By studying correlation functions of two replicas with the damage spreading method, the spin glass transition temperature of the 3D ±J EA model is evaluated by using Campbell's criterion D (Tg, t → ∞) = 1/2 or [Formula: see text], where D and [Formula: see text] are the Hamming distance and the overlap of the two replicas, respectively. The two replicas evolve with the same series of the random numbers and with initial spin-configurations related to each other by [Formula: see text] (for all i). From our simulational data for system sizes up to L = 64, the spin glass transition temperature is estimated as Tg = 1.18 ± 0.06. The replica simulational method and the damage spreading method are compared with each other. The relaxation exponents of the magnetization and the correlation functions are also estimated in the vicinity of Tg on a large lattice and the dynamical critical exponent z is estimated as z ≃ 6.0.
As an analysis of equilibrium phase transitions, the nonequilibrium relaxation method is extended to the spin glass (SG) transition. The $\ifmmode\pm\else\textpm\fi{}J$ Ising SG model is analyzed for three-dimensional (cubic) lattices up to the linear size of
L=127 and for four-dimensional (hypercubic) lattice up to
L=41. These sizes of systems are quite large as compared with those calculated, so far, by equilibrium simulations. As a dynamical order parameter, we calculate the clone correlation function (CCF) ${Q(t,t}_{\mathrm{w}})\ensuremath{\equiv}[〈{S}_{i}^{(1)}{(t+t}_{\mathrm{w}}){S}_{i}^{(2)}{(t+t}_{\mathrm{w}}){〉}^{\mathrm{F}}],$ which is a spin correlation of two replicas produced after the waiting time
tw from a simple starting state. It is found that the CCF shows an exponential decay in the paramagnetic phase, and a power-law decay after aginglike development $(t\ensuremath{\gg}{t}_{\mathrm{w}})$ in the SG phase. This provides a reliable upper bound of the transition temperature
Tg. It is also found that a scaling relation, ${Q(t,t}_{\mathrm{w}}{)=t}_{\mathrm{w}}^{\ensuremath{-}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}_{q}}\overline{q}{(t/t}_{\mathrm{w}}),$ holds just around the transition point providing the lower bound of
Tg. Together with these two bounds, we propose a new dynamical way for the estimation of
Tg from much larger systems. In the SG phase, the power-law behavior of the CCF for $t\ensuremath{\gg}{t}_{\mathrm{w}}$ suggests that the SG phase in short-range Ising models has a rugged phase space.
A spin-glass transition has been investigated for a long time but we have not reached a conclusion yet due to difficulties in the simulation studies. They are slow dynamics, strong finite-size effects, and sample-to-sample dependencies. We found that a size of the spin-glass order reaches a lattice boundary within a very short Monte Carlo step. A competition between the spin-glass order and a boundary condition causes these difficulties. Once the boundary effect was removed, physical quantities exhibited quite normal behaviors. They became self-averaging in a limit of large replica numbers. These findings suggest that the nonequilibrium relaxation method is a good choice for solving the difficulties if a lattice size and a replica number are set sufficiently large. A dynamic scaling analysis on nonequilibrium relaxation functions gave a result that the spin-glass transition and the chiral-glass transition occurs at the same temperature in the Heisenberg model in three dimensions. The estimated critical exponent ν agrees with the experimental result.
Dynamical scaling study for the estimation of dynamical exponent
z of three-dimensional XY spin glass model
To analyze the
±J XY spin-glass in three dimensions, we verified a method aimed at obtaining a high-precision dynamical exponent
z from the correlation length in the nonequilibrium relaxation process. The obtained
z yielded consistent and highly accurate results in previous studies for relatively well-studied models---specifically, the three-dimensional (3D) ferromagnetic Ising model and the 3D
±J Ising model. Building on these previous studies, we used this method and the dynamical scaling method to analyze the 3D
±J XY model and obtained highly precise critical temperatures and exponents. The estimated transition temperatures satisfy $T_{\mathrm{SG}}