Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Superfluid Phase Transitions in One and Two Dimensions

Allan Widom

Published Dec 5, 1968• 35 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A recently proved theorem of statistical physics states that a one- or two-dimensional Bose liquid in homogeneous thermodynamic equilibrium cannot undergo Bose-Einstein condensation. The theorem does not apply to inhomogeneous liquids. This is shown by considering the ideal Bose liquid (i) in the presence of a gravitational field and (ii) in rotational motion. The existence of well-defined one- and two-dimensional phase transitions with Bose-Einstein condensation is proved by these explicit examples.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.176.254

Related papers

Condensation of the Rotating Two-Dimensional Ideal Bose Gas

John J. Rehr, N. David Mermin

The two-dimensional ideal Bose gas in a circular container rotating at fixed rim velocity has some unexpected and instructive properties. In the thermodynamic limit, the system undergoes a phase transition, as argued by Widom. We find that the transition is a type of Bose-Einstein condensation, in which, however, infinitely many one-particle states are macroscopically occupied. The system evades general theorems forbidding Bose-Einstein condensation in two dimensions, not merely because it is inhomogeneous, as Widom suggests, but because the equilibrium density is unbounded near the circumference in the thermodynamic limit. We point out that, independently of the particular model, Bose-Einstein condensation into any single-particle state (or states), spatially uniform or nonuniform, is forbidden in one and two dimensions provided only that (a) the Hamiltonian is real, and (b) the equilibrium density is everywhere bounded in the thermodynamic limit.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Apr 1, 1970•32 citations

Statistical Mechanics of Rotating Quantum Liquids

Allan Widom

The statistical physics of rotating fluids is discussed with particular emphasis on the rules for taking the thermodynamic limit of infinite size. The thermodynamics of a rotating ideal Bose liquid is explicitly worked out. It is found that the rotating ideal Bose liquid undergoes a Bose-Einstein condensation; however, the first-order phase transitions predicted by Blatt and Butler are not present when the thermodynamic limit is properly taken.

Physical Review•Apr 5, 1968•14 citations

Bose-Einstein condensation in layered systems

A Haerdig, F. Ravndal

The thermodynamic properties of an ideal gas of bosons moving freely within layered planes and having a finite amplitude for jumping between neighbouring planes, are derived. As long as this coupling is non-zero, the system becomes effectively two-dimensional at sufficiently high temperatures. At a correspondingly low temperature it undergoes a Bose-Einstein transition into a condensed phase as in three dimensions. Below the critical temperature the specific heat is a universal function of only one dimensionless system variable. The phase transition becomes weaker as the coupling between the planes decreases and eventually disappears when the planes decouple.

European Journal of Physics•Jul 1, 1993•9 citations

Superfluid transition of homogeneous and trapped two-dimensional Bose gases

Markus Holzmann, Gordon Baym, Jean-Paul Blaizot +1 more

Current experiments on atomic gases in highly anisotropic traps present the opportunity to study in detail the low temperature phases of two-dimensional inhomogeneous systems. Although, in an ideal gas, the trapping potential favors Bose-Einstein condensation at finite temperature, interactions tend to destabilize the condensate, leading to a superfluid Kosterlitz-Thouless-Berezinskii phase with a finite superfluid mass density but no long-range order, as in homogeneous fluids. The transition in homogeneous systems is conveniently described in terms of dissociation of topological defects (vortex-antivortex pairs). However, trapped two-dimensional gases are more directly approached by generalizing the microscopic theory of the homogeneous gas. In this paper, we first derive, via a diagrammatic expansion, the scaling structure near the phase transition in a homogeneous system, and then study the effects of a trapping potential in the local density approximation. We find that a weakly interacting trapped gas undergoes a Kosterlitz-Thouless-Berezinskii transition from the normal state at a temperature slightly below the Bose-Einstein transition temperature of the ideal gas. The characteristic finite superfluid mass density of a homogeneous system just below the transition becomes strongly suppressed in a trapped gas.

Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences•Jan 23, 2007•75 citations

Liquid Helium II: Bose-Einstein Condensation and Two-Fluid Model

Paul R. Zilsel

The Bose-Einstein condensation mechanism is shown to be capable of accounting for the existence of separate hydrodynamic velocity fields for the normal and the superfluid, provided suitable assumptions are made with regard to the single-particle energy spectrum. We consider the effect on the microcanonical gas distribution of imposing a nonzero value of the total momentum P. For an ordinary gas the effect is trivial, the whole distribution being merely shifted in momentum space. However, in the case of a degenerate Bose gas whose single-particle energy spectrum has a sharp minimum (gap or cusp), only the excited part of the gas (normal fluid) participates in the imposed motion, the condensate (superfluid) remaining "frozen" in momentum space. This rigidity of the condensate in momentum space plays the same role as the rigidity of the superelectrons on imposition of a magnetic field in the London theory of superconductivity. P acts as an additional thermodynamic variable, states with P \ensuremath{\ne} 0 being macroscopically metastable and corresponding to the existence of a relative velocity between normal and superfluid. The basic hydrodynamic assumption of the two-fluid model is thus reduced to an assumption concerning the form of an effective single-particle energy spectrum, and the parallelism between the theories of superconductivity and superfluidity is clearly exhibited. The present theory permits, in particular, the introduction of the mathematical form of Landau's phonon and "roton" spectra within the framework of the Bose-Einstein condensation picture. The statistical-thermodynamic formulas are derived and are shown to lead to characteristic two-fluid equations derived previously from a variational principle.

Physical Review•Dec 1, 1953•12 citations

Hard bosons in one dimension

E. Buffet, Joseph V. Pulé

We establish a general criterion relating the absence of Bose-Einstein condensation to specific properties of the one-body reduced density matrix. A general model of hard particles in one dimension is investigated in detail. The results are subsequently applied to hard Bosons in a weak gravitational field. The thermodynamic functions of this system show a singularity at a critical value of the density. However, we prove that this phase transition is not Bose-Einstein condensation On demontre l'equivalence entre l'absence de condensation de Bose-Einstein et certaines proprietes de la matrice densite reduite a un corps. On etudie en detail les proprietes des systemes unidimensionnels de particules a cœurs durs. On applique ces resultats au gaz de Bose a cœur dur soumis a un champ de gravitation faible. Dans ce modele, les fonctions thermodynamiques presentent une singularite a une certaine densite critique. Cependant, on demontre que cette transition de phase n'est pas la condensation de Bose-Einstein

Annales De L Institut Henri Poincare-physique Theorique•Jan 1, 1986•4 citations
A recently proved theorem of statistical physics states that a one- or two-dimensional Bose liquid in homogeneous thermodynamic equilibrium cannot undergo Bose-Einstein condensation. The theorem does not apply to inhomogeneous liquids. This is shown by considering the ideal Bose liquid (i) in the presence of a gravitational field and (ii) in rotational motion. The existence of well-defined one- and two-dimensional phase transitions with Bose-Einstein condensation is proved by these explicit examples.
The two-dimensional ideal Bose gas in a circular container rotating at fixed rim velocity has some unexpected and instructive properties. In the thermodynamic limit, the system undergoes a phase transition, as argued by Widom. We find that the transition is a type of Bose-Einstein condensation, in which, however, infinitely many one-particle states are macroscopically occupied. The system evades general theorems forbidding Bose-Einstein condensation in two dimensions, not merely because it is inhomogeneous, as Widom suggests, but because the equilibrium density is unbounded near the circumference in the thermodynamic limit. We point out that, independently of the particular model, Bose-Einstein condensation into any single-particle state (or states), spatially uniform or nonuniform, is forbidden in one and two dimensions provided only that (a) the Hamiltonian is real, and (b) the equilibrium density is everywhere bounded in the thermodynamic limit.
The thermodynamic properties of an ideal gas of bosons moving freely within layered planes and having a finite amplitude for jumping between neighbouring planes, are derived. As long as this coupling is non-zero, the system becomes effectively two-dimensional at sufficiently high temperatures. At a correspondingly low temperature it undergoes a Bose-Einstein transition into a condensed phase as in three dimensions. Below the critical temperature the specific heat is a universal function of only one dimensionless system variable. The phase transition becomes weaker as the coupling between the planes decreases and eventually disappears when the planes decouple.
Current experiments on atomic gases in highly anisotropic traps present the opportunity to study in detail the low temperature phases of two-dimensional inhomogeneous systems. Although, in an ideal gas, the trapping potential favors Bose-Einstein condensation at finite temperature, interactions tend to destabilize the condensate, leading to a superfluid Kosterlitz-Thouless-Berezinskii phase with a finite superfluid mass density but no long-range order, as in homogeneous fluids. The transition in homogeneous systems is conveniently described in terms of dissociation of topological defects (vortex-antivortex pairs). However, trapped two-dimensional gases are more directly approached by generalizing the microscopic theory of the homogeneous gas. In this paper, we first derive, via a diagrammatic expansion, the scaling structure near the phase transition in a homogeneous system, and then study the effects of a trapping potential in the local density approximation. We find that a weakly interacting trapped gas undergoes a Kosterlitz-Thouless-Berezinskii transition from the normal state at a temperature slightly below the Bose-Einstein transition temperature of the ideal gas. The characteristic finite superfluid mass density of a homogeneous system just below the transition becomes strongly suppressed in a trapped gas.
The Bose-Einstein condensation mechanism is shown to be capable of accounting for the existence of separate hydrodynamic velocity fields for the normal and the superfluid, provided suitable assumptions are made with regard to the single-particle energy spectrum. We consider the effect on the microcanonical gas distribution of imposing a nonzero value of the total momentum P. For an ordinary gas the effect is trivial, the whole distribution being merely shifted in momentum space. However, in the case of a degenerate Bose gas whose single-particle energy spectrum has a sharp minimum (gap or cusp), only the excited part of the gas (normal fluid) participates in the imposed motion, the condensate (superfluid) remaining "frozen" in momentum space. This rigidity of the condensate in momentum space plays the same role as the rigidity of the superelectrons on imposition of a magnetic field in the London theory of superconductivity. P acts as an additional thermodynamic variable, states with P \ensuremath{\ne} 0 being macroscopically metastable and corresponding to the existence of a relative velocity between normal and superfluid. The basic hydrodynamic assumption of the two-fluid model is thus reduced to an assumption concerning the form of an effective single-particle energy spectrum, and the parallelism between the theories of superconductivity and superfluidity is clearly exhibited. The present theory permits, in particular, the introduction of the mathematical form of Landau's phonon and "roton" spectra within the framework of the Bose-Einstein condensation picture. The statistical-thermodynamic formulas are derived and are shown to lead to characteristic two-fluid equations derived previously from a variational principle.
We establish a general criterion relating the absence of Bose-Einstein condensation to specific properties of the one-body reduced density matrix. A general model of hard particles in one dimension is investigated in detail. The results are subsequently applied to hard Bosons in a weak gravitational field. The thermodynamic functions of this system show a singularity at a critical value of the density. However, we prove that this phase transition is not Bose-Einstein condensation On demontre l'equivalence entre l'absence de condensation de Bose-Einstein et certaines proprietes de la matrice densite reduite a un corps. On etudie en detail les proprietes des systemes unidimensionnels de particules a cœurs durs. On applique ces resultats au gaz de Bose a cœur dur soumis a un champ de gravitation faible. Dans ce modele, les fonctions thermodynamiques presentent une singularite a une certaine densite critique. Cependant, on demontre que cette transition de phase n'est pas la condensation de Bose-Einstein