Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

On the perturbative estimates of the correlation energy from localized orbitals in periodic systems

Peter Reinhardt, Jean‐Paul Malrieu

Published Nov 1, 1998• 25 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Starting with self-consistent fields (SCFs), localized orbitals should facilitate the calculation of the correlation energy in extended, and in particular periodic, systems. This idea is exploited on model ring systems (H4n+2). It is shown that for insulating materials [(H2)2n+1, presenting a large gap in the band structure], most of the energy lowering brought by the orders larger than 2 in the canonical many-body perturbation expansion are due to the local-hole–local-particle interaction and that the localized Epstein–Nesbet second-order energies are close to the best correlation-energy estimates. The situation is completely different for small-gap (metalliclike) systems, such as cyclic H4n+2, where the localized second-order approach misses a large fraction of the correlation energy, involving the propagation of the holes and of the particles and implying specific higher-order diagrams.

DOI
10.1063/1.477385

Related papers

Second-order many-body perturbation-theory calculations in extended systems

Jun-Qiang Sun, Rodney J. Bartlett

Explicit expressions for electron correlation at the second-order many-body perturbation-theory [MBPT(2)] level are presented and implemented for the total energy per unit cell and for the band structure of extended systems. In the latter case, a formula is presented for a direct evaluation of the band gap rather than obtaining it as a difference of two large numbers. Application is made to alternating trans-polyacetylene. We assess the convergence of MBPT(2) with the number of unit cells (N) included in the lattice summations, the number of k-points (K) taken for the integrals over k in the first Brillouin zone, and the cutoff threshold (10−C) for the two-electron integrals. The MBPT(2) correlation correction to the band structure converges very slowly with N and demands a large K while the MBPT(2) correction to the total energy per unit cell converges much faster with N and needs a much smaller K. Neither MBPT(2) correction is sensitive to the cutoff of the two-electron atomic orbital integrals, 10−C, when C≥5. For polyacetylene, the MBPT(2) band gap is much improved from the SCF result, but does not agree with previous numerical data. Analysis shows that the previous MBPT(2) results were obtained either with too few unit cells such that the convergence with N had not been reached, or that the zeroth-order Hartree–Fock results were inadequately converged. MBPT(2) with a DZP basis improves the Hartree–Fock band gap from 5.57 to 3.22 eV at the experimentally estimated geometry, compared to the measured ∼2 eV peak in the absorption spectrum of the system. We verify our results with three independent programs. We also study the band gap as a function of geometry.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jun 1, 1996•161 citations

Self-consistent density-functional approach to the correlated ground states and an unrestricted many-body perturbation theory

Behnam Farid

We introduce a scheme through which the ground-state electronic density n and total energy Ev [n] of inhomogeneous interacting systems can be determined in a self-consistent (SC) way. It is based on a SC perturbation expansion for the single-particle Green function G. Our employed expansion is argued to be valid under all conditions provided that the ground-state charge density of the interacting system is pure-state non-interacting v representable. The formalism discussed in this paper has been applied to a quasi-one-dimensional periodic system. It has even been possible to carry out SC calculations with the dynamically screened exchange diagram (the so-called GW diagram, where W is the dynamically screened electron-electron interaction function) for the self-energy operator Σ. A coherent mode of interpretation of a number of our results entails that the overwhelming success of the GW framework in relatively accurately reproducing the experimental energy gaps of a number of semiconductors and insulators may be a direct consequence of non-self-consistency effects; whereas a non-self-consistent calculation in our tests increases the value of the local-density approximation (LDA) gap in the range of 40–65% of the ‘experimental’ gaps, self-consistency effects reduce this range to 14–17%. The same line of argument leads us to conclude that, in our model, 26–35% of the LDA error in the gap energies is due to the absence of a well known discontinuity in the LDA exchange-correlation potential, and the remaining part is due to the Kohn-Sham eigenvalues not being identifiable with one-particle excitation energies. A natural conclusion that may be drawn from these observations is that a correct description of excitation energies (e.g. of the gap energy) cannot be achieved without including, at least approximately, the vertex part of Σ, which is entirely absent in the GW scheme.

Philosophical Magazine B•Aug 1, 1997•18 citations

Perturbation theory and electron correlation in extended systems: Cyclic polyene model

M. Takahashi, Josef Paldus, Jakub Čížek

Abstract The applicability of the finite‐order many‐body perturbation theory to the electron correlation problem in extended one‐dimensional systems is examined. The cyclic polyenes CNHN, N = 4ν + 2, ν = 1, 2, …, with the DNh geometry as described by both the Pariser–Parr–Pople and Hubbard Hamiltonians, are employed to model the metallic‐like one‐dimensional systems. The second‐order perturbation theory contributions to the correlation energy are obtained with three different partitionings of the Hamiltonian (Hückel, M⊘ller–Plesset, and Epstein–Nesbet). The third‐ and fourth‐order contributions are also calculated in special cases. A comparison with other methods is given wherever available. For the Hubbard Hamiltonian the asymptotic behavior of the perturbation theory expansion is examined numerically. It is shown that the finite‐order perturbation expansion can provide reliable results for the correlation energy of one‐dimensional systems even in the correlation region which corresponds to the spectroscopically determined physical value of the coupling constant.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Dec 1, 1983•42 citations

Effect of propagator renormalization on the band gap of insulating solids

Sergei Iskakov, Alexander A. Rusakov, Dominika Zgid +1 more

We present momentum-resolved spectral functions and band gaps from bare and self-consistent second-order perturbation theory for insulating periodic solids. We establish that, for systems with large gap sizes, both bare and self-consistent perturbation theory yield reasonable gaps. However, smaller gap sizes require a self-consistent adjustment of the propagator. In contrast to results obtained within a quasiparticle formalism used on top of bare second-order perturbation theory, no unphysical behavior of the band gap is observed. Our implementation of a fully self-consistent, $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$-derivable, and thermodynamically consistent finite-temperature diagrammatic perturbation theory forms a framework on which embedding theories such as the dynamical mean-field theory and self-energy embedding theories can be implemented.

arXiv:1812.07027•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Aug 5, 2019•33 citations

Comparison of three quantum chemicalab initiomethods for band structure calculations: the hydrogen fluoride chain

Viktor Bezugly, M Albrecht, Uwe Birkenheuer

Three different many-body wave-function-based ab initio methods for the calculation of correlated (or quasi-particle) band structures of periodic systems are presented: the local Hamiltonian approach, the incremental self-energy method, and the crystal orbital variant of the algebraic diagrammatic construction. All three methods explicitly exploit the local nature of electron correlation, and by consequently switching to representations in localized Wannier orbitals O(N) scaling could be achieved in all three cases. These methods were applied to single (HF) 2 zigzag chains as found in solid hydrogen fluoride using the same geometries and basis sets. Essentially identical quasi-particle band structures were obtained, corroborating the appropriateness of the different concepts pursued in each of the presented quantum chemical correlation methods for band structures of infinite systems.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2008•6 citations

Self-consistent second-order Green’s function perturbation theory for periodic systems

Alexander A. Rusakov, Dominika Zgid

Despite recent advances, systematic quantitative treatment of the electron correlation problem in extended systems remains a formidable task. Systematically improvable Green's function methods capable of quantitatively describing weak and at least qualitatively strong correlations appear as promising candidates for computational treatment of periodic systems. We present a periodic implementation of temperature-dependent self-consistent 2nd-order Green's function (GF2) method, where the self-energy is evaluated in the basis of atomic orbitals. Evaluating the real-space self-energy in atomic orbitals and solving the Dyson equation in k-space are the key components of a computationally feasible algorithm. We apply this technique to the one-dimensional hydrogen lattice--a prototypical crystalline system with a realistic Hamiltonian. By analyzing the behavior of the spectral functions, natural occupations, and self-energies, we claim that GF2 is able to recover metallic, band insulating, and at least qualitatively Mott regimes. We observe that the iterative nature of GF2 is essential to the emergence of the metallic and Mott phases.

arXiv:1511.03911•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 3, 2016•98 citations
Starting with self-consistent fields (SCFs), localized orbitals should facilitate the calculation of the correlation energy in extended, and in particular periodic, systems. This idea is exploited on model ring systems (H4n+2). It is shown that for insulating materials [(H2)2n+1, presenting a large gap in the band structure], most of the energy lowering brought by the orders larger than 2 in the canonical many-body perturbation expansion are due to the local-hole–local-particle interaction and that the localized Epstein–Nesbet second-order energies are close to the best correlation-energy estimates. The situation is completely different for small-gap (metalliclike) systems, such as cyclic H4n+2, where the localized second-order approach misses a large fraction of the correlation energy, involving the propagation of the holes and of the particles and implying specific higher-order diagrams.
Explicit expressions for electron correlation at the second-order many-body perturbation-theory [MBPT(2)] level are presented and implemented for the total energy per unit cell and for the band structure of extended systems. In the latter case, a formula is presented for a direct evaluation of the band gap rather than obtaining it as a difference of two large numbers. Application is made to alternating trans-polyacetylene. We assess the convergence of MBPT(2) with the number of unit cells (N) included in the lattice summations, the number of k-points (K) taken for the integrals over k in the first Brillouin zone, and the cutoff threshold (10−C) for the two-electron integrals. The MBPT(2) correlation correction to the band structure converges very slowly with N and demands a large K while the MBPT(2) correction to the total energy per unit cell converges much faster with N and needs a much smaller K. Neither MBPT(2) correction is sensitive to the cutoff of the two-electron atomic orbital integrals, 10−C, when C≥5. For polyacetylene, the MBPT(2) band gap is much improved from the SCF result, but does not agree with previous numerical data. Analysis shows that the previous MBPT(2) results were obtained either with too few unit cells such that the convergence with N had not been reached, or that the zeroth-order Hartree–Fock results were inadequately converged. MBPT(2) with a DZP basis improves the Hartree–Fock band gap from 5.57 to 3.22 eV at the experimentally estimated geometry, compared to the measured ∼2 eV peak in the absorption spectrum of the system. We verify our results with three independent programs. We also study the band gap as a function of geometry.
We introduce a scheme through which the ground-state electronic density n and total energy Ev [n] of inhomogeneous interacting systems can be determined in a self-consistent (SC) way. It is based on a SC perturbation expansion for the single-particle Green function G. Our employed expansion is argued to be valid under all conditions provided that the ground-state charge density of the interacting system is pure-state non-interacting v representable. The formalism discussed in this paper has been applied to a quasi-one-dimensional periodic system. It has even been possible to carry out SC calculations with the dynamically screened exchange diagram (the so-called GW diagram, where W is the dynamically screened electron-electron interaction function) for the self-energy operator Σ. A coherent mode of interpretation of a number of our results entails that the overwhelming success of the GW framework in relatively accurately reproducing the experimental energy gaps of a number of semiconductors and insulators may be a direct consequence of non-self-consistency effects; whereas a non-self-consistent calculation in our tests increases the value of the local-density approximation (LDA) gap in the range of 40–65% of the ‘experimental’ gaps, self-consistency effects reduce this range to 14–17%. The same line of argument leads us to conclude that, in our model, 26–35% of the LDA error in the gap energies is due to the absence of a well known discontinuity in the LDA exchange-correlation potential, and the remaining part is due to the Kohn-Sham eigenvalues not being identifiable with one-particle excitation energies. A natural conclusion that may be drawn from these observations is that a correct description of excitation energies (e.g. of the gap energy) cannot be achieved without including, at least approximately, the vertex part of Σ, which is entirely absent in the GW scheme.
Abstract The applicability of the finite‐order many‐body perturbation theory to the electron correlation problem in extended one‐dimensional systems is examined. The cyclic polyenes CNHN, N = 4ν + 2, ν = 1, 2, …, with the DNh geometry as described by both the Pariser–Parr–Pople and Hubbard Hamiltonians, are employed to model the metallic‐like one‐dimensional systems. The second‐order perturbation theory contributions to the correlation energy are obtained with three different partitionings of the Hamiltonian (Hückel, M⊘ller–Plesset, and Epstein–Nesbet). The third‐ and fourth‐order contributions are also calculated in special cases. A comparison with other methods is given wherever available. For the Hubbard Hamiltonian the asymptotic behavior of the perturbation theory expansion is examined numerically. It is shown that the finite‐order perturbation expansion can provide reliable results for the correlation energy of one‐dimensional systems even in the correlation region which corresponds to the spectroscopically determined physical value of the coupling constant.
We present momentum-resolved spectral functions and band gaps from bare and self-consistent second-order perturbation theory for insulating periodic solids. We establish that, for systems with large gap sizes, both bare and self-consistent perturbation theory yield reasonable gaps. However, smaller gap sizes require a self-consistent adjustment of the propagator. In contrast to results obtained within a quasiparticle formalism used on top of bare second-order perturbation theory, no unphysical behavior of the band gap is observed. Our implementation of a fully self-consistent, $\mathrm{\ensuremath{\Phi}}$-derivable, and thermodynamically consistent finite-temperature diagrammatic perturbation theory forms a framework on which embedding theories such as the dynamical mean-field theory and self-energy embedding theories can be implemented.
Three different many-body wave-function-based ab initio methods for the calculation of correlated (or quasi-particle) band structures of periodic systems are presented: the local Hamiltonian approach, the incremental self-energy method, and the crystal orbital variant of the algebraic diagrammatic construction. All three methods explicitly exploit the local nature of electron correlation, and by consequently switching to representations in localized Wannier orbitals O(N) scaling could be achieved in all three cases. These methods were applied to single (HF) 2 zigzag chains as found in solid hydrogen fluoride using the same geometries and basis sets. Essentially identical quasi-particle band structures were obtained, corroborating the appropriateness of the different concepts pursued in each of the presented quantum chemical correlation methods for band structures of infinite systems.
Despite recent advances, systematic quantitative treatment of the electron correlation problem in extended systems remains a formidable task. Systematically improvable Green's function methods capable of quantitatively describing weak and at least qualitatively strong correlations appear as promising candidates for computational treatment of periodic systems. We present a periodic implementation of temperature-dependent self-consistent 2nd-order Green's function (GF2) method, where the self-energy is evaluated in the basis of atomic orbitals. Evaluating the real-space self-energy in atomic orbitals and solving the Dyson equation in k-space are the key components of a computationally feasible algorithm. We apply this technique to the one-dimensional hydrogen lattice--a prototypical crystalline system with a realistic Hamiltonian. By analyzing the behavior of the spectral functions, natural occupations, and self-energies, we claim that GF2 is able to recover metallic, band insulating, and at least qualitatively Mott regimes. We observe that the iterative nature of GF2 is essential to the emergence of the metallic and Mott phases.