Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Beyond the random-phase approximation: A new approximation scheme for the polarization propagator

J. Schirmer

Published Nov 1, 1982• 1,119 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Within the framework of the many-body Green's-function method we present a new approach to the polarization propagator for finite Fermi systems. This approach makes explicit use of the diagrammatic perturbation expansion for the polarization propagator, and reformulates the exact summation in terms of a simple algebraic scheme, referred to as the algebraic diagrammatic construction (ADC). The ADC defines in a natural way a set of approximation schemes ($n$th-order ADC schemes) which represent infinite partial summations exact up to $n$th order of perturbation theory. In contrast to the random-phase-approximation (RPA)-like schemes, the corresponding mathematical procedures are essentially Hermitian eigenvalue problems in limited configuration spaces of unperturbed excited configurations. Explicit equations for the first- and second-order ADC schemes are derived. These schemes are thoroughly discussed and compared with the Tamm-Dancoff approximation and RPA schemes.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.26.2395

Related papers

New approach to the one-particle Green's function for finite Fermi systems

J. Schirmer, Lorenz S. Cederbaum, Olaf Walter

A new approach to the one-particle Green's functions $\mathit{G}$ for finite electronic systems is presented. This approach is based on the diagrammatic perturbation expansions of the Green's function and of the dynamic self-energy part $\mathit{M}$ related to $\mathit{G}$ via the Dyson equation. The exact summation of the latter expansion is reformulated in terms of a simple algebraic form referred to as algebraic diagrammatic construction (ADC). The ADC defines in a systematical way a set of approximation schemes ($n\mathrm{th}$-order ADC schemes) that represent infinite partial summations for $\mathit{M}$ and (via the Dyson equation) for $\mathit{G}$ being complete through $n\mathrm{th}$ order of perturbation theory. The corresponding mathematical procedures are essentially Hermitian eigenvalue problems in restricted configuration spaces of unperturbed ionic configurations. Explicit equations for the second-, third-, and fourth-order ADC schemes are derived and analyzed. While the second- and third-order schemes can be viewed as systematic rederivations of previous approximation schemes, the fourth-order ADC scheme represents a complete fourth-order approximation for the self-energy and the one-particle Green's function which was hitherto not available.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1983•729 citations

Particle-particle propagator in the algebraic diagrammatic construction scheme at third order

A. Tarantelli, Lorenz S. Cederbaum

The algebraic diagrammatic construction scheme at nth order includes all Feynman diagrams up to nth order and a partial summation of diagrams arising from the latter to infinite order. In the present work this scheme is carried out for the first time at third order for the particle-particle propagator. Because of the many diagrams involved in third order the approach requires a very careful analysis of terms which describe the corresponding perturbation expansion of the propagator. The relevant technical details of the analysis are presented.

Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1989•60 citations

Connection between Green’s functions and effective Hamiltonians: Particle-particle propagator

A. Tarantelli, L. S. Cederbaum

A purely algebraic approach to Green's functions is presented. The new formulation allows the determination of a closed-form equation for Green's functions which depends only on the ground state of the system. By a straightforward perturbation expansion of this state an interesting approximation scheme is obtained which is nonperturbative in the final states (e.g., excited or ionic states). This method, which can be used for various propagators, is explicitly applied to the particle-particle propagator carrying out the scheme up to third order. The approach is discussed in detail and briefly compared with the well-established algebraic diagrammatic construction approximation scheme.

Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1989•43 citations

Excited states in finite systems

After studying various approaches to describe the sp propagator in a manyfermion system in Chs. 10 and 11, it is now time to discuss the description of excited states of the system with N particles. In Sec. 13.1 the relevant limit of the tp propagator G II , appropriate for the calculation of these excited states, is introduced. It is possible to develop all the details of the corresponding diagrammatic expansion of this so-called particle–hole (ph) or polarization propagator. Assuming that the reader is now sufficiently familiar with the procedure, a somewhat different approach will be applied. We will identify in Sec. 13.2 the minimal set of diagrams generating a pole structure, similar to the one of the exact polarization propagator. The resulting approximation is widely used, and while the name is not too illuminating at first, it is historically called the random phase approximation (RPA). In Sec. 21.4 the RPA will be linked to the Hartree–Fock description of the sp propagator. In Sec. 13.3 a simple model is employed to illustrate the scope of the RPA in a finite system. Many of the observed properties of excited states in many-fermion systems can be interpreted in terms of this schematic model. Especially the appearance of collective states in relation to the character of the ph interaction, whether on average attractive or repulsive, can be illustrated fruitfully. Collective features also appear in the transition strength to the ground state. The energy-weighted sum rule for the RPA transition strength is the subject of Sec. 13.4. Excited states of atoms are discussed in Sec. 13.5. The summation of diagrams, involved in calculating excited states, can be applied to the determination of the so-called correlation energy as well. This topic is briefly discussed in Sec. 13.6. The chapter concludes with the derivation in Sec. 13.7 of the RPA equations in the angular momentum coupled representation.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 13, 2025•0 citations

First-order static excitation potential: Scheme for excitation energies and transition moments

Joachim Brand, Lorenz S. Cederbaum

We present an approximation scheme for the calculation of the principal excitation energies and transition moments of finite many-body systems. The scheme is derived from a first-order approximation to the self-energy of a recently proposed extended particle-hole Green's function. A Hermitian eigenvalue problem is encountered of the same size as the well-known random phase approximation (RPA). We find that it yields a size consistent description of the excitation properties and removes an inconsistent treatment of the ground-state correlation by the RPA. By presenting a Hermitian eigenvalue problem the new scheme avoids the instabilities of the RPA and should be well suited for large-scale numerical calculations. These and additional properties of the new approximation scheme are illuminated by a very simple exactly solvable model.

arXiv:physics/9710033•Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1998•8 citations

Particle-hole excitations within a self-consistent random-phase approximation

D. Gambacurta, F. Catara

We present a method for the treatment of correlations in finite Fermi systems in a more consistent way than the random phase approximation (RPA). The main differences with respect to previous approaches are underlined and discussed. In particular, no use of renormalized operators is made. By means of the method of linearization of equations of motion, we derive a set of RPA-like equations depending only on the one-body density matrix. The latter is no more assumed to be diagonal and it is expressed in terms of the $X$ and $Y$ amplitudes of the particle-hole phonon operators. This set of nonlinear equations is solved via an iterative procedure, which allows us to calculate the energies and the wave functions of the excited states. After presenting our approach in its general formulation, we test its quality by using metal clusters as a good test laboratory for a generic many-body system. Comparison to RPA shows significant improvements. We discuss also how the present approach can be further extended beyond the particle-hole configuration space, getting an approximation scheme in which energy weighted sum rules are exactly preserved, thus solving a problem common to all extension of RPA proposed until now. The implementation of such approach will be afforded in a future work.

Physical Review B•May 23, 2008•15 citations
Within the framework of the many-body Green's-function method we present a new approach to the polarization propagator for finite Fermi systems. This approach makes explicit use of the diagrammatic perturbation expansion for the polarization propagator, and reformulates the exact summation in terms of a simple algebraic scheme, referred to as the algebraic diagrammatic construction (ADC). The ADC defines in a natural way a set of approximation schemes (nnnth-order ADC schemes) which represent infinite partial summations exact up to nnnth order of perturbation theory. In contrast to the random-phase-approximation (RPA)-like schemes, the corresponding mathematical procedures are essentially Hermitian eigenvalue problems in limited configuration spaces of unperturbed excited configurations. Explicit equations for the first- and second-order ADC schemes are derived. These schemes are thoroughly discussed and compared with the Tamm-Dancoff approximation and RPA schemes.
A new approach to the one-particle Green's functions G\mathit{G}G for finite electronic systems is presented. This approach is based on the diagrammatic perturbation expansions of the Green's function and of the dynamic self-energy part M\mathit{M}M related to G\mathit{G}G via the Dyson equation. The exact summation of the latter expansion is reformulated in terms of a simple algebraic form referred to as algebraic diagrammatic construction (ADC). The ADC defines in a systematical way a set of approximation schemes (nthn\mathrm{th}nth-order ADC schemes) that represent infinite partial summations for M\mathit{M}M and (via the Dyson equation) for G\mathit{G}G being complete through nthn\mathrm{th}nth order of perturbation theory. The corresponding mathematical procedures are essentially Hermitian eigenvalue problems in restricted configuration spaces of unperturbed ionic configurations. Explicit equations for the second-, third-, and fourth-order ADC schemes are derived and analyzed. While the second- and third-order schemes can be viewed as systematic rederivations of previous approximation schemes, the fourth-order ADC scheme represents a complete fourth-order approximation for the self-energy and the one-particle Green's function which was hitherto not available.
The algebraic diagrammatic construction scheme at nth order includes all Feynman diagrams up to nth order and a partial summation of diagrams arising from the latter to infinite order. In the present work this scheme is carried out for the first time at third order for the particle-particle propagator. Because of the many diagrams involved in third order the approach requires a very careful analysis of terms which describe the corresponding perturbation expansion of the propagator. The relevant technical details of the analysis are presented.
A purely algebraic approach to Green's functions is presented. The new formulation allows the determination of a closed-form equation for Green's functions which depends only on the ground state of the system. By a straightforward perturbation expansion of this state an interesting approximation scheme is obtained which is nonperturbative in the final states (e.g., excited or ionic states). This method, which can be used for various propagators, is explicitly applied to the particle-particle propagator carrying out the scheme up to third order. The approach is discussed in detail and briefly compared with the well-established algebraic diagrammatic construction approximation scheme.
After studying various approaches to describe the sp propagator in a manyfermion system in Chs. 10 and 11, it is now time to discuss the description of excited states of the system with N particles. In Sec. 13.1 the relevant limit of the tp propagator G II , appropriate for the calculation of these excited states, is introduced. It is possible to develop all the details of the corresponding diagrammatic expansion of this so-called particle–hole (ph) or polarization propagator. Assuming that the reader is now sufficiently familiar with the procedure, a somewhat different approach will be applied. We will identify in Sec. 13.2 the minimal set of diagrams generating a pole structure, similar to the one of the exact polarization propagator. The resulting approximation is widely used, and while the name is not too illuminating at first, it is historically called the random phase approximation (RPA). In Sec. 21.4 the RPA will be linked to the Hartree–Fock description of the sp propagator. In Sec. 13.3 a simple model is employed to illustrate the scope of the RPA in a finite system. Many of the observed properties of excited states in many-fermion systems can be interpreted in terms of this schematic model. Especially the appearance of collective states in relation to the character of the ph interaction, whether on average attractive or repulsive, can be illustrated fruitfully. Collective features also appear in the transition strength to the ground state. The energy-weighted sum rule for the RPA transition strength is the subject of Sec. 13.4. Excited states of atoms are discussed in Sec. 13.5. The summation of diagrams, involved in calculating excited states, can be applied to the determination of the so-called correlation energy as well. This topic is briefly discussed in Sec. 13.6. The chapter concludes with the derivation in Sec. 13.7 of the RPA equations in the angular momentum coupled representation.
We present an approximation scheme for the calculation of the principal excitation energies and transition moments of finite many-body systems. The scheme is derived from a first-order approximation to the self-energy of a recently proposed extended particle-hole Green's function. A Hermitian eigenvalue problem is encountered of the same size as the well-known random phase approximation (RPA). We find that it yields a size consistent description of the excitation properties and removes an inconsistent treatment of the ground-state correlation by the RPA. By presenting a Hermitian eigenvalue problem the new scheme avoids the instabilities of the RPA and should be well suited for large-scale numerical calculations. These and additional properties of the new approximation scheme are illuminated by a very simple exactly solvable model.
We present a method for the treatment of correlations in finite Fermi systems in a more consistent way than the random phase approximation (RPA). The main differences with respect to previous approaches are underlined and discussed. In particular, no use of renormalized operators is made. By means of the method of linearization of equations of motion, we derive a set of RPA-like equations depending only on the one-body density matrix. The latter is no more assumed to be diagonal and it is expressed in terms of the XXX and YYY amplitudes of the particle-hole phonon operators. This set of nonlinear equations is solved via an iterative procedure, which allows us to calculate the energies and the wave functions of the excited states. After presenting our approach in its general formulation, we test its quality by using metal clusters as a good test laboratory for a generic many-body system. Comparison to RPA shows significant improvements. We discuss also how the present approach can be further extended beyond the particle-hole configuration space, getting an approximation scheme in which energy weighted sum rules are exactly preserved, thus solving a problem common to all extension of RPA proposed until now. The implementation of such approach will be afforded in a future work.