Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Today

Sorting Out the Potts Models

R. J. Baxter

Published Dec 1, 2005• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It was a great pleasure to hear that the American Physical Society had awarded me the 2006 Lars Onsager Prize and to read the informative news story “Order Parameter of the Chiral Potts Model Succumbs at Last to Exact Solution” that appeared on page 19 of the November edition of Physics Today. I have a few comments.There are various models named after Ren Potts, who died in Adelaide, Australia, on 9 August 2005. He was a student of Cyril Domb at Oxford University in 1952, and worked on the vector and scalar extensions of the Ising model. 1 1. R. Potts, Proc. Camb. Phil. Soc. 48, 106 (1952) https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305004100027419. The two are often confused. The vector model is described in the Physics Today story, whereas it is the scalar model that has been solved at criticality. The N-state chiral Potts model is a different model again. Its transfer matrices commute, which makes it “solvable” in the sense that one can calculate the free energy. For N = 2 it reduces to the Ising model. It is true that C. N. Yang took six months to calculate the spontaneous magnetization (order parameter) of the Ising model, 2 2. C. N. Yang, Collected Papers, Freeman and Co, San Francisco (1983), p. 12. whereas I have been puzzling over the extension of that problem to the chiral Potts model for 15 years!For both models the results were previously known: Onsager had announced his result for the Ising model at a conference in 1949, 3 3. L. Onsager, Nuovo Cimento 6(suppl.), 261 (1949). and Giuseppe Albertini, Barry McCoy, Jacques Perk, and Shuang Tang gave the formula for chiral Potts in 1989. However, there are some differences.The story refers to both these announcements as conjectures, but it is clear from a later paper by Onsager 4 4. L. Onsager, in Critical Phenomena in Alloys, Magnets and Superconductors, R. E. Mills, E. Ascher, R. I. Jaffee, eds., McGraw-Hill, New York (1971), p. 3. that he had already derived his answer when he announced it. Being Onsager, he did not rush into print, but worked at refining and polishing his derivation for three years, which gave Yang the opportunity to publish his solution in 1952.By contrast, the chiral Potts result given by Giuseppe Albertini and colleagues really was a conjecture—an elegant formula, inspired by the Ising result, that fitted all known series expansions. It is this conjecture that I have now verified, subject to analyticity assumptions no more drastic than those used for the order parameters of other post-Ising models. From 1998 until recently, I was looking at the Jimbo-Miwa-Nakayashiki method. It depends on solving for a function of two arguments, and I was having trouble. The idea that came to me over two days in December 2004 was to relate those arguments so that there was just one independent variable, in much the same way as in the free energy calculation one starts by looking at the simpler “superintegrable” case. The switch to one variable made the needed analyticity properties fairly obvious, and was sufficient to obtain the order parameters. 5 5. R. J. Baxter, J. Stat. Phys. 120, 1 (2005) https://doi.org/10.1007/s10955-005-5534-3. It was a good illustration of the approach used in these solvable models—one needs to generalize sufficiently to see properties like commuting transfer matrices, but one should beware of generalizing unnecessarily.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. R. Potts, Proc. Camb. Phil. Soc. 48, 106 (1952) https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305004100027419. Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. C. N. Yang, Collected Papers, Freeman and Co, San Francisco (1983), p. 12. Google Scholar3. L. Onsager, Nuovo Cimento 6(suppl.), 261 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref4. L. Onsager, in Critical Phenomena in Alloys, Magnets and Superconductors, R. E. Mills, E. Ascher, R. I. Jaffee, eds., McGraw-Hill, New York (1971), p. 3. Google Scholar5. R. J. Baxter, J. Stat. Phys. 120, 1 (2005) https://doi.org/10.1007/s10955-005-5534-3. Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2005 American Institute of Physics.

DOI
10.1063/1.2169427

Related papers

Yang-Baxter Equations in Paris : proceeding of the conference, Jussieu July 24-30, 1992

J.-M. Maillard

Exact Spectrum of the Critical Three-State Potts Chain (G Albertini) New Results Related to the Chiral Potts Model (H Au-Yang & J H H Perk) Chiral Potts Model: Corner Transfer Matrices and Parametrizations (R J Baxter) Solvable Lattice Models in Three Dimensions (VV Bazhanov) Dressing Symmetries (D Bernard) Knot Theory and Chem-Simons Lagrangian: Some Remarks about the corresponding Diagrams (P Cartier) Recent Progress in 2-D Quantum Gravity (V Dotsenko) On Coordinate Algebras of Quantum Groups at Root of Unity (B Enriquez) Integrability in Discrete Systems (B Grammaticos) New Construction of Solvable RSOS Models (S 0 Warnaar) Birational Automorphisms and Yang-Baxter Equations (J-M Maillard) Yang-Baxter Equations and Non-Commutative Differential Calculus (G Maltsiniotis) Physics Beyond Quasi-Particules: Spectrum and Completeness of the Three-State Superintegrable Chiral Potts Model (B M McCoy) Analytic Calulation of Conformal Weights for A-D-E Lattice Models (P Pearce) Quantum Tops (A Reiman) Remarks on Quasi-Hopf Algebras (M Rosso) Symmetries of the Yang-Baxter Equations: A Remarkable Family of Discrete Groups (C-M Viallet) The Yang-Baxter Equation in Knot Theory (F Y Wu).

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jan 1, 1993•0 citations

On Ising models

Hoede, C., Zandvliet, Henricus J.W.

For various Ising models two approaches are discussed, one is that of simulating lattices, also called gauging on exact equations, the other is that of calculating analytical expressions for the boundary free energy of Ising lattices. The first approach allows to conjecture a solution for some Ising models, that have sofar not been solved, once some exact partial result for the problem is known. The second approach aims at furnishing such a partial result in the form of a condition for the critical temperature. An example of such a result was recently given for the 2D Ising square lattice with nearest and next-nearest-neighbor interactions. The critical line that separates the ordered (ferromagnetic) phase from the disordered (paramagnetic) phase showed good agreement in the moderate and strong nearest neighbor coupling limit with several results obtained by Monte Carlo, transfer matrix and series expansion results. We extend the discussion of the critical line, finding an excellent fit, now also in other points, like the Padé point, as well as cusp behavior at the Onsager point where the lattice decouples into two 2D square lattices with only nearest-neighbor interaction. Combination of this result with a geometrical argument in the simulation approach leads to a critical exponent $2-\sqrt{2} \approx 0.5858,$ comparable to the exponent $4/7 \approx 0.5714$ found from renormalization arguments.

•Jun 1, 2006•0 citations

Derivation of the Order Parameter of the Chiral Potts Model

R. J. Baxter

We derive the order parameter of the chiral Potts model, using the method of Jimbo et al. The result agrees with previous conjectures.

arXiv:cond-mat/0501227•Physical Review Letters•Apr 8, 2005•44 citations

Bohr’s molecular model and the melding of classical and quantum mechanics

Anatoly A. Svidzinsky, Marlan O. Scully, Dudley R. Herschbach

Svidzinsky, Scully, and Herschbach reply: We agree with M. Y. Amusia that a statement we made about the infinite dimension limit is “lacking in rigor.” It was intended simply to provide heuristic insight into why, for a wide variety of problems, the large-D limit has proven to be a useful starting approximation to obtain results for D = 3.Amusia’s other concerns are answered in a 1975 paper on a D-scaling treatment of helium by David Herrick and Frank Stillinger.11. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42 They gave a rigorous derivation of the D-dimensional hydrogen atom Hamiltonian, shown as equation 1 in Amusia’s letter. That solution applies for D ≥ 2, as implied in the figure included in box 1 of our article. Herrick and Stillinger also showed that for the correct D → 1 limit, the Z/r term becomes a δ-function. In D-scaling, contrary to Amusia’s assumption, the D = 3 form of Coulomb’s law can be used for dimensional continuation to the large-D limit. The D-dependent similarity transformation affects the Laplacian, not the potential energy. Both theory and application are amply presented in references given in our article (particularly references 8–11). D-scaling, using just elementary algebra, has attained correlation energies for multielectron atoms with accuracy comparable to or better than conventional electronic calculations.22. See, for example, S. Kais, R. Bleil, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 7472 (1995); https://doi.org/10.1063/1.469059D. K. Watson, D. Z. Goodson, Phys. Rev. A 51, R5 (1995), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.51.R5The papers of Leonard Mlodinow33. See D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys. 84, 838 (1986), for analysis of the papers cited in reference 1 of Mlodinow’s letter. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.450584 and several other authors, especially the earlier paper by Herrick and Stillinger,11. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42 fostered the development of D-scaling for electronic structure. Since the kinship of Bohr’s model to dimensional scaling was not recognized until 2005, we did not dwell on that history, other than citing the tutorial article by Edward Witten. The treatment of H2 that Mlodinow cites in the second part of his reference 3 is a deliberately drastic approximation and gives less than 40% of the bond dissociation energy.As emphasized by Petar Grujic, the bold, perplexing enterprise by Niels Bohr motivated much further work melding classical and quantum mechanics. We note that D-scaling has a distinctive character. It might aptly be termed “semiquantum” rather than semiclassical. Although in the large-D limit the equations become classical, quantum mechanics is hidden in the D-dependent units adopted for distance and energy. At that limit, electrons take fixed positions in the D-scaled space and the first-order correction in (1/D) has them execute harmonic vibrations about those positions. In the prequantum era, such behavior was postulated by Gilbert Lewis and Irving Langmuir,44. P. Coffey, Cathedrals of Science: The Personalities and Rivalries That Made Modern Chemistry, Oxford U. Press, New York (2008), chap. 5, esp. p. 139. motivated by chemical arguments but disdained by physicists and considered incompatible with the Bohr model.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. See, for example, S. Kais, R. Bleil, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 7472 (1995); https://doi.org/10.1063/1.469059, Google ScholarCrossref, ISID. K. Watson, D. Z. Goodson, Phys. Rev. A 51, R5 (1995), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.51.R5, , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. See D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys. 84, 838 (1986), for analysis of the papers cited in reference 1 of Mlodinow’s letter. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.450584, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. P. Coffey, Cathedrals of Science: The Personalities and Rivalries That Made Modern Chemistry, Oxford U. Press, New York (2008), chap. 5, esp. p. 139. Google Scholar© 2014 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Aug 1, 2014•2 citations

A new look at Ernst Ising’s thesis

R. Folk

Abstract The famous paper (Ising in Z Phys 31: 253, A translation to English is by Jane Ising, Tom Cummings, Ulrich Harsch is found Bibliotheca Augustina 2001/02 https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~harsch/anglica/Chronology/20thC/Ising/isi_fm00.html , 1928) contains only a greatly reduced version of the material presented in his thesis. Looking at it therefore provides new insights into the Ising model in terms of its later implications. The method of calculating the partition function from the configuration of the system succeeds by finding a polynomial whose largest root defines the result in the thermodynamic limit and which coincides with the characteristic polynomial of the transfer matrix. This matrix works with the states of the elementary elements of the model and was found later in 1941 by Kramers and Wannier. Ising used his method for several one-dimensional models—variants of the Ising chain: a chain with three instead of two states (a forerunner of the Potts model formulated 1952), the Ising ladder given by two interacting chains and the Ising chain with next nearest-neighbor interaction published by Montroll in 1941. The largest root could not be found in all cases and approximations had to be made. Although no phase transition at finite temperature was found for the Ising chain, it turned out in the following decades that there is a critical point at $$T=0$$ T = 0 . Thus, the simple Ising chain can be used to study all properties approaching a transition point in this exactly solvable model. The historical introduction to the problem, given by Ising in his dissertation, goes back to Richard Kirwan (1733–1812), who was the first to associate ferromagnetism with the ordering of interacting magnetic elements similar to crystallization. Graphical abstract

The European Physical Journal B•Jun 1, 2025•1 citation

Another Visit with Wolfgang Pauli

Karl von Meÿenn, E. L. Schücking

SCHUCKING AND VON MEYENN REPLY: Yes, indeed, it was at the Solvay Conference in 1930 that Bohr reminded Einstein of his elevator. How the wrong date crept into our manuscript baffles us still.Kurt Gottfried is surprised that Pauli thought of Dirac as a formalist. Dirac was a formalist. He wrote in 1931: “The most powerful method of advance that can be suggested at present is to employ all the resources of pure mathematics in attempts to perfect and generalize the mathematical formalism that forms the existing basis of theoretical physics, and after each success in this direction, to try to interpret the new mathematical features in terms of physical entities.” 1 1. P. A. M. Dirac, Proc. R. Soc. A 133, 60 (1931) https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1931.0130. We disagree with Gottfried’s characterization of the Pauli equation for the electron as merely an elegant restatement of a Heisenberg–Jordan paper. Paul Ehrenfest wrote on 25 March 1931 about the Pauli equation: “This work has become very important. It has opened the way to Dirac’s ingenious work on the spin-electrons and probably also to Heisenberg’s famous work about the helium spectrum.” 2 2. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 2, K. von Meyenn, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1985) p. 71. Pauli introduced spinors into quantum mechanics and thus—in hindsight—made the step from two to four components not such a giant leap.We agree with Gottfried that the golden rule 3 3. K. Gottfried, Quantum Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, Calif. (1989), eq. 35, p. 444. is due to Dirac. When Pauli derived this equation using Dirac’s time-dependent perturbation theory, he analyzed its domain of validity using the uncertainty relation for time and energy that he had first pointed out in a letter to Heisenberg. Apparently, Pauli and Heisenberg 4 4. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 1, A. Hermann, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1979), p. 460. had first thought that Dirac had “gemogelt” (cheated) in its derivation.We both cherish Dirac’s beautiful physics, but his approach to theory was different from Pauli’s or Heisenberg’s. By praising Galileo, one does not demean Kepler.On Dirac’s comment about Schrödinger, we stand corrected. Luis Boya also may have a point on vacuum degeneracy. But Pauli’s crucial role in the Heisenberg theory still needs clarification. There are 144 letters from the correspondence between Pauli and Heisenberg in 1957 and 1958, up to 30 pages in length, which still await analysis.With regard to the early history of quantum field theory, we agree that much more could be said about it, and we refer Boya to Tian Yu Cao. 5 5. T. Y. Cao, Conceptual Developments of 20th Century Field Theories, Cambridge U. Press, New York (1997) https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511563997. For the history of nuclear magnetism, we suggest that Boya might consult Hendrik Casimir. 6 6. H. Casimir, Haphazard Reality, Harper & Row, New York (1983); appendix B, p. 322. Boya remarks that Heisenberg “never tried using his newborn matrix mechanics to solve for the hydrogen spectrum.” On 3 November 1925 Heisenberg wrote to Pauli: “After your first letter, I had also tried at once the calculation in three dimensions and was busy just this afternoon with the evaluation of the last equations and the elimination of the many possible mistakes in calculation when the postman entered and made my work superfluous.” 7 7. See ref. 4, p. 252. The postman had brought Pauli’s three-dimensional calculation for the H-atom. We believe that Boya underrates the role Pauli played in the dialogue with Heisenberg and that a careful reading of their correspondence supports our view. Freeman Dyson, with his unique insight into physics and the ways of physicists seems to agree with our assessment.Finally, we thank Gottfried, Boya, and Dyson for their comments.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. P. A. M. Dirac, Proc. R. Soc. A 133, 60 (1931) https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1931.0130. Google ScholarCrossref, CAS2. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 2, K. von Meyenn, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1985) p. 71. Google Scholar3. K. Gottfried, Quantum Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, Calif. (1989), eq. 35, p. 444. Google Scholar4. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 1, A. Hermann, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1979), p. 460. Google Scholar5. T. Y. Cao, Conceptual Developments of 20th Century Field Theories, Cambridge U. Press, New York (1997) https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511563997. Google ScholarCrossref6. H. Casimir, Haphazard Reality, Harper & Row, New York (1983); appendix B, p. 322. Google Scholar7. See ref. 4, p. 252. Google Scholar© 2001 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Aug 1, 2001•0 citations
It was a great pleasure to hear that the American Physical Society had awarded me the 2006 Lars Onsager Prize and to read the informative news story “Order Parameter of the Chiral Potts Model Succumbs at Last to Exact Solution” that appeared on page 19 of the November edition of Physics Today. I have a few comments.There are various models named after Ren Potts, who died in Adelaide, Australia, on 9 August 2005. He was a student of Cyril Domb at Oxford University in 1952, and worked on the vector and scalar extensions of the Ising model. 1 1. R. Potts, Proc. Camb. Phil. Soc. 48, 106 (1952) https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305004100027419. The two are often confused. The vector model is described in the Physics Today story, whereas it is the scalar model that has been solved at criticality. The N-state chiral Potts model is a different model again. Its transfer matrices commute, which makes it “solvable” in the sense that one can calculate the free energy. For N = 2 it reduces to the Ising model. It is true that C. N. Yang took six months to calculate the spontaneous magnetization (order parameter) of the Ising model, 2 2. C. N. Yang, Collected Papers, Freeman and Co, San Francisco (1983), p. 12. whereas I have been puzzling over the extension of that problem to the chiral Potts model for 15 years!For both models the results were previously known: Onsager had announced his result for the Ising model at a conference in 1949, 3 3. L. Onsager, Nuovo Cimento 6(suppl.), 261 (1949). and Giuseppe Albertini, Barry McCoy, Jacques Perk, and Shuang Tang gave the formula for chiral Potts in 1989. However, there are some differences.The story refers to both these announcements as conjectures, but it is clear from a later paper by Onsager 4 4. L. Onsager, in Critical Phenomena in Alloys, Magnets and Superconductors, R. E. Mills, E. Ascher, R. I. Jaffee, eds., McGraw-Hill, New York (1971), p. 3. that he had already derived his answer when he announced it. Being Onsager, he did not rush into print, but worked at refining and polishing his derivation for three years, which gave Yang the opportunity to publish his solution in 1952.By contrast, the chiral Potts result given by Giuseppe Albertini and colleagues really was a conjecture—an elegant formula, inspired by the Ising result, that fitted all known series expansions. It is this conjecture that I have now verified, subject to analyticity assumptions no more drastic than those used for the order parameters of other post-Ising models. From 1998 until recently, I was looking at the Jimbo-Miwa-Nakayashiki method. It depends on solving for a function of two arguments, and I was having trouble. The idea that came to me over two days in December 2004 was to relate those arguments so that there was just one independent variable, in much the same way as in the free energy calculation one starts by looking at the simpler “superintegrable” case. The switch to one variable made the needed analyticity properties fairly obvious, and was sufficient to obtain the order parameters. 5 5. R. J. Baxter, J. Stat. Phys. 120, 1 (2005) https://doi.org/10.1007/s10955-005-5534-3. It was a good illustration of the approach used in these solvable models—one needs to generalize sufficiently to see properties like commuting transfer matrices, but one should beware of generalizing unnecessarily.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. R. Potts, Proc. Camb. Phil. Soc. 48, 106 (1952) https://doi.org/10.1017/S0305004100027419. Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. C. N. Yang, Collected Papers, Freeman and Co, San Francisco (1983), p. 12. Google Scholar3. L. Onsager, Nuovo Cimento 6(suppl.), 261 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref4. L. Onsager, in Critical Phenomena in Alloys, Magnets and Superconductors, R. E. Mills, E. Ascher, R. I. Jaffee, eds., McGraw-Hill, New York (1971), p. 3. Google Scholar5. R. J. Baxter, J. Stat. Phys. 120, 1 (2005) https://doi.org/10.1007/s10955-005-5534-3. Google ScholarCrossref, ISI© 2005 American Institute of Physics.
Exact Spectrum of the Critical Three-State Potts Chain (G Albertini) New Results Related to the Chiral Potts Model (H Au-Yang & J H H Perk) Chiral Potts Model: Corner Transfer Matrices and Parametrizations (R J Baxter) Solvable Lattice Models in Three Dimensions (VV Bazhanov) Dressing Symmetries (D Bernard) Knot Theory and Chem-Simons Lagrangian: Some Remarks about the corresponding Diagrams (P Cartier) Recent Progress in 2-D Quantum Gravity (V Dotsenko) On Coordinate Algebras of Quantum Groups at Root of Unity (B Enriquez) Integrability in Discrete Systems (B Grammaticos) New Construction of Solvable RSOS Models (S 0 Warnaar) Birational Automorphisms and Yang-Baxter Equations (J-M Maillard) Yang-Baxter Equations and Non-Commutative Differential Calculus (G Maltsiniotis) Physics Beyond Quasi-Particules: Spectrum and Completeness of the Three-State Superintegrable Chiral Potts Model (B M McCoy) Analytic Calulation of Conformal Weights for A-D-E Lattice Models (P Pearce) Quantum Tops (A Reiman) Remarks on Quasi-Hopf Algebras (M Rosso) Symmetries of the Yang-Baxter Equations: A Remarkable Family of Discrete Groups (C-M Viallet) The Yang-Baxter Equation in Knot Theory (F Y Wu).
For various Ising models two approaches are discussed, one is that of simulating lattices, also called gauging on exact equations, the other is that of calculating analytical expressions for the boundary free energy of Ising lattices. The first approach allows to conjecture a solution for some Ising models, that have sofar not been solved, once some exact partial result for the problem is known. The second approach aims at furnishing such a partial result in the form of a condition for the critical temperature. An example of such a result was recently given for the 2D Ising square lattice with nearest and next-nearest-neighbor interactions. The critical line that separates the ordered (ferromagnetic) phase from the disordered (paramagnetic) phase showed good agreement in the moderate and strong nearest neighbor coupling limit with several results obtained by Monte Carlo, transfer matrix and series expansion results. We extend the discussion of the critical line, finding an excellent fit, now also in other points, like the Padé point, as well as cusp behavior at the Onsager point where the lattice decouples into two 2D square lattices with only nearest-neighbor interaction. Combination of this result with a geometrical argument in the simulation approach leads to a critical exponent 2−2≈0.5858,2-\sqrt{2} \approx 0.5858,2−2​≈0.5858, comparable to the exponent 4/7≈0.57144/7 \approx 0.57144/7≈0.5714 found from renormalization arguments.
Svidzinsky, Scully, and Herschbach reply: We agree with M. Y. Amusia that a statement we made about the infinite dimension limit is “lacking in rigor.” It was intended simply to provide heuristic insight into why, for a wide variety of problems, the large-D limit has proven to be a useful starting approximation to obtain results for D = 3.Amusia’s other concerns are answered in a 1975 paper on a D-scaling treatment of helium by David Herrick and Frank Stillinger.11. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42 They gave a rigorous derivation of the D-dimensional hydrogen atom Hamiltonian, shown as equation 1 in Amusia’s letter. That solution applies for D ≥ 2, as implied in the figure included in box 1 of our article. Herrick and Stillinger also showed that for the correct D → 1 limit, the Z/r term becomes a δ-function. In D-scaling, contrary to Amusia’s assumption, the D = 3 form of Coulomb’s law can be used for dimensional continuation to the large-D limit. The D-dependent similarity transformation affects the Laplacian, not the potential energy. Both theory and application are amply presented in references given in our article (particularly references 8–11). D-scaling, using just elementary algebra, has attained correlation energies for multielectron atoms with accuracy comparable to or better than conventional electronic calculations.22. See, for example, S. Kais, R. Bleil, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 7472 (1995); https://doi.org/10.1063/1.469059D. K. Watson, D. Z. Goodson, Phys. Rev. A 51, R5 (1995), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.51.R5The papers of Leonard Mlodinow33. See D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys. 84, 838 (1986), for analysis of the papers cited in reference 1 of Mlodinow’s letter. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.450584 and several other authors, especially the earlier paper by Herrick and Stillinger,11. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42 fostered the development of D-scaling for electronic structure. Since the kinship of Bohr’s model to dimensional scaling was not recognized until 2005, we did not dwell on that history, other than citing the tutorial article by Edward Witten. The treatment of H2 that Mlodinow cites in the second part of his reference 3 is a deliberately drastic approximation and gives less than 40% of the bond dissociation energy.As emphasized by Petar Grujic, the bold, perplexing enterprise by Niels Bohr motivated much further work melding classical and quantum mechanics. We note that D-scaling has a distinctive character. It might aptly be termed “semiquantum” rather than semiclassical. Although in the large-D limit the equations become classical, quantum mechanics is hidden in the D-dependent units adopted for distance and energy. At that limit, electrons take fixed positions in the D-scaled space and the first-order correction in (1/D) has them execute harmonic vibrations about those positions. In the prequantum era, such behavior was postulated by Gilbert Lewis and Irving Langmuir,44. P. Coffey, Cathedrals of Science: The Personalities and Rivalries That Made Modern Chemistry, Oxford U. Press, New York (2008), chap. 5, esp. p. 139. motivated by chemical arguments but disdained by physicists and considered incompatible with the Bohr model.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. See, for example, S. Kais, R. Bleil, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 7472 (1995); https://doi.org/10.1063/1.469059, Google ScholarCrossref, ISID. K. Watson, D. Z. Goodson, Phys. Rev. A 51, R5 (1995), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.51.R5, , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. See D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys. 84, 838 (1986), for analysis of the papers cited in reference 1 of Mlodinow’s letter. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.450584, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. P. Coffey, Cathedrals of Science: The Personalities and Rivalries That Made Modern Chemistry, Oxford U. Press, New York (2008), chap. 5, esp. p. 139. Google Scholar© 2014 American Institute of Physics.
Abstract The famous paper (Ising in Z Phys 31: 253, A translation to English is by Jane Ising, Tom Cummings, Ulrich Harsch is found Bibliotheca Augustina 2001/02 https://www.hs-augsburg.de/~harsch/anglica/Chronology/20thC/Ising/isi_fm00.html , 1928) contains only a greatly reduced version of the material presented in his thesis. Looking at it therefore provides new insights into the Ising model in terms of its later implications. The method of calculating the partition function from the configuration of the system succeeds by finding a polynomial whose largest root defines the result in the thermodynamic limit and which coincides with the characteristic polynomial of the transfer matrix. This matrix works with the states of the elementary elements of the model and was found later in 1941 by Kramers and Wannier. Ising used his method for several one-dimensional models—variants of the Ising chain: a chain with three instead of two states (a forerunner of the Potts model formulated 1952), the Ising ladder given by two interacting chains and the Ising chain with next nearest-neighbor interaction published by Montroll in 1941. The largest root could not be found in all cases and approximations had to be made. Although no phase transition at finite temperature was found for the Ising chain, it turned out in the following decades that there is a critical point at T=0T=0T=0 T = 0 . Thus, the simple Ising chain can be used to study all properties approaching a transition point in this exactly solvable model. The historical introduction to the problem, given by Ising in his dissertation, goes back to Richard Kirwan (1733–1812), who was the first to associate ferromagnetism with the ordering of interacting magnetic elements similar to crystallization. Graphical abstract
SCHUCKING AND VON MEYENN REPLY: Yes, indeed, it was at the Solvay Conference in 1930 that Bohr reminded Einstein of his elevator. How the wrong date crept into our manuscript baffles us still.Kurt Gottfried is surprised that Pauli thought of Dirac as a formalist. Dirac was a formalist. He wrote in 1931: “The most powerful method of advance that can be suggested at present is to employ all the resources of pure mathematics in attempts to perfect and generalize the mathematical formalism that forms the existing basis of theoretical physics, and after each success in this direction, to try to interpret the new mathematical features in terms of physical entities.” 1 1. P. A. M. Dirac, Proc. R. Soc. A 133, 60 (1931) https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1931.0130. We disagree with Gottfried’s characterization of the Pauli equation for the electron as merely an elegant restatement of a Heisenberg–Jordan paper. Paul Ehrenfest wrote on 25 March 1931 about the Pauli equation: “This work has become very important. It has opened the way to Dirac’s ingenious work on the spin-electrons and probably also to Heisenberg’s famous work about the helium spectrum.” 2 2. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 2, K. von Meyenn, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1985) p. 71. Pauli introduced spinors into quantum mechanics and thus—in hindsight—made the step from two to four components not such a giant leap.We agree with Gottfried that the golden rule 3 3. K. Gottfried, Quantum Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, Calif. (1989), eq. 35, p. 444. is due to Dirac. When Pauli derived this equation using Dirac’s time-dependent perturbation theory, he analyzed its domain of validity using the uncertainty relation for time and energy that he had first pointed out in a letter to Heisenberg. Apparently, Pauli and Heisenberg 4 4. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 1, A. Hermann, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1979), p. 460. had first thought that Dirac had “gemogelt” (cheated) in its derivation.We both cherish Dirac’s beautiful physics, but his approach to theory was different from Pauli’s or Heisenberg’s. By praising Galileo, one does not demean Kepler.On Dirac’s comment about Schrödinger, we stand corrected. Luis Boya also may have a point on vacuum degeneracy. But Pauli’s crucial role in the Heisenberg theory still needs clarification. There are 144 letters from the correspondence between Pauli and Heisenberg in 1957 and 1958, up to 30 pages in length, which still await analysis.With regard to the early history of quantum field theory, we agree that much more could be said about it, and we refer Boya to Tian Yu Cao. 5 5. T. Y. Cao, Conceptual Developments of 20th Century Field Theories, Cambridge U. Press, New York (1997) https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511563997. For the history of nuclear magnetism, we suggest that Boya might consult Hendrik Casimir. 6 6. H. Casimir, Haphazard Reality, Harper & Row, New York (1983); appendix B, p. 322. Boya remarks that Heisenberg “never tried using his newborn matrix mechanics to solve for the hydrogen spectrum.” On 3 November 1925 Heisenberg wrote to Pauli: “After your first letter, I had also tried at once the calculation in three dimensions and was busy just this afternoon with the evaluation of the last equations and the elimination of the many possible mistakes in calculation when the postman entered and made my work superfluous.” 7 7. See ref. 4, p. 252. The postman had brought Pauli’s three-dimensional calculation for the H-atom. We believe that Boya underrates the role Pauli played in the dialogue with Heisenberg and that a careful reading of their correspondence supports our view. Freeman Dyson, with his unique insight into physics and the ways of physicists seems to agree with our assessment.Finally, we thank Gottfried, Boya, and Dyson for their comments.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<1. P. A. M. Dirac, Proc. R. Soc. A 133, 60 (1931) https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.1931.0130. Google ScholarCrossref, CAS2. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 2, K. von Meyenn, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1985) p. 71. Google Scholar3. K. Gottfried, Quantum Mechanics, Addison-Wesley, Redwood City, Calif. (1989), eq. 35, p. 444. Google Scholar4. W. Pauli, Scientific Correspondence, Vol. 1, A. Hermann, ed., Springer-Verlag, New York (1979), p. 460. Google Scholar5. T. Y. Cao, Conceptual Developments of 20th Century Field Theories, Cambridge U. Press, New York (1997) https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511563997. Google ScholarCrossref6. H. Casimir, Haphazard Reality, Harper & Row, New York (1983); appendix B, p. 322. Google Scholar7. See ref. 4, p. 252. Google Scholar© 2001 American Institute of Physics.