Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A

Indefinite Metrik im Zustandsraum und Wahrscheinlichkeitsinterpretation

Siegfried Schlieder

Published Jun 1, 1960• 7 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The purpose of the following paper, which is published in three parts, is to show the possibility of making consistent use of an indefinite metric in the space of states and of the probability interpretation of quantum mechanics. In the part I bilinear forms, which are invariant under the transformations of symmetry groups, are constructed. The construction of the fundamental metric tensor for the various types of representations is exemplified for the case of inhomogenious LORENTZ group. The results are also applicable for other groups. The representations of the finite and compact group are however normal. In these cases the use of an indefinite metric does not bring about a new look for the theory of representations. In the parts II and III besides invariance of bilinear forms further conditions are stated, which are sufficient for the propability interpretation. The existence of superselection rules by which the space of states breaks up into coherent sectors leads to two procedures. In the part II the facts within one coherent sector are solely studied. These results are important for the representations of those symmetry groups, which leave the coherent sectors invariant (e. g. the inhomogenious LORENTZ group). Each sector is divided by a cut into a subspace, the elements of which represent physical systems, and a rest. The representations in the „subspace of physical systems“ of these symmetry groups, which leave the sectors invariant, are unitary. In the part III the space of states as a whole is investigated. The symmetry group of isotopic spin for a simple case is discussed there as an example of mapping from one coherent sector to another. At the end a possible generalization for the dual vector of a vector is discussed.

DOI
10.1515/zna-1960-5-610

Related papers

Indefinite Metrik im Zustandsraum und Wahrscheinlichkeitsinterpretation

Siegfried Schlieder

The content of the part I was the construction of the fundamental metric tensor; in the part II the conditions which make possible the probability interpretation for elements lying in the same coherent sector were discussed. The subject of the following part is the space of states as a whole. The existence of superselection rules allows one to give up the fundamental tensors formerly introduced as identity matrix in the subspace of the physical states. The mathematical form, in which symmetry groups appear is shown by an example. Finally a possible generalization for the dual element of an element is given.

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A•Jul 1, 1960•2 citations

INDEFINITE METRIC IN THE SPACE OF STATES AND PROBABILITY INTERPRETATION. PART III

Siegfried Schlieder

The content of Part I was the construction of the fundamental metric tensor; in Part II the conditions which make possible the probability interpretation for elements lying in the same coherent sector were discussed. The subject of this part (III) is the space of states as a whole. The existence of superselection rules allows the fundamental tensors formerly introduced as identity matrix in the subspace of the physical states to be given up. The mathematical form in which symmetry groups appear is shown by an example. Finally, a possible generalization for the dual element of an element is given. (auth)

•Jul 1, 1960•0 citations

Indefinite Metrik im Zustandsraum und Wahrscheinlichkeitsinterpretation

Siegfried Schlieder

In part I invariant bilinear forms were constructed by means of suitable fundamental tensors. Invariance is one of the conditions for the probability interpretation. In the following part further conditions are specified for the “space of physical states”. They are sufficient at the first instance for the probability interpretation for elements of one coherent sector.

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A•Jun 1, 1960•2 citations

The Invariant Measure of a Universe: The Inner Product

Kacheong R. Yeung, Lex Yeung

The Euclidean dot product, the Minkowski bilinear form, and the quantum Hilbert-space inner product serve different physical purposes, yet each is preserved by a characteristic symmetry group. This paper examines their common relational role while distinguishing what follows from symmetry from what must be supplied independently. For specified defining representations, invariance under O(n), O(1,3), and U(n) selects the standard Euclidean, Lorentzian, and Hermitian forms up to scale within the appropriate bilinear or sesquilinear classes. We also review the classical averaging result that a compact group acting irreducibly on a finite-dimensional vector space determines an invariant positive form up to scale. The revised analysis then considers the converse problem: whether invariant geometry can arise from an independently specified operational state space. For a finite-dimensional compact convex state space, we show that its full affine automorphism group is compact and construct an invariant positive pairing on the space of state differences from the state's covariance geometry. Under irreducibility, this pairing is unique up to scale. Classical simplices satisfy the same geometric conditions, however, so the construction does not distinguish classical from quantum theory. Continuous reversibility provides an additional discriminator but is likewise insufficient by itself. The results therefore narrow, rather than resolve, the foundational question: what determines the physically admissible transformations from which an invariant pairing might be recovered? In particular, invariant geometry alone neither derives complex quantum theory nor supplies the Born rule. The paper presents a conditional comparative framework for understanding invariant pairings across Euclidean, relativistic, and quantum settings, rather than an origin theorem for physical law. Version note: v2 → v3 Version 3 substantially extends the operational analysis of Version 2. The principal addition is Proposition 3.5, which shows that the full affine automorphism group of a finite-dimensional compact convex state space is compact and constructs an invariant positive-definite pairing on the space of state differences using the covariance of the state space. Under irreducibility, this pairing is unique up to positive scale. A new discussion examines the limits of this result. Classical simplices provide a counterexample to any claim that the existence of such invariant geometry uniquely characterizes quantum theory. The revision therefore considers continuous reversibility as an additional operational distinction, while emphasizing that it too is insufficient to derive complex quantum theory or the Born rule. The qubit/Bloch-vector example further clarifies the distinction between an invariant state-space pairing and quantum transition probability. The central thesis of Version 2 is retained: symmetry can characterize invariant pairings under stated structural assumptions, but does not by itself derive geometry, quantum theory, or probability. Version 3 strengthens this framework by showing how an invariant positive pairing can arise from the automorphisms of a compact convex state space while more sharply identifying what remains unexplained: the physical principles that select the admissible state space and its reversible transformations

•Jun 30, 2026•0 citations

The Case for a Quantum Theory on a Hilbert Space with an Inner Product of Indefinite Signature

Otto C. W. Kong

We present the theoretical considerations for the case of looking into a generalization of quantum theory corresponding to having an inner product with an indefinite signature on the Hilbert space. The latter is essentially a direct analog of having the Minkowski spacetime with an indefinite signature generalizing the metric geometry of the Newtonian space. In fact, the explicit physics setting we have in mind is exactly a Lorentz covariant formulation of quantum mechanics, which has been discussed in the literature for over half a century yet without a nice full picture. From the point of view of the Lorentz symmetry, indefiniteness of the norm for a Minkowski vector may be the exact correspondence of the indefiniteness of the norm for a quantum state vector on the relevant Hilbert space. That, of course, poses a challenge to the usual requirement of unitarity. The related issues will be addressed.

Journal of High Energy Physics Gravitation and Cosmology•Dec 9, 2019•3 citations

Reciprocal relativity of noninertial frames: quantum mechanics

Stephen G. Low

Noninertial transformations on time–position–momentum–energy space { t , q , p , e } with invariant Born–Green metric and the symplectic metric −d e ∧ d t + d p ∧ d q are studied. This group of transformations contains the Lorentz group as the inertial special case and, in the limit of small forces and velocities, reduces to the expected Hamilton transformations leaving invariant the symplectic metric and the nonrelativistic line element d s 2 = −d t 2 . The transformations bound relative velocities by c and relative forces by b . Spacetime is no longer an invariant subspace but is relative to noninertial observer frames. In the limit of b → ∞, spacetime is invariant. Born was lead to the metric by a concept of reciprocity between position and momentum degrees of freedom and for this reason we call this reciprocal relativity. For large b , such effects will almost certainly only manifest in a quantum regime. Wigner showed that special relativistic quantum mechanics follows from the projective representations of the inhomogeneous Lorentz group. Projective representations of a Lie group are equivalent to the unitary representations of its central extension. The same method of projective representations for the inhomogeneous group is used to define the quantum theory in the noninertial case. The central extension of the inhomogeneous group is the cover of the quaplectic group . is the Weyl–Heisenberg group. The group, and the associated Heisenberg commutation relations central to quantum mechanics, results directly from requiring projective representations. A set of second-order wave equations result from the representations of the Casimir operators.

arXiv:math-ph/0606015•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Mar 20, 2007•17 citations
The purpose of the following paper, which is published in three parts, is to show the possibility of making consistent use of an indefinite metric in the space of states and of the probability interpretation of quantum mechanics. In the part I bilinear forms, which are invariant under the transformations of symmetry groups, are constructed. The construction of the fundamental metric tensor for the various types of representations is exemplified for the case of inhomogenious LORENTZ group. The results are also applicable for other groups. The representations of the finite and compact group are however normal. In these cases the use of an indefinite metric does not bring about a new look for the theory of representations. In the parts II and III besides invariance of bilinear forms further conditions are stated, which are sufficient for the propability interpretation. The existence of superselection rules by which the space of states breaks up into coherent sectors leads to two procedures. In the part II the facts within one coherent sector are solely studied. These results are important for the representations of those symmetry groups, which leave the coherent sectors invariant (e. g. the inhomogenious LORENTZ group). Each sector is divided by a cut into a subspace, the elements of which represent physical systems, and a rest. The representations in the „subspace of physical systems“ of these symmetry groups, which leave the sectors invariant, are unitary. In the part III the space of states as a whole is investigated. The symmetry group of isotopic spin for a simple case is discussed there as an example of mapping from one coherent sector to another. At the end a possible generalization for the dual vector of a vector is discussed.
The content of the part I was the construction of the fundamental metric tensor; in the part II the conditions which make possible the probability interpretation for elements lying in the same coherent sector were discussed. The subject of the following part is the space of states as a whole. The existence of superselection rules allows one to give up the fundamental tensors formerly introduced as identity matrix in the subspace of the physical states. The mathematical form, in which symmetry groups appear is shown by an example. Finally a possible generalization for the dual element of an element is given.
The content of Part I was the construction of the fundamental metric tensor; in Part II the conditions which make possible the probability interpretation for elements lying in the same coherent sector were discussed. The subject of this part (III) is the space of states as a whole. The existence of superselection rules allows the fundamental tensors formerly introduced as identity matrix in the subspace of the physical states to be given up. The mathematical form in which symmetry groups appear is shown by an example. Finally, a possible generalization for the dual element of an element is given. (auth)
The Euclidean dot product, the Minkowski bilinear form, and the quantum Hilbert-space inner product serve different physical purposes, yet each is preserved by a characteristic symmetry group. This paper examines their common relational role while distinguishing what follows from symmetry from what must be supplied independently. For specified defining representations, invariance under O(n), O(1,3), and U(n) selects the standard Euclidean, Lorentzian, and Hermitian forms up to scale within the appropriate bilinear or sesquilinear classes. We also review the classical averaging result that a compact group acting irreducibly on a finite-dimensional vector space determines an invariant positive form up to scale. The revised analysis then considers the converse problem: whether invariant geometry can arise from an independently specified operational state space. For a finite-dimensional compact convex state space, we show that its full affine automorphism group is compact and construct an invariant positive pairing on the space of state differences from the state's covariance geometry. Under irreducibility, this pairing is unique up to scale. Classical simplices satisfy the same geometric conditions, however, so the construction does not distinguish classical from quantum theory. Continuous reversibility provides an additional discriminator but is likewise insufficient by itself. The results therefore narrow, rather than resolve, the foundational question: what determines the physically admissible transformations from which an invariant pairing might be recovered? In particular, invariant geometry alone neither derives complex quantum theory nor supplies the Born rule. The paper presents a conditional comparative framework for understanding invariant pairings across Euclidean, relativistic, and quantum settings, rather than an origin theorem for physical law. Version note: v2 → v3 Version 3 substantially extends the operational analysis of Version 2. The principal addition is Proposition 3.5, which shows that the full affine automorphism group of a finite-dimensional compact convex state space is compact and constructs an invariant positive-definite pairing on the space of state differences using the covariance of the state space. Under irreducibility, this pairing is unique up to positive scale. A new discussion examines the limits of this result. Classical simplices provide a counterexample to any claim that the existence of such invariant geometry uniquely characterizes quantum theory. The revision therefore considers continuous reversibility as an additional operational distinction, while emphasizing that it too is insufficient to derive complex quantum theory or the Born rule. The qubit/Bloch-vector example further clarifies the distinction between an invariant state-space pairing and quantum transition probability. The central thesis of Version 2 is retained: symmetry can characterize invariant pairings under stated structural assumptions, but does not by itself derive geometry, quantum theory, or probability. Version 3 strengthens this framework by showing how an invariant positive pairing can arise from the automorphisms of a compact convex state space while more sharply identifying what remains unexplained: the physical principles that select the admissible state space and its reversible transformations
We present the theoretical considerations for the case of looking into a generalization of quantum theory corresponding to having an inner product with an indefinite signature on the Hilbert space. The latter is essentially a direct analog of having the Minkowski spacetime with an indefinite signature generalizing the metric geometry of the Newtonian space. In fact, the explicit physics setting we have in mind is exactly a Lorentz covariant formulation of quantum mechanics, which has been discussed in the literature for over half a century yet without a nice full picture. From the point of view of the Lorentz symmetry, indefiniteness of the norm for a Minkowski vector may be the exact correspondence of the indefiniteness of the norm for a quantum state vector on the relevant Hilbert space. That, of course, poses a challenge to the usual requirement of unitarity. The related issues will be addressed.
Noninertial transformations on time–position–momentum–energy space { t , q , p , e } with invariant Born–Green metric and the symplectic metric −d e ∧ d t + d p ∧ d q are studied. This group of transformations contains the Lorentz group as the inertial special case and, in the limit of small forces and velocities, reduces to the expected Hamilton transformations leaving invariant the symplectic metric and the nonrelativistic line element d s 2 = −d t 2 . The transformations bound relative velocities by c and relative forces by b . Spacetime is no longer an invariant subspace but is relative to noninertial observer frames. In the limit of b → ∞, spacetime is invariant. Born was lead to the metric by a concept of reciprocity between position and momentum degrees of freedom and for this reason we call this reciprocal relativity. For large b , such effects will almost certainly only manifest in a quantum regime. Wigner showed that special relativistic quantum mechanics follows from the projective representations of the inhomogeneous Lorentz group. Projective representations of a Lie group are equivalent to the unitary representations of its central extension. The same method of projective representations for the inhomogeneous group is used to define the quantum theory in the noninertial case. The central extension of the inhomogeneous group is the cover of the quaplectic group . is the Weyl–Heisenberg group. The group, and the associated Heisenberg commutation relations central to quantum mechanics, results directly from requiring projective representations. A set of second-order wave equations result from the representations of the Casimir operators.