Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Progress of Theoretical Physics

Electron Pairs in the Theory of Superconductivity

John M. Blatt

Published Mar 1, 1960• 46 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The detailed mathematical correspondence between the Bogoliubov theory and the quasi-chemical equilibrium theory is established by means of identities. The Bogoliubov-BCS Ansatz is a special case of the quasi-chemical equilibrium Ansatz, corresponding to prefect Bose-Einstein condensation of the electron pairs.
DOI
10.1143/ptp.23.447

Related papers

Self-Consistency in the Quasi-Chemical Equilibrium Theory of Superconductivity

Colin J. Thompson, Takeo Matsubara

By expressing the density matrix, for the special case of one pair state only and simple pairing, in exponential form, we reproduce the results of earlier papers and obtain an expression for the entropy which is formally identical with that of Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer and that of Bogoliubov. The expression for the entropy is shown to be exact in the limit of infinite volume. A variational calculation is then performed and the resulting set of equations is identical with that of B.C.S., thus establishing the relation between the Quasi-Chemical Equilibrium, the B.C.S., and the Bogoliubov theories of superconductivity at non-zero temperature.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Apr 1, 1963•1 citation

BCS and BEC Finally Unified: A Brief Review

Josep Amengual i Batle, Montserrat Casas, Mauricio Fortes +5 more

We review efforts to unify both the Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer (BCS) and Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) pictures of superconductivity. We have finally achieved this in terms of a "\textit{complete} boson-fermion (BF) model" (CBFM) that reduces in special cases to all the main continuum (as opposed to "spin") statistical theories of superconductivity. Our BF model is "complete" in the sense that not only two-electron (2e) but also two-hole (2h) Cooper pairs (CPs) are allowed in arbitrary proportions. In contrast, BCS-Bogoliubov theory--which can also be considered as the theory of a mixture of kinematically independent electrons, 2e- and 2h-CPs--allows only equal, 50%-50%, mixtures of the two kinds of CPs. This is obvious from the perfect symmetry about $μ$, the electron chemical potential, of the well-known Bogoliubov $v^{2}(ε)$ and $u^{2}(ε)$ coefficients, where $ε$ is the electron energy. The CBFM is then applied to see: a) whether the BCS model interaction for the electron-phonon dynamical mechanism is sufficient to predict the unusually high values of $T_{c}$ (in units of the Fermi temperature) of $\simeq 0.01-0.1$ exhibited by the so-called ``exotic'' superconductors \cite{Brandow} in both 2D and 3D--relative to the low values of $\lesssim 10^{-3}$ more or less correctly predicted by BCS theory for conventional, elemental superconductors; and b) whether it can at least suggest, if not explain, why "hole superconductors" have higher $T_{c}$'s.

arXiv:cond-mat/0211456•Nov 21, 2002•13 citations

The Bogoliubov Approach

Monique Combescot, Shiue-Yuan Shiau

Chapter 8 deals with the Bogoliubov approach to the BCS problem. This approach is of fundamental interest because it gives a mathematical support to the BCS ansatz, which was simply proposed by Bardeen, Cooper, and Schrieffer as a trial wave function. This chapter shows that the BCS ansatz corresponds to the ground-state wave function of the one-body Bogoliubov Hamiltonian constructed from the BCS Hamiltonian. This mathematical support is highly welcome because the BCS ansatz contains the questionable idea that composite bosons condense, like elementary bosons, all into the same state, even if the product of N identical electron pair operators substantially differs from that of N single pair operators when N gets large, owing to the moth-eaten effect induced by the Pauli exclusion principle.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 1, 2015•0 citations

BCS Theory of Superconductivity

A. S. Alexandrov, Nevill Mott

The crucial demonstration that superfluidity was linked to Bose particles and Bose-Einstein condensation came after the discovery of He3 in 1949, which failed to show the characteristic A transition within a reasonable wide temperature interval around the critical temperature for the onset of superfluidity in He4. The idea of the bosonization of electrons due to their pairing, introduced by Ogg (1946) became very attractive as an explanation for superconductivity after Schafroth (1955) showed that a gas of charged bosons with charge 2e would indeed show a Meissner effect, which is one of the most crucial features of superconductors (see Chapter 1). However this phenomenological Bose-gas picture was condemned and later on practically forgotten because it was unable to account quantitatively for the critical parameters of the classical (low-temperature) superconductors. Using for Tc the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature Eq.(l.S) one obtains the utterly meaningless result Tc = lOOOO.R&s; with the atomic density of electron pairs ~ 1022cm~3 and with the effective mass m** = 2me. The failure of the Schafroth picture stems from a very large size £ of pairs in classical superconductors, which can be estimated from the uncertainty principle: The uncertainty of the momentum 8p is estimated from the uncertainty of the kinetic energy 8E ~ vpSp, which should be of the order of Tc, the only characteristic energy of the superconducting state. Therefore and turns out to be more than one micron for simple metals with Tc ~ IK and the Fermi velocity VF — I0scm/s. That means that pairs in classical superconductors overlap strongly and the Shafroth model of real space pairs is wrong. The finally successful theory for classical superconductors was formulated by Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer (1957). In this chapter we present the main points of the BCS theory, using the Bogoliubov transformation (1947,1958) for the weak-coupling regime and the Green&s;s function technique for the intermediate coupling in Chapter 3. More details will be found in the excellent books by Schrieffer(1965), De Gennes (1989) and Abrikosov, Gor&s;kov and Dzyaloshinskii (1963).

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Nov 24, 1994•0 citations

Investigations towards an understanding of superconductivity

Robert Mccredie May

The work embodied in this thesis falls into three distinct parts :- the magnetic behaviour of a charged 2-dimensional Bose gas; the Meissner-Ochsenfeld effect in the Bogoljubov theory; and a study of pair correlations in the quasi-chemical equilibrium approach to superconductivity.

•Jan 1, 1959•0 citations

Pairing phenomena

In this chapter the extension of the Green’s function formalism to super-fluid (superconducting) systems is presented. The ground state of these systems can be characterized by a macroscopic occupation of a specific pair state. Such a possibility had already been anticipated in the treatment of Cooper pairing in Sec. 15.3. In Sec. 22.1 the general concept of condensation into a quasi-boson or fermion pair state is introduced. This has much in common with the phenomenon of Bose–Einstein condensation for identical bosons, and throughout this chapter we will emphasize the analogy. In Sec. 22.2 the Fermi gas is revisited and we introduce the concept of anomalous propagators. The perturbation expansion of the propagators, and the corresponding diagram rules, are derived in Sec. 22.3. In lowest-order this leads to the Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer (BCS) treatment of superconductivity, explained in Sec. 22.4. We rederive in Sec. 22.5 the BCS theory by employing the Bogoliubov–Valatin transformation to quasiparticles. This alternative formulation exposes the mean-field character and variational interpretation of BCS. Various applications, such as superconductivity in metals, the superfluid 3 He, and nucleon pairing in neutron stars, are brifley discussed in Sec. 22.6. In Sec. 22.7 the BCS formalism is expressed in terms of an arbitrary sp basis, allowing an extension to inhomogeneous settings. The chapter ends with a discussion of exactly solvable pairing models in Sec. 22.8, a recent topic of importance for finite systems.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Oct 13, 2025•0 citations
By expressing the density matrix, for the special case of one pair state only and simple pairing, in exponential form, we reproduce the results of earlier papers and obtain an expression for the entropy which is formally identical with that of Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer and that of Bogoliubov. The expression for the entropy is shown to be exact in the limit of infinite volume. A variational calculation is then performed and the resulting set of equations is identical with that of B.C.S., thus establishing the relation between the Quasi-Chemical Equilibrium, the B.C.S., and the Bogoliubov theories of superconductivity at non-zero temperature.
We review efforts to unify both the Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer (BCS) and Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) pictures of superconductivity. We have finally achieved this in terms of a "\textit{complete} boson-fermion (BF) model" (CBFM) that reduces in special cases to all the main continuum (as opposed to "spin") statistical theories of superconductivity. Our BF model is "complete" in the sense that not only two-electron (2e) but also two-hole (2h) Cooper pairs (CPs) are allowed in arbitrary proportions. In contrast, BCS-Bogoliubov theory--which can also be considered as the theory of a mixture of kinematically independent electrons, 2e- and 2h-CPs--allows only equal, 50%-50%, mixtures of the two kinds of CPs. This is obvious from the perfect symmetry about μμμ, the electron chemical potential, of the well-known Bogoliubov v2(ε)v^{2}(ε)v2(ε) and u2(ε)u^{2}(ε)u2(ε) coefficients, where εεε is the electron energy. The CBFM is then applied to see: a) whether the BCS model interaction for the electron-phonon dynamical mechanism is sufficient to predict the unusually high values of TcT_{c}Tc​ (in units of the Fermi temperature) of ≃0.01−0.1\simeq 0.01-0.1≃0.01−0.1 exhibited by the so-called ``exotic'' superconductors \cite{Brandow} in both 2D and 3D--relative to the low values of ≲10−3\lesssim 10^{-3}≲10−3 more or less correctly predicted by BCS theory for conventional, elemental superconductors; and b) whether it can at least suggest, if not explain, why "hole superconductors" have higher TcT_{c}Tc​'s.
Chapter 8 deals with the Bogoliubov approach to the BCS problem. This approach is of fundamental interest because it gives a mathematical support to the BCS ansatz, which was simply proposed by Bardeen, Cooper, and Schrieffer as a trial wave function. This chapter shows that the BCS ansatz corresponds to the ground-state wave function of the one-body Bogoliubov Hamiltonian constructed from the BCS Hamiltonian. This mathematical support is highly welcome because the BCS ansatz contains the questionable idea that composite bosons condense, like elementary bosons, all into the same state, even if the product of N identical electron pair operators substantially differs from that of N single pair operators when N gets large, owing to the moth-eaten effect induced by the Pauli exclusion principle.
The crucial demonstration that superfluidity was linked to Bose particles and Bose-Einstein condensation came after the discovery of He3 in 1949, which failed to show the characteristic A transition within a reasonable wide temperature interval around the critical temperature for the onset of superfluidity in He4. The idea of the bosonization of electrons due to their pairing, introduced by Ogg (1946) became very attractive as an explanation for superconductivity after Schafroth (1955) showed that a gas of charged bosons with charge 2e would indeed show a Meissner effect, which is one of the most crucial features of superconductors (see Chapter 1). However this phenomenological Bose-gas picture was condemned and later on practically forgotten because it was unable to account quantitatively for the critical parameters of the classical (low-temperature) superconductors. Using for Tc the Bose-Einstein condensation temperature Eq.(l.S) one obtains the utterly meaningless result Tc = lOOOO.R&s; with the atomic density of electron pairs ~ 1022cm~3 and with the effective mass m** = 2me. The failure of the Schafroth picture stems from a very large size £ of pairs in classical superconductors, which can be estimated from the uncertainty principle: The uncertainty of the momentum 8p is estimated from the uncertainty of the kinetic energy 8E ~ vpSp, which should be of the order of Tc, the only characteristic energy of the superconducting state. Therefore and turns out to be more than one micron for simple metals with Tc ~ IK and the Fermi velocity VF — I0scm/s. That means that pairs in classical superconductors overlap strongly and the Shafroth model of real space pairs is wrong. The finally successful theory for classical superconductors was formulated by Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer (1957). In this chapter we present the main points of the BCS theory, using the Bogoliubov transformation (1947,1958) for the weak-coupling regime and the Green&s;s function technique for the intermediate coupling in Chapter 3. More details will be found in the excellent books by Schrieffer(1965), De Gennes (1989) and Abrikosov, Gor&s;kov and Dzyaloshinskii (1963).
In this chapter the extension of the Green’s function formalism to super-fluid (superconducting) systems is presented. The ground state of these systems can be characterized by a macroscopic occupation of a specific pair state. Such a possibility had already been anticipated in the treatment of Cooper pairing in Sec. 15.3. In Sec. 22.1 the general concept of condensation into a quasi-boson or fermion pair state is introduced. This has much in common with the phenomenon of Bose–Einstein condensation for identical bosons, and throughout this chapter we will emphasize the analogy. In Sec. 22.2 the Fermi gas is revisited and we introduce the concept of anomalous propagators. The perturbation expansion of the propagators, and the corresponding diagram rules, are derived in Sec. 22.3. In lowest-order this leads to the Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer (BCS) treatment of superconductivity, explained in Sec. 22.4. We rederive in Sec. 22.5 the BCS theory by employing the Bogoliubov–Valatin transformation to quasiparticles. This alternative formulation exposes the mean-field character and variational interpretation of BCS. Various applications, such as superconductivity in metals, the superfluid 3 He, and nucleon pairing in neutron stars, are brifley discussed in Sec. 22.6. In Sec. 22.7 the BCS formalism is expressed in terms of an arbitrary sp basis, allowing an extension to inhomogeneous settings. The chapter ends with a discussion of exactly solvable pairing models in Sec. 22.8, a recent topic of importance for finite systems.