Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Monte Carlo Test of Theories for the Planar Model, the F Model, and Related Systems

William J. Shugard, John D. Weeks, George H. Gilmer

Published Nov 13, 1978• 112 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We have performed Monte Carlo simulations for correlation functions in various solid-on-solid models, some of which are equivalent to the $F$ model, the two-dimensional Coulomb gas, and the planar model. Our results for the $F$ model can be quantitatively represented using the theory of Kosterlitz and Thouless. We use this theory to help determine the transition temperatures in other systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.41.1399

Related papers

Two-dimensional Coulomb gas: A Monte Carlo study

Y. Saito, Heiner Muller-Krumbhaar

The two-dimensional Coulomb gas with logarithmic interaction is studied by Monte Carlo simulation. We find clear evidence for the existence of a phase transition without referring to any theory. The analysis relies on the duality between Coulomb gas and discrete Gaussian model. The transition point ${T}_{c}$ is in excellent agreement with the Kosterlitz theory. The correlation functions support the renormalization-group results and disagree with the mean-field results.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 1, 1981•62 citations

Monte Carlo simulation of the planar model using the dual solid-on-solid representation

William J. Shugard, John D. Weeks, George H. Gilmer

The results of a Monte Carlo (MC) simulation of the planar ($\mathrm{XY}$) model in the dual "solid-on-solid" representation are reported. Our estimate for the reduced transition temperature ${T}_{c}$ of 0.90 and our finding of a rather sharp peak in the specific heat about 18% above ${T}_{c}$ are in good agreement with recent MC calculations in the spin representation.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jun 1, 1980•17 citations

The Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition: an introduction for the intrepid student

Victor Drouin-Touchette

This is a set of notes recalling some of the most important results on the XY model from the ground up. They are meant for a junior researcher wanting to get accustomed to the Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition in the context of the 2D classical XY model. The connection to the 2D Coulomb gas is presented in detail, as well as the renormalization group flow obtained from this dual representation. A numerical Monte-Carlo approach to the classical XY model is presented. Finally, two physical setting that realize the celebrated Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition are presented: superfluid and liquid crystal thin films.

arXiv:2207.13748•Jul 27, 2022•11 citations

Monte Carlo Test of Theories for the Planar Model, the F Model and Related Systems.

William J. Shugard, John D. Weeks, George H. Gilmer

Physical Review Letters•Nov 27, 1978•8 citations

Phase transitions in effective lattice models for strongly correlated systems

Steinar Kragset

In three research articles we have studied the critical properties of effective lattice models for strongly correlated electron systems by Monte Carlo simulations. A similar model is used in a fourth article for investigating thermal fluctuations of vortices in a rotating Bose–Einstein condensate. In the first part of this thesis we review the necessary background and introduce the models one by one. The last part is a collection of the papers.\n\nPaper I [1]: We consider the scaling of the mean square dipole moment in a plasma with logarithmic interactions in a two- and three-dimensional system. In both cases, we establish the existence of a low-temperature regime where the mean square dipole moment does not scale with system size and a hightemperature regime does scale with system size. Thus, there is a nonanalytic change in the polarizability of the system as a function of temperature, and hence a metal-insulator transition in both cases. The relevance of this transition in three dimensions to quantum phase transitions in 2 + 1-dimensional systems is briefly discussed.\n\nPaper II [2]: The existence of a discontinuity in the inverse dielectric constant of the two-dimensional Coulomb gas is demonstrated on purely numerical grounds. This is done by expanding the free energy in an applied twist and performing a finite-size scaling analysis of the coefficients of higher-order terms. The phase transition, driven by unbinding of dipoles, corresponds to the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in the 2D XY model. The method developed is also used for investigating the possibility of a Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition in a threedimensional system of point charges interacting with a logarithmic pair-potential, a system related to effective theories of low-dimensional strongly correlated systems. We also contrast the finite-size scaling of the fluctuations of the dipole moments of the two-dimensional Coulomb gas and the three-dimensional logarithmic system to those of the three-dimensional Coulomb gas.\n\nPaper III [3]: We perform large-scale Monte Carlo simulations on an effective gauge theory for an easy plane quantum anti-ferromagnet, including a Berry phase term that projects out the S = 1/2 sector. Without a Berry phase term, the model exhibits a phase transition in the 3DXY universality class associated with proliferation of gauge-charge neutral U(1) vortices. The instantons that eliminate the phase transition in the gauge-charged sector are cancelled by the Berry phases. The result is a first order phase transition. This gauge theory therefore does not exhibit deconfined criticality.\n\nPaper IV [4]: We perform Monte Carlo studies of vortices in three dimensions in a cylindrical confinement, with uniform and nonuniform density. The former is relevant to rotating 4He, the latter is relevant to a rotating trapped Bose condensate. In the former case we find dominant angular thermal vortex fluctuations close to the cylinder wall. For the latter case, a novel effect is that at low temperatures the vortex solid close to the center of the trap crosses directly over to a tension-less vortex tangle near the edge of the trap. At higher temperatures an intermediate tensionful vortex liquid located between the vortex solid and the vortex tangle, may exist.

•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

The Binder cumulant at the Kosterlitz–Thouless transition

Martin Hasenbusch B

We study the behaviour of the Binder cumulant on finite square lattices at the Kosterlitz–Thouless phase transition. We determine the fixed-point value of the Binder cumulant and the coefficient of the leading logarithmic correction. These calculations are supplemented with Monte Carlo simulations of the classical XY (plane rotator) model, the Villain model and the dual of the absolute value solid-on-solid model. Using the single-cluster algorithm, we simulate lattices up to L = 4096. For the lattice sizes reached, subleading corrections are needed to fit the data for the Binder cumulant. We demonstrate that the combined analysis of the Binder cumulant and the second moment correlation length over the lattice size allows for an accurate determination of the Kosterlitz–Thouless transition temperature on relatively small lattices. We test the new method on the example of the two-component ϕ 4 model on the lattice.

arXiv:0804.1880•Journal of Statistical Mechanics Theory and Experiment•Aug 11, 2008•48 citations
We have performed Monte Carlo simulations for correlation functions in various solid-on-solid models, some of which are equivalent to the FFF model, the two-dimensional Coulomb gas, and the planar model. Our results for the FFF model can be quantitatively represented using the theory of Kosterlitz and Thouless. We use this theory to help determine the transition temperatures in other systems.
The two-dimensional Coulomb gas with logarithmic interaction is studied by Monte Carlo simulation. We find clear evidence for the existence of a phase transition without referring to any theory. The analysis relies on the duality between Coulomb gas and discrete Gaussian model. The transition point Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ is in excellent agreement with the Kosterlitz theory. The correlation functions support the renormalization-group results and disagree with the mean-field results.
The results of a Monte Carlo (MC) simulation of the planar (XY\mathrm{XY}XY) model in the dual "solid-on-solid" representation are reported. Our estimate for the reduced transition temperature Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ of 0.90 and our finding of a rather sharp peak in the specific heat about 18% above Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ are in good agreement with recent MC calculations in the spin representation.
This is a set of notes recalling some of the most important results on the XY model from the ground up. They are meant for a junior researcher wanting to get accustomed to the Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition in the context of the 2D classical XY model. The connection to the 2D Coulomb gas is presented in detail, as well as the renormalization group flow obtained from this dual representation. A numerical Monte-Carlo approach to the classical XY model is presented. Finally, two physical setting that realize the celebrated Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition are presented: superfluid and liquid crystal thin films.
In three research articles we have studied the critical properties of effective lattice models for strongly correlated electron systems by Monte Carlo simulations. A similar model is used in a fourth article for investigating thermal fluctuations of vortices in a rotating Bose–Einstein condensate. In the first part of this thesis we review the necessary background and introduce the models one by one. The last part is a collection of the papers.\n\nPaper I [1]: We consider the scaling of the mean square dipole moment in a plasma with logarithmic interactions in a two- and three-dimensional system. In both cases, we establish the existence of a low-temperature regime where the mean square dipole moment does not scale with system size and a hightemperature regime does scale with system size. Thus, there is a nonanalytic change in the polarizability of the system as a function of temperature, and hence a metal-insulator transition in both cases. The relevance of this transition in three dimensions to quantum phase transitions in 2 + 1-dimensional systems is briefly discussed.\n\nPaper II [2]: The existence of a discontinuity in the inverse dielectric constant of the two-dimensional Coulomb gas is demonstrated on purely numerical grounds. This is done by expanding the free energy in an applied twist and performing a finite-size scaling analysis of the coefficients of higher-order terms. The phase transition, driven by unbinding of dipoles, corresponds to the Kosterlitz-Thouless transition in the 2D XY model. The method developed is also used for investigating the possibility of a Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition in a threedimensional system of point charges interacting with a logarithmic pair-potential, a system related to effective theories of low-dimensional strongly correlated systems. We also contrast the finite-size scaling of the fluctuations of the dipole moments of the two-dimensional Coulomb gas and the three-dimensional logarithmic system to those of the three-dimensional Coulomb gas.\n\nPaper III [3]: We perform large-scale Monte Carlo simulations on an effective gauge theory for an easy plane quantum anti-ferromagnet, including a Berry phase term that projects out the S = 1/2 sector. Without a Berry phase term, the model exhibits a phase transition in the 3DXY universality class associated with proliferation of gauge-charge neutral U(1) vortices. The instantons that eliminate the phase transition in the gauge-charged sector are cancelled by the Berry phases. The result is a first order phase transition. This gauge theory therefore does not exhibit deconfined criticality.\n\nPaper IV [4]: We perform Monte Carlo studies of vortices in three dimensions in a cylindrical confinement, with uniform and nonuniform density. The former is relevant to rotating 4He, the latter is relevant to a rotating trapped Bose condensate. In the former case we find dominant angular thermal vortex fluctuations close to the cylinder wall. For the latter case, a novel effect is that at low temperatures the vortex solid close to the center of the trap crosses directly over to a tension-less vortex tangle near the edge of the trap. At higher temperatures an intermediate tensionful vortex liquid located between the vortex solid and the vortex tangle, may exist.
We study the behaviour of the Binder cumulant on finite square lattices at the Kosterlitz–Thouless phase transition. We determine the fixed-point value of the Binder cumulant and the coefficient of the leading logarithmic correction. These calculations are supplemented with Monte Carlo simulations of the classical XY (plane rotator) model, the Villain model and the dual of the absolute value solid-on-solid model. Using the single-cluster algorithm, we simulate lattices up to L = 4096. For the lattice sizes reached, subleading corrections are needed to fit the data for the Binder cumulant. We demonstrate that the combined analysis of the Binder cumulant and the second moment correlation length over the lattice size allows for an accurate determination of the Kosterlitz–Thouless transition temperature on relatively small lattices. We test the new method on the example of the two-component ϕ 4 model on the lattice.