Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Proof of the Third Law of Thermodynamics for Ising Ferromagnets

Harvey S. Leff

Published Dec 1, 1970• 17 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The third law of thermodynamics is proved for a large class of Ising models with generalized ferromagnetic many-body interactions. A sufficient condition for the third law to hold is that the model have nearest-neighbor couplings which are bounded from below by a positive constant. The proof is based on a spin-correlation inequality of Griffiths which implies a corresponding inequality for the bulk entropy per spin. Ground-state degeneracy considerations are completely avoided.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.2.2368

Related papers

Spin Correlation and Entropy

Harold Falk, Masuo Suzuki

A cumulant-like expansion for the entropy of an $N$-spin system is presented. The successive terms in the expansion relate to successively higher orders of statistical association among spins. It is proved that for any Ising system of general dimensionality with ferromagnetic interactions of arbitrary range, the first two terms in the entropy expansion provide a lower bound for the exact entropy. A corollary of the theorem is that the lower-bound property is also valid for any two-sublattice Ising system with antiferromagnetic interactions between sublattices. An example is given which illustrates the fact that the vanishing of the two-spin cumulant (correlation) does not necessarily imply that the spins are statistically independent. The sum of the first two terms in the expansion is compared numerically with the exact entropy of an $N$-spin chain (and also a ring) with nearest-neighbor ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic Ising interactions. The comparison, which measures the validity of a Kirkwood-type truncation in this context, is favorable only at sufficiently high temperatures.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Apr 1, 1970•7 citations

Influence of third-nearest-neighbor interactions on the ground state of Heisenberg linear chains

Jorge M. Mesías, Eugenio Emilio Vogel

Antiferromagnetic ground-state energies for infinite Heisenberg linear chains with up to third-nearest-neighbor interactions have been determined by means of numerical extrapolations. On the other hand, new conditions to produce a ferromagnetic ground state have been established for finite chains. These conditions are expressed as lower bounds for the coupling constants. The particular case in which the coupling constant for third-nearest-neighbor interactions is zero is compared in two different ways with previous calculations by other authors, showing good correspondence.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Dec 1, 1986•1 citation

An Exact Criterion for Finite-Temperature Order in One-Dimensional Ising Ferromagnets

Qihang Wang, Ruisi Wang, Zhiyi Li +2 more

The onset of ferromagnetic order in one dimension reflects a competition between domain energy and entropy. For Ising chains with arbitrary translation-invariant, nonnegative, summable pair interactions, we establish a necessary and sufficient condition for an ordered phase at positive temperature: the energy required to reverse an interval of N spins must be bounded below by a positive multiple of ln N for all sufficiently large N. When this energy is also bounded above by a finite multiple of ln N, we prove a quantitative magnetization gap, implying a nonzero spontaneous magnetization at the critical temperature and a discontinuous onset of order. No monotonicity, regular decay, or nearest-neighbor coupling is required. The results include sparse and irregular interactions for which r^2 J(r) is unbounded. Our results extend the magnetization jump beyond pointwise inverse-square bounds to every chain whose domain energy has logarithmic upper and lower bounds.

•Oct 20, 2026•0 citations

Reducibility of an Ising Ferromagnet from Griffiths "Equalities"

N. Seto

For an Ising ferromagnet, it is shown that the correlation function between a pair of spins vanishes if and only if, irrespective of an external magnetic field, the pair decouples from each other. For the correlation functions between two- and two-body spins as well as one- and two-body spins, it is proved, in the presence of a suitable magnetic field, the vanishing of these implies the reducibility of the system.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Mar 1, 1976•2 citations

The Entropy of an Antiferromagnet in a Magnetic Field

Jill C. Bonner, Michael Ellis Fisher

The Ising model of an antiferromagnet exhibits an anomalous entropy peak at a critical magnetic field which remains even at the absolute zero of temperature, in violation of the third law of thermodynamics. By investigating numerically the behaviour of finite chains of spins interacting through the more general anisotropic Heisenberg coupling, described by the Hamiltonian provided it is shown that the zero point anomalous entropy is peculiar to the Ising model (γ = 0). If the anisotropy is sufficiently great, however, an appreciable entropy peak does persist down to low temperatures although in the anisotropic (pure Heisenberg) limit the entropy has only a broad maximum which falls steadily in height as T approaches zero.

Proceedings of the Physical Society•Aug 1, 1962•28 citations

Thermodynamics of three-dimensional Ising-like systems in the higher non-Gaussian approximation: Calculational method and dependence on microscopic parameters

I. R. Yukhnovskii, Mykhailo P. Kozlovskii, Ihor V. Pylyuk

The original collective variables method for calculating the thermodynamic characteristics of a three-dimensional Ising-like system is developed in the approximation of the sextic distribution for modes of spin-density oscillations $({\ensuremath{\rho}}^{6}$ model), taking into account the first confluent correction. The calculations within the framework of this higher non-Gaussian approximation are performed in the temperature regions above and below the critical value of ${T}_{c}$ and are illustrated by an example of a simple cubic lattice and an exponentially decreasing interaction potential. The collective variables method makes it possible to obtain universal and nonuniversal quantities by using a unified approach. The dependence of the critical region size and phase-transition temperature on the microscopic parameters is investigated. A microscopic analog of the Landau free energy is calculated. Explicit expressions for the thermodynamic characteristics are obtained as functions of temperature and microscopic parameters of the system. It is shown that each of the leading critical amplitudes and correction-to-scaling amplitudes can be represented as a product of a universal factor not depending on the microscopic parameters of the system and a nonuniversal factor depending on these parameters. The thermodynamic characteristics near ${T}_{c}$ and their amplitudes are given for various values of the effective radius of the exponentially decreasing interaction potential (including the values corresponding to the nearest-neighbor interaction and the interactions between the nearest and next-nearest neighbors and between the nearest, next-nearest, and third neighbors). The results of calculations and their comparison with other authors' data show that the ${\ensuremath{\rho}}^{6}$ model provides a better quantitative description of the critical behavior of a three-dimensional Ising ferromagnet than the ${\ensuremath{\rho}}^{4}$ model.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Oct 10, 2002•25 citations
The third law of thermodynamics is proved for a large class of Ising models with generalized ferromagnetic many-body interactions. A sufficient condition for the third law to hold is that the model have nearest-neighbor couplings which are bounded from below by a positive constant. The proof is based on a spin-correlation inequality of Griffiths which implies a corresponding inequality for the bulk entropy per spin. Ground-state degeneracy considerations are completely avoided.
A cumulant-like expansion for the entropy of an NNN-spin system is presented. The successive terms in the expansion relate to successively higher orders of statistical association among spins. It is proved that for any Ising system of general dimensionality with ferromagnetic interactions of arbitrary range, the first two terms in the entropy expansion provide a lower bound for the exact entropy. A corollary of the theorem is that the lower-bound property is also valid for any two-sublattice Ising system with antiferromagnetic interactions between sublattices. An example is given which illustrates the fact that the vanishing of the two-spin cumulant (correlation) does not necessarily imply that the spins are statistically independent. The sum of the first two terms in the expansion is compared numerically with the exact entropy of an NNN-spin chain (and also a ring) with nearest-neighbor ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic Ising interactions. The comparison, which measures the validity of a Kirkwood-type truncation in this context, is favorable only at sufficiently high temperatures.
Antiferromagnetic ground-state energies for infinite Heisenberg linear chains with up to third-nearest-neighbor interactions have been determined by means of numerical extrapolations. On the other hand, new conditions to produce a ferromagnetic ground state have been established for finite chains. These conditions are expressed as lower bounds for the coupling constants. The particular case in which the coupling constant for third-nearest-neighbor interactions is zero is compared in two different ways with previous calculations by other authors, showing good correspondence.
The onset of ferromagnetic order in one dimension reflects a competition between domain energy and entropy. For Ising chains with arbitrary translation-invariant, nonnegative, summable pair interactions, we establish a necessary and sufficient condition for an ordered phase at positive temperature: the energy required to reverse an interval of N spins must be bounded below by a positive multiple of ln N for all sufficiently large N. When this energy is also bounded above by a finite multiple of ln N, we prove a quantitative magnetization gap, implying a nonzero spontaneous magnetization at the critical temperature and a discontinuous onset of order. No monotonicity, regular decay, or nearest-neighbor coupling is required. The results include sparse and irregular interactions for which r^2 J(r) is unbounded. Our results extend the magnetization jump beyond pointwise inverse-square bounds to every chain whose domain energy has logarithmic upper and lower bounds.
The Ising model of an antiferromagnet exhibits an anomalous entropy peak at a critical magnetic field which remains even at the absolute zero of temperature, in violation of the third law of thermodynamics. By investigating numerically the behaviour of finite chains of spins interacting through the more general anisotropic Heisenberg coupling, described by the Hamiltonian provided it is shown that the zero point anomalous entropy is peculiar to the Ising model (γ = 0). If the anisotropy is sufficiently great, however, an appreciable entropy peak does persist down to low temperatures although in the anisotropic (pure Heisenberg) limit the entropy has only a broad maximum which falls steadily in height as T approaches zero.
The original collective variables method for calculating the thermodynamic characteristics of a three-dimensional Ising-like system is developed in the approximation of the sextic distribution for modes of spin-density oscillations $({\ensuremath{\rho}}^{6}$ model), taking into account the first confluent correction. The calculations within the framework of this higher non-Gaussian approximation are performed in the temperature regions above and below the critical value of Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ and are illustrated by an example of a simple cubic lattice and an exponentially decreasing interaction potential. The collective variables method makes it possible to obtain universal and nonuniversal quantities by using a unified approach. The dependence of the critical region size and phase-transition temperature on the microscopic parameters is investigated. A microscopic analog of the Landau free energy is calculated. Explicit expressions for the thermodynamic characteristics are obtained as functions of temperature and microscopic parameters of the system. It is shown that each of the leading critical amplitudes and correction-to-scaling amplitudes can be represented as a product of a universal factor not depending on the microscopic parameters of the system and a nonuniversal factor depending on these parameters. The thermodynamic characteristics near Tc{T}_{c}Tc​ and their amplitudes are given for various values of the effective radius of the exponentially decreasing interaction potential (including the values corresponding to the nearest-neighbor interaction and the interactions between the nearest and next-nearest neighbors and between the nearest, next-nearest, and third neighbors). The results of calculations and their comparison with other authors' data show that the ${\ensuremath{\rho}}^{6}$ model provides a better quantitative description of the critical behavior of a three-dimensional Ising ferromagnet than the ${\ensuremath{\rho}}^{4}$ model.