Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics-Uspekhi

The phase of an oscillator in quantum theory. What is it 'in reality'?

Yurii I. Vorontsov

Published Aug 31, 2002• 12 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An analysis of the current theory of the quantum oscillator phase is presented. Predictions using existing approaches to the phase problem differ not only quantitatively but also qualitatively. The question in the title has not yet been given a generally accepted answer. However, it is logical to argue that all the theoretically predicted properties of the phase are physically meaningful if appropriate measurements are possible. Current phase measurement methods either involve the simultaneous (approximate) measurement of the amplitude and the phase or rely on the simultaneous measurement of quadrature amplitudes.

DOI
10.1070/pu2002v045n08abeh001219

Related papers

Quantum phase and quantum phase operators: some physics and some history

Michael Martin Nieto

After reviewing the role of phase in quantum mechanics, I discuss, with the aid of a number of unpublished documents, the development of quantum phase operators in the 1960's. Interwoven in the discussion are the critical physics questions of the field: are there (unique) quantum phase operators and are there quantum systems which can determine their nature? I conclude with a critique of recent proposals which have shed new light on the problem.

arXiv:hep-th/9304036•Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 1993•61 citations

What does it feel like to be in a quantum superposition

Shan Gao

We suggest a new answer to this intriguing question and argue that the answer may have implications for the solutions to the measurement problem. The main basis of our analysis is the doctrine of psychophysical supervenience. First of all, based on this doctrine, we argue that an observer in a quantum superposition or a quantum observer has a definite conscious experience, which is neither disjunctive nor illusive. The inconsistency of this result with the bare theory is further analyzed, and it is shown that an appropriate use of the strategy of analyzing the disposition of an observer to answer a particular question also leads to the same result. Next, we argue that this new result seems to disfavor Everett's and Bohm's approaches to quantum mechanics when considering the doctrine of psychophysical supervenience. This suggests that dynamical collapse theories are in the right direction to solve the measurement problem. Thirdly, we analyze the concrete content of the conscious experience of a quantum observer. It is argued that the mental content of a quantum observer is related to both the amplitude and relative phase of each branch of the superposition she is physically in, and it is composed of the mental content corresponding to every branch of the superposition. In addition, we argue that when assuming the modulus squared of the amplitude of each branch determines the vividness of the mental content corresponding to the branch, the structured tails problem of dynamical collapse theories can be solved.

•Dec 12, 2015•3 citations

Measurement at the Microscopic Level

It should be clear that the question of the (statistical) verification of the probabilistic predictions of Schrödinger's mechanics is just a particular application of the statistical method in general. Measurements are made on random concrete objects which are instances of the relevant abstract object and summed to form approximate numerical quadratures to be compared to the theoretical measures of the appropriate model subsets. However, the “problem of measurement” and “theories of measurement” are totems in quantum theory and so I do obeisance to them here.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Dec 1, 2002•0 citations

MATHEMATICAL ASPECTS OF QUANTUM PHASE

Daniel A. Dubin, Mark A. Hennings, T.B. SMITH

We consider the current state of the quest for a quantum phase operator, which started in the earliest days of quantum mechanics.4–7 Particular emphasis has been placed on analysis of the structure of the several distinct theories, both physical and mathematical, which has led us from classical function theory to the quantum theory of measurement.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Sep 15, 1995•16 citations

Realistic measurement of phase

Henryk Paul

One of the most delicate problems in quantum optics is the proper description of the phase of a single-mode radiation field. One has first to devise an experimental scheme for phase measurement, thus giving an operational definition of phase, and afterwards search for the proper quantum-mechanical description of the experimental procedure. Several such schemes which differ distinctly in their experimental setup have already been proposed and even partly realized. In this paper, I will describe them in some detail and present the outlines of their theoretical analysis.>

Nonlinear Optics•Dec 17, 2002•0 citations

The Basic Approach

Our goal in this treatment of quantum theory is to provide those aspects of the theory which are most needed for a modem understanding of the world of our experience. Central to this are the many approximations which have turned out to be successful for estimating the properties of matter and predicting the events which occur on a microscopic scale. In that sense the goal is entirely pragmatic, but any study of quantum theory cannot help but raise deep philosophical questions. Perhaps the only real understanding of the theory is through a familiarity with how it works out for many different problems. It seems unlikely that understanding comes from thinking about some complicated extreme case, such as Schroedinger's cat. The approach we take here bypasses much of the question by starting with a single premise of wave-particle duality, from which follows all of quantum theory and its interpretation. Any remaining problems are made moot by the quantum-mechanical view that questions are meaningful only if there is some conceivable experimental way to test the answers. In keeping with this pragmatic approach we will not emphasize mathematical derivations, nor carry out the detailed analysis of harmonic-oscillator states, hydrogen wavefunctions, or angular momentum, which are part of almost all texts in quantum theory. We treat the simplest case in detail, state the general results, and see that they are the plausible generalizations. We leave the more detailed analysis to other texts. The one we used for the course at Stanford was Kroemer's Quantum Mechanics for Engineers and Materials Scientists , which served very well.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jul 1, 2000•0 citations
An analysis of the current theory of the quantum oscillator phase is presented. Predictions using existing approaches to the phase problem differ not only quantitatively but also qualitatively. The question in the title has not yet been given a generally accepted answer. However, it is logical to argue that all the theoretically predicted properties of the phase are physically meaningful if appropriate measurements are possible. Current phase measurement methods either involve the simultaneous (approximate) measurement of the amplitude and the phase or rely on the simultaneous measurement of quadrature amplitudes.
We suggest a new answer to this intriguing question and argue that the answer may have implications for the solutions to the measurement problem. The main basis of our analysis is the doctrine of psychophysical supervenience. First of all, based on this doctrine, we argue that an observer in a quantum superposition or a quantum observer has a definite conscious experience, which is neither disjunctive nor illusive. The inconsistency of this result with the bare theory is further analyzed, and it is shown that an appropriate use of the strategy of analyzing the disposition of an observer to answer a particular question also leads to the same result. Next, we argue that this new result seems to disfavor Everett's and Bohm's approaches to quantum mechanics when considering the doctrine of psychophysical supervenience. This suggests that dynamical collapse theories are in the right direction to solve the measurement problem. Thirdly, we analyze the concrete content of the conscious experience of a quantum observer. It is argued that the mental content of a quantum observer is related to both the amplitude and relative phase of each branch of the superposition she is physically in, and it is composed of the mental content corresponding to every branch of the superposition. In addition, we argue that when assuming the modulus squared of the amplitude of each branch determines the vividness of the mental content corresponding to the branch, the structured tails problem of dynamical collapse theories can be solved.
It should be clear that the question of the (statistical) verification of the probabilistic predictions of Schrödinger's mechanics is just a particular application of the statistical method in general. Measurements are made on random concrete objects which are instances of the relevant abstract object and summed to form approximate numerical quadratures to be compared to the theoretical measures of the appropriate model subsets. However, the “problem of measurement” and “theories of measurement” are totems in quantum theory and so I do obeisance to them here.
One of the most delicate problems in quantum optics is the proper description of the phase of a single-mode radiation field. One has first to devise an experimental scheme for phase measurement, thus giving an operational definition of phase, and afterwards search for the proper quantum-mechanical description of the experimental procedure. Several such schemes which differ distinctly in their experimental setup have already been proposed and even partly realized. In this paper, I will describe them in some detail and present the outlines of their theoretical analysis.>
Our goal in this treatment of quantum theory is to provide those aspects of the theory which are most needed for a modem understanding of the world of our experience. Central to this are the many approximations which have turned out to be successful for estimating the properties of matter and predicting the events which occur on a microscopic scale. In that sense the goal is entirely pragmatic, but any study of quantum theory cannot help but raise deep philosophical questions. Perhaps the only real understanding of the theory is through a familiarity with how it works out for many different problems. It seems unlikely that understanding comes from thinking about some complicated extreme case, such as Schroedinger's cat. The approach we take here bypasses much of the question by starting with a single premise of wave-particle duality, from which follows all of quantum theory and its interpretation. Any remaining problems are made moot by the quantum-mechanical view that questions are meaningful only if there is some conceivable experimental way to test the answers. In keeping with this pragmatic approach we will not emphasize mathematical derivations, nor carry out the detailed analysis of harmonic-oscillator states, hydrogen wavefunctions, or angular momentum, which are part of almost all texts in quantum theory. We treat the simplest case in detail, state the general results, and see that they are the plausible generalizations. We leave the more detailed analysis to other texts. The one we used for the course at Stanford was Kroemer's Quantum Mechanics for Engineers and Materials Scientists , which served very well.