Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review B

Role of quadratic terms in the Heisenberg model for quantum spin dynamics

Robert Wieser

Published Aug 4, 2011• 15 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The dynamics of the expectation value of a spin operator ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{\mathbf{S}}}_{n}$ in the quantum mechanical Heisenberg model has been compared with the trajectory of the corresponding classical spin ${\mathbf{S}}_{n}$. A Hamilton operator $\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{\mathcal{H}}$ linear in the spin operator ${\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{\mathbf{S}}}_{n}$ shows a perfect agreement between quantum mechanical and classical trajectories. Quadratic or higher-order terms in the Hamilton operator lead to disagreement. The corresponding correction term can be found for different physical descriptions and methods dealing with the quantum mechanical Heisenberg model.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.84.054411

Related papers

Comparison of Quantum and Classical Relaxation in Spin Dynamics

Robert Wieser

The classical Landau-Lifshitz equation with a damping term has been derived from the time evolution of a quantum mechanical wave function under the assumption of a non-Hermitian Hamilton operator. Further, the trajectory of a classical spin (S) has been compared with the expectation value of the spin operator (Ŝ). A good agreement between classical and quantum mechanical trajectories can be found for Hamiltonians linear in Ŝ or S, respectively. Quadratic or higher order terms in the Hamiltonian result in a disagreement.

arXiv:1302.1985•Physical Review Letters•Apr 2, 2013•34 citations

Quasiclassical Spin Dynamics for the Heisenberg Model

Yao-Chung Chang, George C. Summerfield, D. M. Kaplan

The Wigner method is employed to develop explicit relationships among quantum-mechanical and classical equations of motion and quantum-mechanical and classical pair-correlation functions of spin operators. In this method, quantum corrections to the classical theory can be accurately estimated. The formalism is applied to a spin-\textonehalf{} Heisenberg model at high temperatures. The most attractive feature of this method is that many of the results are intuitively satisfying. Finally, we make a connection between our results and the classical calculations made by several other authors.

Physical review. B, Solid state•May 1, 1971•9 citations

Comparison between quantum and classical dynamics in the effective action formalism

Fabrizio Cametti, Giovanni Jona-Lasinio, Carlo Presilla A +1 more

A major difficulty in comparing quantum and classical behavior resides in the struc- tural differences between the corresponding mathematical languages. The Heisenberg equations of motion are operator equations only formally identical to the classical equations of motion. By taking the expectation of these equations, the well-known Ehrenfest theorem provides identities which, however, are not a closed system of equations which allows to evaluate the time evolution of the system. The formalism of the effective action seems to offer a possibility of comparing quantum and classical evolutions in a system- atic and logically consistent way by naturally providing approximation schemes for the expectations of the coordinates which at the zeroth order coincide with the classical evolution [1]. The effective action formalism leads to equations of motion which differ from the classical equations by the addition of terms nonlocal in the time variable. This means that for these equations an initial value problem is not meaningful and they have to be interpreted in an appropriate way. Here we analyze situations in which the nonlocal terms can be reasonably approximated by local ones, so that the quantum corrections do not modify the locality of classical equations. In the simplest approximation, the effective Lagrangian differs from the corresponding classical one by a renormalization of both the potential- and the kinetic-energy terms. We shall not discuss the causal formalism used, for example, in refs. [2-4], as in the approximation considered this would lead to the same local equations. The present contribution describes the beginning of a systematic study of semiclassical evolutions using the effective action formalism. In the first part, after introducing the formalism of the effective action and its expansion in powers of hbar (loop expansion) in the context of quantum mechanics, we concentrate on the structure of the first-order corrections in li. These corrections are evaluated to the second order in the derivative expansion [5], by two different methods. The first is based on a Euclidean approach [6], the second one on an adiabatic approximation in evaluating functional determinants. In the second part of the article we put the formalism at work, choosing as our case study a two-dimensional (2D) anharmonic oscillator of the kind considered in molecular physics. The results of the simulations show that by increasing lithe effective dynamics tends to regularize the classical motion and becomes qualitatively very similar to the quantum evolution provided the energy is sufficiently small. The evaluation of the effective dynamics in more general cases will be presented in a forthcoming paper.

arXiv:quant-ph/9910065•Oct 14, 1999•41 citations

Heisenberg dynamics of mixed quantum-classical systems

David Martínez-Crespo, Cesare Tronci

Abstract We consider the dynamics of interacting quantum and classical systems in the Heisenberg representation. Unlike the usual construction in standard quantum mechanics, mixed quantum-classical systems involve the interplay of unitary operators acting on the quantum observables and the Lagrangian trajectories sweeping the classical degrees of freedom. This interplay reflects an intricate structure which is made particularly challenging by the backreaction excerpted on the classical trajectories by the quantum degrees of freedom. While the backreaction is underestimated in the common Ehrenfest model, more recent methodologies succeed in capturing this important effect by resorting to Koopman wavefunctions in classical mechanics. Luckily, both Ehrenfest and Koopman models enjoy a variational framework which is exploited here to unfold the geometric structure underlying quantum-classical coupling. A special role is played by the action of the diffeomorphic Lagrangian paths on a non-Abelian pure-gauge potential which comprises statistical correlations. After presenting the treatment in the simple case of Ehrenfest dynamics, we move on to the Koopman model and present the role of the backreaction terms therein. Finally, we compare both models in the context of pure-dephasing systems.

arXiv:2405.10653•The European Physical Journal Plus•Jun 24, 2025•3 citations

Examination of classical simulations for Heisenberg-Langevin equations for spin-1/2

Scott D. Linz, Jochen Gemmer

A system of spins coupled to a bath is a traditional setup in open quantum systems. Through Heisenberg's equation, the spin dynamics can be modeled by a set of first-order differential equations. Interpreting the terms as colored noise and non-Markovian damping, one can write them as quantummechanical Heisenberg-Langevin (HL) equations. These are notoriously difficult to solve because of the high dimensionality of the Hilbert space. Classical generalized Langevin equations, involving non-Markovian damping and colored noise, are well understood and can be treated numerically with relative ease. Thus, a classical ansatz can be made by substituting quantum expectation values with classical functions. This allows the application of standard methods developed for classical stochastic dynamical systems to tackle spin dynamics. However, this approach is uncontrolled and should be benchmarked against known quantum dynamics. In this investigation, a Hamiltonian for spin dynamics is modified to obtain a setup analogous to the Weisskopf-Wigner (WW) theory of spontaneous emission, enabling a comparison of the results. This will be compared for T = 0 and with a slight adaptation in the high-temperature limit.

quant-pharXiv:2603.04526•APS Open Science•Mar 6, 2026•0 citations

Particle Spin Described by Quantum Hamilton Equations

Michael Beyer, Wolfgang Paul

Abstract The anomalous Zeeman effect made it clear that charged particles like the electron possess a magnetic dipole moment. Classically, this could be understood if the charged particle possesses an eigenrotation, that is, spin. Within Nelson's stochastic mechanics, it was shown that the model of a rotating charged ball is able to reproduce the well‐known spin expectation values. This classically motivated model of intrinsic rotation described in terms of a stochastic process is revisited here within the formalism of stochastic optimal control theory. Quantum Hamilton equations (QHE) for spinning particles are derived, which reduce to their classical counterpart in the zero quantum noise limit. These equations enable the calculation of the common spin expectation values without the use of the wave function. They also offer information on the orientation dynamics of the magnetic moment of charged particles beyond the behavior of the spin averages.

Annalen der Physik•Dec 14, 2022•5 citations
The dynamics of the expectation value of a spin operator S\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fin{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{\mathbf{S}}}_{n}S\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi​n​ in the quantum mechanical Heisenberg model has been compared with the trajectory of the corresponding classical spin Sn{\mathbf{S}}_{n}Sn​. A Hamilton operator H\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{\mathcal{H}}H\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi​ linear in the spin operator S\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fin{\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{\mathbf{S}}}_{n}S\ifmmode^\elseˆ\fi​n​ shows a perfect agreement between quantum mechanical and classical trajectories. Quadratic or higher-order terms in the Hamilton operator lead to disagreement. The corresponding correction term can be found for different physical descriptions and methods dealing with the quantum mechanical Heisenberg model.
The classical Landau-Lifshitz equation with a damping term has been derived from the time evolution of a quantum mechanical wave function under the assumption of a non-Hermitian Hamilton operator. Further, the trajectory of a classical spin (S) has been compared with the expectation value of the spin operator (Ŝ). A good agreement between classical and quantum mechanical trajectories can be found for Hamiltonians linear in Ŝ or S, respectively. Quadratic or higher order terms in the Hamiltonian result in a disagreement.
The Wigner method is employed to develop explicit relationships among quantum-mechanical and classical equations of motion and quantum-mechanical and classical pair-correlation functions of spin operators. In this method, quantum corrections to the classical theory can be accurately estimated. The formalism is applied to a spin-\textonehalf{} Heisenberg model at high temperatures. The most attractive feature of this method is that many of the results are intuitively satisfying. Finally, we make a connection between our results and the classical calculations made by several other authors.
A major difficulty in comparing quantum and classical behavior resides in the struc- tural differences between the corresponding mathematical languages. The Heisenberg equations of motion are operator equations only formally identical to the classical equations of motion. By taking the expectation of these equations, the well-known Ehrenfest theorem provides identities which, however, are not a closed system of equations which allows to evaluate the time evolution of the system. The formalism of the effective action seems to offer a possibility of comparing quantum and classical evolutions in a system- atic and logically consistent way by naturally providing approximation schemes for the expectations of the coordinates which at the zeroth order coincide with the classical evolution [1]. The effective action formalism leads to equations of motion which differ from the classical equations by the addition of terms nonlocal in the time variable. This means that for these equations an initial value problem is not meaningful and they have to be interpreted in an appropriate way. Here we analyze situations in which the nonlocal terms can be reasonably approximated by local ones, so that the quantum corrections do not modify the locality of classical equations. In the simplest approximation, the effective Lagrangian differs from the corresponding classical one by a renormalization of both the potential- and the kinetic-energy terms. We shall not discuss the causal formalism used, for example, in refs. [2-4], as in the approximation considered this would lead to the same local equations. The present contribution describes the beginning of a systematic study of semiclassical evolutions using the effective action formalism. In the first part, after introducing the formalism of the effective action and its expansion in powers of hbar (loop expansion) in the context of quantum mechanics, we concentrate on the structure of the first-order corrections in li. These corrections are evaluated to the second order in the derivative expansion [5], by two different methods. The first is based on a Euclidean approach [6], the second one on an adiabatic approximation in evaluating functional determinants. In the second part of the article we put the formalism at work, choosing as our case study a two-dimensional (2D) anharmonic oscillator of the kind considered in molecular physics. The results of the simulations show that by increasing lithe effective dynamics tends to regularize the classical motion and becomes qualitatively very similar to the quantum evolution provided the energy is sufficiently small. The evaluation of the effective dynamics in more general cases will be presented in a forthcoming paper.
Abstract We consider the dynamics of interacting quantum and classical systems in the Heisenberg representation. Unlike the usual construction in standard quantum mechanics, mixed quantum-classical systems involve the interplay of unitary operators acting on the quantum observables and the Lagrangian trajectories sweeping the classical degrees of freedom. This interplay reflects an intricate structure which is made particularly challenging by the backreaction excerpted on the classical trajectories by the quantum degrees of freedom. While the backreaction is underestimated in the common Ehrenfest model, more recent methodologies succeed in capturing this important effect by resorting to Koopman wavefunctions in classical mechanics. Luckily, both Ehrenfest and Koopman models enjoy a variational framework which is exploited here to unfold the geometric structure underlying quantum-classical coupling. A special role is played by the action of the diffeomorphic Lagrangian paths on a non-Abelian pure-gauge potential which comprises statistical correlations. After presenting the treatment in the simple case of Ehrenfest dynamics, we move on to the Koopman model and present the role of the backreaction terms therein. Finally, we compare both models in the context of pure-dephasing systems.
A system of spins coupled to a bath is a traditional setup in open quantum systems. Through Heisenberg's equation, the spin dynamics can be modeled by a set of first-order differential equations. Interpreting the terms as colored noise and non-Markovian damping, one can write them as quantummechanical Heisenberg-Langevin (HL) equations. These are notoriously difficult to solve because of the high dimensionality of the Hilbert space. Classical generalized Langevin equations, involving non-Markovian damping and colored noise, are well understood and can be treated numerically with relative ease. Thus, a classical ansatz can be made by substituting quantum expectation values with classical functions. This allows the application of standard methods developed for classical stochastic dynamical systems to tackle spin dynamics. However, this approach is uncontrolled and should be benchmarked against known quantum dynamics. In this investigation, a Hamiltonian for spin dynamics is modified to obtain a setup analogous to the Weisskopf-Wigner (WW) theory of spontaneous emission, enabling a comparison of the results. This will be compared for T = 0 and with a slight adaptation in the high-temperature limit.
Abstract The anomalous Zeeman effect made it clear that charged particles like the electron possess a magnetic dipole moment. Classically, this could be understood if the charged particle possesses an eigenrotation, that is, spin. Within Nelson's stochastic mechanics, it was shown that the model of a rotating charged ball is able to reproduce the well‐known spin expectation values. This classically motivated model of intrinsic rotation described in terms of a stochastic process is revisited here within the formalism of stochastic optimal control theory. Quantum Hamilton equations (QHE) for spinning particles are derived, which reduce to their classical counterpart in the zero quantum noise limit. These equations enable the calculation of the common spin expectation values without the use of the wave function. They also offer information on the orientation dynamics of the magnetic moment of charged particles beyond the behavior of the spin averages.