Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Incoherent Scattering and the Concept of Discrete Electrons

Arthur Holly Compton

Published Mar 1, 1935• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Experiment has shown that scattered x-rays contain both a coherent and an incoherent portion. Classical electron theory provides a formula for scattering closely similar to that based on wave mechanics, but includes both coherent and incoherent components only if the atom consists of discrete electrons. From a comparison of the classical and wave-mechanics theories of scattering it is concluded that the most accurate classical analog of Schr\"odinger's $\ensuremath{\psi}{\ensuremath{\psi}}^{*}$ is the probability of occurrence of discrete electrons, and that a particular electron is associated with each particular function ${\ensuremath{\psi}}_{n}{{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{n}}^{*}$.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.47.367

Related papers

Introduction to Theoretical Treatments of Incoherent Light Scattering

Derek A. Long

This chapter contains sections titled: General considerations Induced oscillating electric dipoles as sources of scattered radiation Basis of the classical theory of light scattering Basis of the quantum mechanical treatment of incoherent light-scattering phenomena: electric dipole case Extension of quantum mechanical treatment of incoherent light scattering to include magnetic dipole and electric quadrupole cases Comparison of the classical and quantum mechanical treatments of light scattering The way ahead

Wiley eBooks•Apr 15, 2002•3 citations

Waves

WJ Mullin

Quantum mechanics is introduced here as a fundamental theory that must treat particles equally often as waves. Here, classical waves are introduced in some detail, with discussions of the important concepts of waves: medium, amplitude, frequency, wavelength, period, harmonics, interference, standing waves, etc. Waves can be oscillatory waves with a repeating pattern, or pulse waves, which are localized in space. All of the elements of waves are important in understanding how the Schrödinger equation describes particles. Classical standing waves must have wave lengths that fit between boundaries giving them discrete allowed frequencies, a harbinger of quantized energies in quantum mechanics. Complicated waves can be analyzed in terms of their component frequencies, the fundamental idea of Fourier analysis. This discussion shows that a classical wave has a limit in how accurately one can specify simultaneously the wave’s position and frequency, in analogy with Heisenberg uncertainty principle of quantum mechanics.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Mar 16, 2017•1 citation

Quantum theory of radiation

Hans R. Griem

Atoms and ions containing residual bound electrons do not quite resemble the simple harmonic oscillator model used so successfully in the classical theory of radiation. However, replacing the atoms or ions with sets of harmonic oscillators of a great number of discrete resonance frequencies and having various amplitudes, together with the results of classical radiation theory, go a long way toward a quantitative description of emission or absorption spectra. The set of resonance frequencies is obtained from measured or calculated energy levels using Ritz's combination principle. The amplitudes are associated with matrix elements of appropriate quantum mechanical operators between wave functions of the two energy eigenstates involved at a given frequency. In other words, quantities of the emitters, absorbers, or scatterers are described quantum-mechanically, whereas the electromagnetic field is treated classically.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Oct 2, 1997•19 citations

Electrons make waves

Akira Tonomura

At the atomic scale, the distinction between particles and waves breaks down. The realization, early in the twentieth century, that light consists of discrete packages, or “photons,” prompted the converse suggestion that particles could behave like waves. Confirmation of this idea came in 1927, from an experiment involving the scattering of electrons from a crystal. Today, “wave-particle duality” is central to quantum mechanics, and the wave properties of subatomic particles are widely used in microscopy and crystallography. Electron diffraction techniques are widely used to characterize atomic arrangements on solid surfaces and inside thin films, and to investigate the structures of molecules in gases. The dual nature of waves and particles is part of the “spookiness” of quantum mechanics, which cannot be explained in any classical way. It used to be that one could only imagine an experiment that would simultaneously demonstrate the particle and wave nature of electrons.

University of Chicago Press eBooks•Jan 1, 2003•0 citations

The Relation between Classical Mechanics and Wave Mechanics

Yoshio Nishiyama

Introducing a dimensional unit \hbar into classical mechanics, we make classical wave functions √ρ1exp (iS1/\hbar)-√ρ2exp (iS2/\hbar) for a one-particle system in the configuration space where √ρ1exp (iS1/\hbar) corresponds to the incident path (or one half) of an orbit and √ρ2exp (iS2/\hbar) to the outgoing (or another half), and ρ's and S's are densities and actions respectively. These classical wave functions are compared with the corresponding wave functions of solutions of the Schrödinger equation for three one-particle systems, the scattering by a Coulomb potential, the linear harmonic oscillator and an electron bound by a Coulomb potential. From the essential correspondence between them it is concluded that the Schrödinger wave function describes the steady, causal but a little imaginary motion of the one-particle system as √ρexp (iS/\hbar) in the configuration space where ρ is a density and S an action, and that the states which the wave equation describes exist continuously (not discrete) and the (discrete) stationary states are the ones where √ρexp (iS/\hbar) is uniquely determined throughout an orbit. The Dirac equation shows that an electron of optics (or the electromagnetic wave equation) can be considered as the Schrödinger (or Dirac) equation for the motion of a photon, a particle, in a potential. A quantum-electrodynamical wave equation which is composed of the Dirac equation with a Coulomb potential and the electromagnetic wave equation is constructed for the steady motion of a one-electron system without recource to the so-called second-quantization method. It gives finite energy shifts. A line shift is calculated: ΔE(2S1/2 →2P1/2) \cong709 Mc/s.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Nov 1, 1963•1 citation

A Concise Introduction to Quantum Mechanics

Mark S. Swanson

Assuming a background in basic classical physics, multivariable calculus, and differential equations, A Concise Introduction to Quantum Mechanics provides a self-contained presentation of the mathematics and physics of quantum mechanics. The relevant aspects of classical mechanics and electrodynamics are reviewed, and the basic concepts of wave-particle duality are developed as a logical outgrowth of experiments involving blackbody radiation, the photoelectric effect, and electron diffraction. The Copenhagen interpretation of the wave function and its relation to the particle probability density is presented in conjunction with Fourier analysis and its generalization to function spaces. These concepts are combined to analyze the system consisting of a particle confined to a box, developing the probabilistic interpretation of observations and their associated expectation values. The Schrödinger equation is then derived by using these results and demanding both Galilean invariance of the probability density and Newtonian energy-momentum relations. The general properties of the Schrödinger equation and its solutions are analyzed, and the theory of observables is developed along with the associated Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Basic applications of wave mechanics are made to free wave packet spreading, barrier penetration, the simple harmonic oscillator, the Hydrogen atom, and an electric charge in a uniform magnetic field. In addition, Dirac notation, elements of Hilbert space theory, operator techniques, and matrix algebra are presented and used to analyze coherent states, the linear potential, two state oscillations, and electron diffraction. Applications are made to photon and electron spin and the addition of angular momentum, and direct product multiparticle states are used to formulate both the Pauli exclusion principle and quantum decoherence. The book concludes with an introduction to the rotation group and the general properties of angular momentum.

Morgan & Claypool Publishers eBooks•Feb 1, 2018•4 citations
Experiment has shown that scattered x-rays contain both a coherent and an incoherent portion. Classical electron theory provides a formula for scattering closely similar to that based on wave mechanics, but includes both coherent and incoherent components only if the atom consists of discrete electrons. From a comparison of the classical and wave-mechanics theories of scattering it is concluded that the most accurate classical analog of Schr"odinger's \ensuremathψ\ensuremathψ∗\ensuremath{\psi}{\ensuremath{\psi}}^{*}\ensuremathψ\ensuremathψ∗ is the probability of occurrence of discrete electrons, and that a particular electron is associated with each particular function \ensuremathψn\ensuremathψn∗{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{n}{{\ensuremath{\psi}}_{n}}^{*}\ensuremathψn​\ensuremathψn​∗.
This chapter contains sections titled: General considerations Induced oscillating electric dipoles as sources of scattered radiation Basis of the classical theory of light scattering Basis of the quantum mechanical treatment of incoherent light-scattering phenomena: electric dipole case Extension of quantum mechanical treatment of incoherent light scattering to include magnetic dipole and electric quadrupole cases Comparison of the classical and quantum mechanical treatments of light scattering The way ahead
Quantum mechanics is introduced here as a fundamental theory that must treat particles equally often as waves. Here, classical waves are introduced in some detail, with discussions of the important concepts of waves: medium, amplitude, frequency, wavelength, period, harmonics, interference, standing waves, etc. Waves can be oscillatory waves with a repeating pattern, or pulse waves, which are localized in space. All of the elements of waves are important in understanding how the Schrödinger equation describes particles. Classical standing waves must have wave lengths that fit between boundaries giving them discrete allowed frequencies, a harbinger of quantized energies in quantum mechanics. Complicated waves can be analyzed in terms of their component frequencies, the fundamental idea of Fourier analysis. This discussion shows that a classical wave has a limit in how accurately one can specify simultaneously the wave’s position and frequency, in analogy with Heisenberg uncertainty principle of quantum mechanics.
Atoms and ions containing residual bound electrons do not quite resemble the simple harmonic oscillator model used so successfully in the classical theory of radiation. However, replacing the atoms or ions with sets of harmonic oscillators of a great number of discrete resonance frequencies and having various amplitudes, together with the results of classical radiation theory, go a long way toward a quantitative description of emission or absorption spectra. The set of resonance frequencies is obtained from measured or calculated energy levels using Ritz's combination principle. The amplitudes are associated with matrix elements of appropriate quantum mechanical operators between wave functions of the two energy eigenstates involved at a given frequency. In other words, quantities of the emitters, absorbers, or scatterers are described quantum-mechanically, whereas the electromagnetic field is treated classically.
At the atomic scale, the distinction between particles and waves breaks down. The realization, early in the twentieth century, that light consists of discrete packages, or “photons,” prompted the converse suggestion that particles could behave like waves. Confirmation of this idea came in 1927, from an experiment involving the scattering of electrons from a crystal. Today, “wave-particle duality” is central to quantum mechanics, and the wave properties of subatomic particles are widely used in microscopy and crystallography. Electron diffraction techniques are widely used to characterize atomic arrangements on solid surfaces and inside thin films, and to investigate the structures of molecules in gases. The dual nature of waves and particles is part of the “spookiness” of quantum mechanics, which cannot be explained in any classical way. It used to be that one could only imagine an experiment that would simultaneously demonstrate the particle and wave nature of electrons.
Introducing a dimensional unit \hbar into classical mechanics, we make classical wave functions √ρ1exp (iS1/\hbar)-√ρ2exp (iS2/\hbar) for a one-particle system in the configuration space where √ρ1exp (iS1/\hbar) corresponds to the incident path (or one half) of an orbit and √ρ2exp (iS2/\hbar) to the outgoing (or another half), and ρ's and S's are densities and actions respectively. These classical wave functions are compared with the corresponding wave functions of solutions of the Schrödinger equation for three one-particle systems, the scattering by a Coulomb potential, the linear harmonic oscillator and an electron bound by a Coulomb potential. From the essential correspondence between them it is concluded that the Schrödinger wave function describes the steady, causal but a little imaginary motion of the one-particle system as √ρexp (iS/\hbar) in the configuration space where ρ is a density and S an action, and that the states which the wave equation describes exist continuously (not discrete) and the (discrete) stationary states are the ones where √ρexp (iS/\hbar) is uniquely determined throughout an orbit. The Dirac equation shows that an electron of optics (or the electromagnetic wave equation) can be considered as the Schrödinger (or Dirac) equation for the motion of a photon, a particle, in a potential. A quantum-electrodynamical wave equation which is composed of the Dirac equation with a Coulomb potential and the electromagnetic wave equation is constructed for the steady motion of a one-electron system without recource to the so-called second-quantization method. It gives finite energy shifts. A line shift is calculated: ΔE(2S1/2 →2P1/2) \cong709 Mc/s.
Assuming a background in basic classical physics, multivariable calculus, and differential equations, A Concise Introduction to Quantum Mechanics provides a self-contained presentation of the mathematics and physics of quantum mechanics. The relevant aspects of classical mechanics and electrodynamics are reviewed, and the basic concepts of wave-particle duality are developed as a logical outgrowth of experiments involving blackbody radiation, the photoelectric effect, and electron diffraction. The Copenhagen interpretation of the wave function and its relation to the particle probability density is presented in conjunction with Fourier analysis and its generalization to function spaces. These concepts are combined to analyze the system consisting of a particle confined to a box, developing the probabilistic interpretation of observations and their associated expectation values. The Schrödinger equation is then derived by using these results and demanding both Galilean invariance of the probability density and Newtonian energy-momentum relations. The general properties of the Schrödinger equation and its solutions are analyzed, and the theory of observables is developed along with the associated Heisenberg uncertainty principle. Basic applications of wave mechanics are made to free wave packet spreading, barrier penetration, the simple harmonic oscillator, the Hydrogen atom, and an electric charge in a uniform magnetic field. In addition, Dirac notation, elements of Hilbert space theory, operator techniques, and matrix algebra are presented and used to analyze coherent states, the linear potential, two state oscillations, and electron diffraction. Applications are made to photon and electron spin and the addition of angular momentum, and direct product multiparticle states are used to formulate both the Pauli exclusion principle and quantum decoherence. The book concludes with an introduction to the rotation group and the general properties of angular momentum.