Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. B, Solid state

Generalized Scaling Hypothesis in Multicomponent Systems. II. Scaling Hypothesis at Critical Points of Arbitrary Order

Alex Hankey, T. S. Chang, Eugene Stanley

Published Aug 1, 1973• 27 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We make the scaling hypothesis at a space of critical points of arbitrary order, using the geometric classification of critical points by order proposed in a preceding paper, part I. It follows from the definition of order that there are regions in which several scaling hypotheses are simultaneously valid, one at each space of critical points of order $\mathcal{O}\ensuremath{\ge}2$ which is connected to the point of highest order. The successive hypotheses are conveniently framed in terms of invariants of the groups of transformations about the points of higher order. This procedure facilitates the formation of multiple-power scaling functions. We suggest that the regions of validity of later hypotheses are bounded by hypersurfaces which scale and which are therefore most easily visualized in the spaces of invariants. A general critical point of order 4 is treated as a preliminary example. We then apply the hypothesis in detail to the critical point of order 4 in a specific example: the Ising model with variable interplanar interaction. This is done in two ways: the first shows specifically the relationship to the case of a metamagnet and to scaling with a parameter for change of lattice dimension; the second explicitly demonstrates that the connectivity between the various surfaces of ordinary ($\mathcal{O}=2$) critical points is the same as for the edges of a tetrahedron. As a consequence of this scaling hypothesis, we can make predictions about the shapes of the coexistence and critical surfaces meeting at the critical point of order 4.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.8.1178

Related papers

Generalized Scaling Hypothesis in Multicomponent Systems. I. Classification of Critical Points by Order and Scaling at Tricritical Points

T. S. Chang, Alex Hankey, Eugene Stanley

The goal of this work is to provide an analysis of spaces of critical points for multicomponent systems. First, we propose the geometric concept of order $\mathcal{O}$ for critical points; we distinguish it from a previous definition of a "multicritical" point. Specifically, we may define the intersection of spaces of critical points of order $\mathcal{O}$ to be a space of critical points of order ($\mathcal{O}+1$). Ordinary critical points are defined to be of order $\mathcal{O}=2$, so that the tricritical points introduced by Griffiths are of order $\mathcal{O}=3$. We discuss more general examples of critical spaces of order $\mathcal{O}=3$ which are known for a wide variety of systems; we also propose several examples of models of magnetic systems showing critical points of order $\mathcal{O}=4$---i.e., systems having intersecting lines of tricritical points. The analysis of critical and coexistence spaces also provides a new form of the Gibbs phase rule suitable for complex magnetic models. Next we define---for the critical points of order $\mathcal{O}$ of which examples have been given---special directions in terms of which to make a scaling hypothesis. We give the hypothesis for simple systems and then for tricritical points, and then, in a subsequent paper, part II, the special directions are used to make a scaling hypothesis at spaces of critical points of any order. Certain predictions (e.g., scaling laws and "single-power" scaling functions) follow in a simple and straightforward fashion. We consider the scaling hypothesis at a critical space of order $\mathcal{O}$ in terms of a group of transformations. We can define a set of invariants of the group. It is possible, for $\mathcal{O}\ensuremath{\ge}3$, to make a second scaling hypothesis for the space of order $\mathcal{O}\ensuremath{-}1$ using certain of these invariants as independent variables. This is advantageous because certain "double-power" scaling functions then follow directly; these predict that for $\mathcal{O}=3$, experimental data collapse from a volume onto a line. This prediction is to be contrasted with ordinary scaling functions, which predict that data collapse by only a single dimension (e.g., from a volume onto a surface or from a surface onto a line).

Physical review. B, Solid state•Jul 1, 1973•79 citations

Scaling Hypothesis for a System Exhibiting a Critical Point of Order Four: Ising Planes with Variable Interplanar Interactions

T. S. Chang, Alex Hankey, Fredric Harbus +1 more

A scaling theory for critical points of higher order is reviewed and applied to a point of intersection of tricritical lines in a specific example: the Ising model with variable interplanar interactions. As a consequence of the scaling hypothesis, we can make predictions about the shapes of the coexistence and critical surfaces meeting at this critical point of order 4 where four phases become identical simultaneously.

Annual Conference on Magnetism and Magnetic Materials (MMM)•Jan 1, 1974•0 citations

Scaling Hypothesis and Data Collapsing for Critical Points of Third Order

T. S. Chang, Alex Hankey, Eugene Stanley +3 more

At tricritical points thermodynamic functions scale with respect to three independent field variables. Such points have been called critical points of the third order. We present, in this paper, a general scaling hypothesis for such critical points and demonstrate how the concept of invariant spaces leads naturally to the prediction of data collapsing from volumes to lines in terms of “double‐power scaling functions”.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 1973•0 citations

Scaling Theory and Computer Simulation

Eldred H. Chimowitz

In this chapter, we investigate the concept of scaling, in particular the scaling hypothesis that has proved so important in the development of the modern theory of critical phenomena. Scaling refers to the way in which properties such as the susceptibility behave in the critical region as they approach infinity (or zero). In this discussion, it is important to be specific about the thermodynamic field variables used to represent the system as well as the direction in which the critical point is approached. A useful schematic in this regard is shown in figure 9.1, which shows phase coexistence diagrams for both an Ising-type magnet and a typical fluid. The fields for the magnet are (H, T ) while for the fluid they are (μ, T ). We note immediately from this figure that the magnet’s coexistence curve is coincident with the H = 0 axis and symmetric about the M = 0 axis. However, these features do not reflect in the corresponding diagrams for the fluid, with important implications for a scaling analysis in this system, which we take up later in this chapter. We illustrate the basic critical scaling laws using the Ising (magnet) system; however, the fact that similar scaling laws also apply to fluids is an important consequence of critical-point universality, a topic we have often alluded to in this text and which is discussed in more detail in chapter 10 dealing with the renormalization-group method.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Jun 23, 2005•0 citations

Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena: Universality and Global Multicritical Phase Diagrams From Position-Space Renormalization-Group Studies

A. Nihat Berker

The position-space renormalization-group (PSRG) approach has given impressive results in studies of phase transitions and critical phenomena. Most work has focussed on the local critical properties of rather simple models. After presenting background on phase transitions and reviewing the PSRG procedure in general, we extend this approach to more complicated systems anq global multicritical behavior by two specific studies. First, we introduce the concept of restructuring: A single restructuring transformation maps a given system onto another one with different, hopefully more manageable structure; this prefaces the multiple rescaling transformations of a PSRG treatment. Structurally different systems can thus eventually map onto the same fixed point and manifestly fall into the same universality class. The scope of application of a given PSRG calculation is enlarged. We demonstrate the restructuring concept by constructing a transformation which maps Ising models of arbitrary spin s onto a spin-1/2 Ising mOdel with further-neighbor and many-site interactions. We calculate the critical interactions (i.e., the inverse critical temperatures) of the spin-s Ising models on the triangular lattice, using this spinrestructuring transformation and the results of Niemeijer and van Leeuwen for the critical subspace of the corresponding spin-l/2 Ising model. Our evaluations agree very well with series data. Second, the unified global treatment of a phase diagram with a rich variety of transitions is illustrated: The spin-l Ising (Blume-Emery-Griffiths-Potts) model on the square lattice with nearest-neighbor ferromagnetic exchange interactions (both bilinear (J) and biquadratic (K» and crystal field interaction (A) is studied via a PSRG transformation. By building symmetries into a truncated transformation, we are able to treat a complex problem with a simple transformation. The resulting phase diagram in J, K, A space is found to have one surface of critical phase transitions and two surfaces of first-order phase transitions. These surfaces are variously bounded by an ordinary tricritical line, an isolated critical line, and a line of critical end-points. These three lines join at a special tricritical point corresponding to the transition of the 3-state Potts model. The overall phase diagram is qualitatively similar to that obtained with the meanfield approximation, except in the vicinity of the Potts transition where a four-phase coexistence line in mean-field theory shrinks into a special tricritical point in renormalization-group theory. The global connectivity and local exponents of the thirteen separate fixed points underlying this quite complicated structure are determined. Local analysis with respect to magnetic field (H) and another odd interaction (L) is performed. A one-adjusted parameter version of our transformation yields remarkably quantitative results, predicting the Potts transition temperature, for example, within 0.3% of the exact value.

•Jan 1, 1977•0 citations

Renormalization-group calculations of exponents for critical points of higher order

T. S. Chang, G. F. Tuthill, Eugene Stanley

Critical points of higher order can exist in complex magnetic and fluid systems. By definition, at a critical point of order $\mathcal{O}$, $\mathcal{O}$ phases become identical simultaneously. Here the Wilson renormalization-group method is generalized from ordinary critical points ($\mathcal{O}=2$) and Gaussian tricritical points ($\mathcal{O}=3$) to critical points of arbitrary order $\mathcal{O}$. An expansion scheme in ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\mathcal{O}}\ensuremath{\equiv}\frac{2\mathcal{O}}{(\mathcal{O}\ensuremath{-}1)\ensuremath{-}d}$ is proposed. The nontrivial fixed points and the critical exponents for $\mathcal{O}=3,4$ are calculated to order ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\mathcal{O}}$. We present the relevant scaling fields and densities for $\mathcal{O}=3$, and, in an appendix, justify the validity of the approximate recursion relation to order ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\mathcal{O}}$.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Jun 1, 1974•63 citations
We make the scaling hypothesis at a space of critical points of arbitrary order, using the geometric classification of critical points by order proposed in a preceding paper, part I. It follows from the definition of order that there are regions in which several scaling hypotheses are simultaneously valid, one at each space of critical points of order O\ensuremath≥2\mathcal{O}\ensuremath{\ge}2O\ensuremath≥2 which is connected to the point of highest order. The successive hypotheses are conveniently framed in terms of invariants of the groups of transformations about the points of higher order. This procedure facilitates the formation of multiple-power scaling functions. We suggest that the regions of validity of later hypotheses are bounded by hypersurfaces which scale and which are therefore most easily visualized in the spaces of invariants. A general critical point of order 4 is treated as a preliminary example. We then apply the hypothesis in detail to the critical point of order 4 in a specific example: the Ising model with variable interplanar interaction. This is done in two ways: the first shows specifically the relationship to the case of a metamagnet and to scaling with a parameter for change of lattice dimension; the second explicitly demonstrates that the connectivity between the various surfaces of ordinary (O=2\mathcal{O}=2O=2) critical points is the same as for the edges of a tetrahedron. As a consequence of this scaling hypothesis, we can make predictions about the shapes of the coexistence and critical surfaces meeting at the critical point of order 4.
The goal of this work is to provide an analysis of spaces of critical points for multicomponent systems. First, we propose the geometric concept of order O\mathcal{O}O for critical points; we distinguish it from a previous definition of a "multicritical" point. Specifically, we may define the intersection of spaces of critical points of order O\mathcal{O}O to be a space of critical points of order (O+1\mathcal{O}+1O+1). Ordinary critical points are defined to be of order O=2\mathcal{O}=2O=2, so that the tricritical points introduced by Griffiths are of order O=3\mathcal{O}=3O=3. We discuss more general examples of critical spaces of order O=3\mathcal{O}=3O=3 which are known for a wide variety of systems; we also propose several examples of models of magnetic systems showing critical points of order O=4\mathcal{O}=4O=4---i.e., systems having intersecting lines of tricritical points. The analysis of critical and coexistence spaces also provides a new form of the Gibbs phase rule suitable for complex magnetic models. Next we define---for the critical points of order O\mathcal{O}O of which examples have been given---special directions in terms of which to make a scaling hypothesis. We give the hypothesis for simple systems and then for tricritical points, and then, in a subsequent paper, part II, the special directions are used to make a scaling hypothesis at spaces of critical points of any order. Certain predictions (e.g., scaling laws and "single-power" scaling functions) follow in a simple and straightforward fashion. We consider the scaling hypothesis at a critical space of order O\mathcal{O}O in terms of a group of transformations. We can define a set of invariants of the group. It is possible, for $\mathcal{O}\ensuremath{\ge}3$, to make a second scaling hypothesis for the space of order $\mathcal{O}\ensuremath{-}1$ using certain of these invariants as independent variables. This is advantageous because certain "double-power" scaling functions then follow directly; these predict that for O=3\mathcal{O}=3O=3, experimental data collapse from a volume onto a line. This prediction is to be contrasted with ordinary scaling functions, which predict that data collapse by only a single dimension (e.g., from a volume onto a surface or from a surface onto a line).
In this chapter, we investigate the concept of scaling, in particular the scaling hypothesis that has proved so important in the development of the modern theory of critical phenomena. Scaling refers to the way in which properties such as the susceptibility behave in the critical region as they approach infinity (or zero). In this discussion, it is important to be specific about the thermodynamic field variables used to represent the system as well as the direction in which the critical point is approached. A useful schematic in this regard is shown in figure 9.1, which shows phase coexistence diagrams for both an Ising-type magnet and a typical fluid. The fields for the magnet are (H, T ) while for the fluid they are (μ, T ). We note immediately from this figure that the magnet’s coexistence curve is coincident with the H = 0 axis and symmetric about the M = 0 axis. However, these features do not reflect in the corresponding diagrams for the fluid, with important implications for a scaling analysis in this system, which we take up later in this chapter. We illustrate the basic critical scaling laws using the Ising (magnet) system; however, the fact that similar scaling laws also apply to fluids is an important consequence of critical-point universality, a topic we have often alluded to in this text and which is discussed in more detail in chapter 10 dealing with the renormalization-group method.
The position-space renormalization-group (PSRG) approach has given impressive results in studies of phase transitions and critical phenomena. Most work has focussed on the local critical properties of rather simple models. After presenting background on phase transitions and reviewing the PSRG procedure in general, we extend this approach to more complicated systems anq global multicritical behavior by two specific studies. First, we introduce the concept of restructuring: A single restructuring transformation maps a given system onto another one with different, hopefully more manageable structure; this prefaces the multiple rescaling transformations of a PSRG treatment. Structurally different systems can thus eventually map onto the same fixed point and manifestly fall into the same universality class. The scope of application of a given PSRG calculation is enlarged. We demonstrate the restructuring concept by constructing a transformation which maps Ising models of arbitrary spin s onto a spin-1/2 Ising mOdel with further-neighbor and many-site interactions. We calculate the critical interactions (i.e., the inverse critical temperatures) of the spin-s Ising models on the triangular lattice, using this spinrestructuring transformation and the results of Niemeijer and van Leeuwen for the critical subspace of the corresponding spin-l/2 Ising model. Our evaluations agree very well with series data. Second, the unified global treatment of a phase diagram with a rich variety of transitions is illustrated: The spin-l Ising (Blume-Emery-Griffiths-Potts) model on the square lattice with nearest-neighbor ferromagnetic exchange interactions (both bilinear (J) and biquadratic (K» and crystal field interaction (A) is studied via a PSRG transformation. By building symmetries into a truncated transformation, we are able to treat a complex problem with a simple transformation. The resulting phase diagram in J, K, A space is found to have one surface of critical phase transitions and two surfaces of first-order phase transitions. These surfaces are variously bounded by an ordinary tricritical line, an isolated critical line, and a line of critical end-points. These three lines join at a special tricritical point corresponding to the transition of the 3-state Potts model. The overall phase diagram is qualitatively similar to that obtained with the meanfield approximation, except in the vicinity of the Potts transition where a four-phase coexistence line in mean-field theory shrinks into a special tricritical point in renormalization-group theory. The global connectivity and local exponents of the thirteen separate fixed points underlying this quite complicated structure are determined. Local analysis with respect to magnetic field (H) and another odd interaction (L) is performed. A one-adjusted parameter version of our transformation yields remarkably quantitative results, predicting the Potts transition temperature, for example, within 0.3% of the exact value.
Critical points of higher order can exist in complex magnetic and fluid systems. By definition, at a critical point of order O\mathcal{O}O, O\mathcal{O}O phases become identical simultaneously. Here the Wilson renormalization-group method is generalized from ordinary critical points (O=2\mathcal{O}=2O=2) and Gaussian tricritical points (O=3\mathcal{O}=3O=3) to critical points of arbitrary order O\mathcal{O}O. An expansion scheme in ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\mathcal{O}}\ensuremath{\equiv}\frac{2\mathcal{O}}{(\mathcal{O}\ensuremath{-}1)\ensuremath{-}d}$ is proposed. The nontrivial fixed points and the critical exponents for O=3,4\mathcal{O}=3,4O=3,4 are calculated to order ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\mathcal{O}}$. We present the relevant scaling fields and densities for O=3\mathcal{O}=3O=3, and, in an appendix, justify the validity of the approximate recursion relation to order ${\ensuremath{\epsilon}}_{\mathcal{O}}$.