Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science

The Properties of Modal Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics

Rob Clifton

Published Sep 1, 1996• 90 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Orthodox quantum mechanics includes the principle that an observable of a system possesses a well-defined value if and only if the presence of that value in the system is certain to be confirmed on measurement. Modal interpretations reject the controversial ‘only if’ half of this principle to secure definite outcomes for quantum measurements that leave the apparatus entangled with the object it has measured. However, using a result that turns on the construction of a Kochen–Specker contradiction, I argue that modal interpretations cannot deliver a metaphysically tenable conception of properties in quantum mechanics unless they also abandon the less controversial ‘if’ half of the orthodox principle.

DOI
10.1093/bjps/47.3.371

Related papers

Independently Motivating the Kochen—Dieks Modal Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Rob Clifton

The distinguishing feature of ‘modal’ interpretations of quantum mechanics is their abandonment of the orthodox eigenstate–eigenvalue rule, which says that an observable possesses a definite value if and only if the system is in an eigenstate of that observable. Kochen's and Dieks' new biorthogonal decomposition rule for picking out which observables have definite values is designed specifically to overcome the chief problem generated by orthodoxy's rule, the measurement problem, while avoiding the no-hidden-variable theorems. Otherwise, their new rule seems completely ad hoc.The ad hoc charge can only be laid to rest if there is some way to give Kochen's and Dieks' rule for picking out which observables have definite values some independent motivation. And there is, or so I will argue here. Specifically, I shall show that theirs is the only rule able to save Schrödinger's cat from a fate worse than death, and sidestep the Bell–Kochen–Specker no-hidden-variables theorem, once we impose four independently natural conditions on such rules

The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science•Mar 1, 1995•83 citations

Properties, states, measurement outcomes and effective states

Pieter E. Vermaas

Starting with a more philosophical review, I discuss how modal interpretations describe reality. Firstly, it is shown that they describe states of affairs which need not be observable. Secondly, I underpin my position that in order to be metaphysically tenable, interpretations need only to satisfy the criteria of Consistency and Internal Completeness. Thirdly, I analyse how properties, states and measurement outcomes are related to one another within the modal descriptions of reality. Finally, I show how modal interpretations recover the standard formulation of quantum mechanics if one defines, in addition to the true states, so-called effective states of systems. Noumenal states of affairs The aim of an interpretation of quantum mechanics is, as I said in the introduction, to provide a description of what reality would be like if quantum mechanics were true. This formulation underlines two aspects of interpretations. Firstly, interpretations intend to construe quantum mechanics in terms of a description of reality and not merely in terms of the outcomes of measurements. Secondly, this description need not be correct. The objective is only to prove that there exists a construal of quantum mechanics which yields an acceptable description of reality. And because it is already difficult enough to give such a proof of existence, it is not (yet) the aim of interpretations to provide the one and only correct description of reality. The above formulation, however, disregards another aspect of interpretations of quantum mechanics, namely that they describe states of affairs which need not always be observable.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 5, 2010•0 citations

Logical Foundations for Modal Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics

Michael Dickson

This paper proposes a logic, motivated by modal interpretations, in which every quantum mechanics propositions has a truth-value. This logic is completely classical, hence violates the conditions of the Kochen-Specker theorem. It is shown how the violation occurs, and it is argued that this violation is a natural and acceptable consequence of modal interpretations. It is shown that despite its classicality, the proposed logic is empirically indistinguishable from quantum logic.

Philosophy of Science•Jan 1, 1996•1 citation

A Philosopher's Understanding of Quantum Mechanics: Possibilities and Impossibilities of a Modal Interpretation

Pieter E. Vermaas

This book is about how to understand quantum mechanics by means of a modal interpretation. Modal interpretations provide a general framework within which quantum mechanics can be considered as a theory that describes reality in terms of physical systems possessing definite properties. Quantum mechanics is standardly understood to be a theory about probabilities with which measurements have outcomes. Modal interpretations are relatively new attempts to present quantum mechanics as a theory which, like other physical theories, describes an observer-independent reality. In this book, Pieter Vermaas summarises the results of this work. The book will be of great value to undergraduates, graduate students and researchers in philosophy of science, and physics departments with an interest in learning about modal interpretations of quantum mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jan 1, 2000•7 citations

Kochen’s Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

Frank Arntzenius

It is well-known that developments of quantum mechanical states according to the Schrödinger equation during a measurement seem to prevent measurements from having definite results. For, the usually assumed (idealized) Schrödinger development of the measured object and the measuring apparatus during a measurement typically results in a state of the entire system which is a superposition of the eigenstates of the measured observable and measuring observable. And the most common interpretations of quantum mechanics state that an observable does not have a definite value if the quantum mechanical state is a superposition of the eigenstates of the observable. Many ways out of this problem have been suggested. I want to discuss an interpretation suggested by S. Kochen (Kochen 1985), and suggest similar interpretations, each of which accept the universal validity of the Schrödinger equation, and yet yield definite results for measurements.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1990•17 citations

Quantum Logic and the Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics

R. I. G. Hughes

There is no such thing as “The Quantum Logical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics”. Rather, there is a cluster of interpretations, all of which can be described as “quantum logical”. Here I provide a general framework for discussing interpretations of this kind, and then locate various suggestions within it. The presentation owes much to van Fraassen (see, in particular, van Fraassen 1974 ); his “modal interpretation” is one of those I discuss, along with those of Jauch, Putnam and Kochen. I begin by rehearsing some orthodox quantum theory. Within quantum mechanics we deal with a set 0 of measurable quantities, orobservables(position, momentum, components of spin and so on). Experiment can determine the value of an observable for a given system: the values so determined will be real numbers. A maximal amount of information about what the result would be for a given system, whatever experiment we chose to perform on it, is available once we know thestateof the system.

PSA Proceedings of the Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association•Jan 1, 1980•4 citations
Orthodox quantum mechanics includes the principle that an observable of a system possesses a well-defined value if and only if the presence of that value in the system is certain to be confirmed on measurement. Modal interpretations reject the controversial ‘only if’ half of this principle to secure definite outcomes for quantum measurements that leave the apparatus entangled with the object it has measured. However, using a result that turns on the construction of a Kochen–Specker contradiction, I argue that modal interpretations cannot deliver a metaphysically tenable conception of properties in quantum mechanics unless they also abandon the less controversial ‘if’ half of the orthodox principle.
The distinguishing feature of ‘modal’ interpretations of quantum mechanics is their abandonment of the orthodox eigenstate–eigenvalue rule, which says that an observable possesses a definite value if and only if the system is in an eigenstate of that observable. Kochen's and Dieks' new biorthogonal decomposition rule for picking out which observables have definite values is designed specifically to overcome the chief problem generated by orthodoxy's rule, the measurement problem, while avoiding the no-hidden-variable theorems. Otherwise, their new rule seems completely ad hoc.The ad hoc charge can only be laid to rest if there is some way to give Kochen's and Dieks' rule for picking out which observables have definite values some independent motivation. And there is, or so I will argue here. Specifically, I shall show that theirs is the only rule able to save Schrödinger's cat from a fate worse than death, and sidestep the Bell–Kochen–Specker no-hidden-variables theorem, once we impose four independently natural conditions on such rules
Starting with a more philosophical review, I discuss how modal interpretations describe reality. Firstly, it is shown that they describe states of affairs which need not be observable. Secondly, I underpin my position that in order to be metaphysically tenable, interpretations need only to satisfy the criteria of Consistency and Internal Completeness. Thirdly, I analyse how properties, states and measurement outcomes are related to one another within the modal descriptions of reality. Finally, I show how modal interpretations recover the standard formulation of quantum mechanics if one defines, in addition to the true states, so-called effective states of systems. Noumenal states of affairs The aim of an interpretation of quantum mechanics is, as I said in the introduction, to provide a description of what reality would be like if quantum mechanics were true. This formulation underlines two aspects of interpretations. Firstly, interpretations intend to construe quantum mechanics in terms of a description of reality and not merely in terms of the outcomes of measurements. Secondly, this description need not be correct. The objective is only to prove that there exists a construal of quantum mechanics which yields an acceptable description of reality. And because it is already difficult enough to give such a proof of existence, it is not (yet) the aim of interpretations to provide the one and only correct description of reality. The above formulation, however, disregards another aspect of interpretations of quantum mechanics, namely that they describe states of affairs which need not always be observable.
This book is about how to understand quantum mechanics by means of a modal interpretation. Modal interpretations provide a general framework within which quantum mechanics can be considered as a theory that describes reality in terms of physical systems possessing definite properties. Quantum mechanics is standardly understood to be a theory about probabilities with which measurements have outcomes. Modal interpretations are relatively new attempts to present quantum mechanics as a theory which, like other physical theories, describes an observer-independent reality. In this book, Pieter Vermaas summarises the results of this work. The book will be of great value to undergraduates, graduate students and researchers in philosophy of science, and physics departments with an interest in learning about modal interpretations of quantum mechanics.
It is well-known that developments of quantum mechanical states according to the Schrödinger equation during a measurement seem to prevent measurements from having definite results. For, the usually assumed (idealized) Schrödinger development of the measured object and the measuring apparatus during a measurement typically results in a state of the entire system which is a superposition of the eigenstates of the measured observable and measuring observable. And the most common interpretations of quantum mechanics state that an observable does not have a definite value if the quantum mechanical state is a superposition of the eigenstates of the observable. Many ways out of this problem have been suggested. I want to discuss an interpretation suggested by S. Kochen (Kochen 1985), and suggest similar interpretations, each of which accept the universal validity of the Schrödinger equation, and yet yield definite results for measurements.
There is no such thing as “The Quantum Logical Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics”. Rather, there is a cluster of interpretations, all of which can be described as “quantum logical”. Here I provide a general framework for discussing interpretations of this kind, and then locate various suggestions within it. The presentation owes much to van Fraassen (see, in particular, van Fraassen 1974 ); his “modal interpretation” is one of those I discuss, along with those of Jauch, Putnam and Kochen. I begin by rehearsing some orthodox quantum theory. Within quantum mechanics we deal with a set 0 of measurable quantities, orobservables(position, momentum, components of spin and so on). Experiment can determine the value of an observable for a given system: the values so determined will be real numbers. A maximal amount of information about what the result would be for a given system, whatever experiment we chose to perform on it, is available once we know thestateof the system.