Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Laser excitation of multilevel systems: Limitations on the use of Wilcox-Lamb and other rate-equation approximations

James P. Stone, Myron F. Goodman

Published Dec 1, 1978• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Using the generalized master equation (GME) formalism, we analyze several approximations for the solutions of Boltzmann or optical Bloch equations. Included in our analysis are the Wilcox-Lamb equations, ordinary master equation (OME), and a new approximation which we designate as the renormalized small-eigenvalue (RSE) approximation. We demonstrate that in multilevel systems, the GME formalism allows direct systematic calculation of radiative-transition coefficients required in the Wilcox-Lamb equations, including all multilevel phase-coherent transitions. However, serious limitations in the applicability of the Wilcox-Lamb approximation are noted both in the high-pressure domain, as an asymptotically exact equation, and for low pressures, as a coarse-grained approximation. The Wilcox-Lamb equations, generally assumed to be valid in a high-pressure domain, are shown to fail in the presence of very efficient inelastic (${T}_{1}$) relaxation processes regardless of the pressure. Under similar conditions the presence of efficient inelastic processes is also shown to invalidate the use of an OME even when inelastic cross sections are somewhat smaller and the Wilcox-Lamb equations are valid. In particular, we show that when energy losses to the heat bath are severe, an ordinary master equation, traditionally believed to provide a valid description of radiative contributions to level-population evolution when the ratio of Rabi to elastic collision frequency is small, is not valid under any conditions. On this ground we strongly question the recent use of a multilevel OME description to explain the existence of an energy threshold for laser-induced decomposition of S${\mathrm{F}}_{6}$. Finally, we show that for low gas pressures where Rabi oscillations are a prominent feature of the exact solutions, neither the OME nor the Wilcox-Lamb approximation provides an adequate coarse-grained solution. We show that the Wilcox-Lamb solution is in error primarily because of a circumstance not previously recognized, namely, a systematic large error in the way exponential terms contributing to the solution are normalized. A closely related approximation, the RSE approximation, which we present here for the first time, is shown to provide an accurate coarse-grained approximation to the fully coherent GME solutions.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.18.2642

Related papers

Laser-induced rate processes in gases: Intermolecular and intramolecular relaxation in a polyatomic molecule

James P. Stone, Myron F. Goodman

We present a formalism to analyze the effects of collisions and intramolecular energy transfer and dephasing processes (${T}_{1}$ and ${T}_{2}$ relaxation) on level-population dynamics and unimolecular decay of laser-driven gas molecules. Utilizing a Boltzmann or optical Bloch equation for the density matrix to describe laser excitation of a relaxing multilevel absorber, we develop a generalized master equation (GME) to describe the dynamics of level population evolution for multilevel absorbers having arbitrary numbers of quantum levels $N$. Because the resulting level-population equations explicitly retain phase memory, the effect of complete or partial phase-coherent driving or incoherent driving by the laser field are all included within the GME solutions. The formalism provides straightforward means to calculate time-dependent solutions for arbitrary $N$, where a single expression is valid on transient, post transient, approach to steady state, and steady-state time scales. We illustrate the behavior of these solutions for the special case of three- and eight-level systems, but the method is not restricted with regard to number of levels. In both this and the following paper, we use specific examples and general arguments to show that an ordinary master equation (OME) is invalid even under apparently favorable conditions including saturating field strengths. We demonstrate that, for an $N$-level absorber with given coupling elements, there are $\frac{N}{2}$ [or $\frac{(N+1)}{2}$] independent saturation solutions and that special conditions on the relaxation times are required to produce the ordinary equal-population solution. Explicit forms for the steady-state radiative-transition matrix $W(\ensuremath{\lambda}=0)$ are derived for arbitrary $N$, and general arguments are given to show that the correct description of the dynamics given by the GME results from matrix singularities in $W(\ensuremath{\lambda}=0)$ which can never occur in an OME or similar rate equations.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1978•25 citations

Laser-induced rate processes in gases: Reduction of generalized to ordinary master equation

Myron F. Goodman, James P. Stone, Everett Thiele

The generalized master equation (GME) describing the time evolution of energy level populations for a laser-pumped molecular gas, suffering phase-changing and thermalizing collisions, is analyzed in the weak radiation field limit for a two-level absorber. We show that the GME reduces to an ordinary master equation (OME) when the absorber response is perturbed by collisions, by phase interruptions in the light field, or by a combination of both. The GME to OME reduction is possible only in the low intensity and weak collision limits thereby placing a stringent limitation on the use of ordinary master equations to obtain accurate estimates of the evolution of energy level populations.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Oct 1, 1975•22 citations

Partial secular Bloch-Redfield master equation for incoherent excitation of multilevel quantum systems

Timur V. Tscherbul, Paul W. Brumer

We present an efficient theoretical method for calculating the time evolution of the density matrix of a multilevel quantum system weakly interacting with incoherent light. The method combines the Bloch-Redfield theory with a partial secular approximation for one-photon coherences, resulting in a master equation that explicitly exposes the reliance on transition rates and the angles between transition dipole moments in the energy basis. The partial secular Bloch-Redfield master equation allows an unambiguous distinction between the regimes of quantum coherent vs. incoherent energy transfer under incoherent light illumination. The fully incoherent regime is characterized by orthogonal transition dipole moments in the energy basis, leading to a dynamical evolution governed by a coherence-free Pauli-type master equation. The coherent regime requires non-orthogonal transition dipole moments in the energy basis and leads to the generation of noise-induced quantum coherences and population-to-coherence couplings. As a first application, we consider the dynamics of excited state coherences arising under incoherent light excitation from a single ground state and observe population-to-coherence transfer and the formation of non-equilibrium quasisteady states in the regime of small excited state splitting. Analytical expressions derived earlier for the V-type system [T. V. Tscherbul and P. Brumer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 113601 (2014)] are found to provide a nearly quantitative description of multilevel excited-state populations and coherences in both the small- and large-molecule limits.

arXiv:1412.7807•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Mar 12, 2015•58 citations

Laser-Induced Rate Processes in Gases: Dynamics, Unimolecular Decay, and Scattered Field

Myron F. Goodman, Everett Thiele

We have recast a linear quantum-mechanical Boltzmann equation, describing the dynamics of a gas of $N$-level atoms absorbing light between an arbitrary pair of levels, into the form of a generalized master equation. The atoms are permitted to undergo both phase-changing and energy-changing collisions with a heat bath of inert molecules. The possibility of unimolecular decay is incorporated into the Boltzmann equation. The solutions of the generalized master equation give an accurate description of the system for short as well as long times and for arbitrary light-field intensity. Eigenvalues obtained from the solution of the $N$-level master equation are shown to have particular significance with regard to the scattered electromagnetic field, with the imaginary parts of the complex eigenvalues providing the location and the real parts of the eigenvalues giving the widths of scattered radiation bands. The dynamics and scattered field for a two-level system is discussed in detail. Two collision parameters giving the frequency of phase-changing and energy-changing collisions are important. For special values of these parameters, our results reduce to scattered field spectra calculated previously. When unimolecular decay is included, one identifies the smallest eigenvalue of the generalized master equation with the macroscopic rate constant. Observation of the scattered field for different incident field intensities would permit separation of radiative and thermal effects in an enhanced reaction rate, without requiring an accurate temperature measurement.

Physical Review A•Mar 1, 1972•46 citations

Multiple-time-scale perturbation theory applied to laser excitation of atoms and molecules

Jack Wong, J. C. Garrison, T. H. Einwohner

The multiple-linear-time-scale method is used to construct a perturbation theory for $N$-level quantum systems subjected to time-dependent perturbations. The secular and small-denominator terms which plague conventional time-dependent perturbation theory are avoided; consequently, the theory is useful for treating long-term behavior and resonant interactions. The introduction of a self-energy operator allows the shifts in energy levels to be displayed explicitly. When the perturbation is the dipole interaction with an electromagnetic field, the successive approximations yield the well-known rotating-wave approximation, corrections due to counter rotating terms, and the Bloch-Siegert frequency shift. The formalism is applicable to arbitrary pulse shapes, provided that $\ensuremath{\parallel}{H}_{1}\ensuremath{\parallel}\ensuremath{\ll}\ensuremath{\hbar}\overline{\ensuremath{\omega}}$, where $\ensuremath{\parallel}{H}_{1}\ensuremath{\parallel}$ represents the inter-action strength and $\overline{\ensuremath{\omega}}$ is a characteristic frequency of the field. Rabi oscillations induced by multiphoton resonances are automatically included, and this effect is demonstrated in the case of a square pulse with frequency approximately one half the resonance frequency for a transition between two vibrational levels of a molecule. These calculations are compared to an exact numerical solution in order to find the limits of validity of the approximation. Even at high intensities ($I\ensuremath{\sim}{10}^{14}$ W/${\mathrm{cm}}^{2}$) the shifted resonance frequency is quite accurate; however, the approximate and exact solutions are slightly out of phase, so that the approximate solution can only be trusted for a few Rabi cycles. For much lower intensities ($I\ensuremath{\sim}{10}^{10}$ W/${\mathrm{cm}}^{2}$), the approximate solution is valid for many thousands of Rabi cycles.

Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1976•30 citations

Optical coherent transients: Generalized two-level solutions

Axel Schenzle, Richard G. Brewer

Pulsed radio-frequency transient phenomena of resonant two-level spins are often described by the Bloch equations where the phenomenological dipole (${T}_{2}$) and population (${T}_{1}$) decay times appear. A similar description has been carried over recently into the microwave and infrared regions as well. At visible-ultraviolet wavelengths, however, a more general solution is required because the transition levels do not constitute an isolated system and also spontaneous emission can no longer be disregarded. As a consequence, the lower (1) and upper (2) transition levels are characterized by vastly different decay rates (${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{1}\ensuremath{\ne}{\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{2}$) and the lifetime ${T}_{1}$ is no longer a defined quantity. In view of laser-induced coherent transient phenomena now being observed, we present general solutions of the density-matrix equations of motion for an optically resonant two-level system in contact with a multilevel reservoir where ${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{1}\ensuremath{\ne}{\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{2}$. Particular and perturbative solutions involving intensity-dependent damping and frequency shifts are included with applications to echo and nutation phenomena.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1976•83 citations
Using the generalized master equation (GME) formalism, we analyze several approximations for the solutions of Boltzmann or optical Bloch equations. Included in our analysis are the Wilcox-Lamb equations, ordinary master equation (OME), and a new approximation which we designate as the renormalized small-eigenvalue (RSE) approximation. We demonstrate that in multilevel systems, the GME formalism allows direct systematic calculation of radiative-transition coefficients required in the Wilcox-Lamb equations, including all multilevel phase-coherent transitions. However, serious limitations in the applicability of the Wilcox-Lamb approximation are noted both in the high-pressure domain, as an asymptotically exact equation, and for low pressures, as a coarse-grained approximation. The Wilcox-Lamb equations, generally assumed to be valid in a high-pressure domain, are shown to fail in the presence of very efficient inelastic (T1{T}_{1}T1​) relaxation processes regardless of the pressure. Under similar conditions the presence of efficient inelastic processes is also shown to invalidate the use of an OME even when inelastic cross sections are somewhat smaller and the Wilcox-Lamb equations are valid. In particular, we show that when energy losses to the heat bath are severe, an ordinary master equation, traditionally believed to provide a valid description of radiative contributions to level-population evolution when the ratio of Rabi to elastic collision frequency is small, is not valid under any conditions. On this ground we strongly question the recent use of a multilevel OME description to explain the existence of an energy threshold for laser-induced decomposition of SF6{\mathrm{F}}_{6}F6​. Finally, we show that for low gas pressures where Rabi oscillations are a prominent feature of the exact solutions, neither the OME nor the Wilcox-Lamb approximation provides an adequate coarse-grained solution. We show that the Wilcox-Lamb solution is in error primarily because of a circumstance not previously recognized, namely, a systematic large error in the way exponential terms contributing to the solution are normalized. A closely related approximation, the RSE approximation, which we present here for the first time, is shown to provide an accurate coarse-grained approximation to the fully coherent GME solutions.
We present a formalism to analyze the effects of collisions and intramolecular energy transfer and dephasing processes (T1{T}_{1}T1​ and T2{T}_{2}T2​ relaxation) on level-population dynamics and unimolecular decay of laser-driven gas molecules. Utilizing a Boltzmann or optical Bloch equation for the density matrix to describe laser excitation of a relaxing multilevel absorber, we develop a generalized master equation (GME) to describe the dynamics of level population evolution for multilevel absorbers having arbitrary numbers of quantum levels NNN. Because the resulting level-population equations explicitly retain phase memory, the effect of complete or partial phase-coherent driving or incoherent driving by the laser field are all included within the GME solutions. The formalism provides straightforward means to calculate time-dependent solutions for arbitrary NNN, where a single expression is valid on transient, post transient, approach to steady state, and steady-state time scales. We illustrate the behavior of these solutions for the special case of three- and eight-level systems, but the method is not restricted with regard to number of levels. In both this and the following paper, we use specific examples and general arguments to show that an ordinary master equation (OME) is invalid even under apparently favorable conditions including saturating field strengths. We demonstrate that, for an NNN-level absorber with given coupling elements, there are N2\frac{N}{2}2N​ [or (N+1)2\frac{(N+1)}{2}2(N+1)​] independent saturation solutions and that special conditions on the relaxation times are required to produce the ordinary equal-population solution. Explicit forms for the steady-state radiative-transition matrix $W(\ensuremath{\lambda}=0)$ are derived for arbitrary NNN, and general arguments are given to show that the correct description of the dynamics given by the GME results from matrix singularities in $W(\ensuremath{\lambda}=0)$ which can never occur in an OME or similar rate equations.
The generalized master equation (GME) describing the time evolution of energy level populations for a laser-pumped molecular gas, suffering phase-changing and thermalizing collisions, is analyzed in the weak radiation field limit for a two-level absorber. We show that the GME reduces to an ordinary master equation (OME) when the absorber response is perturbed by collisions, by phase interruptions in the light field, or by a combination of both. The GME to OME reduction is possible only in the low intensity and weak collision limits thereby placing a stringent limitation on the use of ordinary master equations to obtain accurate estimates of the evolution of energy level populations.
We present an efficient theoretical method for calculating the time evolution of the density matrix of a multilevel quantum system weakly interacting with incoherent light. The method combines the Bloch-Redfield theory with a partial secular approximation for one-photon coherences, resulting in a master equation that explicitly exposes the reliance on transition rates and the angles between transition dipole moments in the energy basis. The partial secular Bloch-Redfield master equation allows an unambiguous distinction between the regimes of quantum coherent vs. incoherent energy transfer under incoherent light illumination. The fully incoherent regime is characterized by orthogonal transition dipole moments in the energy basis, leading to a dynamical evolution governed by a coherence-free Pauli-type master equation. The coherent regime requires non-orthogonal transition dipole moments in the energy basis and leads to the generation of noise-induced quantum coherences and population-to-coherence couplings. As a first application, we consider the dynamics of excited state coherences arising under incoherent light excitation from a single ground state and observe population-to-coherence transfer and the formation of non-equilibrium quasisteady states in the regime of small excited state splitting. Analytical expressions derived earlier for the V-type system [T. V. Tscherbul and P. Brumer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 113601 (2014)] are found to provide a nearly quantitative description of multilevel excited-state populations and coherences in both the small- and large-molecule limits.
We have recast a linear quantum-mechanical Boltzmann equation, describing the dynamics of a gas of NNN-level atoms absorbing light between an arbitrary pair of levels, into the form of a generalized master equation. The atoms are permitted to undergo both phase-changing and energy-changing collisions with a heat bath of inert molecules. The possibility of unimolecular decay is incorporated into the Boltzmann equation. The solutions of the generalized master equation give an accurate description of the system for short as well as long times and for arbitrary light-field intensity. Eigenvalues obtained from the solution of the NNN-level master equation are shown to have particular significance with regard to the scattered electromagnetic field, with the imaginary parts of the complex eigenvalues providing the location and the real parts of the eigenvalues giving the widths of scattered radiation bands. The dynamics and scattered field for a two-level system is discussed in detail. Two collision parameters giving the frequency of phase-changing and energy-changing collisions are important. For special values of these parameters, our results reduce to scattered field spectra calculated previously. When unimolecular decay is included, one identifies the smallest eigenvalue of the generalized master equation with the macroscopic rate constant. Observation of the scattered field for different incident field intensities would permit separation of radiative and thermal effects in an enhanced reaction rate, without requiring an accurate temperature measurement.
The multiple-linear-time-scale method is used to construct a perturbation theory for NNN-level quantum systems subjected to time-dependent perturbations. The secular and small-denominator terms which plague conventional time-dependent perturbation theory are avoided; consequently, the theory is useful for treating long-term behavior and resonant interactions. The introduction of a self-energy operator allows the shifts in energy levels to be displayed explicitly. When the perturbation is the dipole interaction with an electromagnetic field, the successive approximations yield the well-known rotating-wave approximation, corrections due to counter rotating terms, and the Bloch-Siegert frequency shift. The formalism is applicable to arbitrary pulse shapes, provided that $\ensuremath{\parallel}{H}_{1}\ensuremath{\parallel}\ensuremath{\ll}\ensuremath{\hbar}\overline{\ensuremath{\omega}}$, where $\ensuremath{\parallel}{H}_{1}\ensuremath{\parallel}$ represents the inter-action strength and $\overline{\ensuremath{\omega}}$ is a characteristic frequency of the field. Rabi oscillations induced by multiphoton resonances are automatically included, and this effect is demonstrated in the case of a square pulse with frequency approximately one half the resonance frequency for a transition between two vibrational levels of a molecule. These calculations are compared to an exact numerical solution in order to find the limits of validity of the approximation. Even at high intensities ($I\ensuremath{\sim}{10}^{14}$ W/cm2{\mathrm{cm}}^{2}cm2) the shifted resonance frequency is quite accurate; however, the approximate and exact solutions are slightly out of phase, so that the approximate solution can only be trusted for a few Rabi cycles. For much lower intensities ($I\ensuremath{\sim}{10}^{10}$ W/cm2{\mathrm{cm}}^{2}cm2), the approximate solution is valid for many thousands of Rabi cycles.
Pulsed radio-frequency transient phenomena of resonant two-level spins are often described by the Bloch equations where the phenomenological dipole (T2{T}_{2}T2​) and population (T1{T}_{1}T1​) decay times appear. A similar description has been carried over recently into the microwave and infrared regions as well. At visible-ultraviolet wavelengths, however, a more general solution is required because the transition levels do not constitute an isolated system and also spontaneous emission can no longer be disregarded. As a consequence, the lower (1) and upper (2) transition levels are characterized by vastly different decay rates (${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{1}\ensuremath{\ne}{\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{2}$) and the lifetime T1{T}_{1}T1​ is no longer a defined quantity. In view of laser-induced coherent transient phenomena now being observed, we present general solutions of the density-matrix equations of motion for an optically resonant two-level system in contact with a multilevel reservoir where ${\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{1}\ensuremath{\ne}{\ensuremath{\gamma}}_{2}$. Particular and perturbative solutions involving intensity-dependent damping and frequency shifts are included with applications to echo and nutation phenomena.