Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review C

Three-body collapse for Tabakin potentials and the Thomas effect

A. Delfino, Sadhan K. Adhikari, Lauro Tomio D, T. Frederico

Published Aug 1, 1992• 13 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A system constituted of three bosons interacting via two-body separable potentials with fixed two-boson binding is known to lead to bound-state collapse in the case where the potential parameters allow two-boson S-matrix poles close to (resonance) and on (continuum bound state) the real momentum axis. The collapse is shown to be accompanied by an increase in the average kinetic energy of the two-body bound state, which signals a decrease in the range of the two-body interaction for fixed two-body binding. The collapse is claimed to be a manifestation of the well-known Thomas effect which leads to a collapse of the three-body system when the range of the two-body interaction goes to zero for a fixed two-body binding.

DOI
10.1103/physrevc.46.471

Related papers

Critical Stability of Few-body Systems

Vladimir A. Karmanov, Jaume Carbonell

When a two-body system is bound by a zero-range interaction, the corresponding three-body system -- considered in a non-relativistic framework -- collapses, that is its binding energy is unbounded from below. In a paper by J.V. Lindesay and H.P. Noyes it was shown that the relativistic effects result in an effective repulsion in such a way that three-body binding energy remains also finite, thus preventing the three-body system from collapse. Later, this property was confirmed in other works based on different versions of relativistic approaches. However, the three-body system exists only for a limited range of two-body binding energy values. For stronger two-body interaction, the relativistic three-body system still collapses. A similar phenomenon was found in a two-body systems themselves: a two-fermion system with one-boson exchange interaction in a state with zero angular momentum J=0 exists if the coupling constant does not exceed some critical value but it also collapses for larger coupling constant. For a J=1 state, it collapses for any coupling constant value. These properties are called "critical stability". This contribution aims to be a brief review of this field pioneered by H.P. Noyes.

arXiv:1312.7082•Series on knots and everything•Dec 17, 2013•0 citations

Binding of three identical bosons in two dimensions

Ludwig W. Bruch, John A. Tjon

Qualitative features are discussed for the binding of three identical bosons interacting through pair potentials in two dimensions. Two special cases, known to yield pathologies in three dimensions, are examined using the Faddeev equation for the bound states. The Thomas effect does not occur: in the model which is treated, the trimer binding energy is finite for a zero-range force with a finite dimer energy. The Efimov effect can only occur under more restrictive conditions than in three dimensions: the number of bound trimer states is finite at the dimer threshold for a range of potential models. The trimer ground-state energy is determined as a function of the coupling constant for a simple model, and variational results for loosely bound Lennard-Jones trimers are shown to reflect a general trend found for the model.

Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1979•100 citations

Three-Body Hamiltonian with Regularized Zero-Range Interactions in Dimension Three

Giulia Basti, Claudio Cacciapuoti, Domenico Finco +1 more

Abstract We study the Hamiltonian for a system of three identical bosons in dimension three interacting via zero-range forces. In order to avoid the fall to the center phenomenon emerging in the standard Ter-Martirosyan–Skornyakov (TMS) Hamiltonian, known as Thomas effect, we develop in detail a suggestion given in a seminal paper of Minlos and Faddeev in 1962 and we construct a regularized version of the TMS Hamiltonian which is self-adjoint and bounded from below. The regularization is given by an effective three-body force, acting only at short distance, that reduces to zero the strength of the interactions when the positions of the three particles coincide. The analysis is based on the construction of a suitable quadratic form which is shown to be closed and bounded from below. Then, domain and action of the corresponding Hamiltonian are completely characterized and a regularity result for the elements of the domain is given. Furthermore, we show that the Hamiltonian is the norm resolvent limit of Hamiltonians with rescaled non-local interactions, also called separable potentials, with a suitably renormalized coupling constant.

arXiv:2107.07188•Annales Henri Poincaré•Jul 10, 2022•16 citations

Subleading contributions to N -boson systems inside the universal window

Paolo Recchia, Alejandro Kievsky, Luca Girlanda +1 more

We study bosonic systems in the regime in which the two-body system has a shallow bound state or, equivalently, a large value of the two-body scattering length. Using the effective field theory framework as a guidance, we construct a series of potential terms which have a decreasing importance in the description of the binding energy of the systems. The leading-order potential terms consist in a two-body term, usually attractive, plus a three-body term, usually repulsive; this last term is required to prevent the collapse of systems with more than two particles. At this order, the parametrization of the two-body potential is done to obtain a correct description of the scattering length, which governs the dynamics in this regime, whereas the three-body term fixes a three-body datum. We investigate the role of the cutoff in the leading-order description, and we extend the exploration beyond the leading order by including the next-to-leading-order terms in both the two- and three-body potentials. We use the requirement of the stability of the $N$-body system, whose energy is variationally estimated, to introduce the three-body forces. The potential parametrization, as a function of the cutoff, is fixed to describe the energy of $^{4}\mathrm{He}$ clusters up to seven particles within the expected accuracy. Finally, we also explore the possibility to describe at the same time the atom-dimer scattering length.

arXiv:2206.06265•Physical Review A•Aug 23, 2022•7 citations

Many-particle systems V. Zero-range interactions

Richard L. Hall

Close upper and lowei bounds are found on the binding energy of a system of N identical bosons interacting in one dimension by an attractive square-well pair potential. In the limit in which the potential has the shape of a δ function the bounds are found to be consistent with McGuire's exact solution. In three dimensions the limit of vanishingly small range, in which the two-particle binding energy is kept constant, gives infinite binding to the N -particle system, in agreement with Thomas's theorem Consideration of other limiting Proc.esses eliminates an apparent contradiction between Thomas and Svartholm.

Proceedings of the Physical Society•Aug 1, 1967•15 citations

Three-body bound states of two bosons and one impurity in one dimension

Yanxia Liu, Yi-Cong Yu, Shu Chen

We investigate one-dimensional three-body systems composed of two identical bosons and one mass-imbalanced atom (impurity) with attractive two-body and three-body zero-range interactions. In the absence of three-body interaction, we give a complete phase diagram of the number of three-body bound states in the whole region of mass ratio and the ratio of intra- and intercomponent interaction strength via direct calculation of Skornyakov-Ter-Martirosyan equations. We demonstrate that other low-lying three-body bound states emerge when the mass of the impurity particle is different from other two identical particles. We obtain the binding energies together with the corresponding wave functions. When the mass of impurity atom is very large, there are at most three three-body bound states. In the presence of three-body zero-range interaction, we reveal that weak three-body interaction will not always induce one more three-body bound state. At some special parameter points, arbitrary small three-body interaction can generate one more three-body bound state. This corresponds to the transition of the number of three-body bound states induced only by two-body attractive interaction.

arXiv:2104.14111•Physical Review A•Sep 2, 2021•6 citations
A system constituted of three bosons interacting via two-body separable potentials with fixed two-boson binding is known to lead to bound-state collapse in the case where the potential parameters allow two-boson S-matrix poles close to (resonance) and on (continuum bound state) the real momentum axis. The collapse is shown to be accompanied by an increase in the average kinetic energy of the two-body bound state, which signals a decrease in the range of the two-body interaction for fixed two-body binding. The collapse is claimed to be a manifestation of the well-known Thomas effect which leads to a collapse of the three-body system when the range of the two-body interaction goes to zero for a fixed two-body binding.
When a two-body system is bound by a zero-range interaction, the corresponding three-body system -- considered in a non-relativistic framework -- collapses, that is its binding energy is unbounded from below. In a paper by J.V. Lindesay and H.P. Noyes it was shown that the relativistic effects result in an effective repulsion in such a way that three-body binding energy remains also finite, thus preventing the three-body system from collapse. Later, this property was confirmed in other works based on different versions of relativistic approaches. However, the three-body system exists only for a limited range of two-body binding energy values. For stronger two-body interaction, the relativistic three-body system still collapses. A similar phenomenon was found in a two-body systems themselves: a two-fermion system with one-boson exchange interaction in a state with zero angular momentum J=0 exists if the coupling constant does not exceed some critical value but it also collapses for larger coupling constant. For a J=1 state, it collapses for any coupling constant value. These properties are called "critical stability". This contribution aims to be a brief review of this field pioneered by H.P. Noyes.
Qualitative features are discussed for the binding of three identical bosons interacting through pair potentials in two dimensions. Two special cases, known to yield pathologies in three dimensions, are examined using the Faddeev equation for the bound states. The Thomas effect does not occur: in the model which is treated, the trimer binding energy is finite for a zero-range force with a finite dimer energy. The Efimov effect can only occur under more restrictive conditions than in three dimensions: the number of bound trimer states is finite at the dimer threshold for a range of potential models. The trimer ground-state energy is determined as a function of the coupling constant for a simple model, and variational results for loosely bound Lennard-Jones trimers are shown to reflect a general trend found for the model.
Abstract We study the Hamiltonian for a system of three identical bosons in dimension three interacting via zero-range forces. In order to avoid the fall to the center phenomenon emerging in the standard Ter-Martirosyan–Skornyakov (TMS) Hamiltonian, known as Thomas effect, we develop in detail a suggestion given in a seminal paper of Minlos and Faddeev in 1962 and we construct a regularized version of the TMS Hamiltonian which is self-adjoint and bounded from below. The regularization is given by an effective three-body force, acting only at short distance, that reduces to zero the strength of the interactions when the positions of the three particles coincide. The analysis is based on the construction of a suitable quadratic form which is shown to be closed and bounded from below. Then, domain and action of the corresponding Hamiltonian are completely characterized and a regularity result for the elements of the domain is given. Furthermore, we show that the Hamiltonian is the norm resolvent limit of Hamiltonians with rescaled non-local interactions, also called separable potentials, with a suitably renormalized coupling constant.
We study bosonic systems in the regime in which the two-body system has a shallow bound state or, equivalently, a large value of the two-body scattering length. Using the effective field theory framework as a guidance, we construct a series of potential terms which have a decreasing importance in the description of the binding energy of the systems. The leading-order potential terms consist in a two-body term, usually attractive, plus a three-body term, usually repulsive; this last term is required to prevent the collapse of systems with more than two particles. At this order, the parametrization of the two-body potential is done to obtain a correct description of the scattering length, which governs the dynamics in this regime, whereas the three-body term fixes a three-body datum. We investigate the role of the cutoff in the leading-order description, and we extend the exploration beyond the leading order by including the next-to-leading-order terms in both the two- and three-body potentials. We use the requirement of the stability of the NNN-body system, whose energy is variationally estimated, to introduce the three-body forces. The potential parametrization, as a function of the cutoff, is fixed to describe the energy of 4He^{4}\mathrm{He}4He clusters up to seven particles within the expected accuracy. Finally, we also explore the possibility to describe at the same time the atom-dimer scattering length.
Close upper and lowei bounds are found on the binding energy of a system of N identical bosons interacting in one dimension by an attractive square-well pair potential. In the limit in which the potential has the shape of a δ function the bounds are found to be consistent with McGuire's exact solution. In three dimensions the limit of vanishingly small range, in which the two-particle binding energy is kept constant, gives infinite binding to the N -particle system, in agreement with Thomas's theorem Consideration of other limiting Proc.esses eliminates an apparent contradiction between Thomas and Svartholm.
We investigate one-dimensional three-body systems composed of two identical bosons and one mass-imbalanced atom (impurity) with attractive two-body and three-body zero-range interactions. In the absence of three-body interaction, we give a complete phase diagram of the number of three-body bound states in the whole region of mass ratio and the ratio of intra- and intercomponent interaction strength via direct calculation of Skornyakov-Ter-Martirosyan equations. We demonstrate that other low-lying three-body bound states emerge when the mass of the impurity particle is different from other two identical particles. We obtain the binding energies together with the corresponding wave functions. When the mass of impurity atom is very large, there are at most three three-body bound states. In the presence of three-body zero-range interaction, we reveal that weak three-body interaction will not always induce one more three-body bound state. At some special parameter points, arbitrary small three-body interaction can generate one more three-body bound state. This corresponds to the transition of the number of three-body bound states induced only by two-body attractive interaction.