Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Education

Uncertainty and complementarity: the heart of quantum physics

Gesche Pospiech

Published Nov 1, 2000• 56 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The discussion of particle-wave dualism still plays an important part in teaching quantum theroy. This surely is for historical reasons, since it was important in grasping the concept of uncertainty. Recent EPR-like experiments, however, indicate new ways of teaching the notions of uncertainty and complementarity. These allow us to achieve a clear understanding without difficult mathematical obstacles and promote also a well-founded discussion of philosophical aspects. The core of the considerations presented here are systems consisting of two-state objects, for example the spin states of photons or electrons.

DOI
10.1088/0031-9120/35/6/303

Related papers

Complementarity and the analog/digital distinction

Michael Friedrich Otte, Luiz Gonzaga Xavier de Barros

Niels Bohr, as is well known, introduced the notion of complementarity into physics, as a fundamental principle of quantum mechanics. It holds that objects have complementary properties that cannot be measured accurately at the same time. For example, the particle and wave aspects of physical objects are such complementary phenomena. Both concepts are borrowed from classical mechanics, where it is impossible to be both, a particle and a wave at the same time. Particle and Wave represent the complementarity of the Discrete and the Continuous. Humans reason by means of concepts (meanings) and language, as well as, by means of logical or arithmetic symbolism. Meanings are continua, whereas logic and arithmetic are based on relations of identity and difference.

•Jul 6, 2015•0 citations

The nature of particle–wave complementarity

Wendell G. Holladay

To resolve the challenges (paradoxes) attending the genesis of quantum theory, Niels Bohr in 1927 proposed a generalization of the conceptual framework of classical physics, termed complementarity, which posited pairs of classical concepts that could be manifested only in mutually exclusive experimental arrangements with both needed to embrace the full range of physical experience. In this context particle–wave complementarity has encountered two major obstacles; (1) No formulation of it has commanded a general consensus; and (2) empirical evidence abounds that contradicts the claim of mutual exclusivity of particle and wave properties of quantum objects in a single experiment. These problems are rooted in the unrestricted scope of this claim. It is shown that a restricted version of particle–wave complementarity, here called “which value–interference” complementarity, is consistent with observations, is naturally contained in the mathematical formalism of quantum theory and, in fact, holds in any representation of quantum theory defined by the eigenvectors of a complete set of commuting observables, such as the configuration space position (kinematic) variables or the complementary linear momentum (dynamic) variables. Thus, the which value–interference form of particle–wave complementarity exists within kinematic–dynamic complementarity, a “layered” complementarity, so to speak. It is hoped that a consistent and valid exposition of particle–wave complementarity will be helpful to those who find the framework of complementarity useful and appropriate for some purpose.

American Journal of Physics•Jan 1, 1998•19 citations

The Principle of Complementarity

T. Bergstein

The wave-particle duality of photons and electrons was thoroughly discussed at a conference held at the Solvay Institute in October 1927, where Albert Einstein and Niels Bohr were the most prominent participants. From the beginning Einstein manifested great hesitation in accepting the renunciation of causal description of physical phenomena introduced by quantum theory. He clearly demonstrated his basic attitude by discussing the example of an atomic object (electron or photon) impinging upon a screen with a single slit (see figure 4). To the left of the screen the object is supposed to have a precisely defined momentum p and hence it is represented as a plane, harmonic wave. When passing through the slit, the plane wave is scattered into a cylindrical wave with an opening angle determined by the wavelength and the slit aperture. Einstein’s problem consisted of the fact that as soon as the object is detected at some point A on a photographic plate placed to the right of the screen, the object-wavecannot be detected in any other part of space whatever, which is directly contradictory to any wave phenomenon in classical physics. But the object-wave cannot be detected in any other part of space whatever, which is directly contradictory to any wave phenomenon is classical physics. But the object-wave just cannot be a classical wave phenomenon because this would imply the possibility of knowing the dynamical state of the object far more precisely than is compatible with the indeterminacy relations.

•Jan 1, 1972•47 citations

Wave-Particle Dualism in Action

Wolfgang P. Schleich

The wave-particle dualism, that is the wave nature of particles and the particle nature of light together with the uncertainty relation of Werner Heisenberg and the principle of complementarity formulated by Niels Bohr represent pillars of quantum theory. We provide an introduction into these fascinating yet strange aspects of the microscopic world and summarize key experiments confirming these concepts so alien to our daily life. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 2016•3 citations

Sixty-Two Years of Uncertainty : Historical, Philosophical, and Physical Inquiries into the Foundations of Quantum Mechanics

Arthur I. Miller

Opening Remarks.- Imagery, Probability and the Roots of Werner Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle Paper.- Against An Exposition of Bell's Theorem.- Wave-Particle Duality: A Case Study.- Sein Kann Was Nicht Sein Darf, Or the Prehistory of the EPR, 1909-1935: Einstein's Early Worries About the Quantum Mechanics of Composite Systems.- to Two-Particle Interferometry.- A New View on the Uncertainty Principle.- Measurement Problems in Quantum Field Theory in the 1930's.- On the Collapse of the Wave Function.- Old and New Ideas in the Theory of Quantum Measurement.- Toward a Relativistic Theory of Statevector Reduction.- The Breakdown of the Superposition Principle.- Mathematical and Philosophical Questions in the Theory of Open and Macroscopic Quantum Systems.- Induced Nonlinear Time Evolution of Open Quantum Objects.- Quantum Logic: A Summary of Some Issues.- Remarks on the Measurement of Discrete Physical Quantities.- Some Comments and Reflections.- Invited Lecturers.

•Jan 1, 1990•83 citations

Secondary and University Students’ Descriptions of Quantum Uncertainty and the Wave Nature of Quantum Particles

Maria Vetleseter Bøe, S. Viefers

Abstract Teaching and learning of quantum physics at secondary level is an active field of research. One important challenge is finding ways to promote understanding of quantum concepts without the mathematical formalism that is embedded in quantum mechanics but unavailable on the secondary level. We investigated Norwegian secondary students’ (N = 291) descriptions of the wave nature of quantum particles and the uncertainty principle, as expressed during work with learning resources using a sociocultural approach emphasizing history, philosophy, and nature of science aspects. Responses from university students (N = 40) given after a formalism-based course in quantum physics were included for comparison. Themes were identified using thematic analysis and analyzed from the perspective of pedagogical link-making, seeing different themes as representing different levels of explanations of the concepts (phenomenological, qualitative, mathematical). The most dominant theme in descriptions of particle wave nature was that particles exhibit wave behavior in experiments, while referring to the mathematical description of particles by wave functions was a less prominent theme, even among university students. Two uncertainty principle themes were found: uncertainty as inability to measure pairs of variables precisely, and uncertainty as innate blurriness in nature. Largely missing from descriptions of both concepts were meaningful links between different levels of explanations. Based on the results, we discuss ways forward for teaching particle wave nature and uncertainty in secondary education.

Science & Education•Nov 27, 2021•23 citations
The discussion of particle-wave dualism still plays an important part in teaching quantum theroy. This surely is for historical reasons, since it was important in grasping the concept of uncertainty. Recent EPR-like experiments, however, indicate new ways of teaching the notions of uncertainty and complementarity. These allow us to achieve a clear understanding without difficult mathematical obstacles and promote also a well-founded discussion of philosophical aspects. The core of the considerations presented here are systems consisting of two-state objects, for example the spin states of photons or electrons.
Niels Bohr, as is well known, introduced the notion of complementarity into physics, as a fundamental principle of quantum mechanics. It holds that objects have complementary properties that cannot be measured accurately at the same time. For example, the particle and wave aspects of physical objects are such complementary phenomena. Both concepts are borrowed from classical mechanics, where it is impossible to be both, a particle and a wave at the same time. Particle and Wave represent the complementarity of the Discrete and the Continuous. Humans reason by means of concepts (meanings) and language, as well as, by means of logical or arithmetic symbolism. Meanings are continua, whereas logic and arithmetic are based on relations of identity and difference.
To resolve the challenges (paradoxes) attending the genesis of quantum theory, Niels Bohr in 1927 proposed a generalization of the conceptual framework of classical physics, termed complementarity, which posited pairs of classical concepts that could be manifested only in mutually exclusive experimental arrangements with both needed to embrace the full range of physical experience. In this context particle–wave complementarity has encountered two major obstacles; (1) No formulation of it has commanded a general consensus; and (2) empirical evidence abounds that contradicts the claim of mutual exclusivity of particle and wave properties of quantum objects in a single experiment. These problems are rooted in the unrestricted scope of this claim. It is shown that a restricted version of particle–wave complementarity, here called “which value–interference” complementarity, is consistent with observations, is naturally contained in the mathematical formalism of quantum theory and, in fact, holds in any representation of quantum theory defined by the eigenvectors of a complete set of commuting observables, such as the configuration space position (kinematic) variables or the complementary linear momentum (dynamic) variables. Thus, the which value–interference form of particle–wave complementarity exists within kinematic–dynamic complementarity, a “layered” complementarity, so to speak. It is hoped that a consistent and valid exposition of particle–wave complementarity will be helpful to those who find the framework of complementarity useful and appropriate for some purpose.
The wave-particle duality of photons and electrons was thoroughly discussed at a conference held at the Solvay Institute in October 1927, where Albert Einstein and Niels Bohr were the most prominent participants. From the beginning Einstein manifested great hesitation in accepting the renunciation of causal description of physical phenomena introduced by quantum theory. He clearly demonstrated his basic attitude by discussing the example of an atomic object (electron or photon) impinging upon a screen with a single slit (see figure 4). To the left of the screen the object is supposed to have a precisely defined momentum p and hence it is represented as a plane, harmonic wave. When passing through the slit, the plane wave is scattered into a cylindrical wave with an opening angle determined by the wavelength and the slit aperture. Einstein’s problem consisted of the fact that as soon as the object is detected at some point A on a photographic plate placed to the right of the screen, the object-wavecannot be detected in any other part of space whatever, which is directly contradictory to any wave phenomenon in classical physics. But the object-wave cannot be detected in any other part of space whatever, which is directly contradictory to any wave phenomenon is classical physics. But the object-wave just cannot be a classical wave phenomenon because this would imply the possibility of knowing the dynamical state of the object far more precisely than is compatible with the indeterminacy relations.
The wave-particle dualism, that is the wave nature of particles and the particle nature of light together with the uncertainty relation of Werner Heisenberg and the principle of complementarity formulated by Niels Bohr represent pillars of quantum theory. We provide an introduction into these fascinating yet strange aspects of the microscopic world and summarize key experiments confirming these concepts so alien to our daily life. These keywords were added by machine and not by the authors. This process is experimental and the keywords may be updated as the learning algorithm improves.
Opening Remarks.- Imagery, Probability and the Roots of Werner Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle Paper.- Against An Exposition of Bell's Theorem.- Wave-Particle Duality: A Case Study.- Sein Kann Was Nicht Sein Darf, Or the Prehistory of the EPR, 1909-1935: Einstein's Early Worries About the Quantum Mechanics of Composite Systems.- to Two-Particle Interferometry.- A New View on the Uncertainty Principle.- Measurement Problems in Quantum Field Theory in the 1930's.- On the Collapse of the Wave Function.- Old and New Ideas in the Theory of Quantum Measurement.- Toward a Relativistic Theory of Statevector Reduction.- The Breakdown of the Superposition Principle.- Mathematical and Philosophical Questions in the Theory of Open and Macroscopic Quantum Systems.- Induced Nonlinear Time Evolution of Open Quantum Objects.- Quantum Logic: A Summary of Some Issues.- Remarks on the Measurement of Discrete Physical Quantities.- Some Comments and Reflections.- Invited Lecturers.
Abstract Teaching and learning of quantum physics at secondary level is an active field of research. One important challenge is finding ways to promote understanding of quantum concepts without the mathematical formalism that is embedded in quantum mechanics but unavailable on the secondary level. We investigated Norwegian secondary students’ (N = 291) descriptions of the wave nature of quantum particles and the uncertainty principle, as expressed during work with learning resources using a sociocultural approach emphasizing history, philosophy, and nature of science aspects. Responses from university students (N = 40) given after a formalism-based course in quantum physics were included for comparison. Themes were identified using thematic analysis and analyzed from the perspective of pedagogical link-making, seeing different themes as representing different levels of explanations of the concepts (phenomenological, qualitative, mathematical). The most dominant theme in descriptions of particle wave nature was that particles exhibit wave behavior in experiments, while referring to the mathematical description of particles by wave functions was a less prominent theme, even among university students. Two uncertainty principle themes were found: uncertainty as inability to measure pairs of variables precisely, and uncertainty as innate blurriness in nature. Largely missing from descriptions of both concepts were meaningful links between different levels of explanations. Based on the results, we discuss ways forward for teaching particle wave nature and uncertainty in secondary education.