Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Optics Letters

Comment on “Resolving the wave vector and the refractive index from the coefficient of reflectance”

Manuel Pérez Molina, L. Carretero

Published Aug 6, 2008• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In a recent Letter, the reflectance coefficient was used to resolve the sign choice of the wave vector and refractive index in active media. We argue that such a coefficient loses its physical meaning for active media (at real frequencies) when the field amplification is limited only by gain saturation. In this case, the amplitude reflectance coefficient leads to fictitious noncausal reflected fields when the backward Fourier transform is used.

DOI
10.1364/ol.33.001828

Related papers

Reply to comment on “Resolving the wave vector and the refractive index from the coefficient of reflectance”

V. U. Nazarov, Yia‐Chung Chang

We reinterpret our earlier letter [Opt. Lett.32, 2939 (2007)] to demonstrate that the resolution it gives to the problem of the sign of the wave vector and the refractive index is valid for active media without instabilities but invalid otherwise.

Optics Letters•Aug 6, 2008•4 citations

On the problem of controlled virtual refractive index

Anatolii N Oraevsky, Игорь Евгеньевич Проценко, A Botero

A method for controlling the refractive index that is based on the backward rescattering of the scattered and amplified electromagnetic waves is proposed and analysed. The resulting field is a sum of the initial (probe) wave and the rescattered wave. The effective wave number of the total wave can be varied by varying the gain. This variation in the wave number can be treated as a variation in the refractive index, although the physical properties of the medium do not change. The effective refractive index for the total wave propagating in such a device was called the virtual refractive index.

Quantum Electronics•Sep 30, 2000•1 citation

Deformation of the signal envelope due to a strong dispersion of the refractive index in the gain region

Nikolai S. Bukhman

It is shown that, when a narrow-band signal with a non-Gaussian envelope propagates in a medium with a strong dispersion, the signal envelope being distorted due to the dispersion of the gain (or) absorption in the medium. Nevertheless, the amplitude-modulated signal having a symmetric (even) intensity envelope remains the same. The propagation velocity of the `middle point' (i.e., the symmetry centre) of the signal coincides with the real group velocity of the wave with a given carrier frequency in the medium and can be subluminal, superluminal or negative. Therefore, the concept of a real group velocity (including the superluminal or negative velocity) is also applicable in media with a strong dispersion of the gain (or absorption).

Quantum Electronics•Feb 28, 2004•9 citations

Reflection of light from amplifying medium

R. V. Karapetyan

The existing linear theory of the reflection of light waves from an amplifying medium is debated. The exiting data are often contradictory, a reflection coefficient of amplifying medium of greater than unity is discussed, an upper bound of 5.82 is imposed on this quantity, significant corrections of prelaser concepts regarding the reflection and refraction of light in such media are proposed, etc. This stimulates reconsideration of the existing results. Evidently, the corresponding analysis must be based on the data obtained with a commonly accepted and, preferably, simplest approach. In our opinion, such an approach represents an analytical continuation of the known prelaser achievements (the Airy formulas for the reflection and transmission of light in a transparent medium proposed in 1833) to the domain of the amplifying media. The results presented can improve the basis of a linear theory for the interaction of light with amplifying media.

Laser Physics•Aug 1, 2007•5 citations

Resolving the wave vector and the refractive index from the coefficient of reflectance

V. U. Nazarov, Yia‐Chung Chang

We resolve the existing controversy concerning the selection of the sign of the normal-to-the-interface component of the wave vector k(z) of an electromagnetic wave in an active (gain) medium. Our method exploits the fact that no ambiguity exists in the case of a film of the active medium, since its coefficient of reflectance is invariant under the inversion of the sign of k(z). Then we show that the limit of the infinite film thickness determines a unique and physically consistent choice of the wave vector and the refractive index. Important practical implications of the theory are identified and discussed.

arXiv:0710.4388•Optics Letters•Oct 4, 2007•14 citations

Possible use of resonantly excited media in wavefront reversal

А. Н. Ораевский

A theoretical analysis is made of the conditions which a resonantly excited medium must have to act as a wavefront-reversing mirror. In the absence of saturation by the incident signal, the absorption cross section at the frequency of this signal should be considerably less than at the reversed-wave frequency. In the case of strong saturation it is preferable to use substances with narrow spectral lines. If a wavefrontreversing mirror is used to compensate distortions of the front of a wave during amplification, the necessary contrast of the reversed wave is a function of the gain and of the width of its profile.

Soviet Journal of Quantum Electronics•Jan 31, 1979•3 citations
In a recent Letter, the reflectance coefficient was used to resolve the sign choice of the wave vector and refractive index in active media. We argue that such a coefficient loses its physical meaning for active media (at real frequencies) when the field amplification is limited only by gain saturation. In this case, the amplitude reflectance coefficient leads to fictitious noncausal reflected fields when the backward Fourier transform is used.
A method for controlling the refractive index that is based on the backward rescattering of the scattered and amplified electromagnetic waves is proposed and analysed. The resulting field is a sum of the initial (probe) wave and the rescattered wave. The effective wave number of the total wave can be varied by varying the gain. This variation in the wave number can be treated as a variation in the refractive index, although the physical properties of the medium do not change. The effective refractive index for the total wave propagating in such a device was called the virtual refractive index.
It is shown that, when a narrow-band signal with a non-Gaussian envelope propagates in a medium with a strong dispersion, the signal envelope being distorted due to the dispersion of the gain (or) absorption in the medium. Nevertheless, the amplitude-modulated signal having a symmetric (even) intensity envelope remains the same. The propagation velocity of the `middle point' (i.e., the symmetry centre) of the signal coincides with the real group velocity of the wave with a given carrier frequency in the medium and can be subluminal, superluminal or negative. Therefore, the concept of a real group velocity (including the superluminal or negative velocity) is also applicable in media with a strong dispersion of the gain (or absorption).
The existing linear theory of the reflection of light waves from an amplifying medium is debated. The exiting data are often contradictory, a reflection coefficient of amplifying medium of greater than unity is discussed, an upper bound of 5.82 is imposed on this quantity, significant corrections of prelaser concepts regarding the reflection and refraction of light in such media are proposed, etc. This stimulates reconsideration of the existing results. Evidently, the corresponding analysis must be based on the data obtained with a commonly accepted and, preferably, simplest approach. In our opinion, such an approach represents an analytical continuation of the known prelaser achievements (the Airy formulas for the reflection and transmission of light in a transparent medium proposed in 1833) to the domain of the amplifying media. The results presented can improve the basis of a linear theory for the interaction of light with amplifying media.
We resolve the existing controversy concerning the selection of the sign of the normal-to-the-interface component of the wave vector k(z) of an electromagnetic wave in an active (gain) medium. Our method exploits the fact that no ambiguity exists in the case of a film of the active medium, since its coefficient of reflectance is invariant under the inversion of the sign of k(z). Then we show that the limit of the infinite film thickness determines a unique and physically consistent choice of the wave vector and the refractive index. Important practical implications of the theory are identified and discussed.
A theoretical analysis is made of the conditions which a resonantly excited medium must have to act as a wavefront-reversing mirror. In the absence of saturation by the incident signal, the absorption cross section at the frequency of this signal should be considerably less than at the reversed-wave frequency. In the case of strong saturation it is preferable to use substances with narrow spectral lines. If a wavefrontreversing mirror is used to compensate distortions of the front of a wave during amplification, the necessary contrast of the reversed wave is a function of the gain and of the width of its profile.