus, Богдан Сусь

Electromagnetic waves are a radio, light, X-rays and gamma rays. However, traditionally electromagnetic waves considered in scientific and in academic literature in different positions. Radio waves are always considered as a waves, while light is represented as electromagnetic waves and as a stream of particles. Light as electromagnetic waves, which undoubtedly confirmed experimentally in such a phenomenon as wave interference, at the same time treated as a stream of particles, which are called photons. Since radio waves, like light, are electromagnetic waves, also the question arises to interpret them in terms of corpuscular approach. It is shown that the range of radio waves as electromagnetic waves also have dual wave-particle nature – this is the wave and a particle at the same time. Some particles of radio waves stay in the vibrational state with the transition of electromagnetic energy to particle mass and vice versa.

Radio Electronics Computer Science Control•Jan 20, 2017•1 citation

The Nature of Light

Brian Culshaw

The question ‘is light a ray, a wave or a particle?’ has long fascinated philosophers and has intensified since the concept of the photon first emerged at the beginning of the twentieth century. The pragmatic answer to the question is ‘it depends what you are looking for’ and is really about how best to conceptualise light in particular circumstances. We have already mentioned such distinctions briefly in Chapter 1. This chapter will extend these basic concepts to introduce the material which follows in later chapters.

SPIE eBooks•Oct 5, 2020•0 citations

What is light?

Muhammad Suhail Zubairy

Abstract A brief history of how light has been perceived since antiquity is presented. The understanding of light underwent tremendous changes over time. We have therefore come a long way from the earliest studies on light, trying to understand vision as light emanating from our eyes, to the description of light as rays, then as particles, and then waves, and finally exhibiting both particle and wave natures. The picture of light quanta as both waves and particles is an incomprehensible but correct picture. It is an irony that the greatest strides taken in the scientific understanding have come in our time, yet we feel least certain of our understanding of what light is, what a photon is.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Sep 14, 2023•0 citations

Atoms

W. Graham Richards, P.R. Scott

This chapter addresses the question of whether light consists of waves or particles. This issue was resolved in the nineteenth century when it was shown that light could undergo interference and diffraction. The chapter reviews well-known properties and key features of wave motions that emphasize that a point illuminated by two sources of light can nevertheless be in darkness. It also looks at the measurements of diffraction experiments that allowed the wavelengths of different forms of light to be determined. The chapter explains how and why atoms come together to form molecules and illustrates the structure of the Periodic Table. It discusses electrons which are emitted from metal when the energy of the photon exceeds the work function, which implies that a single quantum of energy must be transferred to a single electron.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 29, 1994•1 citation
Abstract Though no simple picture has been invented affording a mechanical model of a light ray, by combining the notions of waves and particles a logically consistent theory has been devised which seems essentially capable of accounting for the properties of light as we know them. Radio rays, heat rays, visible and ultra‐violet light, X‐rays, gamma rays and cosmic rays all are thus different varieties of light. We find from our experiments on diffraction and interference that light consists of waves. The photoelectric effect and the scattering of X‐rays give equally convincing reasons for believing that light consists of particles. For centuries it has been supposed that the two conceptions are contradictory. Goaded on, however, by obstinate experiments we seem to have found a way out. We continue to think of light propagated as electromagnetic waves; but whenever the light does something, it does it as photons. In reply to our question, what is light, the answer seems to come, waves and particles, light is both.
Having just described electromagnetic radiation as a wave, it may seem a bit peculiar to embark on a particle description of that radiation. Perhaps it will help to recall from Chapter 2 that our perception of something depends in part on the means we use to perceive it and that we used a specific experiment (interference) to define the wave property. There is no reason to believe that one human-invented experiment is the only one that can be used to describe electromagnetic radiation. In fact, the Einstein photoelectric effect, described next, is consistent with light being a particle.
Have you ever tried to define light? If so, your definition is probably related to vision, the ability to see things. The Merriam-Webster English dictionary defines light as “something that makes vision possible”. However, the definition of the “nature of light” is a complex term already discussed by philosophers of Ancient Greece. In the 17th century, the debate on the matter focused on whether light was a particle or a wave, based on the different properties of light that had been gradually discovered over time. Isaac Newton (1642−1727) was a defender of the corpuscular theory of light, which considered light to be formed by particles, i.e., small pieces of matter, like dust or grains of sand. He was the author of Opticks (1706), the front cover of which appears in Fig. 1.1. Christian Huygens (1629–1695), on the other hand, supported the theory that light is a wave. These are two completely different definitions of the same physical concept. A range of experiments were developed to attempt to clarify this dilemma, but it was only until 1900 when Max Planck (1858-1947) introduced the basis of a theory that would go on to revolutionize scientific thinking, marking the beginning of modern physics: quantum theory. Developed during the 20th century thanks to advances made by scientists such as Niels Bohr, Born, Heisenberg, Schrödinger, Pauli, Dirac, Einstein or de Broglie, quantum theory clarified that light is neither a particle nor a wave, but that it has a dual nature: it behaves like a wave as it spreads but like a particle in its interactions with matter. In this book, we will specify where necessary whether light behaves as a particle or as a wave, although in most cases we refer to rays of light, which always represent the direction of propagation of light.
Electromagnetic waves are a radio, light, X-rays and gamma rays. However, traditionally electromagnetic waves considered in scientific and in academic literature in different positions. Radio waves are always considered as a waves, while light is represented as electromagnetic waves and as a stream of particles. Light as electromagnetic waves, which undoubtedly confirmed experimentally in such a phenomenon as wave interference, at the same time treated as a stream of particles, which are called photons. Since radio waves, like light, are electromagnetic waves, also the question arises to interpret them in terms of corpuscular approach. It is shown that the range of radio waves as electromagnetic waves also have dual wave-particle nature – this is the wave and a particle at the same time. Some particles of radio waves stay in the vibrational state with the transition of electromagnetic energy to particle mass and vice versa.
The question ‘is light a ray, a wave or a particle?’ has long fascinated philosophers and has intensified since the concept of the photon first emerged at the beginning of the twentieth century. The pragmatic answer to the question is ‘it depends what you are looking for’ and is really about how best to conceptualise light in particular circumstances. We have already mentioned such distinctions briefly in Chapter 1. This chapter will extend these basic concepts to introduce the material which follows in later chapters.
Abstract A brief history of how light has been perceived since antiquity is presented. The understanding of light underwent tremendous changes over time. We have therefore come a long way from the earliest studies on light, trying to understand vision as light emanating from our eyes, to the description of light as rays, then as particles, and then waves, and finally exhibiting both particle and wave natures. The picture of light quanta as both waves and particles is an incomprehensible but correct picture. It is an irony that the greatest strides taken in the scientific understanding have come in our time, yet we feel least certain of our understanding of what light is, what a photon is.
This chapter addresses the question of whether light consists of waves or particles. This issue was resolved in the nineteenth century when it was shown that light could undergo interference and diffraction. The chapter reviews well-known properties and key features of wave motions that emphasize that a point illuminated by two sources of light can nevertheless be in darkness. It also looks at the measurements of diffraction experiments that allowed the wavelengths of different forms of light to be determined. The chapter explains how and why atoms come together to form molecules and illustrates the structure of the Periodic Table. It discusses electrons which are emitted from metal when the energy of the photon exceeds the work function, which implies that a single quantum of energy must be transferred to a single electron.