Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Accuracy of the Hartree–Fock approximation for the Hubbard model

Volker Bach, Jurij Poelchau

Published Apr 1, 1997• 11 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A lower bound 0⩾(Egs(n)−Ehf(n))/|Λ|⩾−const[n2/3U4/3(|ln U|+1) +Un1/2|Λ|−1/2d(|ln(|Λ|−1/2)|1)] to the difference of the ground state and the Hartree–Fock energy of the Hubbard model is derived. Here |Λ| is the lattice size, U is the coupling parameter, and n is the electron density per site. This estimate holds for all dimensions d⩾2 and all densities. Thus the Hartree–Fock approximation becomes exact (even beyond terms of order U) for small U and large |Λ|.

DOI
10.1063/1.531922

Related papers

Ferromagnetism of the Low-Density Hubbard Model in the Hartree-Fock Approximation

Volker Bach, Élliott H. Lieb, Marcos V. Travaglia

We prove rigorously that the Hartree-Fock approximation to the ground state of the d-dimensional Hubbard model leads to saturated ferromagnetism when the particle density (more precisely, the chemical potential µ) is small and the coupling constant U is large, but finite. As in the usual Hartree-Fock theory we restrict attention to Slater determinants that are eigenvectors of the z-component of the total spin, Sz = ∑ x nx, ↑ − nx,↓, and we find that the choice 2Sz = N = particle number gives the lowest energy at fixed 0 < µ < 4d. 1 BLT, Version of 27-Jun-2005 2 1

•Jun 27, 2005•1 citation

FERROMAGNETISM OF THE HUBBARD MODEL AT STRONG COUPLING IN THE HARTREE–FOCK APPROXIMATION

VOLKER BACH, Élliott H. Lieb, MARCOS V. TRAVAGLIA

As a contribution to the study of the Hartree–Fock theory, we prove rigorously that the Hartree–Fock approximation to the ground state of the d-dimensional Hubbard model leads to saturated ferromagnetism when the particle density (more precisely, the chemical potential μ) is small and the coupling constant U is large, but finite. This ferromagnetism contradicts the known fact that there is no magnetization at low density, for any U, and thus shows that HF theory is wrong in this case. As in the usual Hartree–Fock theory, we restrict attention to Slater determinants that are eigenvectors of the z-component of the total spin, 𝕊z = ∑x nx,↑ - nx,↓, and we find that the choice 2𝕊z = N = particle number gives the lowest energy at fixed 0 < μ < 4d.

arXiv:cond-mat/0506695•Reviews in Mathematical Physics•Jun 1, 2006•13 citations

The ground state problem in the infinite-U Hubbard model

E. V. Kuz’min

The problem of the ground state of the electronic system in the Hubbard model for U=∞ is discussed. The author investigates the normal (singlet or nonmagnetic) N state of the electronic system over the entire range of electron densities n⩽1. It is shown that the energy of the N state ɛ 0 (1) (n) in a one-particle approximation, such as (e.g.) the extended Hartree-Fock approximation, is lower than the energy of the saturated ferromagnetic FM state ɛ FM(n) for all n. The dynamic magnetic susceptibility is calculated in the random phase approximation, and it is shown that the N state is stable over the entire range of electron densities: The static susceptibility (ω=0) does not have a band singularity in the zero-wave vector limit q→0. A formally exact representation is obtained for the mass operator of the one-particle Green’s function, and an approximation of this operator is proposed: M k(E)⋍λF(E), where λ=n(1−n)/(1−n/2)z is the kinematic interaction parameter, z is the number of nearest neighbors, and F(E) is the total single-site Green’s function. For an elliptical density of states the integral equation for F(E) is solved exactly, ad it is shown that the spectral intensity rigorously satisfies the sum rule. The calculated energy of the strongly correlated N state ɛ 0(n)<ɛ FM(n) for all n, and in light of this relationship the author discusses the hypothesis that the ground state of the system is the normal (singlet) state in the thermodynamic limit. The electron distribution function at T=0 differs significantly from the Fermi step; it is “smeared” along the entire energy spectrum, and discontinuities do not occur in the region of the chemical potential m.

Physics of the Solid State•Feb 1, 1997•3 citations

The Ground State Energy of the Hubbard Model in Hubbard's Approximation

Rainer J. Jelitto

Abstract We have calculated the ground state energy of the Hubbard model in the approximation of Hubbard's first paper1 . For the neutral model with nearest neighbour interaction the energy resulting from the selfconsistent paramagnetic solution is compared with those ones following from the (ferromagnetic) Hartree-Fock and an (antiferromagnetic) single particle theory. The energy of the latter one turns out to be the best approximation of the true ground state energy of the model for all values of the coupling constant V0 , but the energy derived from Hubbard's approximation, in spite of the absence of magnetic ordering, is a reasonable approximation at least for sufficiently large values of V0.

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A•Jun 1, 1972•1 citation

Studies on the six-site Hubbard model: Comparison of various approximations

M. Nauciel‐Bloch, Thomas P. Eggarter

The authors tested several approximations commonly used in molecular energy calculations by applying them to the six-site half-filled Hubbard model and comparing the results with the exact solution. Three main conclusions follow from this study: (i) for $\frac{\ensuremath{\beta}}{U}$ in the range of interest for molecules, perturbations to the molecular-orbital ground state produce better results than the other more elaborate methods tested; (ii) Nesbet's pair theory is only slightly worse in this range but has the advantage of working well for all values of the parameters, and (iii) perturbative corrections to the unrestricted Hartree-Fock ground state give very poor results when this state has lower symmetry than the Hamiltonian.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1979•3 citations

Ground-state energy and the fluctuation contribution to the free energy for the Hubbard model at half filling

Hongguang Chi, A. D. S. Nagi

We have calculated the ground-state energy and the fluctuation contribution to the free-energy for the Hubbard model at half filling. We have used a gauge that leads to the Hartree-Fock solution in the saddle-point approximation. The mean-field ground-state energy calculated here agrees with the results obtained by Dagotto et al. [Phys. Rev. B 45, 10 741 (1992)] with use of the exact-diagonalization techniques on a 4\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}4 site cluster. In the large-U limit, the ground-state energy per site is obtained as ${\mathit{E}}_{\mathit{g}}$/N=-U/4-J+O(${\mathit{J}}^{2}$/U). The fluctuation contribution to the free-energy was found to have a stronger temperature and U dependence than the mean-field contribution, and to play a dominant role for strongly correlated systems.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 1, 1993•0 citations
A lower bound 0⩾(Egs(n)−Ehf(n))/|Λ|⩾−const[n2/3U4/3(|ln U|+1) +Un1/2|Λ|−1/2d(|ln(|Λ|−1/2)|1)] to the difference of the ground state and the Hartree–Fock energy of the Hubbard model is derived. Here |Λ| is the lattice size, U is the coupling parameter, and n is the electron density per site. This estimate holds for all dimensions d⩾2 and all densities. Thus the Hartree–Fock approximation becomes exact (even beyond terms of order U) for small U and large |Λ|.
We prove rigorously that the Hartree-Fock approximation to the ground state of the d-dimensional Hubbard model leads to saturated ferromagnetism when the particle density (more precisely, the chemical potential µ) is small and the coupling constant U is large, but finite. As in the usual Hartree-Fock theory we restrict attention to Slater determinants that are eigenvectors of the z-component of the total spin, Sz = ∑ x nx, ↑ − nx,↓, and we find that the choice 2Sz = N = particle number gives the lowest energy at fixed 0 < µ < 4d. 1 BLT, Version of 27-Jun-2005 2 1
As a contribution to the study of the Hartree–Fock theory, we prove rigorously that the Hartree–Fock approximation to the ground state of the d-dimensional Hubbard model leads to saturated ferromagnetism when the particle density (more precisely, the chemical potential μ) is small and the coupling constant U is large, but finite. This ferromagnetism contradicts the known fact that there is no magnetization at low density, for any U, and thus shows that HF theory is wrong in this case. As in the usual Hartree–Fock theory, we restrict attention to Slater determinants that are eigenvectors of the z-component of the total spin, 𝕊z = ∑x nx,↑ - nx,↓, and we find that the choice 2𝕊z = N = particle number gives the lowest energy at fixed 0 < μ < 4d.
The problem of the ground state of the electronic system in the Hubbard model for U=∞ is discussed. The author investigates the normal (singlet or nonmagnetic) N state of the electronic system over the entire range of electron densities n⩽1. It is shown that the energy of the N state ɛ 0 (1) (n) in a one-particle approximation, such as (e.g.) the extended Hartree-Fock approximation, is lower than the energy of the saturated ferromagnetic FM state ɛ FM(n) for all n. The dynamic magnetic susceptibility is calculated in the random phase approximation, and it is shown that the N state is stable over the entire range of electron densities: The static susceptibility (ω=0) does not have a band singularity in the zero-wave vector limit q→0. A formally exact representation is obtained for the mass operator of the one-particle Green’s function, and an approximation of this operator is proposed: M k(E)⋍λF(E), where λ=n(1−n)/(1−n/2)z is the kinematic interaction parameter, z is the number of nearest neighbors, and F(E) is the total single-site Green’s function. For an elliptical density of states the integral equation for F(E) is solved exactly, ad it is shown that the spectral intensity rigorously satisfies the sum rule. The calculated energy of the strongly correlated N state ɛ 0(n)<ɛ FM(n) for all n, and in light of this relationship the author discusses the hypothesis that the ground state of the system is the normal (singlet) state in the thermodynamic limit. The electron distribution function at T=0 differs significantly from the Fermi step; it is “smeared” along the entire energy spectrum, and discontinuities do not occur in the region of the chemical potential m.
Abstract We have calculated the ground state energy of the Hubbard model in the approximation of Hubbard's first paper1 . For the neutral model with nearest neighbour interaction the energy resulting from the selfconsistent paramagnetic solution is compared with those ones following from the (ferromagnetic) Hartree-Fock and an (antiferromagnetic) single particle theory. The energy of the latter one turns out to be the best approximation of the true ground state energy of the model for all values of the coupling constant V0 , but the energy derived from Hubbard's approximation, in spite of the absence of magnetic ordering, is a reasonable approximation at least for sufficiently large values of V0.
The authors tested several approximations commonly used in molecular energy calculations by applying them to the six-site half-filled Hubbard model and comparing the results with the exact solution. Three main conclusions follow from this study: (i) for $\frac{\ensuremath{\beta}}{U}$ in the range of interest for molecules, perturbations to the molecular-orbital ground state produce better results than the other more elaborate methods tested; (ii) Nesbet's pair theory is only slightly worse in this range but has the advantage of working well for all values of the parameters, and (iii) perturbative corrections to the unrestricted Hartree-Fock ground state give very poor results when this state has lower symmetry than the Hamiltonian.
We have calculated the ground-state energy and the fluctuation contribution to the free-energy for the Hubbard model at half filling. We have used a gauge that leads to the Hartree-Fock solution in the saddle-point approximation. The mean-field ground-state energy calculated here agrees with the results obtained by Dagotto et al. [Phys. Rev. B 45, 10 741 (1992)] with use of the exact-diagonalization techniques on a 4\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}4 site cluster. In the large-U limit, the ground-state energy per site is obtained as Eg{\mathit{E}}_{\mathit{g}}Eg​/N=-U/4-J+O(J2{\mathit{J}}^{2}J2/U). The fluctuation contribution to the free-energy was found to have a stronger temperature and U dependence than the mean-field contribution, and to play a dominant role for strongly correlated systems.