Vorontsov and Rembovsky pointed out recently a problem that unphysical states appear after an approximate quantum measurement of the Pegg-Barnett phase [Phys. Lett. A 254 (1999), 7; 262 (1999), 486]. To give a solution to this problem, we introduce a quantum phase in the extended number-state space and show that there is no Vorontsov-Rembovsky problem in the extended space. In the infinite-dimensional limit, the present extended formalism gives the same results in almost all cases as the Pegg-Barnett formalism. Also, it is shown that unphysical states can be suppressed by using the projection operator to the physical number space.
A simple formalism is introduced for describing the quantum phase of a single-mode field (or, equivalently, a harmonic oscillator) using a particular infinite-dimensional Hilbert space
Hsym. This space is spanned by vectors which represent states of the single field mode containing non-negative numbers of photons. It has a symmetry in the sense that it contains vectors in the neighborhood of both the vacuum state and the infinite photon number state. A striking property of
Hsym is that it supports Hermitian and unitary phase operators. Indeed the Pegg-Barnett unitary phase operators are shown to converge strongly on the Hilbert space
Hsym and so the correponding limit points are ordinary operators on
Hsym. This can be compared with the situation for the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space H conventionally used in quantum optics on which the Pegg-Barnett unitary phase operators converge weakly, in general.