Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Magnetic properties of some itinerant-electron systems atT>0

Michael Aizenman, Élliott H. Lieb

Published Sep 17, 1990• 41 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Lieb-Mattis theorem on the absence of one-dimensional ferromagnetism is extended here from ground states to T>0 by proving, inter alia, that M(\ensuremath{\beta},h), the magnetization of a quantum system in a field h>0, is always less than the pure paramagnetic value ${\mathit{M}}_{0}$(\ensuremath{\beta},h)=tanh(\ensuremath{\beta}h), with \ensuremath{\beta}==1/kT. Our proof rests on a new formulation in terms of path integrals that holds in any dimension; another of its applications is that the Nagaoka-Thouless theorem on the Hubbard model also extends to T>0 in the sense that M(\ensuremath{\beta},h) exceeds ${\mathit{M}}_{0}$(\ensuremath{\beta},h).

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.65.1470

Related papers

Magnetic Properties of Some Itineraat-Electron Systems at T > 0

Michael Aizenman, Élliott H. Lieb

To many physicists the study of magnetism begins with a Heisenberg model, or something similar, in which localized spins interact witb eacb other. Unfortunately, nature docs not present us witb sucb a starting point. In­ stead, at a reasonably (thougb not absolutely) funda­ mental level, we are presented witb the Scbriidinger equation for electrons wbose interaction is, to a very good approximation, spin independent. It is left to the Pauli principle to induce a spin dependence, and for tbis it is essential tbat the electrons are itinerant, i.e., rwt lo­ calized a priori. Given the subtlety of the phenomenon, it is crucial to elucidate the conditions which encourage or discourage the emergence of ferromagnetism. Some years ago Lieb and Mattis 1 showed that one never gets ferromagnetism in the ground states of itinerant electrons on a line. The results presented here include an extension of that earlier theorem (by a different method) to positive tempera­ tures, and an opposite statement for systems in any di­ mension with a certain parity t:onstraint (requiring hard -core repulsions)- for which we show that parallel spin alignments are favored at all temperatures. Exam­ ples of the second kind are one-dimensional systems of odd numbers of electrons on a ring (j.e., periodit: bound­ ary conditionS>, for which we extend the T-O result of Herring, 2 and a particular case of the Hubbard model whose ground state was shown to be ferromagnetic by Nagaoka J and Thouless. 45 We deal with the following general (spin-independent) Hamiltonian for N identical, itinerant particles of mass

•Jan 1, 2004•0 citations

A finite temperature version of the Nagaoka--Thouless theorem in the $\mathrm{SU}(n)$ Hubbard model

Tadahiro Miyao

The Aizenman--Lieb theorem for the $\mathrm{SU}(2)$ Hubbard model expands upon the Nagaoka--Thouless theorem for the ground state to encompass finite temperatures. It can be succinctly stated that the magnetization $m(β, b)$ of the system in the presence of a field $b$ surpasses the pure paramagnetic value $m_0(β, b)=\tanh(βb)$. In this manuscript, we present an extension of the Aizenman--Lieb theorem to the $\mathrm{SU}(n)$ Hubbard model. Our proof relies on a random-loop representation of the partition function, which becomes accessible when expressing the partition function in terms of path integrals.

arXiv:2112.14475•Dec 29, 2021•1 citation

Spontaneous spin polarization in quantum wires

A. D. Klironomos, Julia S. Meyer, К. А. Матвеев

A number of recent experiments report spin polarization in quantum wires in the absence of magnetic fields. These observations are in apparent contradiction with the Lieb-Mattis theorem, which forbids spontaneous spin polarization in one dimension. We show that sufficiently strong interactions between electrons induce deviations from the strictly one-dimensional geometry and indeed give rise to a ferromagnetic ground state in a certain range of electron densities.

arXiv:cond-mat/0507387•Europhysics Letters (EPL)•Apr 11, 2006•49 citations

Bounds on ferromagnetism atT>0 in the hard-core electron lattice gas

András Sütö

In a recent paper by Aizenman and Lieb [Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 1470 (1990)], it was reported that the Nagaoka ferromagnet preserves its ferromagnetic character at temperatures T>0 in any finite volume. It is shown here that at any T>0 the Nagaoka ferromagnet becomes a perfect paramagnet in the thermodynamic limit. By using an inequality for the free energy, this result is extended to the general case when the number of electrons per site goes to 1. At any T>0 the spontaneous magnetization m(T,\ensuremath{\rho}) tends to zero as the electron density \ensuremath{\rho} tends to 1. Thus, a rigorous upper bound on m(T,\ensuremath{\rho}) is obtained. The results are independent of the statistics.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 1, 1991•16 citations

An algebraic approach to revealing magnetic structures of ground states in many-electron systems

Tadahiro Miyao

Mathematical understanding of the origin of ferromagnetism is still incomplete and remains an important research topic in mathematical physics. In this paper, we give a model-independent mathematical framework describing the magnetic features of the ground states in many-electron systems. Within this framework, we also present a new approach to understanding magnetic orders in macroscopic systems. Based on these, we construct a general theory that explains the stability of magnetic orders in the ground states despite the interaction of electrons with the environment. Methodologically, the theory presented in this paper is formulated using von Neumann algebras and their associated standard forms. A benefit of working in such an algebraic setting is that we can define operator inequalities that preserve the ordered structures that naturally follow from the standard forms; by exploiting these operator inequalities, we can develop new descriptions of the magnetic structures of the ground states. As specific applications of the proposed theory, we first analyze the Marshall--Lieb--Mattis theorem, Lieb's theorem, and their stabilities under various perturbations. Next, the Nagaoka--Thouless theorem and its stability are addressed. In addition, we interpret various other examples from the new theory and give a unified perspective on existing results.

arXiv:2108.05104•Aug 11, 2021•3 citations

Ferromagnetism in the Hubbard models with degenerate single-electron ground states

Hal Tasaki

We study a class of Hubbard models in which the corresponding single-electron ground states have bulk degeneracy. We prove that the ground states of the models exhibit ferromagnetism when the electron filling factor is not more than and sufficiently close to ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{0}$=\ensuremath{\Vert}V\ensuremath{\Vert}/2\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Lambda}\ensuremath{\Vert} (where \ensuremath{\Vert}V\ensuremath{\Vert} is the dimension of degeneracy and \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Lambda}\ensuremath{\Vert} is the number of sites), and exhibit paramagnetism when the filling factor is sufficiently small. This is the first time that a three-dimensional itinerant-electron system is proved to exhibit ferromagnetism in a finite range of the electron filling factor.

Physical Review Letters•Sep 7, 1992•587 citations
The Lieb-Mattis theorem on the absence of one-dimensional ferromagnetism is extended here from ground states to T>0 by proving, inter alia, that M(\ensuremath{\beta},h), the magnetization of a quantum system in a field h>0, is always less than the pure paramagnetic value M0{\mathit{M}}_{0}M0​(\ensuremath{\beta},h)=tanh(\ensuremath{\beta}h), with \ensuremath{\beta}==1/kT. Our proof rests on a new formulation in terms of path integrals that holds in any dimension; another of its applications is that the Nagaoka-Thouless theorem on the Hubbard model also extends to T>0 in the sense that M(\ensuremath{\beta},h) exceeds M0{\mathit{M}}_{0}M0​(\ensuremath{\beta},h).
To many physicists the study of magnetism begins with a Heisenberg model, or something similar, in which localized spins interact witb eacb other. Unfortunately, nature docs not present us witb sucb a starting point. In­ stead, at a reasonably (thougb not absolutely) funda­ mental level, we are presented witb the Scbriidinger equation for electrons wbose interaction is, to a very good approximation, spin independent. It is left to the Pauli principle to induce a spin dependence, and for tbis it is essential tbat the electrons are itinerant, i.e., rwt lo­ calized a priori. Given the subtlety of the phenomenon, it is crucial to elucidate the conditions which encourage or discourage the emergence of ferromagnetism. Some years ago Lieb and Mattis 1 showed that one never gets ferromagnetism in the ground states of itinerant electrons on a line. The results presented here include an extension of that earlier theorem (by a different method) to positive tempera­ tures, and an opposite statement for systems in any di­ mension with a certain parity t:onstraint (requiring hard -core repulsions)- for which we show that parallel spin alignments are favored at all temperatures. Exam­ ples of the second kind are one-dimensional systems of odd numbers of electrons on a ring (j.e., periodit: bound­ ary conditionS>, for which we extend the T-O result of Herring, 2 and a particular case of the Hubbard model whose ground state was shown to be ferromagnetic by Nagaoka J and Thouless. 45 We deal with the following general (spin-independent) Hamiltonian for N identical, itinerant particles of mass
A finite temperature version of the Nagaoka--Thouless theorem in the SU(n)\mathrm{SU}(n)SU(n) Hubbard model
The Aizenman--Lieb theorem for the SU(2)\mathrm{SU}(2)SU(2) Hubbard model expands upon the Nagaoka--Thouless theorem for the ground state to encompass finite temperatures. It can be succinctly stated that the magnetization m(β,b)m(β, b)m(β,b) of the system in the presence of a field bbb surpasses the pure paramagnetic value m0(β,b)=tanh⁡(βb)m_0(β, b)=\tanh(βb)m0​(β,b)=tanh(βb). In this manuscript, we present an extension of the Aizenman--Lieb theorem to the SU(n)\mathrm{SU}(n)SU(n) Hubbard model. Our proof relies on a random-loop representation of the partition function, which becomes accessible when expressing the partition function in terms of path integrals.
In a recent paper by Aizenman and Lieb [Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 1470 (1990)], it was reported that the Nagaoka ferromagnet preserves its ferromagnetic character at temperatures T>0 in any finite volume. It is shown here that at any T>0 the Nagaoka ferromagnet becomes a perfect paramagnet in the thermodynamic limit. By using an inequality for the free energy, this result is extended to the general case when the number of electrons per site goes to 1. At any T>0 the spontaneous magnetization m(T,\ensuremath{\rho}) tends to zero as the electron density \ensuremath{\rho} tends to 1. Thus, a rigorous upper bound on m(T,\ensuremath{\rho}) is obtained. The results are independent of the statistics.
Mathematical understanding of the origin of ferromagnetism is still incomplete and remains an important research topic in mathematical physics. In this paper, we give a model-independent mathematical framework describing the magnetic features of the ground states in many-electron systems. Within this framework, we also present a new approach to understanding magnetic orders in macroscopic systems. Based on these, we construct a general theory that explains the stability of magnetic orders in the ground states despite the interaction of electrons with the environment. Methodologically, the theory presented in this paper is formulated using von Neumann algebras and their associated standard forms. A benefit of working in such an algebraic setting is that we can define operator inequalities that preserve the ordered structures that naturally follow from the standard forms; by exploiting these operator inequalities, we can develop new descriptions of the magnetic structures of the ground states. As specific applications of the proposed theory, we first analyze the Marshall--Lieb--Mattis theorem, Lieb's theorem, and their stabilities under various perturbations. Next, the Nagaoka--Thouless theorem and its stability are addressed. In addition, we interpret various other examples from the new theory and give a unified perspective on existing results.
We study a class of Hubbard models in which the corresponding single-electron ground states have bulk degeneracy. We prove that the ground states of the models exhibit ferromagnetism when the electron filling factor is not more than and sufficiently close to ${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\rho}}}_{0}$=\ensuremath{\Vert}V\ensuremath{\Vert}/2\ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Lambda}\ensuremath{\Vert} (where \ensuremath{\Vert}V\ensuremath{\Vert} is the dimension of degeneracy and \ensuremath{\Vert}\ensuremath{\Lambda}\ensuremath{\Vert} is the number of sites), and exhibit paramagnetism when the filling factor is sufficiently small. This is the first time that a three-dimensional itinerant-electron system is proved to exhibit ferromagnetism in a finite range of the electron filling factor.