Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics

Uncertainty in Bohr's response to the Heisenberg microscope

Scott Tanona

Published Jul 8, 2004• 26 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1016/j.shpsb.2004.04.007

Related papers

Heisenberg uncertainty principle and spatial resolution of optical microscope

Volodymyr N. Borovytsky

Physics Letters A•Apr 15, 2026•0 citations

Contextual Heisenberg microscope

Jan-Åke Larsson

The Heisenberg microscope provides a powerful mental image of the measurement process of quantum mechanics (QM), attempting to explain the uncertainty relation through an uncontrollable backaction from the measurement device. However, Heisenberg's proposed backaction uses features that are not present in the QM description of the world, and according to Bohr not present in the world. Therefore, Bohr argues, the mental image proposed by Heisenberg should be avoided. Later developments by Bell and Kochen-Specker show that a model that contains the features used for the Heisenberg microscope is in principle possible but must necessarily be nonlocal and contextual. In this paper we will reexamine the measurement process within a restriction of QM known as Stabilizer QM (SQM), that still exhibits, for example, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger nonlocality and Peres-Mermin contextuality. The reexamination will use a recent extension of SQM, the Contextual Ontological Model (COM), where the system state gives a complete description of future measurement outcomes reproducing the quantum predictions, including the mentioned phenomena. We will see that the resulting contextual Heisenberg microscope backaction can be completely described within COM, and that the associated randomness originates in the initial state of the pointer system, exactly as in the original description of the Heisenberg microscope. The presence of contextuality, usually seen as prohibiting ontological models, suggests that the contextual Heisenberg microscope picture could perhaps be enabled in general QM.

arXiv:2504.20816•Physical Review A•Mar 27, 2026•1 citation

The Bohr-Heisenberg Meeting from a Distance

Finn Aaserud

•Jan 1, 2002•0 citations

The uncertainty principle and the Bohr theory

T. Tietz

Acta Physica Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae•Sep 1, 1961•0 citations

Complementarity and uncertainty relations for matter-wave interferometry

Karl-Peter Marzlin, Barry C. Sanders, P. L. Knight

We establish a rigorous quantitative connection between (i) the interferometric duality relation for which-way information and fringe visibility and (ii) Heisenberg's uncertainty relation for position and modular momentum. We apply our theory to atom interferometry, wherein spontaneously emitted photons provide which-way information and unambiguously resolve the challenge posed by the metamaterial ``perfect lens'' to complementarity and to the Heisenberg-Bohr interpretation of the Heisenberg microscope thought experiment.

arXiv:0709.0613•Physical Review A•Dec 9, 2008•7 citations

A Heisenberg Microscope for Atoms

Christian Kurtsiefer, Tilman Pfau, Stefan J. Spalter +2 more

Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences•Apr 1, 1995•6 citations
The Heisenberg microscope provides a powerful mental image of the measurement process of quantum mechanics (QM), attempting to explain the uncertainty relation through an uncontrollable backaction from the measurement device. However, Heisenberg's proposed backaction uses features that are not present in the QM description of the world, and according to Bohr not present in the world. Therefore, Bohr argues, the mental image proposed by Heisenberg should be avoided. Later developments by Bell and Kochen-Specker show that a model that contains the features used for the Heisenberg microscope is in principle possible but must necessarily be nonlocal and contextual. In this paper we will reexamine the measurement process within a restriction of QM known as Stabilizer QM (SQM), that still exhibits, for example, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger nonlocality and Peres-Mermin contextuality. The reexamination will use a recent extension of SQM, the Contextual Ontological Model (COM), where the system state gives a complete description of future measurement outcomes reproducing the quantum predictions, including the mentioned phenomena. We will see that the resulting contextual Heisenberg microscope backaction can be completely described within COM, and that the associated randomness originates in the initial state of the pointer system, exactly as in the original description of the Heisenberg microscope. The presence of contextuality, usually seen as prohibiting ontological models, suggests that the contextual Heisenberg microscope picture could perhaps be enabled in general QM.
We establish a rigorous quantitative connection between (i) the interferometric duality relation for which-way information and fringe visibility and (ii) Heisenberg's uncertainty relation for position and modular momentum. We apply our theory to atom interferometry, wherein spontaneously emitted photons provide which-way information and unambiguously resolve the challenge posed by the metamaterial ``perfect lens'' to complementarity and to the Heisenberg-Bohr interpretation of the Heisenberg microscope thought experiment.