Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Philosophical Magazine B

A Luttinger's theorem revisited

Behnam Farid

Published Aug 1, 1999• 12 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For uniform systems of spinless fermions in d spatial dimensions with d > 1, interacting through the isotropic two-body potential ν(r -r′), a celebrated theorem due to Luttinger (1961) states that under the assumption of validity of the many-body perturbation theory the self-energy ∑(k;ϵ), with 0 ⩽ k ≲ 3k F (where k F stands for the Fermi wavenumber), satisfies the following universal asymptotic relation as ε approaches the Fermi energy εF: Im [∑(k; ϵ)]∼ ∓ α k (ϵ - ϵF) 2, ϵ ≶ ϵF, with α k ⩾ 0. As this is, by definition, specific to self-energies of the Landau Fermi-liquid systems, treatment of non-Fermi-liquid systems are therefore thought to lie outside the domain of applicability of the many-body perturbation theory; that, for these systems, the many-body perturbation theory? should necessarily break down. We demonstrate that Im [∑(k; ϵ)]∼ ∓ α k (ϵ - ϵF) 2, ϵ ≶ ϵF, is implicit in Luttinger's proof and that, for d > 1, in principle nothing prohibits a non-Fermi-liquid-type (and, in particular a Luttinger-liquid-type) ∑(k; ϵ) from being obtained within the framework of the many-body perturbation theory. We in addition indicate how seemingly innocuous Taylor expansions of the self-energy with respect to k. ϵ or both amount to tacitly assuming that the metallic system under consideration is a Fermi liquid, whether the self-energy is calculated perturbatively or otherwise. Proofs that a certain metallic system is in a Fermiliquid state, based on such expansions, are therefore tautologies.

DOI
10.1080/13642819908218309

Related papers

A Luttinger's theorem revisited

Behnam Farid

For uniform systems of spin-less fermions in d spatial dimensions with d > 1, interacting through the isotropic two-body potential v(r-r'), a celebrated theorem due to Luttinger (1961) states that under the_assumption_ of validity of the many-body perturbation theory the self-energy Sigma(k;epsilon), with 0 ,< epsilon_F, with alpha_k >,= 0. As this is, by definition, specific to self-energies of Landau Fermi-liquid systems, treatment of non-Fermi-liquid systems are therefore thought to lie outside the domain of applicability of the many-body perturbation theory; that, for these systems, the many-body perturbation theory should_necessarily_ break down. We demonstrate that Im[Sigma(k;epsilon)] ~ -,+ alpha_k (epsilon-epsilon_F)^2, epsilon >,< epsilon_F, is_implicit_ in Luttinger's proof and that, for d > 1, in principle nothing prohibits a non-Fermi-liquid-type (and, in particular Luttinger-liquid-type) Sigma(k;epsilon) from being obtained within the framework of the many-body perturbation theory. We in addition indicate how seemingly innocuous Taylor expansions of the self-energy with respect to k, epsilon or both amount to tacitly assuming that the metallic system under consideration is a Fermi liquid, whether the self-energy is calculated perturbatively or otherwise. Proofs that a certain metallic system is in a Fermi-liquid state, based on such expansions, are therefore tautologies.

arXiv:cond-mat/0004476•Apr 27, 2000•0 citations

Luttinger liquid: spinons and holons

In three dimensions (3D), Landau theory of Fermi liquids applies to a wide class of many-body fermion assemblies, and enables one to describe these as a system of non-interacting quasiparticles, but with physical properties such as mass renormalized because of interparticle interaction, in the limit of low-energy excitations ( i.e . energy close to the Fermi level) and low temperature. In lower dimensions, the paradigm of Landau-Fermi liquids may break down and, in one dimension (1D), the so-called Luttinger liquid may prevail (Haldane, 1981). Below, we closely follow Carmelo and Ovchinnikov (1991, CO, below), who deal in particular with the 1D Hubbard model.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•May 30, 2016•0 citations

On the Luttinger theorem concerning number of particles in the ground states of systems of interacting fermions

Behnam Farid

We analyze the original proof by Luttinger and Ward of the Luttinger theorem, according to which for uniform ground states of systems of (interacting) fermions, which may be metallic or insulating, the number of k points corresponding to non-negative values of G_s(k;mu) is equal to the total number of particles with spin index s in these ground states. Here G_s(k;mu) is the single-particle Green function of particles with spin index s at the chemical potential mu. For the cases where the two-body interaction potential is short-range, and in particular for lattice models, we explicitly demonstrate that this theorem is unconditionally valid, irrespective of the strength of the bare interaction potential. We arrive at this conclusion by amongst other things demonstrating that the perturbation series expansion for self-energy in terms of skeleton diagrams, as encountered in the proof of the Luttinger-Ward identity, is uniformly convergent for almost all momenta and energies. We further investigate the mechanisms underlying some reported instances of failure of the Luttinger theorem. With one exception, for all the cases considered in this paper, we show that the apparent failures of the Luttinger theorem can be attributed either to shortcomings of the employed single-particle Green functions or to misapplication of this theorem. The one exceptional case brings to light the possibility of a genuine failure of the Luttinger theorem for insulating ground states, which we show to be brought about by a false limit that in principle can be reached on taking the zero-temperature limit without the value of mu coinciding with the zero-temperature limit of the chemical potential satisfying the equation of state at finite temperatures; no such ambiguity can arise for metallic states.

arXiv:0711.0952•Nov 6, 2007•14 citations

Derivation of the Luttinger theorem

Richard M. Martin, Lucia Reining, David M. Ceperley

This appendix summarizes the arguments of the papers by Luttinger and Ward to derive the Luttinger theorem that is stated in Sec. 3.6. This is not a proof that the theorem applies to all possible states of a crystal; it is the derivation of arguments that it applies to all states that can be analytically continued from some non-interacting system, i.e., a “normal state of matter” as defined in Sec. 3.4. The derivation is an example of the use of the T ≠ 0 Green's functions in App. D and the conclusions for T = 0. The Luttinger theorem is a cornerstone in the theory of condensed matter. As described qualitatively in Sec. 3.6, it requires that the volume enclosed by the Fermi surface is conserved independent of interactions, i.e., it is the same as for a system of non-interacting particles. Similarly, the Friedel sum rule is the requirement that the sum of phase shifts around an impurity is determined by charge neutrality, which was derived by Friedel [163] for non-interacting electrons. This section is devoted to a short summary of the original work of Luttinger and Ward and the extension of the arguments to the Freidel sum rule [166]. Here we explicitly indicate the chemical potential μ , since the variation from μ is essential to the arguments. There are two key points: in the interacting system the wavevector in the Brillouin zone k is conserved so that excitations can be labeled k , and the self-energy ∑ k ( ω ) is purely real at the Fermi energy ω = μ at temperature T = 0. The latter point is an essential feature of a Fermi liquid or a “normal metal,” which is justified by the argument that the phase space for scattering at T = 0 vanishes as ω → μ (see Sec. 7.5). Thus, at the Fermi energy the Green's function as a function of k is the same as for an independent-particle problem with eigenvalues. (Of course, for an interacting system at any other energy cannot be described by independent particles.) In an independent-particle system at T = 0 the occupation numbers jump from 1 to 0 as a function of k at the Fermi surface, and in the interacting system there is still a discontinuity in n k that defines the surface (Sec. 7.5).

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 31, 2016•1 citation

A pole in the self-energy does not always imply a violation of the Luttinger theorem

Ar. Abanov, Andrey V. Chubukov

Luttinger theorem relates Fermi surface volume to electron density per spin $n$. It holds in an arbitrary Fermi liquid but is widely believed to break when a fermionic self-energy has a pole. We show that this is not necessarily the case. As an example, we consider a fermionic system consisting of two gapped bands, originating from a self-energy $Σ(ω, \mathbf{k})$ with a pole, and a narrow residual quasiparticle band crossing $ω=0$, with a small residue $Z \ll 1$ (a residual Fermi liquid). We consider Model I, in which $Z$ also renormalizes quasiparticle bandwidth $W$ to $ZW$ and Model II, in which $W$ remains unrenormalized. The Green's function for such a system $G(ω, \mathbf{k})$ contains two zeros and three poles --- one from the quasiparticle band and two from the gapped bands. Yet, we show that in Model I, the Luttinger-Ward analysis is fully applicable for any $Z >0$, and the results are exactly the same as if the gapped bands did not exist. For Model II, the Luttinger-Ward analysis recovers once $Z$ exceeds some critical value, which depends on fermionic density.

arXiv:2610.04663•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Nov 10, 2026•0 citations

One-dimensional Fermi liquids

Johannes Voit

We review the progress in the theory of one-dimensional (ID) Fermi liquids which has occurred over the past decade. The usual Fermi liquid theory, based on a quasi-particle picture, breaks down in one dimension because of the Peierls divergence in the particle-hole bubble, producing anomalous dimensions of operators, and because of charge-spin separation. Both are related to the importance of scattering processes transferring finite momentum. A description of the low-energy properties of gapless 1D quantum systems can be based on the exactly solvable Luttinger model which incorporates these features, and whose correlation functions can be calculated. Special properties of the eigenvalue spectrum, parameterized by one renormalized velocity and one effective coupling constant per degree of freedom, fully describe the physics of this model. Other gapless 1D models share these properties in a low-energy subspace. The concept of a "Luttinger liquid" implies that their low-energy properties are described by an effective Luttinger model, and constitutes the universality class of these quantum systems. Once the mapping on the Luttinger model is achieved, one has an asymptotically exact solution of the 1D many-body problem. Lattice models identified as Luttinger liquids include the 1D Hubbard model off half-filling, and variants such as the t-J- or the extended Hubbard model. In addition, 1D electron-phonon systems or metals with impurities can be Luttinger liquids, as well as the edge states in the quantum Hall effect.

arXiv:cond-mat/9510014•Reports on Progress in Physics•Sep 1, 1995•1,304 citations
For uniform systems of spinless fermions in d spatial dimensions with d > 1, interacting through the isotropic two-body potential ν(r -r′), a celebrated theorem due to Luttinger (1961) states that under the assumption of validity of the many-body perturbation theory the self-energy ∑(k;ϵ), with 0 ⩽ k ≲ 3k F (where k F stands for the Fermi wavenumber), satisfies the following universal asymptotic relation as ε approaches the Fermi energy εF: Im [∑(k; ϵ)]∼ ∓ α k (ϵ - ϵF) 2, ϵ ≶ ϵF, with α k ⩾ 0. As this is, by definition, specific to self-energies of the Landau Fermi-liquid systems, treatment of non-Fermi-liquid systems are therefore thought to lie outside the domain of applicability of the many-body perturbation theory; that, for these systems, the many-body perturbation theory? should necessarily break down. We demonstrate that Im [∑(k; ϵ)]∼ ∓ α k (ϵ - ϵF) 2, ϵ ≶ ϵF, is implicit in Luttinger's proof and that, for d > 1, in principle nothing prohibits a non-Fermi-liquid-type (and, in particular a Luttinger-liquid-type) ∑(k; ϵ) from being obtained within the framework of the many-body perturbation theory. We in addition indicate how seemingly innocuous Taylor expansions of the self-energy with respect to k. ϵ or both amount to tacitly assuming that the metallic system under consideration is a Fermi liquid, whether the self-energy is calculated perturbatively or otherwise. Proofs that a certain metallic system is in a Fermiliquid state, based on such expansions, are therefore tautologies.
For uniform systems of spin-less fermions in d spatial dimensions with d > 1, interacting through the isotropic two-body potential v(r-r'), a celebrated theorem due to Luttinger (1961) states that under the_assumption_ of validity of the many-body perturbation theory the self-energy Sigma(k;epsilon), with 0 ,< epsilon_F, with alpha_k >,= 0. As this is, by definition, specific to self-energies of Landau Fermi-liquid systems, treatment of non-Fermi-liquid systems are therefore thought to lie outside the domain of applicability of the many-body perturbation theory; that, for these systems, the many-body perturbation theory should_necessarily_ break down. We demonstrate that Im[Sigma(k;epsilon)] ~ -,+ alpha_k (epsilon-epsilon_F)^2, epsilon >,< epsilon_F, is_implicit_ in Luttinger's proof and that, for d > 1, in principle nothing prohibits a non-Fermi-liquid-type (and, in particular Luttinger-liquid-type) Sigma(k;epsilon) from being obtained within the framework of the many-body perturbation theory. We in addition indicate how seemingly innocuous Taylor expansions of the self-energy with respect to k, epsilon or both amount to tacitly assuming that the metallic system under consideration is a Fermi liquid, whether the self-energy is calculated perturbatively or otherwise. Proofs that a certain metallic system is in a Fermi-liquid state, based on such expansions, are therefore tautologies.
In three dimensions (3D), Landau theory of Fermi liquids applies to a wide class of many-body fermion assemblies, and enables one to describe these as a system of non-interacting quasiparticles, but with physical properties such as mass renormalized because of interparticle interaction, in the limit of low-energy excitations ( i.e . energy close to the Fermi level) and low temperature. In lower dimensions, the paradigm of Landau-Fermi liquids may break down and, in one dimension (1D), the so-called Luttinger liquid may prevail (Haldane, 1981). Below, we closely follow Carmelo and Ovchinnikov (1991, CO, below), who deal in particular with the 1D Hubbard model.
We analyze the original proof by Luttinger and Ward of the Luttinger theorem, according to which for uniform ground states of systems of (interacting) fermions, which may be metallic or insulating, the number of k points corresponding to non-negative values of G_s(k;mu) is equal to the total number of particles with spin index s in these ground states. Here G_s(k;mu) is the single-particle Green function of particles with spin index s at the chemical potential mu. For the cases where the two-body interaction potential is short-range, and in particular for lattice models, we explicitly demonstrate that this theorem is unconditionally valid, irrespective of the strength of the bare interaction potential. We arrive at this conclusion by amongst other things demonstrating that the perturbation series expansion for self-energy in terms of skeleton diagrams, as encountered in the proof of the Luttinger-Ward identity, is uniformly convergent for almost all momenta and energies. We further investigate the mechanisms underlying some reported instances of failure of the Luttinger theorem. With one exception, for all the cases considered in this paper, we show that the apparent failures of the Luttinger theorem can be attributed either to shortcomings of the employed single-particle Green functions or to misapplication of this theorem. The one exceptional case brings to light the possibility of a genuine failure of the Luttinger theorem for insulating ground states, which we show to be brought about by a false limit that in principle can be reached on taking the zero-temperature limit without the value of mu coinciding with the zero-temperature limit of the chemical potential satisfying the equation of state at finite temperatures; no such ambiguity can arise for metallic states.
This appendix summarizes the arguments of the papers by Luttinger and Ward to derive the Luttinger theorem that is stated in Sec. 3.6. This is not a proof that the theorem applies to all possible states of a crystal; it is the derivation of arguments that it applies to all states that can be analytically continued from some non-interacting system, i.e., a “normal state of matter” as defined in Sec. 3.4. The derivation is an example of the use of the T ≠ 0 Green's functions in App. D and the conclusions for T = 0. The Luttinger theorem is a cornerstone in the theory of condensed matter. As described qualitatively in Sec. 3.6, it requires that the volume enclosed by the Fermi surface is conserved independent of interactions, i.e., it is the same as for a system of non-interacting particles. Similarly, the Friedel sum rule is the requirement that the sum of phase shifts around an impurity is determined by charge neutrality, which was derived by Friedel [163] for non-interacting electrons. This section is devoted to a short summary of the original work of Luttinger and Ward and the extension of the arguments to the Freidel sum rule [166]. Here we explicitly indicate the chemical potential μ , since the variation from μ is essential to the arguments. There are two key points: in the interacting system the wavevector in the Brillouin zone k is conserved so that excitations can be labeled k , and the self-energy ∑ k ( ω ) is purely real at the Fermi energy ω = μ at temperature T = 0. The latter point is an essential feature of a Fermi liquid or a “normal metal,” which is justified by the argument that the phase space for scattering at T = 0 vanishes as ω → μ (see Sec. 7.5). Thus, at the Fermi energy the Green's function as a function of k is the same as for an independent-particle problem with eigenvalues. (Of course, for an interacting system at any other energy cannot be described by independent particles.) In an independent-particle system at T = 0 the occupation numbers jump from 1 to 0 as a function of k at the Fermi surface, and in the interacting system there is still a discontinuity in n k that defines the surface (Sec. 7.5).
Luttinger theorem relates Fermi surface volume to electron density per spin nnn. It holds in an arbitrary Fermi liquid but is widely believed to break when a fermionic self-energy has a pole. We show that this is not necessarily the case. As an example, we consider a fermionic system consisting of two gapped bands, originating from a self-energy Σ(ω,k)Σ(ω, \mathbf{k})Σ(ω,k) with a pole, and a narrow residual quasiparticle band crossing ω=0ω=0ω=0, with a small residue Z≪1Z \ll 1Z≪1 (a residual Fermi liquid). We consider Model I, in which ZZZ also renormalizes quasiparticle bandwidth WWW to ZWZWZW and Model II, in which WWW remains unrenormalized. The Green's function for such a system G(ω,k)G(ω, \mathbf{k})G(ω,k) contains two zeros and three poles --- one from the quasiparticle band and two from the gapped bands. Yet, we show that in Model I, the Luttinger-Ward analysis is fully applicable for any Z>0Z >0Z>0, and the results are exactly the same as if the gapped bands did not exist. For Model II, the Luttinger-Ward analysis recovers once ZZZ exceeds some critical value, which depends on fermionic density.
We review the progress in the theory of one-dimensional (ID) Fermi liquids which has occurred over the past decade. The usual Fermi liquid theory, based on a quasi-particle picture, breaks down in one dimension because of the Peierls divergence in the particle-hole bubble, producing anomalous dimensions of operators, and because of charge-spin separation. Both are related to the importance of scattering processes transferring finite momentum. A description of the low-energy properties of gapless 1D quantum systems can be based on the exactly solvable Luttinger model which incorporates these features, and whose correlation functions can be calculated. Special properties of the eigenvalue spectrum, parameterized by one renormalized velocity and one effective coupling constant per degree of freedom, fully describe the physics of this model. Other gapless 1D models share these properties in a low-energy subspace. The concept of a "Luttinger liquid" implies that their low-energy properties are described by an effective Luttinger model, and constitutes the universality class of these quantum systems. Once the mapping on the Luttinger model is achieved, one has an asymptotically exact solution of the 1D many-body problem. Lattice models identified as Luttinger liquids include the 1D Hubbard model off half-filling, and variants such as the t-J- or the extended Hubbard model. In addition, 1D electron-phonon systems or metals with impurities can be Luttinger liquids, as well as the edge states in the quantum Hall effect.