Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Europhysics Letters (EPL)

Statistical Treatment of Dipole-Dipole Interaction in Small-Sample Superradiance

A. Crubellier

Published Jan 15, 1987• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

We describe a new approach of the problem of superradiance in the so-called small samples, based on a statistical treatment of the dipole-dipole interaction. It is first shown that the most probable state of the system is a state in which about half the atoms are still excited. An evolution equation describing the relaxation of the symmetry properties of the collective state under the influence of the dipole-dipole interaction is then derived, by maximizing the entropy of the atomic state for given mean values of the "physical" observables. The temporal evolution of the system is found to simply depend on which process is faster, either the symmetry relaxation or the co-operative spontaneous emission, in each collective energy level.

DOI
10.1209/0295-5075/3/2/010

Related papers

Superradiance and subradiance. III. Small samples

A. Crubellier

For pt.II see ibid., vol.19, p.2109 (1986). This paper is the third in a theoretical study of subradiance, i.e. the cooperative inhibition of spontaneous emission by a destructive interatomic interference, a phenomenon which has recently been observed. The paper is devoted to the problem of the cooperative spontaneous emission of atomic samples with linear dimensions much smaller than the wavelength of the emitted light. The treatment, which is based on a fully quantum mechanical description of the problem, corroborates the results obtained in a semiclassical treatment by Friedberg and Hartmann (1974). Starting from a master equation describing both the cooperative spontaneous emission and the dipole-dipole interaction, a statistical treatment of the latter is introduced and the corresponding symmetry relaxation is studied. The evolution of the atoms is described in three typical cases that correspond to different sample geometries and/or atomic distributions. In one of these cases, in particular, the symmetry is first conserved and the atoms follow Dicke's predictions for a time. A 'retarded' symmetry breaking then occurs suddenly, near the zero value of the collective energy, as in Friedberg and Hartmann's calculations for a small sphere. With regard to the further evolution of the atoms in this case, which cannot be studied in a semiclassical model, it is shown that the decay rate quickly becomes much smaller than the incoherent decay rate. An unquestionable subradiance phenomenon is thus predicted in this case.

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics•Mar 14, 1987•18 citations

Quantum Statistical Theory of Superradiance. I

R. Bonifacio, P. Schwendimann, Fritz Haake

We discuss the cooperative decay of initial atomic excitation for a pencil-shaped active volume filled with two-level atoms. As long as the length of the sample is much smaller than a certain maximal cooperation length, the atom-field interaction producing the superradiant pulse can be treated in terms of the simplest possible laser model (single mode). The basic laser master equation turns out to be exactly solvable if specified for the superradiance limit which is characterized by two conditions: (i) The photons escape from the low-$Q$ cavity so fast that they cannot feed themselves back into atomic excitation to any appreciable amount (this no-feedback condition is equivalent to the above-mentioned requirement for the length of the sample). (ii) The incoherent atomic decay due to natural relaxation is so slow that the individual atomic dipoles do not dephase before engaging themselves cooperatively in the interaction with the electromagnetic field. The present paper presents the derivation and general discussion of the equations describing the statistical properties of atoms and field in a superradiant pulse. Analytical and numerical solutions will be presented in a subsequent paper.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1971•524 citations

Level-degeneracy effects in superradiance theory

A. Crubellier

Up to now, the problem of the influence of level degeneracy on superradiance has been neglected. We describe here a first approach to this problem, in the frame of "small system" quantum model, generalized to the case of a collection of atoms with two degenerate levels of angular momenta $j$ and ${j}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ connected by an electric or magnetic dipole transition. The differences between this case and the well-known case of two (nondegenerate) level atoms are of two types. The first type is due to the competition between different transitions sharing a common state: superradiant emission on a transition inhibits or initiates superradiance on transitions with smaller transition probability, depending upon which state, upper or lower, is the common one. This effect does not come from the equality of the different wavelengths and would also appear with the same states even if the degeneracy were removed; its qualitative influence on the features of the superradiant pulse can be easily estimated. The second type of differences is quite specific to level degeneracy and consists in interferences between the transitions of the collective system having the same frequency and polarization. In analogy with the description of collections of two-level atoms as spin-\textonehalf{} systems, a group-theoretical description of the considered collection of atoms is found suitable; the problem of the determination of a basis of collective states and its group-theoretical implications are discussed; in particular, it is found that the isotropic character of spontaneous emission allows us to use tensorial formalism and simplifies the formal description of the problem.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1977•22 citations

Exact solution of the superradiance master equation. II. Arbitrary initial excitation

Ching Tsung Lee

The cooperative spontaneous emission from a system of $N$ identical two-level atoms, excited arbitrarily and interacting with a single mode of radiation, is studied by using the Bonifacio-Schwendimann-Haake approach. The evolution of the probability distribution of the atomic system is considered as a Markov process described by a time-evolution matrix (TEM). The exact analytic expressions for the elements of this TEM are obtained by solving the superradiance master equation. It is proved that the TEM satisfies the normalization condition and the Chapman-Kolmogorov equation as required. The exact general formulas for the expectation values of various physical observables, expressed in terms of an arbitrary initial distribution, are obtained. Finally, these results are applied to a specific example, the superradiant initial state.

Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1977•18 citations

A Quasi-Probability Approach to the Cooperative Spontaneous Emission

Kensuke S. Ikeda, H. Ito

The dynamics of the co-operative. spontaneous emission· from many· two-level atoms is investigated by introducing a specific form of quasi-probability distribution which apparently excludes the vacuum fluctuation of the radiation field but includes the ·fluctuation of the atomic dipole moment. It is shown that the equation of motion for the random variables associated with the atom-field coupled system can be written in a quite classical form. As a result, the formula is derived for computing the multi-time correlation functions of the radi­ ation field-essential to its coherence properties-which generalizes Bonifacio, Schwendimann and Haake's adiabatic corresponding theorem. § 1. Introduction. The co-operative spontaneous emission (so-called superradiance) from an as­ sembly of many two-level atoms first discussed by Dicke in 1954n has been studied by many authors with different methods, roughly speaking, classicall/> and quantum mechanically. 3>-5> The classical approach, though simple, has a special significance for the dynamics of a large number of atoms participating in phase, and has succeeded except when the population of the atoms is completely inverted. The failure of the simple classical treatment in the case of complete inversion is due to the fact that the effect of spontaneous emission is not considered at all, so that emission is impossible from such a state as with no dipole moment.2>.s> Therefore, if one takes into account adequately the quantum fluctuation of the tdtal dipole moment which exists even when the atoms are fully excited, one should be able to describe the spontaneous emission from a classical point of view. This idea was suggested by Senitzky6> in a rather intuitive argument. In the present paper an attempt is made to formulate the above problem from a quasi-probability point of view. To this end we make here a particular choice of the representation of the quantum density operators (or quasi-probability. distri­ bution functions abbreviated by QPDF hereafter) among others7l-Io> by which the quantum mechanical equation of motion may be transformed into a form in an . associated c-number phase space, i.e., the yvell-known P-representation 9> of Glauber IS taken for the field variables and the so-~alled Q~representation based on the

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Feb 1, 1976•4 citations

Dicke-like superradiance of distant noninteracting atoms

Manuel Bojer, Joachim von Zanthier

Fully excited two-level atoms separated by less than the transition wavelength cooperatively emit light in a short burst, a phenomenon called superradiance by R. Dicke in 1954 [Phys. Rev. 93, 99 (1954)]. The burst is characterized by a maximum intensity scaling with the square of the number of atoms $N$ and a temporal width reduced by $N$ compared to the single atom spontaneous decay time. Both effects are usually attributed to a synchronization of the electric dipole moments of the atoms occurring during the process of light emission. Contrary to this explanation, it was recently shown by use of a quantum path description that the peak intensity results from the quantum correlations among the atoms when occupying symmetric Dicke states. Here we investigate from this perspective the temporal evolution of the ensemble, starting in the small sample limit, i.e., when the atoms have mutual separations much smaller than the transition wavelength $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and pass down the ladder of symmetric Dicke states. In addition, we explore the temporal evolution for the case of distant noninteracting atoms with mutual separations much larger than $\ensuremath{\lambda}$. We show that in this case a similar superradiant burst of the emitted radiation is observed if the quantum correlations of the atoms are generated by conditional photon measurements retaining the atomic ensemble within or close to the symmetric subspace.

arXiv:2206.14646•Physical Review A•Nov 17, 2022•11 citations
We describe a new approach of the problem of superradiance in the so-called small samples, based on a statistical treatment of the dipole-dipole interaction. It is first shown that the most probable state of the system is a state in which about half the atoms are still excited. An evolution equation describing the relaxation of the symmetry properties of the collective state under the influence of the dipole-dipole interaction is then derived, by maximizing the entropy of the atomic state for given mean values of the "physical" observables. The temporal evolution of the system is found to simply depend on which process is faster, either the symmetry relaxation or the co-operative spontaneous emission, in each collective energy level.
For pt.II see ibid., vol.19, p.2109 (1986). This paper is the third in a theoretical study of subradiance, i.e. the cooperative inhibition of spontaneous emission by a destructive interatomic interference, a phenomenon which has recently been observed. The paper is devoted to the problem of the cooperative spontaneous emission of atomic samples with linear dimensions much smaller than the wavelength of the emitted light. The treatment, which is based on a fully quantum mechanical description of the problem, corroborates the results obtained in a semiclassical treatment by Friedberg and Hartmann (1974). Starting from a master equation describing both the cooperative spontaneous emission and the dipole-dipole interaction, a statistical treatment of the latter is introduced and the corresponding symmetry relaxation is studied. The evolution of the atoms is described in three typical cases that correspond to different sample geometries and/or atomic distributions. In one of these cases, in particular, the symmetry is first conserved and the atoms follow Dicke's predictions for a time. A 'retarded' symmetry breaking then occurs suddenly, near the zero value of the collective energy, as in Friedberg and Hartmann's calculations for a small sphere. With regard to the further evolution of the atoms in this case, which cannot be studied in a semiclassical model, it is shown that the decay rate quickly becomes much smaller than the incoherent decay rate. An unquestionable subradiance phenomenon is thus predicted in this case.
We discuss the cooperative decay of initial atomic excitation for a pencil-shaped active volume filled with two-level atoms. As long as the length of the sample is much smaller than a certain maximal cooperation length, the atom-field interaction producing the superradiant pulse can be treated in terms of the simplest possible laser model (single mode). The basic laser master equation turns out to be exactly solvable if specified for the superradiance limit which is characterized by two conditions: (i) The photons escape from the low-QQQ cavity so fast that they cannot feed themselves back into atomic excitation to any appreciable amount (this no-feedback condition is equivalent to the above-mentioned requirement for the length of the sample). (ii) The incoherent atomic decay due to natural relaxation is so slow that the individual atomic dipoles do not dephase before engaging themselves cooperatively in the interaction with the electromagnetic field. The present paper presents the derivation and general discussion of the equations describing the statistical properties of atoms and field in a superradiant pulse. Analytical and numerical solutions will be presented in a subsequent paper.
Up to now, the problem of the influence of level degeneracy on superradiance has been neglected. We describe here a first approach to this problem, in the frame of "small system" quantum model, generalized to the case of a collection of atoms with two degenerate levels of angular momenta jjj and ${j}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ connected by an electric or magnetic dipole transition. The differences between this case and the well-known case of two (nondegenerate) level atoms are of two types. The first type is due to the competition between different transitions sharing a common state: superradiant emission on a transition inhibits or initiates superradiance on transitions with smaller transition probability, depending upon which state, upper or lower, is the common one. This effect does not come from the equality of the different wavelengths and would also appear with the same states even if the degeneracy were removed; its qualitative influence on the features of the superradiant pulse can be easily estimated. The second type of differences is quite specific to level degeneracy and consists in interferences between the transitions of the collective system having the same frequency and polarization. In analogy with the description of collections of two-level atoms as spin-\textonehalf{} systems, a group-theoretical description of the considered collection of atoms is found suitable; the problem of the determination of a basis of collective states and its group-theoretical implications are discussed; in particular, it is found that the isotropic character of spontaneous emission allows us to use tensorial formalism and simplifies the formal description of the problem.
The cooperative spontaneous emission from a system of NNN identical two-level atoms, excited arbitrarily and interacting with a single mode of radiation, is studied by using the Bonifacio-Schwendimann-Haake approach. The evolution of the probability distribution of the atomic system is considered as a Markov process described by a time-evolution matrix (TEM). The exact analytic expressions for the elements of this TEM are obtained by solving the superradiance master equation. It is proved that the TEM satisfies the normalization condition and the Chapman-Kolmogorov equation as required. The exact general formulas for the expectation values of various physical observables, expressed in terms of an arbitrary initial distribution, are obtained. Finally, these results are applied to a specific example, the superradiant initial state.
The dynamics of the co-operative. spontaneous emission· from many· two-level atoms is investigated by introducing a specific form of quasi-probability distribution which apparently excludes the vacuum fluctuation of the radiation field but includes the ·fluctuation of the atomic dipole moment. It is shown that the equation of motion for the random variables associated with the atom-field coupled system can be written in a quite classical form. As a result, the formula is derived for computing the multi-time correlation functions of the radi­ ation field-essential to its coherence properties-which generalizes Bonifacio, Schwendimann and Haake's adiabatic corresponding theorem. § 1. Introduction. The co-operative spontaneous emission (so-called superradiance) from an as­ sembly of many two-level atoms first discussed by Dicke in 1954n has been studied by many authors with different methods, roughly speaking, classicall/> and quantum mechanically. 3>-5> The classical approach, though simple, has a special significance for the dynamics of a large number of atoms participating in phase, and has succeeded except when the population of the atoms is completely inverted. The failure of the simple classical treatment in the case of complete inversion is due to the fact that the effect of spontaneous emission is not considered at all, so that emission is impossible from such a state as with no dipole moment.2>.s> Therefore, if one takes into account adequately the quantum fluctuation of the tdtal dipole moment which exists even when the atoms are fully excited, one should be able to describe the spontaneous emission from a classical point of view. This idea was suggested by Senitzky6> in a rather intuitive argument. In the present paper an attempt is made to formulate the above problem from a quasi-probability point of view. To this end we make here a particular choice of the representation of the quantum density operators (or quasi-probability. distri­ bution functions abbreviated by QPDF hereafter) among others7l-Io> by which the quantum mechanical equation of motion may be transformed into a form in an . associated c-number phase space, i.e., the yvell-known P-representation 9> of Glauber IS taken for the field variables and the so-~alled Q~representation based on the
Fully excited two-level atoms separated by less than the transition wavelength cooperatively emit light in a short burst, a phenomenon called superradiance by R. Dicke in 1954 [Phys. Rev. 93, 99 (1954)]. The burst is characterized by a maximum intensity scaling with the square of the number of atoms NNN and a temporal width reduced by NNN compared to the single atom spontaneous decay time. Both effects are usually attributed to a synchronization of the electric dipole moments of the atoms occurring during the process of light emission. Contrary to this explanation, it was recently shown by use of a quantum path description that the peak intensity results from the quantum correlations among the atoms when occupying symmetric Dicke states. Here we investigate from this perspective the temporal evolution of the ensemble, starting in the small sample limit, i.e., when the atoms have mutual separations much smaller than the transition wavelength $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ and pass down the ladder of symmetric Dicke states. In addition, we explore the temporal evolution for the case of distant noninteracting atoms with mutual separations much larger than $\ensuremath{\lambda}$. We show that in this case a similar superradiant burst of the emitted radiation is observed if the quantum correlations of the atoms are generated by conditional photon measurements retaining the atomic ensemble within or close to the symmetric subspace.