Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Applicability of Approximate Quantum-Mechanical Wave Functions Having Discontinuities in Their First Derivatives

Joseph O. Hirschfelder, George V. Nazaroff

Published May 1, 1961• 27 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The method of convolutions is used to form smoothed functions from approximate wave functions which are discontinuous or have discontinuous first derivatives. As a parameter ε in the smoothed function decreases, the smoothed function approaches the approximate wave function. The expectation values for physical properties corresponding to the approximate wave function are defined to be the limit as ε approaches zero of the expectation values corresponding to the smoothed function. It is found that if the approximate wave function is discontinuous, the corresponding expectation value for the kinetic energy is infinite. Therefore, it seems unlikely that discontinuous approximate wave functions can ever be useful. However, if the approximate wave function is continuous but has a discontinuity in its first derivative, then, as a result of the discontinuity, there is a contribution δT̄12 to the expectation value of the kinetic energy. For a one-dimensional problem δT̄12=−(ℏ2/2m)ψ*(0) [ψ2′(0)−ψ1′(0)].Here ψ(0) is the value of the approximate wave function at the point zero where the discontinuity in its first derivative occurs, and ψ1′(0) and ψ2′(0) are the first derivatives of ψ taken from the left and from the right, respectively, at this point. Similarly, for an N-dimensional problem having a surface S12=0 over which the first derivatives of the approximate wave function are discontinuous, δT̄12= ∫ surfaceψ*[(∂/∂n) (ψ2−ψ1)]dS12.Here the ∂/∂n is the normal derivative with the normal pointed from region 1 towards region 2.

DOI
10.1063/1.1701062

Related papers

The effect of discontinuous wave functions on optimizations of VMC calculations of quantum systems

A. Najafi

Here, a relatively good comparison has been done between the performance results of discontinuous and continuous forms of wave function on quantum systems as well. In this project, we’ve estimated the energy of ground and first state as the expectation value of Hamiltonian of harmonic oscillator and binding energy of nucleons confined in a Yukawa potential by making use of following three wave function: exponential, linear and Gaussian form which are convenient to optimize and may be evaluated rapidly are devised and tested and we stress the advantages of using expressions which are Gaussian in the variable parameters. Exponential function is quite different from a Gaussian ones as it has a cusp at x=0, hence a discontinuity in its derivatives. We then have performed to test inaccuracy of the discontinuous wave function and energy’s error of its exact value because using of exponential and linear function by mathematical statements of calculation of delta and Heaviside function and either VMC calculation of wave function optimization, as both of them will have the same result of error value. The result of our study is very promising for future applications of quantum Monte Carlo methods especially in many body systems

Advanced Studies in Theoretical Physics•Jan 1, 2013•0 citations

Less than perfect quantum wavefunctions in momentum-space: How ϕ(p) senses disturbances in the force

M. Belloni, R. W. Robinett

We develop a systematic approach to determine the large |p| behavior of the momentum-space wave function, ϕ(p), of a one-dimensional quantum system for which the position-space wave function, ψ(x), has a discontinuous derivative at any order. We find that if the kth derivative of the potential energy function for the system has a discontinuity, there is a corresponding discontinuity in ψ(k+2)(x) at the same point. This discontinuity leads directly to a power-law tail in the momentum-space wave function proportional to 1/pk+3. A number of familiar pedagogical examples are examined in this context, leading to a general derivation of the result.

arXiv:1010.4244•American Journal of Physics•Dec 13, 2010•5 citations

Continuity, Discontinuity and Relative Differences in Quantum Mechanics

Francesco R. Ruggeri

We argue that continuity and discontinuity in special relativity play an important role in the probabilistic wave properties of quantum mechanics. Special relativity is involved with transformations from a rest frame to a frame moving with a constant -v, for example . The discontinuity appears in the form of a change from v=0 to v, while the continuity arises from Lorentz invariants which indicate one has the same physical state whether it is viewed from a frame with one velocity or another. This invariance applied to E, p (momentum) as a modulus forces a minus sign between the two, in order to allow for linkage with E=mo (c=1) and p=0, i.e. -EE + pp = -momo (c=1). Another invariant, however, is A= -Et’ + px’, and in this case the minus sign and the discontinuity lead to a new x’,t’ (in comparison with the rest frame for a particle with rest mass mo), but also to t’ -> t’+ b/E and x->x’ +b/p leaving A unchanged (b=constant). The discontinuity in v, which leads to a jump in x’,t’ (as seen in the moving frame) also manifests itself in a time-length interval which ultimately leads to exp(-iEt+ px), we argue. In other words, classically one considers constant velocity as smooth continuous motion, but the introduction of two frames, v=0 and -v, leads to a discontinuity which leads to “chunkiness” in the form of a frequency and wavelength. If these cannot be perceived classically (as is often the case), then one considers only smoothness. Relative differences in time or length or in frequency or wavelength, however, can appear in nature for length scales of the order of the frequency/length scale. In the case of n-slit interference-diffraction, a relative difference leads to a “jump” (so to speak) which manifests the wavelength. In particular, a photon moves along the y direction with a phase px (considering a steady state picture). It reaches a two-slit system along the x-axis and there is probability for it to interact with both slits. If one considers two parallel rays from each slit moving towards a point on a screen very far away (as is done traditionally), there is again smooth motion with a rotated p vector (same magnitude), but for a point on the screen to the left of the center, there is a jump in the length associated with the right slit. In other words, there is a jump similar to the v=0, -v jump. This leads to a relative difference in length associated with both rays (linked to an OR probability situation using exp(ip dot r). This relative difference in length displays the phase difference initiated by special relativity. In the case of a bound state, different impulse hits by a potential create different momenta which have different phases exp(ipx) because of special relativity and one has interference. The same phase A= -Et + p dot r, which is linked with a chunkiness due to a discontinuity, is also associated with continuity because A is a Lorentz invariant. Thus A=constant may be used to solve for refraction/reflection problems with or without moving mirrors/interfaces with different indices of refraction. Continuity appears further in a 1-dimensional reflection/refraction problem when applied to the exp(ipx), i.e. Aexp(ipx) + Bexp(-ipx) = C exp(ip2x) where E=pc = p2 c2, p2=n2p and c2=c/n2 with n1=1, together with a continuity equation for the first derivative. Thus, both continuity and discontinuity (or jumps), which follow from special relativity, seem to play an important role in quantum mechanics.

•Oct 3, 2023•0 citations

Discontinuity in the first derivative of the Schrödinger wave function

Dipankar Home, S. Sengupta

Bound state problems in quantum mechanics are considered for the edge of a square well potential and singular points of a Coulomb and a δ-function potential. (AIP)

American Journal of Physics•Jun 1, 1982•7 citations

Quantum and classical limits in a potential step

CLAUDIO O. DIB, Oscar F. Orellana

Abstract We have often found among many of our students and colleagues the common idea that the mathematical expression for a physical quantity that is essentially of quantum nature must contain a dependence on ℏ. Conversely, a phenomenon described by classical physics should contain no explicit reference to ℏ. However, the problem of a particle encountering a discontinuous potential step, which is one of the simplest examples in quantum mechanics, contradicts this common thought: even when the particle carries enough kinetic energy to go across the step, the resulting expression for the reflection probability is non-zero—a purely quantum phenomenon—and yet it contains no reference to ℏ. We show that the absence of ℏ in this purely quantum expression is due to the idealised limit in which the potential rises sharply at a single position, thus losing any reference to a length dimension in the problem. To address the correct classical limit of the phenomenon we first regularise the discontinuity in the potential by taking a continuous linearly rising function over a distance a . We show that the correct classical limit, which is when no reflection occurs, is obtained for large values of a , not for vanishing a . The latter actually corresponds to a purely quantum case, albeit in a limiting case of a discontinuously abrupt change in the potential at a single point in space.

European Journal of Physics•Apr 20, 2017•2 citations

Point and surface interactions in quantum mechanics

Rutger‐Jan Lange

Much of the literature on point interactions in quantum mechanics has focused on the differential form of Schrodinger's equation. This paper, in contrast, investigates the integral form of Schrodinger's equation. While both forms are known to be equivalent for smooth potentials, this is not true for distributional potentials. Here, we assume that the potential is given by a distribution defined on the space of discontinuous test functions. First, by using Schrodinger's integral equation, we confirm a seminal result by Kurasov, which was originally obtained in the context of Schrodinger's differential equation. This hints at a possible deeper connection between both forms of the equation. We also sketch a generalisation of Kurasov's result to hypersurfaces. Second, we derive a new closed-form solution to Schrodinger's integral equation with a delta prime potential. This potential has attracted considerable attention, including some controversy. Interestingly, the derived propagator satisfies boundary conditions that were previously derived using Schrodinger's differential equation. Third, we derive boundary conditions for `super-singular' potentials given by higher-order derivatives of the delta potential. These boundary conditions cannot be incorporated into the normal framework of self-adjoint extensions. We show that the boundary conditions depend on the energy of the solution, and that probability is conserved. This paper thereby confirms several seminal results and derives some new ones. In sum, it shows that Schrodinger's integral equation is viable tool for studying singular interactions in quantum mechanics.

•Jan 29, 2014•0 citations
The method of convolutions is used to form smoothed functions from approximate wave functions which are discontinuous or have discontinuous first derivatives. As a parameter ε in the smoothed function decreases, the smoothed function approaches the approximate wave function. The expectation values for physical properties corresponding to the approximate wave function are defined to be the limit as ε approaches zero of the expectation values corresponding to the smoothed function. It is found that if the approximate wave function is discontinuous, the corresponding expectation value for the kinetic energy is infinite. Therefore, it seems unlikely that discontinuous approximate wave functions can ever be useful. However, if the approximate wave function is continuous but has a discontinuity in its first derivative, then, as a result of the discontinuity, there is a contribution δT̄12 to the expectation value of the kinetic energy. For a one-dimensional problem δT̄12=−(ℏ2/2m)ψ*(0) [ψ2′(0)−ψ1′(0)].Here ψ(0) is the value of the approximate wave function at the point zero where the discontinuity in its first derivative occurs, and ψ1′(0) and ψ2′(0) are the first derivatives of ψ taken from the left and from the right, respectively, at this point. Similarly, for an N-dimensional problem having a surface S12=0 over which the first derivatives of the approximate wave function are discontinuous, δT̄12= ∫ surfaceψ*[(∂/∂n) (ψ2−ψ1)]dS12.Here the ∂/∂n is the normal derivative with the normal pointed from region 1 towards region 2.
Here, a relatively good comparison has been done between the performance results of discontinuous and continuous forms of wave function on quantum systems as well. In this project, we’ve estimated the energy of ground and first state as the expectation value of Hamiltonian of harmonic oscillator and binding energy of nucleons confined in a Yukawa potential by making use of following three wave function: exponential, linear and Gaussian form which are convenient to optimize and may be evaluated rapidly are devised and tested and we stress the advantages of using expressions which are Gaussian in the variable parameters. Exponential function is quite different from a Gaussian ones as it has a cusp at x=0, hence a discontinuity in its derivatives. We then have performed to test inaccuracy of the discontinuous wave function and energy’s error of its exact value because using of exponential and linear function by mathematical statements of calculation of delta and Heaviside function and either VMC calculation of wave function optimization, as both of them will have the same result of error value. The result of our study is very promising for future applications of quantum Monte Carlo methods especially in many body systems
We develop a systematic approach to determine the large |p| behavior of the momentum-space wave function, ϕ(p), of a one-dimensional quantum system for which the position-space wave function, ψ(x), has a discontinuous derivative at any order. We find that if the kth derivative of the potential energy function for the system has a discontinuity, there is a corresponding discontinuity in ψ(k+2)(x) at the same point. This discontinuity leads directly to a power-law tail in the momentum-space wave function proportional to 1/pk+3. A number of familiar pedagogical examples are examined in this context, leading to a general derivation of the result.
We argue that continuity and discontinuity in special relativity play an important role in the probabilistic wave properties of quantum mechanics. Special relativity is involved with transformations from a rest frame to a frame moving with a constant -v, for example . The discontinuity appears in the form of a change from v=0 to v, while the continuity arises from Lorentz invariants which indicate one has the same physical state whether it is viewed from a frame with one velocity or another. This invariance applied to E, p (momentum) as a modulus forces a minus sign between the two, in order to allow for linkage with E=mo (c=1) and p=0, i.e. -EE + pp = -momo (c=1). Another invariant, however, is A= -Et’ + px’, and in this case the minus sign and the discontinuity lead to a new x’,t’ (in comparison with the rest frame for a particle with rest mass mo), but also to t’ -> t’+ b/E and x->x’ +b/p leaving A unchanged (b=constant). The discontinuity in v, which leads to a jump in x’,t’ (as seen in the moving frame) also manifests itself in a time-length interval which ultimately leads to exp(-iEt+ px), we argue. In other words, classically one considers constant velocity as smooth continuous motion, but the introduction of two frames, v=0 and -v, leads to a discontinuity which leads to “chunkiness” in the form of a frequency and wavelength. If these cannot be perceived classically (as is often the case), then one considers only smoothness. Relative differences in time or length or in frequency or wavelength, however, can appear in nature for length scales of the order of the frequency/length scale. In the case of n-slit interference-diffraction, a relative difference leads to a “jump” (so to speak) which manifests the wavelength. In particular, a photon moves along the y direction with a phase px (considering a steady state picture). It reaches a two-slit system along the x-axis and there is probability for it to interact with both slits. If one considers two parallel rays from each slit moving towards a point on a screen very far away (as is done traditionally), there is again smooth motion with a rotated p vector (same magnitude), but for a point on the screen to the left of the center, there is a jump in the length associated with the right slit. In other words, there is a jump similar to the v=0, -v jump. This leads to a relative difference in length associated with both rays (linked to an OR probability situation using exp(ip dot r). This relative difference in length displays the phase difference initiated by special relativity. In the case of a bound state, different impulse hits by a potential create different momenta which have different phases exp(ipx) because of special relativity and one has interference. The same phase A= -Et + p dot r, which is linked with a chunkiness due to a discontinuity, is also associated with continuity because A is a Lorentz invariant. Thus A=constant may be used to solve for refraction/reflection problems with or without moving mirrors/interfaces with different indices of refraction. Continuity appears further in a 1-dimensional reflection/refraction problem when applied to the exp(ipx), i.e. Aexp(ipx) + Bexp(-ipx) = C exp(ip2x) where E=pc = p2 c2, p2=n2p and c2=c/n2 with n1=1, together with a continuity equation for the first derivative. Thus, both continuity and discontinuity (or jumps), which follow from special relativity, seem to play an important role in quantum mechanics.
Abstract We have often found among many of our students and colleagues the common idea that the mathematical expression for a physical quantity that is essentially of quantum nature must contain a dependence on ℏ. Conversely, a phenomenon described by classical physics should contain no explicit reference to ℏ. However, the problem of a particle encountering a discontinuous potential step, which is one of the simplest examples in quantum mechanics, contradicts this common thought: even when the particle carries enough kinetic energy to go across the step, the resulting expression for the reflection probability is non-zero—a purely quantum phenomenon—and yet it contains no reference to ℏ. We show that the absence of ℏ in this purely quantum expression is due to the idealised limit in which the potential rises sharply at a single position, thus losing any reference to a length dimension in the problem. To address the correct classical limit of the phenomenon we first regularise the discontinuity in the potential by taking a continuous linearly rising function over a distance a . We show that the correct classical limit, which is when no reflection occurs, is obtained for large values of a , not for vanishing a . The latter actually corresponds to a purely quantum case, albeit in a limiting case of a discontinuously abrupt change in the potential at a single point in space.
Much of the literature on point interactions in quantum mechanics has focused on the differential form of Schrodinger's equation. This paper, in contrast, investigates the integral form of Schrodinger's equation. While both forms are known to be equivalent for smooth potentials, this is not true for distributional potentials. Here, we assume that the potential is given by a distribution defined on the space of discontinuous test functions. First, by using Schrodinger's integral equation, we confirm a seminal result by Kurasov, which was originally obtained in the context of Schrodinger's differential equation. This hints at a possible deeper connection between both forms of the equation. We also sketch a generalisation of Kurasov's result to hypersurfaces. Second, we derive a new closed-form solution to Schrodinger's integral equation with a delta prime potential. This potential has attracted considerable attention, including some controversy. Interestingly, the derived propagator satisfies boundary conditions that were previously derived using Schrodinger's differential equation. Third, we derive boundary conditions for `super-singular' potentials given by higher-order derivatives of the delta potential. These boundary conditions cannot be incorporated into the normal framework of self-adjoint extensions. We show that the boundary conditions depend on the energy of the solution, and that probability is conserved. This paper thereby confirms several seminal results and derives some new ones. In sum, it shows that Schrodinger's integral equation is viable tool for studying singular interactions in quantum mechanics.