Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

A connection between spin and statistics based on Galilean invariant delta functions

Masanori Kobayashi, M. de Montigny, F. C. Khanna

Published Aug 1, 2010• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We define Galilean invariant delta functions by using the Takahashi formulation, which describes particles with arbitrary spin. The direct calculation of the Galilean invariant delta functions in the (N+1)-dimensional Galilean covariant extended manifolds reveals that, for N odd, there exists a surface on which these delta functions vanish. This feature corresponds to the spacelike separation in the relativistic quantum field theory, and it enables us to discuss a connection between spin and statistics in the Galilean covariant theories. These results show that a spin-statistics connection holds for even-dimensional Galilean covariant extended manifolds; that is, for N-dimensional space-times with odd N≥5. Likewise, we observe that there is no such connection for odd-dimensional Galilean covariant extended manifolds; that is, for N-dimensional space-times with even N≥4. Thus, our results support the claim that there is no connection between spin and statistics in the usual nonrelativistic theory, for which N=4.

DOI
10.1063/1.3456059

Related papers

Spin and statistics in Galilean covariant field theory

C. R. Hägen

The existence of a possible connection between spin and statistics is explored within the framework of Galilean covariant field theory. To this end fields of arbitrary spin are constructed and admissible interaction terms introduced. By explicitly solving such a model in the two-particle sector it is shown that no spin and statistics connection can be established.

arXiv:quant-ph/0403039•Physical Review A•Jul 6, 2004•5 citations

Non-relativistic proofs of the spin-statistics connection

Anil Shaji, E. C. G. Sudarshan

A recent paper by Peshkin [1] has drawn attention again to the problem of understanding the spin statistics connection in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Allen and Mondragon [2] has pointed out correctly some of the flaws in Peshkin's arguments which are based on the single valuedness under rotation of the wave functions of systems of identical particles. We examine carefully the claim that is made in the title of [2] that there can be ``no spin-statistics connection in non-relativistic quantum mechanics''. We show that we can derive the spin statistics connection for non-relativistic quantum field theories which have equations of motion of the Hamiltonian type based on SU(2) invariance of the Lagrangian. The formalism and machinary of non-relativistic quantum field theory as opposed to usual quantum mechanics is necessary for constructing our proof.

arXiv:quant-ph/0306033•Jun 4, 2003•18 citations

Proof of the spin-statistics theorem in the relativistic regimen by Weyl’s conformal quantum mechanics

F. De Martini, Enrico Santamato

The traditional standard theory of quantum mechanics is unable to solve the spin-statistics problem, i.e. to justify the utterly important “Pauli Exclusion Principle” but by the adoption of the complex standard relativistic quantum field theory. In a recent paper [E. Santamato and F. D. De Martini, Found. Phys. 45 (2015) 858] we presented a complete proof of the spin-statistics problem in the nonrelativistic approximation on the basis of the “Conformal Quantum Geometrodynamics” (CQG). In this paper, by the same theory, the proof of the spin-statistics theorem (SST) is extended to the relativistic domain in the scenario of curved spacetime. No relativistic quantum field operators are used in the present proof and the particle exchange properties are drawn from rotational invariance rather than from Lorentz invariance. Our relativistic approach allows to formulate a manifestly step-by-step Weyl gauge invariant theory and to emphasize some fundamental aspects of group theory in the demonstration. As in the nonrelativistic case, we find once more that the “intrinsic helicity” of the elementary particles enters naturally into play. It is therefore this property, not considered in the standard quantum mechanics (SQM), which determines the correct spin-statistics connection observed in Nature.

International Journal of Quantum Information•Apr 28, 2016•4 citations

Weyl-gauge invariant proof of the Spin-Statistics Theorem

Enrico Santamato, F. De Martini

The traditional standard theory of quantum mechanics is unable to solve the spin-statistics problem, i.e. to justify the utterly important \qo{Pauli Exclusion Principle} but by the adoption of the complex standard relativistic quantum field theory. In a recent paper (Ref. [1]) we presented a proof of the spin-statistics problem in the nonrelativistic approximation on the basis of the \qo{Conformal Quantum Geometrodynamics}. In the present paper, by the same theory the proof of the Spin-Statistics Theorem is extended to the relativistic domain in the general scenario of curved spacetime. The relativistic approach allows to formulate a manifestly step-by-step Weyl gauge invariant theory and to emphasize some fundamental aspects of group theory in the demonstration. No relativistic quantum field operators are used and the particle exchange properties are drawn from the conservation of the intrinsic helicity of elementary particles. It is therefore this property, not considered in the Standard Quantum Mechanics, which determines the correct spin-statistics connection observed in Nature [1]. The present proof of the Spin-Statistics Theorem is simpler than the one presented in Ref. [1], because it is based on symmetry group considerations only, without having recourse to frames attached to the particles.

arXiv:1604.06253•Apr 21, 2016•3 citations

Nonrelativistic Quantum Mechanics for Particles with Arbitrary Spin

William J. Hurley

Motivated by the difficulties which persist in the construction of a consistent description of interacting relativistic particles with spin greater than 1, we examine the analogous problem within the framework of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics and find that all of the difficulties vanish in the (Galilei-invariant) limit. It is found that a unique, first-order, Galilei-covariant wave equation describing massive, spin-$s$ particles follows from general invariance assumptions and a minimality condition on the number of components of the wave function. The minimal theory has $6s+1$ components ($2s+1$ of which are independent) and admits a consistent quantum-mechanical interpretation. An external electromagnetic field interaction is introduced via the minimal-coupling replacement, and, in contrast with the relativistic case, a consistent theory emerges for arbitrary spin. The Galilean spin-$s$ particles so described are found to possess only an electric charge and a magnetic dipole with a $g$ factor of $\frac{1}{s}$. The Galilei-invariant addition of arbitrary moment terms is also described. The extension of the formalism to second-quantized spin-$s$ fields is discussed, and it is found that in that case, too, the difficulties are peculiar to the relativistic case. Reasons for the simplicity of the Galilei case are presented. Finally, for the sake of completeness, the first-order form of the Schr\"odinger theory is presented, as well as examples of theories which violate the minimality condition.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•May 15, 1971•35 citations

On the Galilean Duffin–Kemmer–Petiau equation in arbitrary dimensions

M. de Montigny, E. S. Santos

We obtain the representations of the Galilean covariant Duffin–Kemmer–Petiau equation in an arbitrary number of dimensions. Their purpose is to facilitate the study of nonrelativistic many-body systems with spinless and spin-one fields. A Galilean covariant formalism exploits the tensor structure of relativistic Lorentz-invariant theories by adding one extra spacelike coordinate and working with light-cone coordinates.

International Journal of Modern Physics A•Jun 17, 2020•2 citations
We define Galilean invariant delta functions by using the Takahashi formulation, which describes particles with arbitrary spin. The direct calculation of the Galilean invariant delta functions in the (N+1)-dimensional Galilean covariant extended manifolds reveals that, for N odd, there exists a surface on which these delta functions vanish. This feature corresponds to the spacelike separation in the relativistic quantum field theory, and it enables us to discuss a connection between spin and statistics in the Galilean covariant theories. These results show that a spin-statistics connection holds for even-dimensional Galilean covariant extended manifolds; that is, for N-dimensional space-times with odd N≥5. Likewise, we observe that there is no such connection for odd-dimensional Galilean covariant extended manifolds; that is, for N-dimensional space-times with even N≥4. Thus, our results support the claim that there is no connection between spin and statistics in the usual nonrelativistic theory, for which N=4.
A recent paper by Peshkin [1] has drawn attention again to the problem of understanding the spin statistics connection in non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Allen and Mondragon [2] has pointed out correctly some of the flaws in Peshkin's arguments which are based on the single valuedness under rotation of the wave functions of systems of identical particles. We examine carefully the claim that is made in the title of [2] that there can be ``no spin-statistics connection in non-relativistic quantum mechanics''. We show that we can derive the spin statistics connection for non-relativistic quantum field theories which have equations of motion of the Hamiltonian type based on SU(2) invariance of the Lagrangian. The formalism and machinary of non-relativistic quantum field theory as opposed to usual quantum mechanics is necessary for constructing our proof.
The traditional standard theory of quantum mechanics is unable to solve the spin-statistics problem, i.e. to justify the utterly important “Pauli Exclusion Principle” but by the adoption of the complex standard relativistic quantum field theory. In a recent paper [E. Santamato and F. D. De Martini, Found. Phys. 45 (2015) 858] we presented a complete proof of the spin-statistics problem in the nonrelativistic approximation on the basis of the “Conformal Quantum Geometrodynamics” (CQG). In this paper, by the same theory, the proof of the spin-statistics theorem (SST) is extended to the relativistic domain in the scenario of curved spacetime. No relativistic quantum field operators are used in the present proof and the particle exchange properties are drawn from rotational invariance rather than from Lorentz invariance. Our relativistic approach allows to formulate a manifestly step-by-step Weyl gauge invariant theory and to emphasize some fundamental aspects of group theory in the demonstration. As in the nonrelativistic case, we find once more that the “intrinsic helicity” of the elementary particles enters naturally into play. It is therefore this property, not considered in the standard quantum mechanics (SQM), which determines the correct spin-statistics connection observed in Nature.
The traditional standard theory of quantum mechanics is unable to solve the spin-statistics problem, i.e. to justify the utterly important \qo{Pauli Exclusion Principle} but by the adoption of the complex standard relativistic quantum field theory. In a recent paper (Ref. [1]) we presented a proof of the spin-statistics problem in the nonrelativistic approximation on the basis of the \qo{Conformal Quantum Geometrodynamics}. In the present paper, by the same theory the proof of the Spin-Statistics Theorem is extended to the relativistic domain in the general scenario of curved spacetime. The relativistic approach allows to formulate a manifestly step-by-step Weyl gauge invariant theory and to emphasize some fundamental aspects of group theory in the demonstration. No relativistic quantum field operators are used and the particle exchange properties are drawn from the conservation of the intrinsic helicity of elementary particles. It is therefore this property, not considered in the Standard Quantum Mechanics, which determines the correct spin-statistics connection observed in Nature [1]. The present proof of the Spin-Statistics Theorem is simpler than the one presented in Ref. [1], because it is based on symmetry group considerations only, without having recourse to frames attached to the particles.
Motivated by the difficulties which persist in the construction of a consistent description of interacting relativistic particles with spin greater than 1, we examine the analogous problem within the framework of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics and find that all of the difficulties vanish in the (Galilei-invariant) limit. It is found that a unique, first-order, Galilei-covariant wave equation describing massive, spin-sss particles follows from general invariance assumptions and a minimality condition on the number of components of the wave function. The minimal theory has 6s+16s+16s+1 components (2s+12s+12s+1 of which are independent) and admits a consistent quantum-mechanical interpretation. An external electromagnetic field interaction is introduced via the minimal-coupling replacement, and, in contrast with the relativistic case, a consistent theory emerges for arbitrary spin. The Galilean spin-sss particles so described are found to possess only an electric charge and a magnetic dipole with a ggg factor of 1s\frac{1}{s}s1​. The Galilei-invariant addition of arbitrary moment terms is also described. The extension of the formalism to second-quantized spin-sss fields is discussed, and it is found that in that case, too, the difficulties are peculiar to the relativistic case. Reasons for the simplicity of the Galilei case are presented. Finally, for the sake of completeness, the first-order form of the Schr\"odinger theory is presented, as well as examples of theories which violate the minimality condition.