Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Lagrangians and systems they describe—how not to treat dissipation in quantum mechanics

John R. Ray

Published Jul 1, 1979• 84 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A Lagrangian that yields equations of motion for a damped simple harmonic oscillator is shown not to describe this system, but a completely different physical system. Thus, we have a simple counterexample to the statement: ’’If a Lagrangian gives the correct equations of motion for a given system then the Lagrangian describes the system.’’ We also construct a physical system that the Lagrangian describes and derive some of its properties. The quantum theory based on the above Lagrangian has been used to attempt to discuss the quantum theory of dissipation. This is, however, incorrect since the system the Lagrangian describes has no dissipation.

DOI
10.1119/1.11767

Related papers

Lagrangians and Hamiltonians with friction

C E Smith

Methods are presented for extending a promising formalism that incorporates dissipative forces into Quantum Mechanics. Hamiltonians and Lagrangians are constructed that have additional force and frictional terms while still being consistent with the rules of the formalism. The simple systems of a damped particle in a force field and a quadratically damped oscillator are discussed.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2010•10 citations

Physical consequences of the choice of the Lagrangian

Nivaldo Agostinho Lemos

The physical consequences of the existence of inequivalent Lagrangians associated with a given equation of motion are examined in quantum mechanics. It is shown that in the case of conservative systems one additional condition is sufficient to select the physically correct Lagrangian. It is remarked that in the case of dissipative systems the situation is quite different, and no conditions are known to single out a unique Lagrangian.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Aug 15, 1981•33 citations

Quantum Damped Harmonic Oscillator

Kazuyuki Fujii

In this chapter we treat the quantum damped harmonic oscillator, and study mathematical structure of the model, and construct general solution with any initial condition, and give a quantum counterpart in the case of taking coherent state as an initial condition. This is a simple and good model of Quantum Mechanics with dissipation which is important to understand real world, and readers will get a powerful weapon for Quantum Physics.

arXiv:1209.1437•InTech eBooks•Apr 3, 2013•22 citations

Dissipation in Quantum Mechanics. The Harmonic Oscillator

I. R. Senitzky

The need for a quantum-mechanical formalism for systems with dissipation which is applicable to the radiation field of a cavity is discussed. Two methods that have been used in this connection are described. The first, which starts with the classical Newtonian equation of motion for a damped oscillator and applies the conventional formal quantization techniques, leads to an exact solution; but subsequent discussion shows that this method is invalid, the results being unacceptable from a quantum-mechanical viewpoint. The second method, which considers the interaction of two systems, the lossless oscillator and the loss mechanism, is adopted in the present article. No special model is used for the loss mechanism, but this mechanism is assumed to have a large number of densely-spaced energy states.The approximations with respect to the loss mechanism that underlie the concept of dissipation are discussed. These approximations are then applied to the analysis, and a differential equation for a coordinate operator of the harmonic oscillator is obtained which has the formal appearance of the Newtonian equation of motion for a driven damped harmonic oscillator, the driving term being an operator referring to the loss mechanism. The presence of the driving term is responsible for the difference between the present theory and that of the first method mentioned above. A solution of the differential equation for the coordinate operator is given explicitly. An examination of the physical significance of the solution shows that the driving term is responsible not only for the thermal fluctuations which are due to the loss mechanism, but also for the proper commutation relationship of the conjugate coordinates of the oscillator and for its zero-point fluctuations.A generalization of the solution to provide for a classical driving force and coupled atomic systems is given. The results are then restated in a form that refers to the loss mechanism only through the two parameters by which it is usually described---the dissipation constant and the temperature.

Physical Review•Jul 15, 1960•464 citations

On the quantization of linearly damped harmonic oscillator

Sunita Srivastava, Vishwamittar, I. S. Minhas

Using the equation of motion for a linearly damped harmonic oscillator as fundamental equation, a condition has been obtained that must be satisfied by its Lagrangian and a number of functional forms has been critically investigated. The Lagrangians that successfully describe a classical damped oscillator have been quantized using Feynman’s elegant path integral method. However, it is found that the expectation value of energy of the damped oscillator in all the cases becomes infinitely large for t→∞, ruling out the possibility of treating the damped quantum system as a one-body problem.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jun 1, 1991•9 citations

THE LAGRANGIAN IN QUANTUM MECHANICS

P. A. M. Dirac

Quantum mechanics was built up on a foundation of analogy with the Hamiltonian theory of classical mechanics. This is because the classical notion of canonical coordinates and momenta was found to be one with a very simple quantum analogue, as a result of which the whole of the classical Hamiltonian theory, which is just a structure built up on this notion, could be taken over in all its details into quantum mechanics. Now there is an alternative formulation for classical dynamics, provided by the Lagrangian. This requires one to work in terms of coordinates and velocities instead of coordinates and momenta. The two formulations are, of course, closely related, but there are reasons for believing that the Lagrangian one is the more fundamental. In the first place the Lagrangian method allows one to collect together all the equations of motion and express them as the stationary property of a certain action function. (This action function is just the time-integral of the Lagrangian.) There is no corresponding action principle in terms of the coordinates and momenta of the Hamiltonian theory. Secondly the Lagrangian method can easily be expressed relativistically, on account of the action function being a relativistic invariant; while the Hamiltonian method is essentially non-relativistic in form, since it marks out a particular time variable as the canonical conjugate of the Hamiltonian function. For these reasons it would seem desirable to take up the question of what corresponds in the quantum theory to the Lagrangian method of the classical theory. A little consideration shows, however, that one cannot expect to be able to take over the classical Lagrangian equations in any very direct way. These equations involve partial derivatives of the Lagrangian with respect to the coordinates and velocities and no meaning can be given to such derivatives in quantum mechanics. The only differentiation process that can be carried out with respect to the dynamical variables of quantum mechanics is that of forming Poisson brackets and this process leads to the Hamiltonian theory. 1 We must therefore seek our quantum Lagrangian theory in an indirect way. We must try to take over the ideas of the classical Lagrangian theory, not the equations of the classical Lagrangian theory.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Aug 1, 2005•288 citations
A Lagrangian that yields equations of motion for a damped simple harmonic oscillator is shown not to describe this system, but a completely different physical system. Thus, we have a simple counterexample to the statement: ’’If a Lagrangian gives the correct equations of motion for a given system then the Lagrangian describes the system.’’ We also construct a physical system that the Lagrangian describes and derive some of its properties. The quantum theory based on the above Lagrangian has been used to attempt to discuss the quantum theory of dissipation. This is, however, incorrect since the system the Lagrangian describes has no dissipation.
The need for a quantum-mechanical formalism for systems with dissipation which is applicable to the radiation field of a cavity is discussed. Two methods that have been used in this connection are described. The first, which starts with the classical Newtonian equation of motion for a damped oscillator and applies the conventional formal quantization techniques, leads to an exact solution; but subsequent discussion shows that this method is invalid, the results being unacceptable from a quantum-mechanical viewpoint. The second method, which considers the interaction of two systems, the lossless oscillator and the loss mechanism, is adopted in the present article. No special model is used for the loss mechanism, but this mechanism is assumed to have a large number of densely-spaced energy states.The approximations with respect to the loss mechanism that underlie the concept of dissipation are discussed. These approximations are then applied to the analysis, and a differential equation for a coordinate operator of the harmonic oscillator is obtained which has the formal appearance of the Newtonian equation of motion for a driven damped harmonic oscillator, the driving term being an operator referring to the loss mechanism. The presence of the driving term is responsible for the difference between the present theory and that of the first method mentioned above. A solution of the differential equation for the coordinate operator is given explicitly. An examination of the physical significance of the solution shows that the driving term is responsible not only for the thermal fluctuations which are due to the loss mechanism, but also for the proper commutation relationship of the conjugate coordinates of the oscillator and for its zero-point fluctuations.A generalization of the solution to provide for a classical driving force and coupled atomic systems is given. The results are then restated in a form that refers to the loss mechanism only through the two parameters by which it is usually described---the dissipation constant and the temperature.
Using the equation of motion for a linearly damped harmonic oscillator as fundamental equation, a condition has been obtained that must be satisfied by its Lagrangian and a number of functional forms has been critically investigated. The Lagrangians that successfully describe a classical damped oscillator have been quantized using Feynman’s elegant path integral method. However, it is found that the expectation value of energy of the damped oscillator in all the cases becomes infinitely large for t→∞, ruling out the possibility of treating the damped quantum system as a one-body problem.
Quantum mechanics was built up on a foundation of analogy with the Hamiltonian theory of classical mechanics. This is because the classical notion of canonical coordinates and momenta was found to be one with a very simple quantum analogue, as a result of which the whole of the classical Hamiltonian theory, which is just a structure built up on this notion, could be taken over in all its details into quantum mechanics. Now there is an alternative formulation for classical dynamics, provided by the Lagrangian. This requires one to work in terms of coordinates and velocities instead of coordinates and momenta. The two formulations are, of course, closely related, but there are reasons for believing that the Lagrangian one is the more fundamental. In the first place the Lagrangian method allows one to collect together all the equations of motion and express them as the stationary property of a certain action function. (This action function is just the time-integral of the Lagrangian.) There is no corresponding action principle in terms of the coordinates and momenta of the Hamiltonian theory. Secondly the Lagrangian method can easily be expressed relativistically, on account of the action function being a relativistic invariant; while the Hamiltonian method is essentially non-relativistic in form, since it marks out a particular time variable as the canonical conjugate of the Hamiltonian function. For these reasons it would seem desirable to take up the question of what corresponds in the quantum theory to the Lagrangian method of the classical theory. A little consideration shows, however, that one cannot expect to be able to take over the classical Lagrangian equations in any very direct way. These equations involve partial derivatives of the Lagrangian with respect to the coordinates and velocities and no meaning can be given to such derivatives in quantum mechanics. The only differentiation process that can be carried out with respect to the dynamical variables of quantum mechanics is that of forming Poisson brackets and this process leads to the Hamiltonian theory. 1 We must therefore seek our quantum Lagrangian theory in an indirect way. We must try to take over the ideas of the classical Lagrangian theory, not the equations of the classical Lagrangian theory.