Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields

Comment on "Formal scattering theory with shadow states"

Roger G. Newton

Published Feb 15, 1975• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is pointed out that examination of a double-scattering experiment reveals an inconsistency in the scattering theory proposed by Richard in connection with Sudarshan's "shadow states." The theory gives different amplitudes for a double-scattering experiment, depending on the stage at which the "shadow world" is eliminated from explicit reference.

DOI
10.1103/physrevd.11.958

Related papers

Radiative Effect in Semiclassical Theory

Michael D. Crisp, E. T. Jaynes

There is an inconsistency in the phase conventions used in various equations.Equation ( 7) is derived by W.

Physical Review•Sep 25, 1969•39 citations

Comment on ‘‘Dirac states for unit position and momentum: Phase consistency of their angular momentum representations’’

G. E. Hahne

The argument presented makes two points about Snider’s [J. Chem. Phys. 76, 3543 (1982)] transformation between ‘‘unit position’’ states ‖r̂〉 and ‘‘unit momentum’’ states ‖p〉 for the motion of a structureless particle in three space: Snider’s transformation (1) implicitly defines an operator p̂ that has a classical limit a unit vector that is perpendicular to both r̂ and l=r×p, while on a classical scattering trajectory for r→∞, the physical unit vector p/p≊±r̂, and (2) attempts, inconsistent with the kinematics of states and observables of the system, to pass from r̂ to p̂ amplitudes of a state vector without any reference to the scalar r or p dependence of the wave functions.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 1, 1983•1 citation

Finite Cross Section for Three-Particle Scattering

M. Yamazaki

In the scattering of three free incident particles, a finite cross section for the double scattering has to be defined differently from the processes other than the double scattering. That is, we want to maintain that, in order to obtain a definite quantity being connected to the experimental observation, a particular definition of the cross section has to be required for the double scattering owing to a particular time dependence of its scattering rate. Our definition differs from the ones given recently by others in a form depending on some macroscopic quantities.1), 2) In the previous paper (refered as I in the following)3), we have attained to a finite cross section by working on the basis of the wave packet formalism, while we want to give here a clear-cut derivation in a simple and familear form.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Mar 1, 1979•0 citations

Review of "Two-particle States on a Torus and Their Relation to the Scattering Matrix"

Masanori Okawa

素粒子論研究•Sep 20, 1992•0 citations

Comparison between the classical and quantum theories of incoherent scattering

Lajos Jánossy

Acta Physica Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae•Jan 1, 1975•1 citation

Initial states of maximal entropy in formal scattering theory

Peter Pfeifer, Raphael David Levine

For a precollision state which is not sharply defined, not all details of the dynamics can be obtained by examination of the final state. A version of formal collision theory which takes full advantage of the inherent loss of detail is provided. Only the relevant aspects of the dynamics need then be computed and an explicit identification of the relevant details is provided by a generalized intertwining theorem. Several explicit examples where this point of view can be implemented are worked out.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Apr 15, 1983•13 citations
It is pointed out that examination of a double-scattering experiment reveals an inconsistency in the scattering theory proposed by Richard in connection with Sudarshan's "shadow states." The theory gives different amplitudes for a double-scattering experiment, depending on the stage at which the "shadow world" is eliminated from explicit reference.
The argument presented makes two points about Snider’s [J. Chem. Phys. 76, 3543 (1982)] transformation between ‘‘unit position’’ states ‖r̂〉 and ‘‘unit momentum’’ states ‖p〉 for the motion of a structureless particle in three space: Snider’s transformation (1) implicitly defines an operator p̂ that has a classical limit a unit vector that is perpendicular to both r̂ and l=r×p, while on a classical scattering trajectory for r→∞, the physical unit vector p/p≊±r̂, and (2) attempts, inconsistent with the kinematics of states and observables of the system, to pass from r̂ to p̂ amplitudes of a state vector without any reference to the scalar r or p dependence of the wave functions.
In the scattering of three free incident particles, a finite cross section for the double scattering has to be defined differently from the processes other than the double scattering. That is, we want to maintain that, in order to obtain a definite quantity being connected to the experimental observation, a particular definition of the cross section has to be required for the double scattering owing to a particular time dependence of its scattering rate. Our definition differs from the ones given recently by others in a form depending on some macroscopic quantities.1), 2) In the previous paper (refered as I in the following)3), we have attained to a finite cross section by working on the basis of the wave packet formalism, while we want to give here a clear-cut derivation in a simple and familear form.
For a precollision state which is not sharply defined, not all details of the dynamics can be obtained by examination of the final state. A version of formal collision theory which takes full advantage of the inherent loss of detail is provided. Only the relevant aspects of the dynamics need then be computed and an explicit identification of the relevant details is provided by a generalized intertwining theorem. Several explicit examples where this point of view can be implemented are worked out.