Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Phenomenological Distinction between Unitary and Antiunitary Symmetry Operators

Eugene Paul Wigner

Published Sep 1, 1960• 23 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is well known that one always can find as many orthogonal states (i.e., states between which the transition probability is zero) as the Hilbert space has dimensions which are invariant under a given unitary transformation. The corresponding vectors are characteristic vectors of the unitary operator. In contrast, most antiunitary operators leave not more than one state invariant. However, if there are two orthogonal invariant states, a consideration of the states for which the transition probability is ½ into both invariant states surely provides a distinction. In the antiunitary case, one of these states is also invariant, another one is transformed into an orthogonal state, the rest are in between. In the unitary case, the transition probability between original state and transformed state is the same for all states for which the transition probability is ½ into two orthogonal states. This provides a ``directly observable'' distinction between unitary and antiunitary transformations.

DOI
10.1063/1.1703673

Related papers

Equivalence and Antiequivalence of Irreducible Sets of Operators. I. Finite Dimensional Spaces

John S. Lomont, H. E. Moses, K. Yu

A fundamental problem which arises in determining whether two quantum mechanical systems are essentially identical is whether a unitary or antiunitary transformation exists which maps one set of dynamical variables into another. Since an elementary dynamical system is specified by giving an irreducible set of dynamical variables, we are led to investigate the following problem: Given two irreducible sets of operators with a one-to-one correspondence between them, find the algebraic properties of the two sets which make it possible to infer the existence of a unitary or antiunitary operator relating them. A series of theorems is obtained from such considerations for finite dimensional spaces. It is shown that if the second set of operators contains some of the algebraic properties of the first set, the two sets are related by a similarity transformation. By altering the requirements, this transformation is a unitary transformation. Indications are also given to show how the theorems can be extended to Hilbert spaces. The rigorous statements of the theorems and the proofs will be given in a second paper. Finally, in the Appendix there is given a definition of invariance of elementary quantum-mechanical systems based on the above theorems, giving the same results as Wigner's definition in terms of transition probabilities.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1963•2 citations

Unitary and Antiunitary Operators Mapping Vectors to Parallel or to Orthogonal Ones, with Applications to Symmetry Transformations

PEKKA J. LAHTI, Maciej Mączyński, Kari Ylinen

Letters in Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2001•0 citations

Generalized Wigner theorem for noninvertible symmetries

Gerardo Ortíz, Chinmay Giridhar, Philipp Vojta +2 more

We establish the conditions under which a conservation law associated with a non-invertible operator may be realized as a symmetry in quantum physics. As established by Wigner, all quantum symmetries must be represented by either unitary or antiunitary transformations. Relinquishing an implicit assumption of invertibility, we demonstrate that the fundamental invariance of quantum transition probabilities under the application of symmetries mandates that all non-invertible symmetries may only correspond to {\it projective} unitary or antiunitary transformations, i.e., {\it partial isometries}. This extends the notion of physical states beyond conventional rays in Hilbert space to equivalence classes in an {\it extended, gauged Hilbert space}, thereby broadening the traditional understanding of symmetry transformations in quantum theory. Our generalized theorem applies irrespective of the origin of the (non)invertible symmetry, holds in arbitrary spatial dimensions, and is independent of the Hamiltonian or action. We explore its physical consequences and, using simple model systems, illustrate how the distinction between invertible and non-invertible symmetries can sometimes be tied to the choice of boundary conditions.

arXiv:2509.25327•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 12, 2026•5 citations

Transformations on the set of all $n$-dimensional subspaces of a Hilbert space preserving orthogonality

Máté Győry

In our paper we generalize Uhlhorn's version of Wigner's famous unitary-antiunitary theorem by describing the transformations preserving the orthogonality between higher dimensional subspaces under certain conditions.

Publicationes Mathematicae Debrecen•Jul 1, 2004•23 citations

Phenomenological Distinction Between Unitary and Antiunitary Symmetry Operators

E. P. Wigner

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1993•4 citations

Symmetry in quantum mechanics

Symmetry in quantum mechanicsRoughly speaking, a symmetry of some mathematical object is an invertible transformation that leaves all relevant structure as it is.Thus a symmetry of a set is just a bijection (as sets have no further structure, whence invertibility is the only demand on a symmetry), a symmetry of a topological space is a homeomorphism, a symmetry of a Banach space is a linear isometric isomorphism, and, crucially important for this chapter, a symmetry of a Hilbert space H is a unitary operator, i.e., a linear map u : H → H satisfying one and hence all of the following equivalent conditions:• u is invertible and preserves the inner product, i.e., uϕ, uψ = ϕ, ψ (ϕ, ψ ∈ H).The discussion of symmetries in quantum physics is based on the above idea, but the mathematically obvious choices need not be the physically relevant ones.Even in elementary quantum mechanics, where A = B(H), i.e., the C*-algebra of all bounded operators on some Hilbert space H, the concept of a symmetry is already diverse.The main structures whose symmetries we shall study in this chapter are:1.The normal pure state space P 1 (H), i.e., the set of one-dimensional projections on H, with transition probability τ : P 1 (H) × P 1 (H) → [0, 1] defined by (2.44).2. The normal state space D(H), i.e. the convex set of density operators ρ on H. The self-adjoint operators B(H)sa on H, seen as a Jordan algebra (see below).4. The effects E (H) = [0, 1] B(H) , seen as a convex partially ordered set (poset). 5.The projections P(H) on H, seen as an orthocomplemented lattice.6.The unital commutative C*-subalgebras C (B(H)) of B(H), seen as a poset.Each of these structures comes with its own notion of a symmetry, but the main point of this chapter will be to show these notions are equivalent, corresponding in all cases to either unitary or-surprisingly-anti-unitary operators, both merely defined up to a phase.The latter subtlety will open the world of projective unitary group representation to quantum mechanics (without which the existence of spin-1 2 particles such as electrons, and therewith also of ourselves, would be impossible).

Institute of Physics eBooks•Nov 26, 2004•0 citations
It is well known that one always can find as many orthogonal states (i.e., states between which the transition probability is zero) as the Hilbert space has dimensions which are invariant under a given unitary transformation. The corresponding vectors are characteristic vectors of the unitary operator. In contrast, most antiunitary operators leave not more than one state invariant. However, if there are two orthogonal invariant states, a consideration of the states for which the transition probability is ½ into both invariant states surely provides a distinction. In the antiunitary case, one of these states is also invariant, another one is transformed into an orthogonal state, the rest are in between. In the unitary case, the transition probability between original state and transformed state is the same for all states for which the transition probability is ½ into two orthogonal states. This provides a ``directly observable'' distinction between unitary and antiunitary transformations.
A fundamental problem which arises in determining whether two quantum mechanical systems are essentially identical is whether a unitary or antiunitary transformation exists which maps one set of dynamical variables into another. Since an elementary dynamical system is specified by giving an irreducible set of dynamical variables, we are led to investigate the following problem: Given two irreducible sets of operators with a one-to-one correspondence between them, find the algebraic properties of the two sets which make it possible to infer the existence of a unitary or antiunitary operator relating them. A series of theorems is obtained from such considerations for finite dimensional spaces. It is shown that if the second set of operators contains some of the algebraic properties of the first set, the two sets are related by a similarity transformation. By altering the requirements, this transformation is a unitary transformation. Indications are also given to show how the theorems can be extended to Hilbert spaces. The rigorous statements of the theorems and the proofs will be given in a second paper. Finally, in the Appendix there is given a definition of invariance of elementary quantum-mechanical systems based on the above theorems, giving the same results as Wigner's definition in terms of transition probabilities.
We establish the conditions under which a conservation law associated with a non-invertible operator may be realized as a symmetry in quantum physics. As established by Wigner, all quantum symmetries must be represented by either unitary or antiunitary transformations. Relinquishing an implicit assumption of invertibility, we demonstrate that the fundamental invariance of quantum transition probabilities under the application of symmetries mandates that all non-invertible symmetries may only correspond to {\it projective} unitary or antiunitary transformations, i.e., {\it partial isometries}. This extends the notion of physical states beyond conventional rays in Hilbert space to equivalence classes in an {\it extended, gauged Hilbert space}, thereby broadening the traditional understanding of symmetry transformations in quantum theory. Our generalized theorem applies irrespective of the origin of the (non)invertible symmetry, holds in arbitrary spatial dimensions, and is independent of the Hamiltonian or action. We explore its physical consequences and, using simple model systems, illustrate how the distinction between invertible and non-invertible symmetries can sometimes be tied to the choice of boundary conditions.
Transformations on the set of all nnn-dimensional subspaces of a Hilbert space preserving orthogonality
Symmetry in quantum mechanicsRoughly speaking, a symmetry of some mathematical object is an invertible transformation that leaves all relevant structure as it is.Thus a symmetry of a set is just a bijection (as sets have no further structure, whence invertibility is the only demand on a symmetry), a symmetry of a topological space is a homeomorphism, a symmetry of a Banach space is a linear isometric isomorphism, and, crucially important for this chapter, a symmetry of a Hilbert space H is a unitary operator, i.e., a linear map u : H → H satisfying one and hence all of the following equivalent conditions:• u is invertible and preserves the inner product, i.e., uϕ, uψ = ϕ, ψ (ϕ, ψ ∈ H).The discussion of symmetries in quantum physics is based on the above idea, but the mathematically obvious choices need not be the physically relevant ones.Even in elementary quantum mechanics, where A = B(H), i.e., the C*-algebra of all bounded operators on some Hilbert space H, the concept of a symmetry is already diverse.The main structures whose symmetries we shall study in this chapter are:1.The normal pure state space P 1 (H), i.e., the set of one-dimensional projections on H, with transition probability τ : P 1 (H) × P 1 (H) → [0, 1] defined by (2.44).2. The normal state space D(H), i.e. the convex set of density operators ρ on H. The self-adjoint operators B(H)sa on H, seen as a Jordan algebra (see below).4. The effects E (H) = [0, 1] B(H) , seen as a convex partially ordered set (poset). 5.The projections P(H) on H, seen as an orthocomplemented lattice.6.The unital commutative C*-subalgebras C (B(H)) of B(H), seen as a poset.Each of these structures comes with its own notion of a symmetry, but the main point of this chapter will be to show these notions are equivalent, corresponding in all cases to either unitary or-surprisingly-anti-unitary operators, both merely defined up to a phase.The latter subtlety will open the world of projective unitary group representation to quantum mechanics (without which the existence of spin-1 2 particles such as electrons, and therewith also of ourselves, would be impossible).