Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Communications in Theoretical Physics

Logarithm Versus Square Root: Comparing Quantum Fisher Information

Shun Luo

Published Apr 1, 2007• 12 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In classical statistics, the Fisher information is unique in the sense that it is essentially the only monotone Riemannian metric on the space of probability densities. In quantum theory, this uniqueness breaks down, and there are many natural quantum analogues of the Fisher information, among which two particular versions distinguish themselves by their intuitive and informational significance: The first has its origin in the skew information introduced by Wigner and Yanase in 1963 in the context of quantum measurement, and is defined via the square root of the density operator. The second arises from Helstrom's study of quantum detection in 1967, and is defined via the symmetric logarithmic derivative. The aim of this paper is to compare these two versions of quantum Fisher information, and to establish two informational inequalities relating them.

DOI
10.1088/0253-6102/47/4/005

Related papers

Wigner-Yanase skew information vs. quantum Fisher information

Shunlong Luo

Among concepts describing the information contents of quantum mechanical density operators, both the Wigner-Yanase skew information and the quantum Fisher information defined via symmetric logarithmic derivatives are natural generalizations of the classical Fisher information. We will establish a relationship between these two fundamental quantities and show that they are comparable.

Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society•Jul 7, 2003•202 citations

Fisher Information of Wavefunctions: Classical and Quantum

骆顺龙

A parametric quantum mechanical wavefunction naturally induces parametric probability distributions by taking absolute square, and we can consider its classical Fisher information. On the other hand, it also induces parametric rank-one projections which may be viewed as density operators, and we can talk about its quantum Fisher information. Among many versions of quantum Fisher information, there are two prominent ones. The first, defined via a quantum score function, was introduced by Helstrom in 1967 and is well known. The second, defined via the square root of the density operator, has its origin in the skew information introduced by Wigner and Yanase in 1963 and remains relatively unnoticed. This study is devoted to investigating the relationships between the classical Fisher information and these two versions of quantum Fisher information for wavefunctions. It is shown that the two versions of quantum Fisher information differ by a factor 2 and that they dominate the classical Fisher information. The non-coincidence of these two versions of quantum Fisher information may be interpreted as a manifestation of quantum discord. We further calculate the difference between the Helstrom quantum Fisher information and the classical Fisher information, and show that it is precisely the instantaneous phase fluctuation of the wavefunctions.

Chinese Physics Letters•Nov 29, 2006•21 citations

Quantum covariance via quantum information

Xia-Yun Gui, Yi C. Huang

Abstract For a quantum state and a set of observables, S. Luo found a matrix inequality linking the quantum covariance and the quantum Fisher information defined via the symmetric logarithmic derivatives. In this paper, we provide the corresponding matrix inequality based on the Wigner–Yanase skew information.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 6, 2023•1 citation

Skew Information Revisited: Its Variants and a Comparison of Them

Shunlong Luo, Yuan Sun

Skew information was introduced by Wigner and Yanase in the context of quantum measurements. It was later recognized that skew information in addition to its original significance as a measure of the information content of states admits several interpretations of a more physical and information theory nature. This quantity has now found many applications in quantum information. An intriguing and subtle feature of skew information is the involvement of the square root of quantum states (density operators). Comparing skew information with some of its natural modifications reveals mathematical and also physical reasons for using the square root. We further use skew information to quantify the asymmetry of quantum states with respect to group representations.

Theoretical and Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 2020•21 citations

On the Relation between Kullback Divergence and Fisher Information: From Classical Systems to Quantum Systems

Hiroshi Nagaoka

Kullback divergence D(p ∥ q) for a couple of probability distributions {p, q} and Fisher information J(θ) for a parametric family of probability distributions {p θ } are very important notions in the classical theory of statistical inference. Quantum analogues of these notions are known as Umegaki's relative entropy D(ρ ‖ σ) for a couple of density operators {ρ, σ} and the quantum Fisher information J(θ) based on the pymmetric logarithmic derivatives for a parametric family of density operators {ρ Θ }. In the classical case, the relation holds, which connects the asymptotic theory of hypothesis testing and that of parameter estimation. In the quantum case, the relation defines , which is not equal to J(θ) in general and is another quantum analogue of Fisher information. We show the inequality and elucidate its meaning in connection with the statistical inference for quantum states.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Feb 1, 2005•8 citations

Quantum and Fisher information from the Husimi and related distributions

Paul B. Slater

The two principal/immediate influences—which we seek to interrelate here—upon the undertaking of this study are papers of Życzkowski and Słomczyński [J. Phys. A 34, 6689 (2001)] and of Petz and Sudár [J. Math. Phys. 37, 2262 (1996)]. In the former work, a metric (the Monge one, specifically) over generalized Husimi distributions was employed to define a distance between two arbitrary density matrices. In the Petz-Sudár work (completing a program of Chentsov), the quantum analog of the (classically unique) Fisher information (monotone) metric of a probability simplex was extended to define an uncountable infinitude of Riemannian (also monotone) metrics on the set of positive definite density matrices. We pose here the questions of what is the specific/unique Fisher information metric for the (classically defined) Husimi distributions and how does it relate to the infinitude of (quantum) metrics over the density matrices of Petz and Sudár? We find a highly proximate (small relative entropy) relationship between the probability distribution (the quantum Jeffreys’ prior) that yields quantum universal data compression, and that which (following Clarke and Barron) gives its classical counterpart. We also investigate the Fisher information metrics corresponding to the escort Husimi, positive-P and certain Gaussian probability distributions, as well as, in some sense, the discrete Wigner pseudoprobability. The comparative noninformativity of prior probability distributions—recently studied by Srednicki [Phys. Rev. A 71, 052107 (2005)]—formed by normalizing the volume elements of the various information metrics, is also discussed in our context.

arXiv:quant-ph/0504066•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 2006•8 citations
In classical statistics, the Fisher information is unique in the sense that it is essentially the only monotone Riemannian metric on the space of probability densities. In quantum theory, this uniqueness breaks down, and there are many natural quantum analogues of the Fisher information, among which two particular versions distinguish themselves by their intuitive and informational significance: The first has its origin in the skew information introduced by Wigner and Yanase in 1963 in the context of quantum measurement, and is defined via the square root of the density operator. The second arises from Helstrom's study of quantum detection in 1967, and is defined via the symmetric logarithmic derivative. The aim of this paper is to compare these two versions of quantum Fisher information, and to establish two informational inequalities relating them.
A parametric quantum mechanical wavefunction naturally induces parametric probability distributions by taking absolute square, and we can consider its classical Fisher information. On the other hand, it also induces parametric rank-one projections which may be viewed as density operators, and we can talk about its quantum Fisher information. Among many versions of quantum Fisher information, there are two prominent ones. The first, defined via a quantum score function, was introduced by Helstrom in 1967 and is well known. The second, defined via the square root of the density operator, has its origin in the skew information introduced by Wigner and Yanase in 1963 and remains relatively unnoticed. This study is devoted to investigating the relationships between the classical Fisher information and these two versions of quantum Fisher information for wavefunctions. It is shown that the two versions of quantum Fisher information differ by a factor 2 and that they dominate the classical Fisher information. The non-coincidence of these two versions of quantum Fisher information may be interpreted as a manifestation of quantum discord. We further calculate the difference between the Helstrom quantum Fisher information and the classical Fisher information, and show that it is precisely the instantaneous phase fluctuation of the wavefunctions.
Skew information was introduced by Wigner and Yanase in the context of quantum measurements. It was later recognized that skew information in addition to its original significance as a measure of the information content of states admits several interpretations of a more physical and information theory nature. This quantity has now found many applications in quantum information. An intriguing and subtle feature of skew information is the involvement of the square root of quantum states (density operators). Comparing skew information with some of its natural modifications reveals mathematical and also physical reasons for using the square root. We further use skew information to quantify the asymmetry of quantum states with respect to group representations.
Kullback divergence D(p ∥ q) for a couple of probability distributions {p, q} and Fisher information J(θ) for a parametric family of probability distributions {p θ } are very important notions in the classical theory of statistical inference. Quantum analogues of these notions are known as Umegaki's relative entropy D(ρ ‖ σ) for a couple of density operators {ρ, σ} and the quantum Fisher information J(θ) based on the pymmetric logarithmic derivatives for a parametric family of density operators {ρ Θ }. In the classical case, the relation holds, which connects the asymptotic theory of hypothesis testing and that of parameter estimation. In the quantum case, the relation defines , which is not equal to J(θ) in general and is another quantum analogue of Fisher information. We show the inequality and elucidate its meaning in connection with the statistical inference for quantum states.
The two principal/immediate influences—which we seek to interrelate here—upon the undertaking of this study are papers of Życzkowski and Słomczyński [J. Phys. A 34, 6689 (2001)] and of Petz and Sudár [J. Math. Phys. 37, 2262 (1996)]. In the former work, a metric (the Monge one, specifically) over generalized Husimi distributions was employed to define a distance between two arbitrary density matrices. In the Petz-Sudár work (completing a program of Chentsov), the quantum analog of the (classically unique) Fisher information (monotone) metric of a probability simplex was extended to define an uncountable infinitude of Riemannian (also monotone) metrics on the set of positive definite density matrices. We pose here the questions of what is the specific/unique Fisher information metric for the (classically defined) Husimi distributions and how does it relate to the infinitude of (quantum) metrics over the density matrices of Petz and Sudár? We find a highly proximate (small relative entropy) relationship between the probability distribution (the quantum Jeffreys’ prior) that yields quantum universal data compression, and that which (following Clarke and Barron) gives its classical counterpart. We also investigate the Fisher information metrics corresponding to the escort Husimi, positive-P and certain Gaussian probability distributions, as well as, in some sense, the discrete Wigner pseudoprobability. The comparative noninformativity of prior probability distributions—recently studied by Srednicki [Phys. Rev. A 71, 052107 (2005)]—formed by normalizing the volume elements of the various information metrics, is also discussed in our context.