Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Reply to comments by George and Prigogine on the paper 'On the validity of the Brussels formalism in statistical mechanics'

Peter V. Coveney, O. Penrose

Published Aug 7, 1993• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For original paper see Coveney et. al., ibid., vol.25, p.4947 (1992). George and Prigogine (ibid., vol.26, p.3905, 1993) interpret the authors previous paper as destructive criticism of the Brussels formalism. However they argue that their aim was to discover conditions under which this method might be supported by rigorous analysis and that their results give a set of sufficient conditions, admittedly quite restrictive, for the validity of a part of the formalism. The Brussels school has never promulgated any agreed choice for the function space in which the formalism's operators are to act. In their work they chose a Hilbert space. This structure sufficed for the theorems they could prove, which concern only the P subspace. They agree that additional structure, such as that of a rigged Hilbert space, may be necessary to give effect to the Brussels formalism outside the P subspace, but since this additional structure would not have affected their results they do not see that its omission was a misrepresentation. Further comments are made.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/26/15/039

Related papers

Comments on the paper by Coveney and Penrose 'On the validity of the Brussels formalism in statistical mechanics'

Claude D. George, Ilya Prigogine

For original paper see Coveney et. al. ibid., vol.25, p.4947 (1992). The previous authors state, in the introductory section of their paper that they are looking only at a 'small part' of the Brussels formalism. The title of their paper does not reflect this restriction and refers to the general validity of the Brussels formalism. The criticisms are focused on a few papers published about twenty years ago. However, even restricted to these papers, their claims do not apply. The present authors point out two major misrepresentations.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Aug 7, 1993•3 citations

A comment on disordered systems

Theodore Kaplan, L. J. Gray

For original papers see ibid., vol.10, p.L597 (1977) and vol.11, p.L949 (1978). The authors respond to two recent letters which comment on the augmented space formalism.

Journal of Physics C Solid State Physics•Sep 28, 1979•3 citations

Brussels-Austin Nonequilibrium Statistical Mechanics in the Early Years: Similarity Transformations between Deterministic and Probabilistic Descriptions

Robert C. Bishop

The fundamental problem on which Ilya Prigogine and the Brussels-Austin Group have focused can be stated briefly as follows. Our observations indicate that there is an arrow of time in our experience of the world (e.g., decay of unstable radioactive atoms like Uranium, or the mixing of cream in coffee). Most of the fundamental equations of physics are time reversible, however, presenting an apparent conflict between our theoretical descriptions and experimental observations. Many have thought that the observed arrow of time was either an artifact of our observations or due to very special initial conditions. An alternative approach, followed by the Brussels-Austin Group, is to consider the observed direction of time to be a basics physical phenomenon and to develop a mathematical formalism that can describe this direction as being due to the dynamics of physical systems. In part I of this essay, I review and assess an attempt to carry out an approach that received much of their attention from the early 1970s to the mid 1980s. In part II, I will discuss their more recent approach using rigged Hilbert spaces.

arXiv:physics/0304018•Apr 7, 2003•1 citation

Reply to the Comment on ‘The correspondence between quantum and classical mechanics: An experimental demonstration of the smooth transition between the two regimes’ [Chem. Phys. Lett. 402 (2005) 519]

Anthony J. Horsewill

Chemical Physics Letters•Nov 29, 2006•4 citations

Application of the statistical mechanics transformation theory to a soluble model

R. W. Gibberd, Claude D. George

One of us (C.G) has developed a transformation theory in nonequilibrium statistical mechanics that generalizes the usual transformation theory of quantum mechanics in the framework of the resolvent formalism of the Liouville-von Neumann operator extensively used by the Brussels school. Prigogine, George, and Henin have shown that the evolution of a dissipative system can be decomposed into separate subdynamics in orthogonal subspaces. The π subspace, containing all thermodynamics, can be seen as an extension of the subspace of the invariants in the absence of dissipation. In this subspace a suitable contracted description of the system can be given through a dressing operator χ, which has the property that HR = χ−1H0 can be considered as the renormalized energy. A differential equation that determines χ has been proposed by Mandel. It is useful to see, even for a nondissipative system, what relation the transformation theory in the Liouville-von Neumann formalism has to the standard transformations used in quantum mechanics. In this paper we consider a system that can be completely diagonalized by the Bogoliubov transformation. It is shown that in this case the Mandel equation can be solved and that χ−1H0 = HD, where HD is the diagonalized Hamiltonian, obtained by the Bogoliubov transformation.

Transport Theory and Statistical Physics•Jan 1, 1972•3 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Remarks on the structure of states of composite quantum systems and envariance’ [Phys. Lett. A 355 (2006) 180]” [Phys. Lett. A 375 (2011) 1160]

Ph. Blanchard, Erwin Brüning

Physics Letters A•Dec 31, 2010•1 citation
For original paper see Coveney et. al., ibid., vol.25, p.4947 (1992). George and Prigogine (ibid., vol.26, p.3905, 1993) interpret the authors previous paper as destructive criticism of the Brussels formalism. However they argue that their aim was to discover conditions under which this method might be supported by rigorous analysis and that their results give a set of sufficient conditions, admittedly quite restrictive, for the validity of a part of the formalism. The Brussels school has never promulgated any agreed choice for the function space in which the formalism's operators are to act. In their work they chose a Hilbert space. This structure sufficed for the theorems they could prove, which concern only the P subspace. They agree that additional structure, such as that of a rigged Hilbert space, may be necessary to give effect to the Brussels formalism outside the P subspace, but since this additional structure would not have affected their results they do not see that its omission was a misrepresentation. Further comments are made.
For original paper see Coveney et. al. ibid., vol.25, p.4947 (1992). The previous authors state, in the introductory section of their paper that they are looking only at a 'small part' of the Brussels formalism. The title of their paper does not reflect this restriction and refers to the general validity of the Brussels formalism. The criticisms are focused on a few papers published about twenty years ago. However, even restricted to these papers, their claims do not apply. The present authors point out two major misrepresentations.
The fundamental problem on which Ilya Prigogine and the Brussels-Austin Group have focused can be stated briefly as follows. Our observations indicate that there is an arrow of time in our experience of the world (e.g., decay of unstable radioactive atoms like Uranium, or the mixing of cream in coffee). Most of the fundamental equations of physics are time reversible, however, presenting an apparent conflict between our theoretical descriptions and experimental observations. Many have thought that the observed arrow of time was either an artifact of our observations or due to very special initial conditions. An alternative approach, followed by the Brussels-Austin Group, is to consider the observed direction of time to be a basics physical phenomenon and to develop a mathematical formalism that can describe this direction as being due to the dynamics of physical systems. In part I of this essay, I review and assess an attempt to carry out an approach that received much of their attention from the early 1970s to the mid 1980s. In part II, I will discuss their more recent approach using rigged Hilbert spaces.
One of us (C.G) has developed a transformation theory in nonequilibrium statistical mechanics that generalizes the usual transformation theory of quantum mechanics in the framework of the resolvent formalism of the Liouville-von Neumann operator extensively used by the Brussels school. Prigogine, George, and Henin have shown that the evolution of a dissipative system can be decomposed into separate subdynamics in orthogonal subspaces. The π subspace, containing all thermodynamics, can be seen as an extension of the subspace of the invariants in the absence of dissipation. In this subspace a suitable contracted description of the system can be given through a dressing operator χ, which has the property that HR = χ−1H0 can be considered as the renormalized energy. A differential equation that determines χ has been proposed by Mandel. It is useful to see, even for a nondissipative system, what relation the transformation theory in the Liouville-von Neumann formalism has to the standard transformations used in quantum mechanics. In this paper we consider a system that can be completely diagonalized by the Bogoliubov transformation. It is shown that in this case the Mandel equation can be solved and that χ−1H0 = HD, where HD is the diagonalized Hamiltonian, obtained by the Bogoliubov transformation.