Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Annals of the Japan Association for Philosophy of Science

On the Problem of Hidden Variables in Algebraic Quantum Field Theory

Yuichiro Kitajima

Published Jan 1, 2006• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

There have been many discussions about whether all observational propositions in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics can be taken as simultaneously definite without contradiction. Von Neumann, Jauch and Piron, and Bell have shown that not all observational propositions in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics can be interpreted in this way. In the present paper, I examine these theorems from an operator algebraic point view in order to apply these theorems to algebraic quantum field theory. Then I point out that not all observational propositions in local algebras can be taken as definite, in addition to nonrelativistic quantum mechanics.

DOI
10.4288/jafpos1956.15.25

Related papers

Bell's Inequalities, Relativistic Quantum Field Theory and the Problem of Hidden Variables

Miklós Rédei

Based partly on proving that algebraic relativistic quantum field theory (ARQFT) is a stochastic Einstein local (SEL) theory in the sense of SEL which was introduced by Hellman (1982b) and which is adapted in this paper to ARQFT, the recently proved maximal and typical violation of Bell's inequalities in ARQFT (Summers and Werner 1987a–c) is interpreted in this paper as showing that Bell's inequalities are, in a sense, irrelevant for the problem of Einstein local stochastic hidden variables, especially if this problem is raised in connection with ARQFT. This leads to the question of how to formulate the problem of local hidden variables in ARQFT. By giving a precise definition of hidden-variable theory within the operator algebraic framework of quantum mechanics, it will be argued that the aim of hidden-variable investigations is to determine those classes of quantum theories whose elements represent a statistical content that cannot be reduced in a given way. In some particular way to be stated, a proposition will be stated which distinguishes quantum field theories whose statistical content cannot be reduced without violating some relativistic locality principle.

Philosophy of Science•Dec 1, 1991•10 citations

A Refutation of the Proof by Jauch and Piron that Hidden Variables Can be Excluded in Quantum Mechanics

David Böhm, Jeffrey Bub

In this paper, we examine an argument of Jauch and Piron, which aims to prove the impossibility of hidden variables underlying the quantum theory, on the basis of certain assumptions that are weaker than those used by von Neumann for the same purpose. We show that, while the assumptions of Jauch and Piron are in fact weaker than those of von Neumann, the net result is that they actually prove nothing new at all. The conclusions of Jauch and Piron concerning the nonexistence of hidden variables are indeed seen to follow from a false assumption; i.e., that the impossibility of propositions that describe simultaneously the results of measurements of two noncommuting observables is an "empirical fact." Actually, it is shown that this assumption follows if and only if one first assumes what the authors set out to prove; i.e., that the current linguistic structure of quantum mechanics is the only one that can be used correctly to describe the empirical facts underlying the theory.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Jul 1, 1966•90 citations

Can hidden variables be excluded in quantum mechanics?

J. M. Jauch, C. Piron

The question of the possible existence of hidden variables is re-examined. It is shown that hidden variables can exist only if every proposition (yes-no experiment) is compatible with every other one. It is further shown that this property is in contradiction with empirical facts. The theorem which leads to this conclusion is a strengthening of the theorem of von Neumann on the same subject. The question is raised whether there exist perhaps quantum mechanical systems which admit approximate dispersion-free states.

•Dec 15, 1963•104 citations

Experimental test of local hidden-variable theories

Abner Shimony

The study of hidden-variable interpretations of quantum mechanics was transformed by two papers of Bell. In his 1966 paper in Reviews of Modern Physics [1] he analysed the argument of von Neumann [2] and the more powerful arguments of Jauch and Piron [3] and of Gleason [4], all leading to similar conclusions about the nonassignability of simultaneous values to all the observables of a nontrivial quantum system; and he showed that these arguments do not exclude what may be called “contextualistic” hidden-variable theories, in which the value of an observable O is allowed to depend not only upon the hidden state λ, but also upon the set C of compatible observables measured along with O. In Bell's 1964 paper in Physics [5] (written later than the other, in spite of the earlier publication date) he gave a new kind of argument against a hidden-variable interpretation of quantum mechanics, by showing that no hidden-variables theory which satisfies a certain condition of locality can agree with all the statistical predictions of quantum mechanics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Feb 26, 1993•116 citations

About Hidden Variables

J. C. Aron

The problem of hidden variables, purely conceptual at the start, has been early influenced by the practical aims of “causal theories” towards a mathematical scheme broader than the quantum formalism. Thus several authors have examined if a new formalism, built in the same spirit as that of quantum mechanics, however more general, might admit a determination by means of hidden parameters, and concluded negatively. In the present paper the two aspects (conceptual and practical) are considered separately. It first contains a study of the unrestricted proofs (Von Neumann, Jauch and Piron), given for the non-existence of hidden parameters. They are focussed on the dispersion-free states bound to them. Thus a preliminary stage consists in analyzing what properties these states should have. A method is given here for displaying these; they are shown to have an artificial character, which fits neither Von Neumann's proof nor that of Jauch and Piron and other authors (Misra). Thus, these proofs do not establish the inexistence of hidden variables, but only that of dispersion free states built more or less on the pattern of the quantum states. Suggestions are then proposed on the probable features of hidden parameters. They lead us to regard as improbable the hope of building a new deterministic scheme to be substituted for the quantum formalism. Thus, the determinism which can be maintained appears as purely conceptual. The question of a “deeper level” and the relation between determination and pictorial description are discussed briefly.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Sep 1, 1969•2 citations

Valuations on Functionally Closed Sets of Quantum Mechanical Observables and Von Neumann's 'No-Hidden-Variables' Theorem

Jason Zimba, Rob Clifton

We apply the machinery of projection lattices and von Neumann algebras to analyze the question of how modal interpretations can (and do) circumvent von Neumann's infamous 'no-hidden-variables' theorem.

arXiv:quant-ph/9802038•Feb 13, 1998•1 citation
There have been many discussions about whether all observational propositions in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics can be taken as simultaneously definite without contradiction. Von Neumann, Jauch and Piron, and Bell have shown that not all observational propositions in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics can be interpreted in this way. In the present paper, I examine these theorems from an operator algebraic point view in order to apply these theorems to algebraic quantum field theory. Then I point out that not all observational propositions in local algebras can be taken as definite, in addition to nonrelativistic quantum mechanics.
Based partly on proving that algebraic relativistic quantum field theory (ARQFT) is a stochastic Einstein local (SEL) theory in the sense of SEL which was introduced by Hellman (1982b) and which is adapted in this paper to ARQFT, the recently proved maximal and typical violation of Bell's inequalities in ARQFT (Summers and Werner 1987a–c) is interpreted in this paper as showing that Bell's inequalities are, in a sense, irrelevant for the problem of Einstein local stochastic hidden variables, especially if this problem is raised in connection with ARQFT. This leads to the question of how to formulate the problem of local hidden variables in ARQFT. By giving a precise definition of hidden-variable theory within the operator algebraic framework of quantum mechanics, it will be argued that the aim of hidden-variable investigations is to determine those classes of quantum theories whose elements represent a statistical content that cannot be reduced in a given way. In some particular way to be stated, a proposition will be stated which distinguishes quantum field theories whose statistical content cannot be reduced without violating some relativistic locality principle.
In this paper, we examine an argument of Jauch and Piron, which aims to prove the impossibility of hidden variables underlying the quantum theory, on the basis of certain assumptions that are weaker than those used by von Neumann for the same purpose. We show that, while the assumptions of Jauch and Piron are in fact weaker than those of von Neumann, the net result is that they actually prove nothing new at all. The conclusions of Jauch and Piron concerning the nonexistence of hidden variables are indeed seen to follow from a false assumption; i.e., that the impossibility of propositions that describe simultaneously the results of measurements of two noncommuting observables is an "empirical fact." Actually, it is shown that this assumption follows if and only if one first assumes what the authors set out to prove; i.e., that the current linguistic structure of quantum mechanics is the only one that can be used correctly to describe the empirical facts underlying the theory.
The question of the possible existence of hidden variables is re-examined. It is shown that hidden variables can exist only if every proposition (yes-no experiment) is compatible with every other one. It is further shown that this property is in contradiction with empirical facts. The theorem which leads to this conclusion is a strengthening of the theorem of von Neumann on the same subject. The question is raised whether there exist perhaps quantum mechanical systems which admit approximate dispersion-free states.
The study of hidden-variable interpretations of quantum mechanics was transformed by two papers of Bell. In his 1966 paper in Reviews of Modern Physics [1] he analysed the argument of von Neumann [2] and the more powerful arguments of Jauch and Piron [3] and of Gleason [4], all leading to similar conclusions about the nonassignability of simultaneous values to all the observables of a nontrivial quantum system; and he showed that these arguments do not exclude what may be called “contextualistic” hidden-variable theories, in which the value of an observable O is allowed to depend not only upon the hidden state λ, but also upon the set C of compatible observables measured along with O. In Bell's 1964 paper in Physics [5] (written later than the other, in spite of the earlier publication date) he gave a new kind of argument against a hidden-variable interpretation of quantum mechanics, by showing that no hidden-variables theory which satisfies a certain condition of locality can agree with all the statistical predictions of quantum mechanics.
The problem of hidden variables, purely conceptual at the start, has been early influenced by the practical aims of “causal theories” towards a mathematical scheme broader than the quantum formalism. Thus several authors have examined if a new formalism, built in the same spirit as that of quantum mechanics, however more general, might admit a determination by means of hidden parameters, and concluded negatively. In the present paper the two aspects (conceptual and practical) are considered separately. It first contains a study of the unrestricted proofs (Von Neumann, Jauch and Piron), given for the non-existence of hidden parameters. They are focussed on the dispersion-free states bound to them. Thus a preliminary stage consists in analyzing what properties these states should have. A method is given here for displaying these; they are shown to have an artificial character, which fits neither Von Neumann's proof nor that of Jauch and Piron and other authors (Misra). Thus, these proofs do not establish the inexistence of hidden variables, but only that of dispersion free states built more or less on the pattern of the quantum states. Suggestions are then proposed on the probable features of hidden parameters. They lead us to regard as improbable the hope of building a new deterministic scheme to be substituted for the quantum formalism. Thus, the determinism which can be maintained appears as purely conceptual. The question of a “deeper level” and the relation between determination and pictorial description are discussed briefly.