How realistic is it to adopt a quantum random walk model to account for decisions involving two choices? Here, we discuss the neural plausibility and the effect of initial state and boundary thresholds on such a model and contrast it with various features of the classical random walk model of decision making.
Markov processes, such as random walk models, have been successfully used by cognitive and neural scientists to model human choice behavior and decision time for over 50 years. Recently, quantum walk models have been introduced as an alternative way to model the dynamics of human choice and confidence across time. Empirical evidence points to the need for both types of processes, and open system models provide a way to incorporate them both into a single process. However, some of the constraints required by open system models present challenges for achieving this goal. The purpose of this article is to address these challenges and formulate open system models that have good potential to make important advancements in cognitive science.
Recent findings of Markov violations challenge Markov random walk processes for decision making. On the other hand, quantum walk processes explain these Markov violations in a natural way, but they have only been applied to binary alternative decision making. In this work, we propose a general framework for extending quantum walk processes to multi-alternative decision making. The multi-alternative quantum walk model operates in a direct sum space of the alternatives, with Hamiltonian built for each pair of alternatives to model context effects. Order effects come naturally from the matrix non-commutativity of the Hamiltonians. Future works built on this framework can connect parameters of the models with the expected utilities.
In the world of computational probing, random walks and quantum walks are two separate but tightly linked paradigms. Classical stochastic processes like random walks are based on the random movement of particles in mathematical space and have been extensively used in data mining, network analysis, computer vision, etc. Quantum walks, by contrast generalize random walks into the quantum realm, taking the benefit of the quantum superposition and interference in order to investigate multiple paths at the same time. Quantum walks provide significant potential for algorithmic development: in quantum computing and communication, and in Scientific modelling and simulation. This paper provides an in-depth survey of random walks and quantum walks, outlining historical context, fundamental principles, applications, challenges, and future prospects. In this paper, motivated by the abstractness of both random walks and quantum walks, we survey the field of computational exploration at large scales, coalescing the myriad notions and difficult challenges addressed by existing research efforts on random and quantum walks, inferring a nuanced and multifaceted view on how both random walks and quantum walks are involved in paving the way to future development in many fields.
Humans do not always make the most rational decisions. As studies have shown, even when logic and reasoning point in one direction, sometimes humans “walk” to the opposite route, motivated by personal bias or simply wishful thinking. This paradoxical human behavior has resisted explanation by classical decision theory for over a decade. Scientists have shown that a quantum probability model can provide a simple explanation for human decision-making. In military, decision-making process is considered to be the most neuralgic one. With the recent interest in quantum computing and quantum information theory, there has been an effort to recast classical game theory using quantum probability amplitudes, and hence study the effect of quantum superposition, interference and entanglement on the agents’ optimal strategies. Apart from unsolved problems in quantum information theory, quantum game theory and decision –making, may be useful in studying quantum communication since that can be considered as a game where the objective is to maximize effective communication. This paper discusses the idea of using quantum theory to decision making. 1 HellemicArmy 14, Kanigos Str., Piraeus 18534, Greece.
We define and analyze quantum computational variants of \nrandom walks on one-dimensional lattices. In particular, we analyze a quantum analog of the symmetric random \nwalk, which we call the Hadamard walk. Several striking \ndifferences between the quantum and classical cases are ob- served. For example, when unrestricted in either direction, \nthe Hadamard walk has position that is nearly uniformly \ndistributed in the range [-t/√2, t/√2] after t steps, which \nis in sharp contrast to the classical random walk, which has \ndistance O(√t) from the origin with high probability. With \nan absorbing boundary immediately to the left of the starting position, the probability that the walk exits to the left is 2/π, and with an additional absorbing boundary at location n, the probability that the walk exits to the left actually increases, approaching 1/√2 in the limit. In the classical case both values are 1.
We present a short review of discrete-time quantum walks (DTQW) as a potentially useful and rich formalism to model human decision-making. We present a pedagogical introduction of the underlying formalism and main structural properties. We suggest that DTQW are particularly suitable for combining the two strands of literature on evidence accumulator models and on the quantum formalism of cognition. Due to the additional spin degree of freedom, models based on DTQW allow for a natural modeling of model choice and confidence rating in separate bases. Levels of introspection and self-assessment during choice deliberations can be modeled by the introduction of a probability for measurement of either position and/or spin of the DTQW, where each measurement act leads to a partial decoherence (corresponding to a step towards rationalization) of the deliberation process. We show how quantum walks predict observed probabilistic misperception like S-shaped subjective probability and conjunction fallacy. Our framework emphasizes the close relationship between response times and type of preferences and of responses. In particular, decision theories based on DTQW do not need to invoke two systems ("fast" and "slow") as in dual process theories. Within our DTQW framework, the two fast and slow systems are replaced by a single system, but with two types of self-assessment or introspection. The "thinking fast" regime is obtained with no or little self-assessment, while the "thinking slow" regime corresponds to a strong rate of self-assessment. We predict a trade-off between speed and accuracy, as empirically reported.