Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Symmetry of the Two-Dimensional Hydrogen Atom

Arturo Cisneros, Harold V. McIntosh

Published Feb 1, 1969• 92 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A paradox has arisen from some recent treatments of accidental degeneracy which claim that, for three degrees of freedom, SU(3) should be a universal symmetry group. Such conclusions are in disagreement both with experimentally observed spectra and with the generally accepted solutions of Schrödinger's equation. The discrepancy occurs in the transition between classical and quantum-mechanical formulations of the problems, and illustrates the care necessary in forming quantum-mechanical operators from classical expressions. The hydrogen atom in parabolic coordinates in two dimensions, for which the traditional treatment of Fock, extended by Alliluev, requires the symmetry group O(3), is a case for which the newer methods of Fradkin, Mukunda, Dulock, and others require SU(2). Although these groups are only slightly different, SU(2) fails to be the ``universal'' symmetry group on account of the multiple-valuedness of the parabolic representation. This conclusion extends a result of Han and Stehle: that, for rather similar reasons, SU(2) cannot be the classical symmetry group for the two-dimensional hydrogen atom.

DOI
10.1063/1.1664843

Related papers

Search for a Universal Symmetry Group in Two Dimensions

Arturo Cisneros, Harold V. McIntosh

Recently several authors have proposed a universal symmetry group and demonstrated the classical validity of the concept. Supposedly, an SU(n) symmetry group could be constructed for whatsoever system of n degrees of freedom. The claim is assuredly valid for all classically degenerate systems, but is in contradiction with most of the well-known and widely accepted solutions of Schrödinger's equation. We examine the reasons for this discrepancy on the quantum-mechanical level. The construction of the universal symmetry group requires ladder operators, which in most cases are the ladder operators of Infeld and Hill. Complications which owe their origin entirely to numerical relationships imposed by quantization prevent these operators from forming a von Neumann algebra and, in turn, an SU(n) group of constants of the motion. Two important effects are those imposed by anisotropy, wherein not all quanta have the same size, and by non-Cartesian coordinates, wherein quanta in some dimensions are restricted in size by those in other dimensions. These effects can be seen quite clearly in two-dimensional systems: anisotropy in the Cartesian anisotropic harmonic oscillator, and conflict between dimensions in the polar form of the isotropic oscillator. Further complications arise when the two effects are combined, as in the harmonic oscillator or hydrogen atom with ``excess'' angular momentum. Enough residue of the universal symmetry concept remains that many similarities between the hydrogen atom and harmonic oscillator may be understood, including the fact that some levels of the hydrogen atom, which ordinarily transform according to an orthogonal group, may form irreducible representations of the unitary group.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1970•41 citations

The “accidental” degeneracy of the hydrogen atom is no accident

Pranawa C. Deshmukh, Aarthi Ganesan, N. Shanthi +3 more

The Schrödinger equation does not account for the 2n2 degeneracy of the hydrogen atom, which it dismisses as an “accidental” degeneracy. The factor of “2” in the 2n2 degeneracy is well-accounted-for in the relativistic formulation by the two spin states of the electron. The n2 degeneracy is nevertheless not quite an “accident”; it is due to the SO(4), rather than SO(3), symmetry of the hydrogen atom. This result is well known, but is inadequately commented upon in most courses in quantum mechanics and atomic physics, leaving the student wondering about the origins of the n2 degeneracy of the hydrogen atom. A pedagogical analysis of this interesting aspect, which highlights the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics, is presented in this article. While doing so, not only is the n2 degeneracy of the hydrogen atom explained, but its energy spectrum and eigenfunctions are obtained without even using the Schrödinger equation, employing only the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics rather than the Schrödinger equation.

Canadian Journal of Physics•Aug 28, 2014•5 citations

On the Theory of the Hydrogen Atom. Comments on the paper of the same title by V. Fock

V. Fock, V. Bargmann

It will be shown that a group theoretical interpretation of the matrix equations that Pauli used as a basis of his treatment of the hydrogen atom leads to the method recently developed by Fock. The separation of the Schrödinger equation in parabolic coordinates will be introduced in this connection.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Dec 1, 1988•0 citations

On the Problem of Degeneracy in Quantum Mechanics

J. M. Jauch, Edward L. Hill

The problem of degeneracy in quantum mechanics is related to the existence of groups of contact transformations under which the Hamiltonian is invariant. The correspondence between transformations in classical and quantum theories is developed. The Fock-Bargmann treatment of the symmetry group of the hydrogenic atom comes under this theory. The symmetry group of the 2-dimensional Kepler problem is found to be the 3-dimensional rotation group; that of the $n$-dimensional isotropic oscillator is isomorphic to the unimodular unitary group in $n$ dimensions. The 2-dimensional anisotropic oscillator has the same symmetry as the isotropic oscillator in classical mechanics, but the quantum-mechanical problem presents complications which leave its symmetry group in doubt.

Physical Review•Apr 1, 1940•359 citations

On the hidden symmetry of a one-dimensional hydrogen atom

Levon S. Davtyan, GEORGE S. POGOSYAN, A. N. Sissakian +1 more

The Fock method is applied to the problem of a one-dimensional hydrogen atom. Integral Fock equations are obtained in discrete and continuous spectra; the case of zero energy is studied and wavefunctions and normalisation constants are calculated in the momentum representation.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jul 11, 1987•28 citations

The Three-dimensional Schro¨dinger Equations

Alastair I. M. Rae, Jim Napolitano

In the previous chapter we saw that for a particle in a one-dimensional potential well, physically acceptable solutions to the one-dimensional Schro¨dinger equation are possible only for particular discrete values of the total energy. Moreover, in the case of an electron in a well of atomic dimensions, the spacings between these energy levels are in qualitative agreement with the separations experimentally observed in atoms; we also interpreted the square of the wave function as a probability distribution for the position of the particle. These ideas led us to phenomena, such as quantum-mechanical tunnelling, that have been observed experimentally. The real world, however, is three-dimensional and, although one-dimensional examples often provide useful insights and analogies, we shall have to extend our theory into three dimensions before we can make quantitative predictions of most experimental results. In the present chapter, therefore, we shall set up the three-dimensional Schro¨dinger equation and obtain its solutions in a number of cases, culminating in a discussion of the hydrogen atom where we shall find that theory and experiment agree to a remarkable degree of accuracy.

CRC Press eBooks•Dec 16, 2015•0 citations
A paradox has arisen from some recent treatments of accidental degeneracy which claim that, for three degrees of freedom, SU(3) should be a universal symmetry group. Such conclusions are in disagreement both with experimentally observed spectra and with the generally accepted solutions of Schrödinger's equation. The discrepancy occurs in the transition between classical and quantum-mechanical formulations of the problems, and illustrates the care necessary in forming quantum-mechanical operators from classical expressions. The hydrogen atom in parabolic coordinates in two dimensions, for which the traditional treatment of Fock, extended by Alliluev, requires the symmetry group O(3), is a case for which the newer methods of Fradkin, Mukunda, Dulock, and others require SU(2). Although these groups are only slightly different, SU(2) fails to be the ``universal'' symmetry group on account of the multiple-valuedness of the parabolic representation. This conclusion extends a result of Han and Stehle: that, for rather similar reasons, SU(2) cannot be the classical symmetry group for the two-dimensional hydrogen atom.
Recently several authors have proposed a universal symmetry group and demonstrated the classical validity of the concept. Supposedly, an SU(n) symmetry group could be constructed for whatsoever system of n degrees of freedom. The claim is assuredly valid for all classically degenerate systems, but is in contradiction with most of the well-known and widely accepted solutions of Schrödinger's equation. We examine the reasons for this discrepancy on the quantum-mechanical level. The construction of the universal symmetry group requires ladder operators, which in most cases are the ladder operators of Infeld and Hill. Complications which owe their origin entirely to numerical relationships imposed by quantization prevent these operators from forming a von Neumann algebra and, in turn, an SU(n) group of constants of the motion. Two important effects are those imposed by anisotropy, wherein not all quanta have the same size, and by non-Cartesian coordinates, wherein quanta in some dimensions are restricted in size by those in other dimensions. These effects can be seen quite clearly in two-dimensional systems: anisotropy in the Cartesian anisotropic harmonic oscillator, and conflict between dimensions in the polar form of the isotropic oscillator. Further complications arise when the two effects are combined, as in the harmonic oscillator or hydrogen atom with ``excess'' angular momentum. Enough residue of the universal symmetry concept remains that many similarities between the hydrogen atom and harmonic oscillator may be understood, including the fact that some levels of the hydrogen atom, which ordinarily transform according to an orthogonal group, may form irreducible representations of the unitary group.
The Schrödinger equation does not account for the 2n2 degeneracy of the hydrogen atom, which it dismisses as an “accidental” degeneracy. The factor of “2” in the 2n2 degeneracy is well-accounted-for in the relativistic formulation by the two spin states of the electron. The n2 degeneracy is nevertheless not quite an “accident”; it is due to the SO(4), rather than SO(3), symmetry of the hydrogen atom. This result is well known, but is inadequately commented upon in most courses in quantum mechanics and atomic physics, leaving the student wondering about the origins of the n2 degeneracy of the hydrogen atom. A pedagogical analysis of this interesting aspect, which highlights the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics, is presented in this article. While doing so, not only is the n2 degeneracy of the hydrogen atom explained, but its energy spectrum and eigenfunctions are obtained without even using the Schrödinger equation, employing only the fundamental principles of quantum mechanics rather than the Schrödinger equation.
The problem of degeneracy in quantum mechanics is related to the existence of groups of contact transformations under which the Hamiltonian is invariant. The correspondence between transformations in classical and quantum theories is developed. The Fock-Bargmann treatment of the symmetry group of the hydrogenic atom comes under this theory. The symmetry group of the 2-dimensional Kepler problem is found to be the 3-dimensional rotation group; that of the nnn-dimensional isotropic oscillator is isomorphic to the unimodular unitary group in nnn dimensions. The 2-dimensional anisotropic oscillator has the same symmetry as the isotropic oscillator in classical mechanics, but the quantum-mechanical problem presents complications which leave its symmetry group in doubt.
In the previous chapter we saw that for a particle in a one-dimensional potential well, physically acceptable solutions to the one-dimensional Schro¨dinger equation are possible only for particular discrete values of the total energy. Moreover, in the case of an electron in a well of atomic dimensions, the spacings between these energy levels are in qualitative agreement with the separations experimentally observed in atoms; we also interpreted the square of the wave function as a probability distribution for the position of the particle. These ideas led us to phenomena, such as quantum-mechanical tunnelling, that have been observed experimentally. The real world, however, is three-dimensional and, although one-dimensional examples often provide useful insights and analogies, we shall have to extend our theory into three dimensions before we can make quantitative predictions of most experimental results. In the present chapter, therefore, we shall set up the three-dimensional Schro¨dinger equation and obtain its solutions in a number of cases, culminating in a discussion of the hydrogen atom where we shall find that theory and experiment agree to a remarkable degree of accuracy.