Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Progress of Theoretical Physics

On Consistency between Lagrange and Hamilton Formalisms in Quantum Mechanics: Case of Non-Relativistic Velocity-Dependent Potential

Reiji Sugano

Published Jul 1, 1971• 18 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Consistency between the Lagrangean and the Hamiltonian formalisms in the quantum mechanics is investigatedc for the type of Lagrangean L=½\dotqigij(q)\dotqj-v(q) as an extension of a previous paper. The variations δqi and δ\dotqi should be considered as q-numbers. When the Lagrangean can be transformed into the standard form L=½\dotQα2-V(Q), the commutation relations of δqi and δ\dotqi with qj and \dotqj are found with the help of the Q-coordinate system. It is shown that using the commutation relations, the variation principle leads to the same equation of motion as the canonical equation of motion which is obtained in the previous paper.

DOI
10.1143/ptp.46.297

Related papers

Schwinger's Variation Principle by Means ofQ-Number Variation for Non-Linear Lagrangian

Reiji Sugano

Since the ordinary c-number variation principle does not lead, for a non-linear Lagrangian, to the result consistent between the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formalisms, Schwinger's variation principle is reformulated for a type of Lagrangian L=½\dotqigij(q)\dotqj-u(q) by means of a q-number variation. The canonical momentum, the Hamiltonian, the canonical commutation relations and equation of motion are derived. Also the Euler-Lagrange equation is obtained, which is consistent with the canonical equation of motion. These consequences are exactly the same as those of previous papers, but different from the ordinary ones in the Euler-Lagrange equation and the Hamiltonian.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Apr 1, 1973•1 citation

Development of canonical transformations from Hamilton’s principle

Charles Richard Quade

It is shown that the variations δqj and δQi cannot both be simultaneously zero at the limits of integration in application of Hamilton’s principle to the development of the theory of canonical transformations. This means that δF1 does not vanish. However, the derivation requires only that the δqj be zero at the end points. This lack of symmetry between the qj and Qi in the formulaion is noted with respect to the Lagrangian and the fundamental commutator relations of quantum mechanics. Further, what is meant by an independent variation of pj and qj (or Qi and Pi) in the formalism is discussed in the use of Hamilton’s principle in the derivation of Hamilton’s equations of motion.

American Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 1979•3 citations

Variation Principle for Non-Linear Lagrangian in Quantum Mechanics

Teruya Ohtani, Reiji Sugano

The variation principle has not been well defined in quantum mechanics for a Lagrangian containing a velocity dependent potential. We investigate the method of variation to derive an Euler-Lagrange equation in connection with Noether's theorem when the Lagrangian is invariant under some point transformation. Obtained are the Euler-Lagrange equation retaining the above invariance by means of the variation method and the Hamiltonian with which the canonical equation of motion leads to the Euler-Lagrange equation.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•May 1, 1972•8 citations

Schwinger's Variational Principle in Quantum Mechanics with Velocity Dependent Potential. I: One Dimensional Case

Toshiharu Kawai

Schwinger's variational principle is formulated for the quantum system which corresponds to the one-dimensional classical system described by the Lagrangian Lc(\dotx, x) = (M/2) f-1(x)\dotx2 - v(x). It is sufficient for the purpose of deriving the laws of quantum mechanics to consider only c-number variations of coordinate and time. The Euler-Lagrange equation, the canonical equations of motion and the canonical commutation relation are derived from the principle. All resulting relations are consistent with one another. Further, it is shown that an arbitrary point transformation leaves the forms of the fundamental equations invariant and is suitable to be called a canonical transformation. The appropriate choice of the Lagrangian operator is essential in our formulation.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Dec 1, 1972•6 citations

Schwinger's Variational Principle in Quantum Mechanics with Velocity Dependent Potential. III

Hideki Kamo, Toshiharu Kawai

Schwinger’s variational principle is formulated for the multi-dimensional quantum system which corresponds to the classical system described by the Lagrangian Lc(\dotx,x)=(M/2)gij(x)\dotxi\dotxj-v(x). The c-number variations of coordinates and time are sufficient to give the laws of quantum mechanics. The Euler-Lagrange equation, the canonical equations of motion and the canonical commutation relations are derived from this principle and there is no inconsistency. An appropriate choice of the Lagrangian operator is essential in our formulation. It is shown that an arbitrary point transformation is entitled to be called a canonical transformation. Ambiguities in the quantal Lagrangian are also discussed.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Aug 1, 1973•12 citations

Q-Number Variational Method for Non-Linear Lagrangian in Quantum Mechanics

T. Ohtani, Reiji Sugano

A previous q-number variational method is extended to be applicable to any quantum system for which the classical Lagrangian is given by Lc=½gij\dotqi\dotqj+ui\dotqi-v. The q-number variation is necessary for the formulation to be form-invariant under a general space-time transformation. From the action principle, not only the Euler-Lagrange equation but also the commutation relations up to a constant factor are obtained. Futhermore the form of the quantum Lagrangian is, to some extent, decided in order for solutions to exist for the action principle. It is shown that the first Noether theorem holds and the quantization is consistent with the canonical formalism.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Nov 1, 1973•14 citations
Consistency between the Lagrangean and the Hamiltonian formalisms in the quantum mechanics is investigatedc for the type of Lagrangean L=½\dotqigij(q)\dotqj-v(q) as an extension of a previous paper. The variations δqi and δ\dotqi should be considered as q-numbers. When the Lagrangean can be transformed into the standard form L=½\dotQα2-V(Q), the commutation relations of δqi and δ\dotqi with qj and \dotqj are found with the help of the Q-coordinate system. It is shown that using the commutation relations, the variation principle leads to the same equation of motion as the canonical equation of motion which is obtained in the previous paper.
Since the ordinary c-number variation principle does not lead, for a non-linear Lagrangian, to the result consistent between the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formalisms, Schwinger's variation principle is reformulated for a type of Lagrangian L=½\dotqigij(q)\dotqj-u(q) by means of a q-number variation. The canonical momentum, the Hamiltonian, the canonical commutation relations and equation of motion are derived. Also the Euler-Lagrange equation is obtained, which is consistent with the canonical equation of motion. These consequences are exactly the same as those of previous papers, but different from the ordinary ones in the Euler-Lagrange equation and the Hamiltonian.
It is shown that the variations δqj and δQi cannot both be simultaneously zero at the limits of integration in application of Hamilton’s principle to the development of the theory of canonical transformations. This means that δF1 does not vanish. However, the derivation requires only that the δqj be zero at the end points. This lack of symmetry between the qj and Qi in the formulaion is noted with respect to the Lagrangian and the fundamental commutator relations of quantum mechanics. Further, what is meant by an independent variation of pj and qj (or Qi and Pi) in the formalism is discussed in the use of Hamilton’s principle in the derivation of Hamilton’s equations of motion.
The variation principle has not been well defined in quantum mechanics for a Lagrangian containing a velocity dependent potential. We investigate the method of variation to derive an Euler-Lagrange equation in connection with Noether's theorem when the Lagrangian is invariant under some point transformation. Obtained are the Euler-Lagrange equation retaining the above invariance by means of the variation method and the Hamiltonian with which the canonical equation of motion leads to the Euler-Lagrange equation.
Schwinger's variational principle is formulated for the quantum system which corresponds to the one-dimensional classical system described by the Lagrangian Lc(\dotx, x) = (M/2) f-1(x)\dotx2 - v(x). It is sufficient for the purpose of deriving the laws of quantum mechanics to consider only c-number variations of coordinate and time. The Euler-Lagrange equation, the canonical equations of motion and the canonical commutation relation are derived from the principle. All resulting relations are consistent with one another. Further, it is shown that an arbitrary point transformation leaves the forms of the fundamental equations invariant and is suitable to be called a canonical transformation. The appropriate choice of the Lagrangian operator is essential in our formulation.
Schwinger’s variational principle is formulated for the multi-dimensional quantum system which corresponds to the classical system described by the Lagrangian Lc(\dotx,x)=(M/2)gij(x)\dotxi\dotxj-v(x). The c-number variations of coordinates and time are sufficient to give the laws of quantum mechanics. The Euler-Lagrange equation, the canonical equations of motion and the canonical commutation relations are derived from this principle and there is no inconsistency. An appropriate choice of the Lagrangian operator is essential in our formulation. It is shown that an arbitrary point transformation is entitled to be called a canonical transformation. Ambiguities in the quantal Lagrangian are also discussed.
A previous q-number variational method is extended to be applicable to any quantum system for which the classical Lagrangian is given by Lc=½gij\dotqi\dotqj+ui\dotqi-v. The q-number variation is necessary for the formulation to be form-invariant under a general space-time transformation. From the action principle, not only the Euler-Lagrange equation but also the commutation relations up to a constant factor are obtained. Futhermore the form of the quantum Lagrangian is, to some extent, decided in order for solutions to exist for the action principle. It is shown that the first Noether theorem holds and the quantization is consistent with the canonical formalism.