Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

A Note on the Quantum Rule of the Harmonic Oscillator

L. M. Yang

Published Nov 15, 1951• 226 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The purpose of the present note is to show, with the aid of an elementary example, that the commutation rules, which are usually given the rule of postulates in quantum mechanics, are in fact not arbitrary, provided that a more stringent definition of the Hilbert space and a strict expansion theorem are adopted.
DOI
10.1103/physrev.84.788

Related papers

The Quantum-Mechanical Equations of Motion and Commutation Relations

Calvin R. Putnam

It has been shown by Wigner that the equations of motion of a quantum-mechanical system with a hamiltonian $H=\frac{1}{2}{p}^{2}+V(q)$ need not imply the commutation relation $i[p,q]=1$. Particular examples are furnished by the free particle and the harmonic oscillator. On the other hand, Wigner points out that the above commutation rule does follow from the equations of motion if $V(q)$ is of the form $V=aq+b$ or $V=a{q}^{3}$. In the present note, this latter result is generalized to the case of an arbitrary potential $V=a{q}^{n}+b$, where $n$ is an odd integer; the last-named potentials are, in fact, particular cases of those satisfying a general criterion contained in the article.

Physical Review•Sep 1, 1951•4 citations

Classical Behavior of Systems of Quantum Oscillators

Roy J. Glauber

There are many contexts in which the quantum mechanical behavior of a harmonic oscillator or of a set of coupled oscillators is found to be quite similar to the classical behavior of the same systems. A considerable number of instances in which this similarity exists may be explained by means of an elementary theorem which we shall prove in the present note.

Wiley eBooks•Dec 15, 2006•0 citations

On a Quantum Action Principle

Natalya Gorobey, Alexander S. Lukyanenko

A quantum version of the action principle is formulated in terms of real parameters of a wave functional. The classical limit of the quantum action of a harmonic oscillator is obtained.

arXiv:0810.2255•Oct 13, 2008•4 citations

The Harmonic Oscillator, a Review of Classicaland Elementary Quantum Mechanics

Carl W David

The classical harmonic oscillator and an elementary discussion of the quantum mechanical solutions for the harmonic oscillator are discussed.

•Jan 1, 2006•0 citations

From Operational Axioms, UEIR Ordering, and Conductance Geometry to Hilbert-Space Quantum Theory

Tajudeen H. Sikiru

We extend the operational uniqueness result of the ℓ2-norm sample-and-query rule [1] to the full quantum reconstruction programme. Starting from the five operational axioms A1–A5 of the companion note, we generalise them to the framework of generalised probabilistic theories (GPTs). We impose two additional structural postulates: the strict non-commutative UEIR ordering R ◦ I ◦ E ◦ U and the conductance geometry Φ = k/n derived from the Boolean hypercube Qn.We prove (Theorem 5.1) that the only GPT satisfying A1–A5 together with the UEIR ordering and the conductance geometry is complex Hilbert-space quantum mechanics (d ≥ 2). As corollaries we recover the standard Born rule p(k|ρ) = Tr(ρEk) on density operators and the emergence of Tang’s ℓ2-norm SQ access model as the unique R-layer classical realisation.We further prove (Theorem 7.1) that under Born-rule ℓ2-norm sampling, the expected conductance of Haar-random quantum states satisfies EHaar[Φeff ] = (n + 1)/(2n) → 1/2 as n → ∞. This makes the quantum-classical threshold pc = 1/2 a proved theorem derivable from quantum mechanics, not an external postulate. We identify a structural parallel between this convergence and the Riemann critical line Re(s) = 1/2, arising from the shared involution structure of L2-norm squaring, and state a precise open conjecture.

•Jun 5, 2026•0 citations

Coherent mixed states and a generalised P representation

R. F. Bishop, Apostol Vourdas

The pure Glauber (harmonic oscillator) coherent states provide a very useful basis for many purposes. They are complete in the sense that an arbitrary state in the Hilbert space may be expanded in terms of them. Furthermore, the well known P representation provides a diagonal expansion of an arbitrary operator in the Hilbert space in terms of the projection operators onto the coherent states. The authors study the extensions of these results to the analogous mixed states which describe comparable harmonic oscillator systems in thermodynamic equilibrium at non-zero temperatures. Their results are given for the general density operator which describes the mixed squeezed coherent states of the displaced and squeezed harmonic oscillator. They show how these squeezed coherent mixed states similarly provide a very convenient complete description of a Hilbert space. In particular they show how the usual P and Q representations of operators in terms of pure states may be extended to finite temperatures with the corresponding mixed states, and various relations between them are demonstrated. The question of the existence of the generalised P representation for an arbitrary operator is further examined and some pertinent theorems are proven. They also show how their results relate to the Glauber-Lachs formalism in quantum optics for mixtures of coherent and incoherent radiation. Particular attention is focused both on the interplay between the quantum mechanical and thermodynamical uncertainties and on the entropy associated with such mixed states.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 21, 1987•45 citations
It has been shown by Wigner that the equations of motion of a quantum-mechanical system with a hamiltonian H=12p2+V(q)H=\frac{1}{2}{p}^{2}+V(q)H=21​p2+V(q) need not imply the commutation relation i[p,q]=1i[p,q]=1i[p,q]=1. Particular examples are furnished by the free particle and the harmonic oscillator. On the other hand, Wigner points out that the above commutation rule does follow from the equations of motion if V(q)V(q)V(q) is of the form V=aq+bV=aq+bV=aq+b or V=aq3V=a{q}^{3}V=aq3. In the present note, this latter result is generalized to the case of an arbitrary potential V=aqn+bV=a{q}^{n}+bV=aqn+b, where nnn is an odd integer; the last-named potentials are, in fact, particular cases of those satisfying a general criterion contained in the article.
We extend the operational uniqueness result of the ℓ2-norm sample-and-query rule [1] to the full quantum reconstruction programme. Starting from the five operational axioms A1–A5 of the companion note, we generalise them to the framework of generalised probabilistic theories (GPTs). We impose two additional structural postulates: the strict non-commutative UEIR ordering R ◦ I ◦ E ◦ U and the conductance geometry Φ = k/n derived from the Boolean hypercube Qn.We prove (Theorem 5.1) that the only GPT satisfying A1–A5 together with the UEIR ordering and the conductance geometry is complex Hilbert-space quantum mechanics (d ≥ 2). As corollaries we recover the standard Born rule p(k|ρ) = Tr(ρEk) on density operators and the emergence of Tang’s ℓ2-norm SQ access model as the unique R-layer classical realisation.We further prove (Theorem 7.1) that under Born-rule ℓ2-norm sampling, the expected conductance of Haar-random quantum states satisfies EHaar[Φeff ] = (n + 1)/(2n) → 1/2 as n → ∞. This makes the quantum-classical threshold pc = 1/2 a proved theorem derivable from quantum mechanics, not an external postulate. We identify a structural parallel between this convergence and the Riemann critical line Re(s) = 1/2, arising from the shared involution structure of L2-norm squaring, and state a precise open conjecture.
The pure Glauber (harmonic oscillator) coherent states provide a very useful basis for many purposes. They are complete in the sense that an arbitrary state in the Hilbert space may be expanded in terms of them. Furthermore, the well known P representation provides a diagonal expansion of an arbitrary operator in the Hilbert space in terms of the projection operators onto the coherent states. The authors study the extensions of these results to the analogous mixed states which describe comparable harmonic oscillator systems in thermodynamic equilibrium at non-zero temperatures. Their results are given for the general density operator which describes the mixed squeezed coherent states of the displaced and squeezed harmonic oscillator. They show how these squeezed coherent mixed states similarly provide a very convenient complete description of a Hilbert space. In particular they show how the usual P and Q representations of operators in terms of pure states may be extended to finite temperatures with the corresponding mixed states, and various relations between them are demonstrated. The question of the existence of the generalised P representation for an arbitrary operator is further examined and some pertinent theorems are proven. They also show how their results relate to the Glauber-Lachs formalism in quantum optics for mixtures of coherent and incoherent radiation. Particular attention is focused both on the interplay between the quantum mechanical and thermodynamical uncertainties and on the entropy associated with such mixed states.