Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Some Relativistic Oddities in the Quantum Theory of Observation

Ingram Bloch

Published Apr 25, 1967• 63 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The orthodox quantum theory of observations is summarized and then applied to particle detection. Probabilities and state vectors are worked out for instantaneous observations, at stated times, by one counter, two counters, and three counters. The same cases are then examined in the context of a relativistic theory. It is found that, if attempts are made to detect a given particle in two space-time regions that have space-like separation, the nonrelativistic probability formulas have to be supplemented by additional conditions, and the wave function of the particle being detected becomes ambiguous and noncovariant. This ambiguity does not affect any probabilities for observations whose effect on the wave function has already been taken into account, and these are, by implication, the only observations whose probabilities could possibly be affected by the ambiguities in question. Possible consequences of these results are briefly discussed.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.156.1377

Related papers

The wave function and the distribution of the observables in relativistic quantum theory

V. F. Krotov

Here the probability density of relativistic particles coordinates, satisfying the formal conditions of the quantum mechanics and the special relativity, is determined (under textbooks view, such density does not exist). It is specified for the boson, neutral and charged, scalar and vector, including the photon, the electron. Uniqueness of this design has been proved. This is a relativistic invariant, describing the probability of the particle observation in points of space-time. The time is deprived of his role of a dynamic parameter of distribution and formally equalized with other coordinates. Also the meaning of the energy-momentum distribution is clarified. Conditions of such distributions observation are described. As applied to the quantum field these structures are transformed into new characteristics of particles distribution in space-time in addition to those for momentum states. Their operators for free fields are obtained. Under such model the Heisenberg's uncertainty relations are grounded for the relativistic particle; both particles and antiparticles turn out to be different states of a single particle; vacuum state of boson quantum field has zero energy.

arXiv:0903.2725•Mar 16, 2009•0 citations

Wave function of particle and the coordinates distribution in relativistic quantum theory

V. F. Krotov

The conditions for observation of the particle coordinates, required by logic of the Special Relativity and filtering the quantum field effects, are described. A general relation between the corresponding density of probability and the wave function is found. It is a relativistic invariant describing probability of the particle emergences in space -time. This density is concretized for bosons, both scalar and vector (including photon), charged and neutral, also electron. The Heisenberg's uncertainty relations have been approved in regards to relativistic particle. As applied to the quantum field, this new construction is transformed to new characteristic of the particles distribution in space-time, which complete distribution throughout impulses. The operators of these distributions and the invariant relativistic description for free quantum fields have been obtained. These new properties of the particles and fields are proposed for experimental investigations.

arXiv:0804.4374•Apr 28, 2008•0 citations

Presence of a particle in a given space-time region and the continuous action of a particle detector

Ingram Bloch, D. A. Burba

We attempt to answer several questions relating to the presence of a particle, with known initial state, in a given region of space during a given period of time. In the process, we try to extend the quantum theory of observation to the case in which the observation goes on continuously. Although this mode of observation is common in practice, the theory does not seem to describe it adequately. In general, questions like those that we are asking do not have simple, unambiguous answers in quantum theory. In order to approach such a question, we usually have to assume that the particle interacts with something in the space-time region of interest, and then to infer the probability of the particle's presence from the probability of its interacting with the other object. This fact suggests either that we are asking the wrong questions or that perhaps quantum mechanics should be regarded as a theory of interaction events rather than a theory of systems.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Nov 15, 1974•14 citations

Quantum Mechanical Probabilities on a General Spacetime-Surface

Norifumi Yamada, Shin Takagi

A theoretical aspect of quantum mechanical probabilities is studied. In nonrelativistic quantum mechanics (NRQM) for a particle, Schrödinger's wave function assigns probabilities to possible places where the particle is found on a surface (hypersurface in Newtonian spacetime) of constant time. We may then ask if quantum mechanical probabilities can be defined for an exhaustive set of exclusive outcomes of observations made on a surface on which Newtonian time is not constant. Such a question may be said to belong to the study of the role of time in NRQM in a broad sense. Specifically we investigate the theoretical possibility of a probabilistic description of (I) where and how many times the particle intersects the surface, and of (II) where and how many times the particle is found on the surface. For each case we formulate two conditions for the success of a probabilistic description. They are the classifiability condition and the no-interference condition, both of which are conditions on the propagator of the particle. For each case it is proved that the former condition does not hold and that consequently a probabilistic description is theoretically impossible either for (I) or for (II).

Progress of Theoretical Physics•May 1, 1991•69 citations

Wavefunctions and Minkowski Space-Time: On the Reconciliation of Quantum Theory with Special Relativity

Beck, Christian

The implications of the relativistic space-time structure for a physical description by quantum mechanical wave-functions are investigated. On the basis of a detailed analysis of Bell's concept of local causality, which is violated in quantum theory, we argue that this is a subtle, as well as an important effort. A central requirement appearing in relativistic quantum mechanics, namely local commutativity, is analyzed in detail and possible justifications are given and discussed. The complexity of the implications of wave function reduction in connection with Minkowski space-time are illustrated by a quantum mechanical measurement procedure which was proposed by Aharonov and Albert. This procedure and its relativistic implications are explicitly analyzed and discussed in terms of state evolution. This analysis shows that the usual notion of state evolution fails in relativistic quantum theory. Two possible solutions of this problem are given. In particular, it is shown that also a theory with a distinguished foliation of space-time into space-like leafs - accounting for nonlocality - makes the right predictions for the Aharonov-Albert experiment. We will repeatedly encounter that an analysis of the wave-function alone does not suffice to answer the question of relativistic compatibility of the theory, but that the actual events in space time, which are predicted and described by the theory, are crucial. Relativistic versions of quantum mechanical theories which precisely describe actual processes in space-time are briefly described and discussed in the appendix.

arXiv:2009.00440•Aug 29, 2020•1 citation

Stochastic Theory of Relativistic Quantum Mechanics

M. Godart

The stochastic theory of relativistic quantum mechanics presented here is modelled on the one that has been proposed previously and that was claimed to be a promising substitute to the orthodox theory in the non-relativistic domain. So it also relies heavily upon the theory of stochastic processes, with its definitions, theorems and specific vocabulary as well. Its main hypothesis states indeed that the classical trajectories of the particles are identical to the sample functions of a diffusion Markov process, whose conditional probability density is proposed as a substitute for the wave function. Along the way, we introduce ad hoc hypotheses for the sole reason that they facilitate and even make possible the further development of the theory. These and the so-called Nelson equations are used to determine the drift vectors and the diffusion tensor characteristic of such a process. It is then possible to write down the Fokker-Planck and Kolmogorov equations that can be used to determine the normal and conditional probability densities. This logical sequence of steps leads to the solution of specific problems and we apply it to the special case of the free particle.

arXiv:1412.1508•Dec 3, 2014•0 citations
The orthodox quantum theory of observations is summarized and then applied to particle detection. Probabilities and state vectors are worked out for instantaneous observations, at stated times, by one counter, two counters, and three counters. The same cases are then examined in the context of a relativistic theory. It is found that, if attempts are made to detect a given particle in two space-time regions that have space-like separation, the nonrelativistic probability formulas have to be supplemented by additional conditions, and the wave function of the particle being detected becomes ambiguous and noncovariant. This ambiguity does not affect any probabilities for observations whose effect on the wave function has already been taken into account, and these are, by implication, the only observations whose probabilities could possibly be affected by the ambiguities in question. Possible consequences of these results are briefly discussed.
Here the probability density of relativistic particles coordinates, satisfying the formal conditions of the quantum mechanics and the special relativity, is determined (under textbooks view, such density does not exist). It is specified for the boson, neutral and charged, scalar and vector, including the photon, the electron. Uniqueness of this design has been proved. This is a relativistic invariant, describing the probability of the particle observation in points of space-time. The time is deprived of his role of a dynamic parameter of distribution and formally equalized with other coordinates. Also the meaning of the energy-momentum distribution is clarified. Conditions of such distributions observation are described. As applied to the quantum field these structures are transformed into new characteristics of particles distribution in space-time in addition to those for momentum states. Their operators for free fields are obtained. Under such model the Heisenberg's uncertainty relations are grounded for the relativistic particle; both particles and antiparticles turn out to be different states of a single particle; vacuum state of boson quantum field has zero energy.
The conditions for observation of the particle coordinates, required by logic of the Special Relativity and filtering the quantum field effects, are described. A general relation between the corresponding density of probability and the wave function is found. It is a relativistic invariant describing probability of the particle emergences in space -time. This density is concretized for bosons, both scalar and vector (including photon), charged and neutral, also electron. The Heisenberg's uncertainty relations have been approved in regards to relativistic particle. As applied to the quantum field, this new construction is transformed to new characteristic of the particles distribution in space-time, which complete distribution throughout impulses. The operators of these distributions and the invariant relativistic description for free quantum fields have been obtained. These new properties of the particles and fields are proposed for experimental investigations.
We attempt to answer several questions relating to the presence of a particle, with known initial state, in a given region of space during a given period of time. In the process, we try to extend the quantum theory of observation to the case in which the observation goes on continuously. Although this mode of observation is common in practice, the theory does not seem to describe it adequately. In general, questions like those that we are asking do not have simple, unambiguous answers in quantum theory. In order to approach such a question, we usually have to assume that the particle interacts with something in the space-time region of interest, and then to infer the probability of the particle's presence from the probability of its interacting with the other object. This fact suggests either that we are asking the wrong questions or that perhaps quantum mechanics should be regarded as a theory of interaction events rather than a theory of systems.
A theoretical aspect of quantum mechanical probabilities is studied. In nonrelativistic quantum mechanics (NRQM) for a particle, Schrödinger's wave function assigns probabilities to possible places where the particle is found on a surface (hypersurface in Newtonian spacetime) of constant time. We may then ask if quantum mechanical probabilities can be defined for an exhaustive set of exclusive outcomes of observations made on a surface on which Newtonian time is not constant. Such a question may be said to belong to the study of the role of time in NRQM in a broad sense. Specifically we investigate the theoretical possibility of a probabilistic description of (I) where and how many times the particle intersects the surface, and of (II) where and how many times the particle is found on the surface. For each case we formulate two conditions for the success of a probabilistic description. They are the classifiability condition and the no-interference condition, both of which are conditions on the propagator of the particle. For each case it is proved that the former condition does not hold and that consequently a probabilistic description is theoretically impossible either for (I) or for (II).
The implications of the relativistic space-time structure for a physical description by quantum mechanical wave-functions are investigated. On the basis of a detailed analysis of Bell's concept of local causality, which is violated in quantum theory, we argue that this is a subtle, as well as an important effort. A central requirement appearing in relativistic quantum mechanics, namely local commutativity, is analyzed in detail and possible justifications are given and discussed. The complexity of the implications of wave function reduction in connection with Minkowski space-time are illustrated by a quantum mechanical measurement procedure which was proposed by Aharonov and Albert. This procedure and its relativistic implications are explicitly analyzed and discussed in terms of state evolution. This analysis shows that the usual notion of state evolution fails in relativistic quantum theory. Two possible solutions of this problem are given. In particular, it is shown that also a theory with a distinguished foliation of space-time into space-like leafs - accounting for nonlocality - makes the right predictions for the Aharonov-Albert experiment. We will repeatedly encounter that an analysis of the wave-function alone does not suffice to answer the question of relativistic compatibility of the theory, but that the actual events in space time, which are predicted and described by the theory, are crucial. Relativistic versions of quantum mechanical theories which precisely describe actual processes in space-time are briefly described and discussed in the appendix.
The stochastic theory of relativistic quantum mechanics presented here is modelled on the one that has been proposed previously and that was claimed to be a promising substitute to the orthodox theory in the non-relativistic domain. So it also relies heavily upon the theory of stochastic processes, with its definitions, theorems and specific vocabulary as well. Its main hypothesis states indeed that the classical trajectories of the particles are identical to the sample functions of a diffusion Markov process, whose conditional probability density is proposed as a substitute for the wave function. Along the way, we introduce ad hoc hypotheses for the sole reason that they facilitate and even make possible the further development of the theory. These and the so-called Nelson equations are used to determine the drift vectors and the diffusion tensor characteristic of such a process. It is then possible to write down the Fokker-Planck and Kolmogorov equations that can be used to determine the normal and conditional probability densities. This logical sequence of steps leads to the solution of specific problems and we apply it to the special case of the free particle.