Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Nonorthogonal orbital based N-body reduced density matrices and their applications to valence bond theory. I. Hamiltonian matrix elements between internally contracted excited valence bond wave functions

Zhenhua Chen, Xun Chen, Wei Wu

Published Apr 26, 2013• 40 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this series, the n-body reduced density matrix (n-RDM) approach for nonorthogonal orbitals and their applications to ab initio valence bond (VB) methods are presented. As the first paper of this series, Hamiltonian matrix elements between internally contracted VB wave functions are explicitly provided by means of nonorthogonal orbital based RDM approach. To this end, a more generalized Wick's theorem, called enhanced Wick's theorem, is presented both in arithmetical and in graphical forms, by which the deduction of expressions for the matrix elements between internally contracted VB wave functions is dramatically simplified, and the matrix elements are finally expressed in terms of tensor contractions of electronic integrals and n-RDMs of the reference VB self-consistent field wave function. A string-based algorithm is developed for the purpose of evaluating n-RDMs in an efficient way. Using the techniques presented in this paper, one is able to develop new methods and efficient algorithms for nonorthogonal orbital based many-electron theory much easier than by use of the first quantized formulism.

DOI
10.1063/1.4801631

Related papers

Generalized nonorthogonal matrix elements: Unifying Wick’s theorem and the Slater–Condon rules

Hugh G. A. Burton

Matrix elements between nonorthogonal Slater determinants represent an essential component of many emerging electronic structure methods. However, evaluating nonorthogonal matrix elements is conceptually and computationally harder than their orthogonal counterparts. While several different approaches have been developed, these are predominantly derived from the first-quantized generalized Slater-Condon rules and usually require biorthogonal occupied orbitals to be computed for each matrix element. For coupling terms between nonorthogonal excited configurations, a second-quantized approach such as the nonorthogonal Wick's theorem is more desirable, but this fails when the two reference determinants have a zero many-body overlap. In this contribution, we derive an entirely generalized extension to the nonorthogonal Wick's theorem that is applicable to all pairs of determinants with nonorthogonal orbitals. Our approach creates a universal methodology for evaluating any nonorthogonal matrix element and allows Wick's theorem and the generalized Slater-Condon rules to be unified for the first time. Furthermore, we present a simple well-defined protocol for deriving arbitrary coupling terms between nonorthogonal excited configurations. In the case of overlap and one-body operators, this protocol recovers efficient formulas with reduced scaling, promising significant computational acceleration for methods that rely on such terms.

arXiv:2101.10944•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Apr 13, 2021•29 citations

Parametrization of the two-electron reduced density matrix for its direct calculation without the many-electron wave function: Generalizations and applications

David A. Mazziotti

An improved parametrization of the two-electron reduced density matrix (2-RDM) [D. A. Mazziotti, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 253002 (2008)] was recently shown to yield energies and properties that are markedly better than those calculated by traditional ab initio methods of similar computational scaling. In this paper a family of such energy functionals, generalizing the ones obtained previously, is derived through the use of (i) $p$-particle contraction relations based on the contraction of the cumulant expansions of $p$-particle RDMs and (ii) Cauchy-Schwarz relations that arise from an important set of $N$-representability constraints known as the two-positivity conditions. The 2-RDMs are explicitly parameterized in terms of the first-order part of the cumulant 2-RDM and, for the inclusion of single excitations, a second-order part of the 1-RDM. In contrast to earlier formulations based on the coefficients from configuration interaction with single and double excitations (CISD), the cumulant-based parametric 2-RDM methods, from the properties of cumulants, are rigorously size extensive. We also show that writing the energy functionals in terms of correlated 1-RDMs and cumulant 2-RDMs reduces the computational cost of the parametric 2-RDM methods to that of CISD. Applications are made to ground-state energies of several molecules, equilibrium bond distances, and frequencies of HF, ${\mathrm{F}}_{2}$, and CO, the relative energy of the cis and trans isomers of ${\mathrm{HO}}_{3}$${}^{\ensuremath{-}}$, and the HCN-HNC isomerization reaction. For bond breaking in hydrogen fluoride the improved and more efficient parametric 2-RDM methods yield energies with similar accuracies at both equilibrium and nonequilibrium geometries in 6-31G** and polarized valence quadruple-$\ensuremath{\zeta}$ basis sets. Computed 2-RDMs very nearly satisfy well-known $N$-representability conditions.

Physical Review A•Jun 30, 2010•52 citations

Many-body valence-bond theory

Douglas J. Klein, H. Zhu, Roser Valentí +1 more

The classical theory of chemical valence, first, is naturally formalized in mathematics in the area of graph theory and, second, finds an extension in quantum mechanics in terms of the Heitler–London–Pauling “valence-bond” (VB) theory. Thus, VB theory stands in a fairly unique position, although in quantum chemistry, there often has been a preference for the alternative (perhaps even “complementary”) molecular orbital (MO) theory, presumably in large part because of computational efficacy for general molecular structures. Indeed, as formulated by Pauling and others, VB theory was described as a configuration interaction (CI) problem when there were multiple relevant classical valence structures for the same molecular structure. Also, as now recognized, a direct assault on CI is computationally intensive, prone to size-inconsistency problems, and effectively limited to smaller systems—whereas indirect approaches, e.g., via wave-function cluster expansions or renormalization-group theory, often neatly avoid these problems. Thus, what is (and perhaps always has been) needed is “many-body” schemes for VB computations (as well as for higher-order MO-based approaches, too). Here, then, certain such many-body VB-amenable computational schemes are to be discussed, in the context of semiempirical (explicitly correlated) graphical models. The collection of models are described and interrelated in a fairly comprehensive systematic manner. A selection of many-body cluster expansion methods are then discussed with special reference to resonating VB wave functions and the fundamental graph-theoretic nature of the consequent problems (such as also are noted to arise in lattice-discretized statistical-mechanical problems, too). Some examples are described incorporating resonance among exponentially great numbers of VB structures as applied: for large icosahedral-symmetry fullerenic structures, for the (polyacetylenic) linear chain, and for ladderlike conjugated polymers. It is contended that practicable many-body VB-theoretic methods are now available, retaining clear links to classical chemical valence theory. Hopefully, too, these methods may soon find use beyond the semi-empirical framework. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quant Chem 65: 421–438, 1997

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jan 1, 1997•28 citations

THE VARIATIONAL TWO-ELECTRON REDUCED-DENSITY-MATRIX METHOD FOR EXTENDED SYSTEMS

Nicholas C. Rubin

In this thesis we develop the variational two-electron reduced-density-matrix method for extended systems. Extended systems are represented in two ways: i) lattice models describing the dominant valence electronic structure with periodic boundaries to account for their extended nature and ii) a crystalline-orbital basis built from atomic orbitals using the generalization of molecular orbital theory to polymers. The first part of this thesis (Ch. 3-4) examines the performance of the variational 2-RDM method on lattice systems with tunable electron correlation. The first of these systems is the classic Hubbard model with linear and ladder lattice topologies. Because electron correlation functions, such as charge- and spin-ordering, are linear functions of the 2-RDM, the difference in electronic structure between one- and quasi-one-dimensional systems is accurately characterized. The second model contains only two-body interactions and is unique among typical spin models in that it does not have a mean-field reference wave function. The ground state wave functions from all Hamiltonians in the model have the same 1-electron reduced density matrix; consequently, one-electron theories are largely inapplicable. The superconducting eta-pairing ground states make the model a unique tool for demonstrating the necessary N-representability in highly correlated environments. The second part of this thesis (Ch. 5-6) develops a formalism for modeling materials by solving the full Schrodinger equation. Crystalline-orbital Hartree-Fock provides a set of orbitals and integral tensors for the variational 2-RDM method. We demonstrate that time-reversal symmetry, which is implicitly included in position space electronic structure calculations, must be explicitly included as an N-representability constraint on the 2-RDM when using a momentum space basis. The necessity of these equality constraints is demonstrated by the accurate recovery of the binding energy of two polymers and the symmetry of their natural orbital occupations.

•Jan 1, 2016•0 citations

Reduced density matrices for valence-bond wave functions

Walter R. Thorson, J. H. Choi, R. B. Hake

First and second-order reduced density matrices, and their eigenvalues and eigenvectors, have been obtained for resonating valence-bond wave functions for N-membered rings of atoms with one orbital site and one electron per atom (one-dimensional lattice system). Such a wave function offers a good description of the electron correlation which dominates behavior at very low electron density (large atomic spacing). Results are compared briefly with the amo model.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jun 18, 2009•6 citations

Jordan-Wigner mapping for nonorthogonal spin orbitals

Alessandro Genoni, Mosè Casalegno, Piero Macchi +1 more

Quantum computing offers a promising platform to address the computational challenges inherent in quantum chemistry, and particularly in valence bond (VB) methods, which are chemically appealing but suffer from high computational cost due to the use of nonorthogonal orbitals. While various fermionic-to-spin mappings exist for orthonormal spin orbitals, such as the widely used Jordan–Wigner transformations, an analogous framework for nonorthogonal spin orbitals remains undeveloped. In this work, we propose an alternative Jordan–Wigner-type mapping tailored for the nonorthogonal case, with the goal of enabling efficient quantum simulations of VB-type wavefunctions. Our approach paves the way towards the development of chemically interpretable and computationally feasible valence bond algorithms on near-term quantum devices.

•Jul 3, 2025•0 citations
In this series, the n-body reduced density matrix (n-RDM) approach for nonorthogonal orbitals and their applications to ab initio valence bond (VB) methods are presented. As the first paper of this series, Hamiltonian matrix elements between internally contracted VB wave functions are explicitly provided by means of nonorthogonal orbital based RDM approach. To this end, a more generalized Wick's theorem, called enhanced Wick's theorem, is presented both in arithmetical and in graphical forms, by which the deduction of expressions for the matrix elements between internally contracted VB wave functions is dramatically simplified, and the matrix elements are finally expressed in terms of tensor contractions of electronic integrals and n-RDMs of the reference VB self-consistent field wave function. A string-based algorithm is developed for the purpose of evaluating n-RDMs in an efficient way. Using the techniques presented in this paper, one is able to develop new methods and efficient algorithms for nonorthogonal orbital based many-electron theory much easier than by use of the first quantized formulism.
Matrix elements between nonorthogonal Slater determinants represent an essential component of many emerging electronic structure methods. However, evaluating nonorthogonal matrix elements is conceptually and computationally harder than their orthogonal counterparts. While several different approaches have been developed, these are predominantly derived from the first-quantized generalized Slater-Condon rules and usually require biorthogonal occupied orbitals to be computed for each matrix element. For coupling terms between nonorthogonal excited configurations, a second-quantized approach such as the nonorthogonal Wick's theorem is more desirable, but this fails when the two reference determinants have a zero many-body overlap. In this contribution, we derive an entirely generalized extension to the nonorthogonal Wick's theorem that is applicable to all pairs of determinants with nonorthogonal orbitals. Our approach creates a universal methodology for evaluating any nonorthogonal matrix element and allows Wick's theorem and the generalized Slater-Condon rules to be unified for the first time. Furthermore, we present a simple well-defined protocol for deriving arbitrary coupling terms between nonorthogonal excited configurations. In the case of overlap and one-body operators, this protocol recovers efficient formulas with reduced scaling, promising significant computational acceleration for methods that rely on such terms.
An improved parametrization of the two-electron reduced density matrix (2-RDM) [D. A. Mazziotti, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 253002 (2008)] was recently shown to yield energies and properties that are markedly better than those calculated by traditional ab initio methods of similar computational scaling. In this paper a family of such energy functionals, generalizing the ones obtained previously, is derived through the use of (i) ppp-particle contraction relations based on the contraction of the cumulant expansions of ppp-particle RDMs and (ii) Cauchy-Schwarz relations that arise from an important set of NNN-representability constraints known as the two-positivity conditions. The 2-RDMs are explicitly parameterized in terms of the first-order part of the cumulant 2-RDM and, for the inclusion of single excitations, a second-order part of the 1-RDM. In contrast to earlier formulations based on the coefficients from configuration interaction with single and double excitations (CISD), the cumulant-based parametric 2-RDM methods, from the properties of cumulants, are rigorously size extensive. We also show that writing the energy functionals in terms of correlated 1-RDMs and cumulant 2-RDMs reduces the computational cost of the parametric 2-RDM methods to that of CISD. Applications are made to ground-state energies of several molecules, equilibrium bond distances, and frequencies of HF, F2{\mathrm{F}}_{2}F2​, and CO, the relative energy of the cis and trans isomers of HO3{\mathrm{HO}}_{3}HO3​${}^{\ensuremath{-}}$, and the HCN-HNC isomerization reaction. For bond breaking in hydrogen fluoride the improved and more efficient parametric 2-RDM methods yield energies with similar accuracies at both equilibrium and nonequilibrium geometries in 6-31G** and polarized valence quadruple-$\ensuremath{\zeta}$ basis sets. Computed 2-RDMs very nearly satisfy well-known NNN-representability conditions.
The classical theory of chemical valence, first, is naturally formalized in mathematics in the area of graph theory and, second, finds an extension in quantum mechanics in terms of the Heitler–London–Pauling “valence-bond” (VB) theory. Thus, VB theory stands in a fairly unique position, although in quantum chemistry, there often has been a preference for the alternative (perhaps even “complementary”) molecular orbital (MO) theory, presumably in large part because of computational efficacy for general molecular structures. Indeed, as formulated by Pauling and others, VB theory was described as a configuration interaction (CI) problem when there were multiple relevant classical valence structures for the same molecular structure. Also, as now recognized, a direct assault on CI is computationally intensive, prone to size-inconsistency problems, and effectively limited to smaller systems—whereas indirect approaches, e.g., via wave-function cluster expansions or renormalization-group theory, often neatly avoid these problems. Thus, what is (and perhaps always has been) needed is “many-body” schemes for VB computations (as well as for higher-order MO-based approaches, too). Here, then, certain such many-body VB-amenable computational schemes are to be discussed, in the context of semiempirical (explicitly correlated) graphical models. The collection of models are described and interrelated in a fairly comprehensive systematic manner. A selection of many-body cluster expansion methods are then discussed with special reference to resonating VB wave functions and the fundamental graph-theoretic nature of the consequent problems (such as also are noted to arise in lattice-discretized statistical-mechanical problems, too). Some examples are described incorporating resonance among exponentially great numbers of VB structures as applied: for large icosahedral-symmetry fullerenic structures, for the (polyacetylenic) linear chain, and for ladderlike conjugated polymers. It is contended that practicable many-body VB-theoretic methods are now available, retaining clear links to classical chemical valence theory. Hopefully, too, these methods may soon find use beyond the semi-empirical framework. © 1997 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quant Chem 65: 421–438, 1997
In this thesis we develop the variational two-electron reduced-density-matrix method for extended systems. Extended systems are represented in two ways: i) lattice models describing the dominant valence electronic structure with periodic boundaries to account for their extended nature and ii) a crystalline-orbital basis built from atomic orbitals using the generalization of molecular orbital theory to polymers. The first part of this thesis (Ch. 3-4) examines the performance of the variational 2-RDM method on lattice systems with tunable electron correlation. The first of these systems is the classic Hubbard model with linear and ladder lattice topologies. Because electron correlation functions, such as charge- and spin-ordering, are linear functions of the 2-RDM, the difference in electronic structure between one- and quasi-one-dimensional systems is accurately characterized. The second model contains only two-body interactions and is unique among typical spin models in that it does not have a mean-field reference wave function. The ground state wave functions from all Hamiltonians in the model have the same 1-electron reduced density matrix; consequently, one-electron theories are largely inapplicable. The superconducting eta-pairing ground states make the model a unique tool for demonstrating the necessary N-representability in highly correlated environments. The second part of this thesis (Ch. 5-6) develops a formalism for modeling materials by solving the full Schrodinger equation. Crystalline-orbital Hartree-Fock provides a set of orbitals and integral tensors for the variational 2-RDM method. We demonstrate that time-reversal symmetry, which is implicitly included in position space electronic structure calculations, must be explicitly included as an N-representability constraint on the 2-RDM when using a momentum space basis. The necessity of these equality constraints is demonstrated by the accurate recovery of the binding energy of two polymers and the symmetry of their natural orbital occupations.
Quantum computing offers a promising platform to address the computational challenges inherent in quantum chemistry, and particularly in valence bond (VB) methods, which are chemically appealing but suffer from high computational cost due to the use of nonorthogonal orbitals. While various fermionic-to-spin mappings exist for orthonormal spin orbitals, such as the widely used Jordan–Wigner transformations, an analogous framework for nonorthogonal spin orbitals remains undeveloped. In this work, we propose an alternative Jordan–Wigner-type mapping tailored for the nonorthogonal case, with the goal of enabling efficient quantum simulations of VB-type wavefunctions. Our approach paves the way towards the development of chemically interpretable and computationally feasible valence bond algorithms on near-term quantum devices.