Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Convergence of many-body perturbation methods with lattice summations in extended systems

Jun-Qiang Sun, Rodney J. Bartlett

Published Apr 1, 1997• 22 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Recently the possible divergence of many-body perturbation theory or many-body green function (propagator) methods with lattice summations in extended systems has been raised. The convergence of these methods with lattice summations is not only the key to establishing their correct scaling properties in inhomogeneous systems, but is also a necessity if numerical calculations are to be meaningful. In this report, it is rigorously shown that many-body perturbation theory (MBPT), coupled cluster theory (CC), and many-body green function (MBGF) methods all converge uniformly with lattice summations, although the integrand for the integration over the reciprocal lattice vector, k, could become infinite at special k values. Our proof is given not only for infinite polymers but also for crystals. In our proof, only the continuity of the zeroth-order band structure and Bloch orbitals with k is used. We show that MBPT, CC, and MBGF methods converge with the radius of the lattice summation range R at least as fast as 1/R1/n where n is the dimensionality of the system. It could be much faster if the zeroth-order band structure and Bloch orbitals have continuous first- or even higher-order derivatives with k. In practical numerical calculations, one should not pursue the convergence of the integrand, but the convergence of the correction considered with lattice summations.

DOI
10.1063/1.473577

Related papers

Convergence Behavior of Many-Body Perturbation Theory with Lattice Summations in Polymers

Jun-Qiang Sun, Rodney J. Bartlett

The convergence behavior of many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) with lattice summations directly reflects the spatial property of electron correlation in extended systems. A knowledge of such properties is essential for both theory and numerical calculations. It is shown solely from theory that the second-order MBPT contribution to the total energy per unit cell in polymers converges with lattice size $N$ as $1/{N}^{3}$ while the second-order MBPT contribution to the band energy converges as $1/{N}^{2}$. These convergence behaviors are demonstrated numerically for polyacetylene.

Physical Review Letters•Jan 12, 1998•21 citations

Second-order many-body perturbation-theory calculations in extended systems

Jun-Qiang Sun, Rodney J. Bartlett

Explicit expressions for electron correlation at the second-order many-body perturbation-theory [MBPT(2)] level are presented and implemented for the total energy per unit cell and for the band structure of extended systems. In the latter case, a formula is presented for a direct evaluation of the band gap rather than obtaining it as a difference of two large numbers. Application is made to alternating trans-polyacetylene. We assess the convergence of MBPT(2) with the number of unit cells (N) included in the lattice summations, the number of k-points (K) taken for the integrals over k in the first Brillouin zone, and the cutoff threshold (10−C) for the two-electron integrals. The MBPT(2) correlation correction to the band structure converges very slowly with N and demands a large K while the MBPT(2) correction to the total energy per unit cell converges much faster with N and needs a much smaller K. Neither MBPT(2) correction is sensitive to the cutoff of the two-electron atomic orbital integrals, 10−C, when C≥5. For polyacetylene, the MBPT(2) band gap is much improved from the SCF result, but does not agree with previous numerical data. Analysis shows that the previous MBPT(2) results were obtained either with too few unit cells such that the convergence with N had not been reached, or that the zeroth-order Hartree–Fock results were inadequately converged. MBPT(2) with a DZP basis improves the Hartree–Fock band gap from 5.57 to 3.22 eV at the experimentally estimated geometry, compared to the measured ∼2 eV peak in the absorption spectrum of the system. We verify our results with three independent programs. We also study the band gap as a function of geometry.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jun 1, 1996•161 citations

Connection between GW and Extended Coupled Cluster

Johannes Tölle, Marios‐Petros Kitsaras, Andreas Irmler +2 more

Coupled-cluster (CC) theory and Green’s function many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) have long evolved as distinct yet complementary frameworks for describing electronic correlation. While CC methods employ exponential wave function parametrizations that guarantee size extensivity and systematic improvability, Green’s function approaches, such as the GW approximation, describe quasiparticle and optical excitations through diagrammatic resummations. Recent analyses have established a formal correspondence between these frameworks: the GW approximation is equivalent to an equation-of-motion (EOM) treatment of the direct-ring coupled-cluster doubles (drCCD) method. Within this context, the extended CC (ECC) ansatz offers a unified framework connecting CC and MBPT. This formulation bridges CC-based and Green’s function-based methods, providing novel avenues for incorporating vertex corrections within a CC framework that preserves a sum-over-state representation of the self-energy and leads to potentially systematically improvable Green’s function approaches.

arXiv:2602.10887•Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation•Jun 29, 2026•6 citations

Coupled Cluster Theory in Materials Science

Igor Ying Zhang, Andreas Grüneis

The workhorse method of computational materials science is undeniably density functional theory in the Kohn-Sham framework of approximate exchange and correlation energy functionals. However, the need for highly accurate predictions of ground and excited state properties in materials science motivates the further development and exploration of alternative as well as complementary techniques. Among these alternative approaches, quantum chemical wavefunction based theories and in particular coupled cluster theory hold the promise to fill a gap in the toolbox of computational materials scientists. Coupled cluster (CC) theory provides a compelling framework of approximate infinite-order perturbation theory in the form of an exponential of cluster operators describing the true quantum many-body effects of the electronic wave function at a computational cost that, despite being significantly more expensive than DFT, scales polynomially with system size. The hierarchy of size-extensive approximate methods established in the framework of CC theory achieves systematic improvability for many materials properties. This is in contrast to currently available density functionals that often suffer from uncontrolled approximations that limit the accuracy in the prediction of materials properties. In this tutorial-style review we will introduce basic concepts of coupled cluster theory and recent developments that increase its computational efficiency for calculations of molecules, solids and materials in general. We will touch upon the connection between coupled cluster theory and the random-phase approximation to bridge the gap between traditional quantum chemistry and many-body Green’s function theories that are widely-used in the field of solid state physics. We will discuss various approaches to improve the computational performance without compromising accuracy. These approaches include large-scale parallel design as well as techniques that reduce the prefactor of the computational complexity. A central part of this article discusses the convergence of calculated properties to the thermodynamic limit which is of significant importance for reliable predictions of materials properties and constitutes an additional challenge compared to calculations of large molecules. Furthermore we mention technical aspects of computer code implementations of periodic coupled cluster theories in different numerical frameworks of the one-electron orbital basis; the projector-augmented-wave formalism using a plane wave basis set and the numeric atom-centered-orbital with resolution-of-identity.

arXiv:2004.06424•Frontiers in Materials•Jun 5, 2019•147 citations

Analysis of long‐range effects in many‐body correlation approaches for one‐dimensional periodic systems

Marcel Nooijen, Rodney J. Bartlett

We analyze the divergent contributions to the Hamiltonian for extended, nonmetallic systems in one dimension, to both the ground-state correlation energy and to the correlated band structure. It is shown that the contribution from the long-range divergent part of the Hamiltonian tends to zero as 1/M−2, where M is the extent of the troublesome lattice summations. Therefore, it is well justified to neglect such contributions in higher order many-body perturbation theory or coupled cluster treatments of the electronic structure for polymers. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jan 1, 1997•16 citations

One-particle many-body Green’s function theory: Algebraic recursive definitions, linked-diagram theorem, irreducible-diagram theorem, and general-order algorithms

So Hirata, Alexander E. Doran, Peter J. Knowles +1 more

A thorough analytical and numerical characterization of the whole perturbation series of one-particle many-body Green's function (MBGF) theory is presented in a pedagogical manner. Three distinct but equivalent algebraic (first-quantized) recursive definitions of the perturbation series of the Green's function are derived, which can be combined with the well-known recursion for the self-energy. Six general-order algorithms of MBGF are developed, each implementing one of the three recursions, the ΔMPn method (where n is the perturbation order) [S. Hirata et al., J. Chem. Theory Comput. 11, 1595 (2015)], the automatic generation and interpretation of diagrams, or the numerical differentiation of the exact Green's function with a perturbation-scaled Hamiltonian. They all display the identical, nondivergent perturbation series except ΔMPn, which agrees with MBGF in the diagonal and frequency-independent approximations at 1≤n≤3 but converges at the full-configuration-interaction (FCI) limit at n=∞ (unless it diverges). Numerical data of the perturbation series are presented for Koopmans and non-Koopmans states to quantify the rate of convergence towards the FCI limit and the impact of the diagonal, frequency-independent, or ΔMPn approximation. The diagrammatic linkedness and thus size-consistency of the one-particle Green's function and self-energy are demonstrated at any perturbation order on the basis of the algebraic recursions in an entirely time-independent (frequency-domain) framework. The trimming of external lines in a one-particle Green's function to expose a self-energy diagram and the removal of reducible diagrams are also justified mathematically using the factorization theorem of Frantz and Mills. Equivalence of ΔMPn and MBGF in the diagonal and frequency-independent approximations at 1≤n≤3 is algebraically proven, also ascribing the differences at n = 4 to the so-called semi-reducible and linked-disconnected diagrams.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jul 27, 2017•81 citations
Recently the possible divergence of many-body perturbation theory or many-body green function (propagator) methods with lattice summations in extended systems has been raised. The convergence of these methods with lattice summations is not only the key to establishing their correct scaling properties in inhomogeneous systems, but is also a necessity if numerical calculations are to be meaningful. In this report, it is rigorously shown that many-body perturbation theory (MBPT), coupled cluster theory (CC), and many-body green function (MBGF) methods all converge uniformly with lattice summations, although the integrand for the integration over the reciprocal lattice vector, k, could become infinite at special k values. Our proof is given not only for infinite polymers but also for crystals. In our proof, only the continuity of the zeroth-order band structure and Bloch orbitals with k is used. We show that MBPT, CC, and MBGF methods converge with the radius of the lattice summation range R at least as fast as 1/R1/n where n is the dimensionality of the system. It could be much faster if the zeroth-order band structure and Bloch orbitals have continuous first- or even higher-order derivatives with k. In practical numerical calculations, one should not pursue the convergence of the integrand, but the convergence of the correction considered with lattice summations.
The convergence behavior of many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) with lattice summations directly reflects the spatial property of electron correlation in extended systems. A knowledge of such properties is essential for both theory and numerical calculations. It is shown solely from theory that the second-order MBPT contribution to the total energy per unit cell in polymers converges with lattice size NNN as 1/N31/{N}^{3}1/N3 while the second-order MBPT contribution to the band energy converges as 1/N21/{N}^{2}1/N2. These convergence behaviors are demonstrated numerically for polyacetylene.
Explicit expressions for electron correlation at the second-order many-body perturbation-theory [MBPT(2)] level are presented and implemented for the total energy per unit cell and for the band structure of extended systems. In the latter case, a formula is presented for a direct evaluation of the band gap rather than obtaining it as a difference of two large numbers. Application is made to alternating trans-polyacetylene. We assess the convergence of MBPT(2) with the number of unit cells (N) included in the lattice summations, the number of k-points (K) taken for the integrals over k in the first Brillouin zone, and the cutoff threshold (10−C) for the two-electron integrals. The MBPT(2) correlation correction to the band structure converges very slowly with N and demands a large K while the MBPT(2) correction to the total energy per unit cell converges much faster with N and needs a much smaller K. Neither MBPT(2) correction is sensitive to the cutoff of the two-electron atomic orbital integrals, 10−C, when C≥5. For polyacetylene, the MBPT(2) band gap is much improved from the SCF result, but does not agree with previous numerical data. Analysis shows that the previous MBPT(2) results were obtained either with too few unit cells such that the convergence with N had not been reached, or that the zeroth-order Hartree–Fock results were inadequately converged. MBPT(2) with a DZP basis improves the Hartree–Fock band gap from 5.57 to 3.22 eV at the experimentally estimated geometry, compared to the measured ∼2 eV peak in the absorption spectrum of the system. We verify our results with three independent programs. We also study the band gap as a function of geometry.
Coupled-cluster (CC) theory and Green’s function many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) have long evolved as distinct yet complementary frameworks for describing electronic correlation. While CC methods employ exponential wave function parametrizations that guarantee size extensivity and systematic improvability, Green’s function approaches, such as the GW approximation, describe quasiparticle and optical excitations through diagrammatic resummations. Recent analyses have established a formal correspondence between these frameworks: the GW approximation is equivalent to an equation-of-motion (EOM) treatment of the direct-ring coupled-cluster doubles (drCCD) method. Within this context, the extended CC (ECC) ansatz offers a unified framework connecting CC and MBPT. This formulation bridges CC-based and Green’s function-based methods, providing novel avenues for incorporating vertex corrections within a CC framework that preserves a sum-over-state representation of the self-energy and leads to potentially systematically improvable Green’s function approaches.
The workhorse method of computational materials science is undeniably density functional theory in the Kohn-Sham framework of approximate exchange and correlation energy functionals. However, the need for highly accurate predictions of ground and excited state properties in materials science motivates the further development and exploration of alternative as well as complementary techniques. Among these alternative approaches, quantum chemical wavefunction based theories and in particular coupled cluster theory hold the promise to fill a gap in the toolbox of computational materials scientists. Coupled cluster (CC) theory provides a compelling framework of approximate infinite-order perturbation theory in the form of an exponential of cluster operators describing the true quantum many-body effects of the electronic wave function at a computational cost that, despite being significantly more expensive than DFT, scales polynomially with system size. The hierarchy of size-extensive approximate methods established in the framework of CC theory achieves systematic improvability for many materials properties. This is in contrast to currently available density functionals that often suffer from uncontrolled approximations that limit the accuracy in the prediction of materials properties. In this tutorial-style review we will introduce basic concepts of coupled cluster theory and recent developments that increase its computational efficiency for calculations of molecules, solids and materials in general. We will touch upon the connection between coupled cluster theory and the random-phase approximation to bridge the gap between traditional quantum chemistry and many-body Green’s function theories that are widely-used in the field of solid state physics. We will discuss various approaches to improve the computational performance without compromising accuracy. These approaches include large-scale parallel design as well as techniques that reduce the prefactor of the computational complexity. A central part of this article discusses the convergence of calculated properties to the thermodynamic limit which is of significant importance for reliable predictions of materials properties and constitutes an additional challenge compared to calculations of large molecules. Furthermore we mention technical aspects of computer code implementations of periodic coupled cluster theories in different numerical frameworks of the one-electron orbital basis; the projector-augmented-wave formalism using a plane wave basis set and the numeric atom-centered-orbital with resolution-of-identity.
We analyze the divergent contributions to the Hamiltonian for extended, nonmetallic systems in one dimension, to both the ground-state correlation energy and to the correlated band structure. It is shown that the contribution from the long-range divergent part of the Hamiltonian tends to zero as 1/M−2, where M is the extent of the troublesome lattice summations. Therefore, it is well justified to neglect such contributions in higher order many-body perturbation theory or coupled cluster treatments of the electronic structure for polymers. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
A thorough analytical and numerical characterization of the whole perturbation series of one-particle many-body Green's function (MBGF) theory is presented in a pedagogical manner. Three distinct but equivalent algebraic (first-quantized) recursive definitions of the perturbation series of the Green's function are derived, which can be combined with the well-known recursion for the self-energy. Six general-order algorithms of MBGF are developed, each implementing one of the three recursions, the ΔMPn method (where n is the perturbation order) [S. Hirata et al., J. Chem. Theory Comput. 11, 1595 (2015)], the automatic generation and interpretation of diagrams, or the numerical differentiation of the exact Green's function with a perturbation-scaled Hamiltonian. They all display the identical, nondivergent perturbation series except ΔMPn, which agrees with MBGF in the diagonal and frequency-independent approximations at 1≤n≤3 but converges at the full-configuration-interaction (FCI) limit at n=∞ (unless it diverges). Numerical data of the perturbation series are presented for Koopmans and non-Koopmans states to quantify the rate of convergence towards the FCI limit and the impact of the diagonal, frequency-independent, or ΔMPn approximation. The diagrammatic linkedness and thus size-consistency of the one-particle Green's function and self-energy are demonstrated at any perturbation order on the basis of the algebraic recursions in an entirely time-independent (frequency-domain) framework. The trimming of external lines in a one-particle Green's function to expose a self-energy diagram and the removal of reducible diagrams are also justified mathematically using the factorization theorem of Frantz and Mills. Equivalence of ΔMPn and MBGF in the diagonal and frequency-independent approximations at 1≤n≤3 is algebraically proven, also ascribing the differences at n = 4 to the so-called semi-reducible and linked-disconnected diagrams.