Two experiments of fundamental interest utilizing photon counting techniques are discussed. The first, not carried out as yet, aims to demonstrate an unusual phenomenon known as photon antibunching. Particular consideration is given to the experimental realization of the specific essentially nonclassical states of the electromagnetic field in which antibunching is observed. The second experiment, already carried out successfully, is concerned with the old quantum mechanical problem of the existence of hidden variables. This provides a very sensitive test of the fundamental quantum-mechanical concepts, and the results clearly confirm the quantum-mechanical prediction, and rule out any theories of local hidden variables.
Two experiments of fundamental interest utilizing photon counting techniques are discussed. The first, not carried out as yet, aims to demonstrate an unusual phenomenon known as photon antibunching. Particular consideration is given to the experimental realization of the specific essentially nonclassical states of the electromagnetic field in which antibunching is observed. The second experiment, already carried out successfully, is concerned with the old quantum mechanical problem of the existence of hidden variables. This provides a very sensitive test of the fundamental quantum-mechanical concepts, and the results clearly confirm the quantum-mechanical prediction, and rule out any theories of local hidden variables.
A review is given of recent theoretical studies devoted to the problem of generating radiation fields that exhibit the opposite of the well-known bunching of photons observed in light from thermal sources, the so-called antibunching effect. It is made clear that this phenomenon reflects the corpuscular nature of light and, hence, cannot be interpreted in terms of classical electrodynamics, needing, instead, the quantum-mechanical formalism for its description. It is shown in some detail that nonlinear interaction mechanisms like multiphoton absorption and parametric three-wave interaction are suited to change the photon statistical properties of incident (in most cases coherent) light such that the output field will be endowed with antibunching properties. Special emphasis is given to the problem of correctly specifying the dimensions of the mode volume occurring in the usual single-mode treatment of the field, which is, in fact, of great practical interest, since the magnitude of the antibunching effect is determined by the inverse average number of photons contained in that volume. In a later section it is pointed out that destructive interference with a coherent reference beam provides a means of (a) effectively enhancing photon antibunching that is already present in a high-intensity field, through reduction of the intensity, and (b) transforming phase fluctuations produced in a Kerr medium into antibunching-type intensity fluctuations. On the other hand, there exists a way of directly generating light with antibunching properties, the physical mechanism being resonance fluorescence from a single atom. The main features of this technique, both theoretical and experimental, are outlined, including a discussion of the first experimental results obtained a few years ago.
Over the past three decades or so, experiments of the type called Gedanken have become real. Recall the Schrödinger quote from Chapter 8: “… we never experiment with just one electron or atom or (small) molecule.” This is no longer true. We can do experiments involving single atoms or molecules and even on single photons, and thus it becomes possible to demonstrate that the “ridiculous consequences” alluded to by Schrödinger are, in fact, quite real. We have already discussed some examples of single-photon experiments in Chapter 6, and in Chapter 10 we shall discuss experiments performed with single atoms and single trapped ions. In the present chapter, we shall elaborate further on experimental tests of fundamentals of quantum mechanics involving a small number of photons. By fundamental tests we mean tests of quantum mechanics against the predictions of local realistic theories (i.e. hidden variable theories). Specifically, we discuss optical experiments demonstrating violations of Bell's inequalities, violations originally discussed by Bell in the context of two spin-one-half particles. Such violations, if observed experimentally, falsify local realistic hidden-variable theories. Locality refers to the notion, familiar in classical physics, that there cannot be a causal relationship between events with space-like separations. That is, the events cannot be connected by any signal moving at, or less than, the speed of light; i.e. the events are outside the light-cone. But in quantum mechanics, it appears that nonlocal effects, effects seemly violating the classical notion of locality in a certain restricted sense, are possible.
The studies concerning the possible existence of a deterministic theory, of which quantum mechanics would be an approximation, date to the celebrated 1935 Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paper. Since Bell's proposal of 1964 various experiments were addressed to a general experimental test of local hidden variable theories, leading to strong indications favourable to Standard Quantum Mechanics. Nevertheless, detection loophole still persists. After a short presentation of recent PDC photon experiments, we will present our recent works in this field and, in particular, a conclusive negative test of stochastic electrodynamics. Finally, we will also mention possible tests of non-local deterministic models and give some detail on our test of the dBB model.
In this paper we will show some recent experiments performed in the "Carlo Novero" labs of the Optics Division of the National Institute of Metrological Research (INRIM, Torino, Italy), in order to discriminate between Standard Quantum Mechanics and some specific, restricted class of Hidden Variable Theories (HVTs). The first experiment will be on the testing of two restricted Local Realistic Theories (LRTs) [1, 2], properly built to describe polarization entangled photons experiments, whose inequalities are not affected by the detection loophole. The second and third experiments instead will perform the Alicki – Van Ryn non-classicality test [3] on single particles, by means of two different setups based on heralded single photon sources.
In the classical world where we are, it is usually difficult to observe quantum phenomena. What we measure in experiments, such as current, voltage, etc., are all macroscopic classical quantities. Then, how can we observe the quantum behavior of optical fields from these measured classical quantities? It turns out that, as we discussed in Chapter 5, the quantum behaviors of light are revealed in the statistical correlations among the measured quantities. The experimental techniques to be discussed in this chapter and Chapter 9 will be some special experimental methods for observing these statistical correlations that will show quantum phenomena in optics. To understand these, we must connect what we learned in the previous chapters about the quantum theory of light with the physical observables measured in the experiments. In this way, we will use the quantum theory of light to explain the phenomena observed in experiments and furthermore to guide the experiments in search of new quantum phenomena. In this chapter, we will discuss the photon counting technique, one of the two techniques commonly used in the experimental study of quantum optics.
In a series of experiments performed by Mandel and co-workers, nonclassical effects have been demonstrated in the interference of two photons generated in a process of parametric down-conversion. The nonclassical effects in the two-photon interference effects can be discussed in the framework of two different descriptions. In the first description, a stochastic theory of electromagnetic field fluctuations can be used in order to calculate the interference pattern. In the second description, a theory of hidden-variable fluctuations can be applied in order to calculate correlations of the interference pattern. A stochastic theory leads to statistical inequalities for the light intensities, while a local hidden-variable theory leads to Bell's inequalities. Using the Schwinger-boson representation of the angular momentum, we show that the two-photon interference effects can be described in terms of spin-correlated states. In particular, we show that the action of a beam splitter on the photons in a parametric down-conversion is equivalent to the production of an entangled state that is very similar to the well-known Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen spin-singlet state. We show that the stochastic theory of two-photon fluctuations is not equivalent to a hidden-variable theory of photon correlations. We establish a range for which the stochastic theory fails but the hidden-variable theory is still possible. We compare our theoretical predictions with the experimental results and conclude that a violation of the stochastic theory has been clearly observed, while the violation of the hidden-variable theory is less pronounced.