Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Science

Strange Metal Transport Realized by Gauge/Gravity Duality

Thomas Faulkner, Nabil Iqbal, Hong Liu, John McGreevy, David Vegh

Published Aug 6, 2010• 150 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Black Holes as Tools When confronted with a difficult problem, physicists often resort to mapping it to a more tractable one. A good example of this strategy is provided by new developments linking string theory and condensed-matter physics to make theoretical connections between gravity and complex systems of interacting electrons. This theoretical convergence provides a description of Fermi liquids, which can be thought of as interacting systems of electrons whose excitations can be expressed in terms of non-interacting quasiparticles. Several interesting systems elude quasiparticle description, but Faulkner et al. (p. 1043 , published online 5 August) have now developed a mathematical framework that describes the non-Fermi liquid represented by the strange metal phase of cuprate high-temperature superconductors. They calculate the electronic response and, for a particular value of a tunable parameter, recover the linear resistivity. Further development of this framework may allow elucidation of other exotic properties of the cuprates and similar complex systems.

DOI
10.1126/science.1189134

Related papers

Strange connections to strange metals

Hong Liu

Liu replies: While many ingenious ideas have been advanced to explain the strange-metal phase, the community has not reached a consensus, and many of the phase’s properties remain mysterious. Philip W. Anderson’s hidden Fermi liquid theory, arguably a most ambitious attempt, has provided a useful lens to view various aspects of the phase, but further developments are worthwhile.As described in my Quick Study, a key obstacle in the pursuit to explain the strange metal phase is the lack of a suitable mathematical framework to characterize “quantum soups”—strongly interacting, dense quantum matter whose constituents have lost their individuality. Holographic duality has now provided such a framework, although only for the class of systems that have gravity duals. It does for those quantum soups what Boltzmann equations do for a dilute gas of quasiparticles: It enables one to calculate reliably all equilibrium and nonequilibrium properties.At short distances, holographic systems are conformal, Lorentz invariant, and often supersymmetric, all of which make them seem poor models for real-life condensed-matter systems. Those symmetries, however, are all destroyed at long distances if a temperature or a chemical potential is turned on. The surprise of the past few years is that despite significant differences in short-distance details, at long distances most states of matter that have been understood—superfluids, Fermi liquids, magnets, stripes, and so on—can be described in terms of dual gravity systems. Such insensitivity to microscopic detail gives hope that the striking parallels in macroscopic behavior found between black holes and strange metals are not accidents, and gravity may help us decipher the mysteries of strange metals.I thank Anderson for emphasizing other anomalies exhibited by the strange-metal phase of cuprates that I did not have space to mention. He is correct that the holographic approach has not yet produced a model that could account for all anomalous properties. However, the power-law dependence of photoemission spectra on energy, his last bullet point, is a hallmark of holographic strange metals. I discussed that point in the last part of the Quick Study, in terms of the power-law temperature dependence of scattering rates. Such power laws follow from the semilocal property emphasized in the second-to-last paragraph.Whether or not one finds a “conventional” explanation for strange metals, connections between the physics of strange metals and black holes are worth exploring. They hint at a new paradigm for thinking about strongly correlated quantum soups. As an added bonus, we may also obtain new insights into quantum gravity from advances in condensed-matter physics.© 2013 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Mar 29, 2013•1 citation

String Theory and Condensed Matter

The complex interactions involving highly correlated electron systems can give rise to “exotic behavior” in electronic systems, such as quantum criticality and superconductivity. The usual theoretical tools, however, are limited when describing these states. String theory is a highly mathematical approach initially developed to describe gravity and high-energy particle physics. Certain aspects of string theory may be relevant to describe condensed matter systems. Cubrovic et al. (p. [439][1]; published online 25 June) take one such approach, and show that the characteristic properties of a Fermi liquid can emerge from string theory. The formulation may provide an approach to describing the exotic states of matter that arise in condensed matter systems. [1]: /lookup/volpage/325/439

Science•Jul 23, 2009•1 citation

From black holes to strange metals

Thomas Faulkner, Nabil Iqbal, Hong Liu +2 more

Since the mid-eighties there has been an accumulation of metallic materials whose thermodynamic and transport properties differ significantly from those predicted by Fermi liquid theory. Examples of these so-called non-Fermi liquids include the strange metal phase of high transition temperature cuprates, and heavy fermion systems near a quantum phase transition. We report on a class of non-Fermi liquids discovered using gauge/gravity duality. The low energy behavior of these non-Fermi liquids is shown to be governed by a nontrivial infrared (IR) fixed point which exhibits nonanalytic scaling behavior only in the temporal direction. Within this class we find examples whose single-particle spectral function and transport behavior resemble those of strange metals. In particular, the contribution from the Fermi surface to the conductivity is inversely proportional to the temperature. In our treatment these properties can be understood as being controlled by the scaling dimension of the fermion operator in the emergent IR fixed point.

arXiv:1003.1728•Mar 8, 2010•128 citations

Higher-dimensional Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev non-Fermi liquids at Lifshitz transitions

Arijit Haldar, Sumilan Banerjee, Vijay B. Shenoy

Some of the most interesting phenomena in condensed matter occur in high-temperature superconductors and heavy fermions, and arise from a parent non-Fermi-liquid background. Although the non-Fermi-liquid phase has metallic character, it is very different from typical metals in that the electronic excitations are not particlelike (no quasiparticles), and this has lead to these phases eluding a clear theoretical description. Here, the authors develop a model that provides a route to describe non-Fermi liquids realized in condensed matter systems. Building on the zero-dimensional Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model that is inspired by connections between a non-Fermi liquid and black holes, the authors construct a model in a lattice system where the bands touch to give a divergent density of states (Lifshitz point). The resulting non-Fermi-liquid phases exhibit intriguing properties such as scaling symmetry, nontrivial power-law dependence of entropy on temperature, and fast information scrambling with rate linear in temperature, as well as dynamical transitions to more conventional phases with well-defined quasiparticles.

arXiv:1710.00842•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Jun 14, 2018•52 citations

Applications of the gauge/gravity duality to the cuprate strange metal

Enea Mauri

We studied the mysterious behavior of a class of materials known as cuprates, of particular practical interests due to their high transition temperature to a superconducting phase, where electricity is carried without resistance. Due to the strong interactions among the electrons, these systems cannot be described in terms of any conventional theory of metals and new approaches are needed. One such approach is the holographic duality, that allows us to model strongly interacting quantum system through an higher-dimensional, but easier to treat, theory of gravity. In this thesis we used the duality to study certain features of the non-superconducting phase of cuprates, known as the strange metal. We presented how to introduce the long-range Coulomb interaction, that allowed us to model plasmon excitations experimentally observed in multilayer cuprates, and to study a phenomenon of a two-layer system known as Coulomb drag. Furthermore, we showed that a prediction from the duality of a peculiar momentum-dependet scaling of the Fermionic self-energy is able to very accurately model a recently-observed feature of the spectral function measured in high-quality photoemission-spectroscopy measurements on a cuprate.

•Nov 30, 2022•0 citations

A strange metal in a bosonic system

Chao Yang, Haiwen Liu, Yi Liu +10 more

Fermi liquid theory forms the basis for our understanding of the majority of metals, which is manifested in the description of transport properties that the electrical resistivity goes as temperature squared in the limit of zero temperature. However, the observations of strange metal states in various quantum materials, notably high-temperature superconductors, bring this spectacularly successful theoretical framework into crisis. When electron scattering rate 1/τ hits its limit, kBT/{\hbar} where {\hbar} is the reduced Planck's constant, T represents absolute temperature and kB denotes Boltzmann's constant, Planckian dissipation occurs and lends strange metals a surprising link to black holes, gravity, and quantum information theory. Here, we show the characteristic signature of strange metallicity arising unprecedentedly in a bosonic system. Our nanopatterned YBa2Cu3O7-δ(YBCO) film arrays reveal T-linear resistance as well as B-linear magnetoresistance over an extended temperature and magnetic field range in a quantum critical region in the phase diagram. Moreover, the slope of the T-linear resistance α_cp appears bounded by α_cp {\approx} h/2e^2 [1/T]_c^onset where T_c^onset is the temperature at which Cooper pairs form, intimating a common scale-invariant transport mechanism corresponding to Planckian dissipation.In contrast to fermionic systems where the temperature and magnetic field dependent scattering rates combine in quadrature of {\hbar}/τ {\approx} {\sqrt} (((k_B T)^2+(μ_B B)^2)), both terms linearly combine in the present bosonic system, i.e. {\hbar}/τ {\approx} (k_B T+[γμ]_B B), where γ is a constant. By extending the reach of strange metal phenomenology to a bosonic system, our results suggest that there is a fundamental principle governing their transport which transcends particle statistics.

arXiv:2105.02654•May 6, 2021•2 citations
Black Holes as Tools When confronted with a difficult problem, physicists often resort to mapping it to a more tractable one. A good example of this strategy is provided by new developments linking string theory and condensed-matter physics to make theoretical connections between gravity and complex systems of interacting electrons. This theoretical convergence provides a description of Fermi liquids, which can be thought of as interacting systems of electrons whose excitations can be expressed in terms of non-interacting quasiparticles. Several interesting systems elude quasiparticle description, but Faulkner et al. (p. 1043 , published online 5 August) have now developed a mathematical framework that describes the non-Fermi liquid represented by the strange metal phase of cuprate high-temperature superconductors. They calculate the electronic response and, for a particular value of a tunable parameter, recover the linear resistivity. Further development of this framework may allow elucidation of other exotic properties of the cuprates and similar complex systems.
Liu replies: While many ingenious ideas have been advanced to explain the strange-metal phase, the community has not reached a consensus, and many of the phase’s properties remain mysterious. Philip W. Anderson’s hidden Fermi liquid theory, arguably a most ambitious attempt, has provided a useful lens to view various aspects of the phase, but further developments are worthwhile.As described in my Quick Study, a key obstacle in the pursuit to explain the strange metal phase is the lack of a suitable mathematical framework to characterize “quantum soups”—strongly interacting, dense quantum matter whose constituents have lost their individuality. Holographic duality has now provided such a framework, although only for the class of systems that have gravity duals. It does for those quantum soups what Boltzmann equations do for a dilute gas of quasiparticles: It enables one to calculate reliably all equilibrium and nonequilibrium properties.At short distances, holographic systems are conformal, Lorentz invariant, and often supersymmetric, all of which make them seem poor models for real-life condensed-matter systems. Those symmetries, however, are all destroyed at long distances if a temperature or a chemical potential is turned on. The surprise of the past few years is that despite significant differences in short-distance details, at long distances most states of matter that have been understood—superfluids, Fermi liquids, magnets, stripes, and so on—can be described in terms of dual gravity systems. Such insensitivity to microscopic detail gives hope that the striking parallels in macroscopic behavior found between black holes and strange metals are not accidents, and gravity may help us decipher the mysteries of strange metals.I thank Anderson for emphasizing other anomalies exhibited by the strange-metal phase of cuprates that I did not have space to mention. He is correct that the holographic approach has not yet produced a model that could account for all anomalous properties. However, the power-law dependence of photoemission spectra on energy, his last bullet point, is a hallmark of holographic strange metals. I discussed that point in the last part of the Quick Study, in terms of the power-law temperature dependence of scattering rates. Such power laws follow from the semilocal property emphasized in the second-to-last paragraph.Whether or not one finds a “conventional” explanation for strange metals, connections between the physics of strange metals and black holes are worth exploring. They hint at a new paradigm for thinking about strongly correlated quantum soups. As an added bonus, we may also obtain new insights into quantum gravity from advances in condensed-matter physics.© 2013 American Institute of Physics.
The complex interactions involving highly correlated electron systems can give rise to “exotic behavior” in electronic systems, such as quantum criticality and superconductivity. The usual theoretical tools, however, are limited when describing these states. String theory is a highly mathematical approach initially developed to describe gravity and high-energy particle physics. Certain aspects of string theory may be relevant to describe condensed matter systems. Cubrovic et al. (p. [439][1]; published online 25 June) take one such approach, and show that the characteristic properties of a Fermi liquid can emerge from string theory. The formulation may provide an approach to describing the exotic states of matter that arise in condensed matter systems. [1]: /lookup/volpage/325/439
Since the mid-eighties there has been an accumulation of metallic materials whose thermodynamic and transport properties differ significantly from those predicted by Fermi liquid theory. Examples of these so-called non-Fermi liquids include the strange metal phase of high transition temperature cuprates, and heavy fermion systems near a quantum phase transition. We report on a class of non-Fermi liquids discovered using gauge/gravity duality. The low energy behavior of these non-Fermi liquids is shown to be governed by a nontrivial infrared (IR) fixed point which exhibits nonanalytic scaling behavior only in the temporal direction. Within this class we find examples whose single-particle spectral function and transport behavior resemble those of strange metals. In particular, the contribution from the Fermi surface to the conductivity is inversely proportional to the temperature. In our treatment these properties can be understood as being controlled by the scaling dimension of the fermion operator in the emergent IR fixed point.
Some of the most interesting phenomena in condensed matter occur in high-temperature superconductors and heavy fermions, and arise from a parent non-Fermi-liquid background. Although the non-Fermi-liquid phase has metallic character, it is very different from typical metals in that the electronic excitations are not particlelike (no quasiparticles), and this has lead to these phases eluding a clear theoretical description. Here, the authors develop a model that provides a route to describe non-Fermi liquids realized in condensed matter systems. Building on the zero-dimensional Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model that is inspired by connections between a non-Fermi liquid and black holes, the authors construct a model in a lattice system where the bands touch to give a divergent density of states (Lifshitz point). The resulting non-Fermi-liquid phases exhibit intriguing properties such as scaling symmetry, nontrivial power-law dependence of entropy on temperature, and fast information scrambling with rate linear in temperature, as well as dynamical transitions to more conventional phases with well-defined quasiparticles.
We studied the mysterious behavior of a class of materials known as cuprates, of particular practical interests due to their high transition temperature to a superconducting phase, where electricity is carried without resistance. Due to the strong interactions among the electrons, these systems cannot be described in terms of any conventional theory of metals and new approaches are needed. One such approach is the holographic duality, that allows us to model strongly interacting quantum system through an higher-dimensional, but easier to treat, theory of gravity. In this thesis we used the duality to study certain features of the non-superconducting phase of cuprates, known as the strange metal. We presented how to introduce the long-range Coulomb interaction, that allowed us to model plasmon excitations experimentally observed in multilayer cuprates, and to study a phenomenon of a two-layer system known as Coulomb drag. Furthermore, we showed that a prediction from the duality of a peculiar momentum-dependet scaling of the Fermionic self-energy is able to very accurately model a recently-observed feature of the spectral function measured in high-quality photoemission-spectroscopy measurements on a cuprate.
Fermi liquid theory forms the basis for our understanding of the majority of metals, which is manifested in the description of transport properties that the electrical resistivity goes as temperature squared in the limit of zero temperature. However, the observations of strange metal states in various quantum materials, notably high-temperature superconductors, bring this spectacularly successful theoretical framework into crisis. When electron scattering rate 1/τ hits its limit, kBT/{\hbar} where {\hbar} is the reduced Planck's constant, T represents absolute temperature and kB denotes Boltzmann's constant, Planckian dissipation occurs and lends strange metals a surprising link to black holes, gravity, and quantum information theory. Here, we show the characteristic signature of strange metallicity arising unprecedentedly in a bosonic system. Our nanopatterned YBa2Cu3O7-δ(YBCO) film arrays reveal T-linear resistance as well as B-linear magnetoresistance over an extended temperature and magnetic field range in a quantum critical region in the phase diagram. Moreover, the slope of the T-linear resistance α_cp appears bounded by α_cp {\approx} h/2e^2 [1/T]_c^onset where T_c^onset is the temperature at which Cooper pairs form, intimating a common scale-invariant transport mechanism corresponding to Planckian dissipation.In contrast to fermionic systems where the temperature and magnetic field dependent scattering rates combine in quadrature of {\hbar}/τ {\approx} {\sqrt} (((k_B T)^2+(μ_B B)^2)), both terms linearly combine in the present bosonic system, i.e. {\hbar}/τ {\approx} (k_B T+[γμ]_B B), where γ is a constant. By extending the reach of strange metal phenomenology to a bosonic system, our results suggest that there is a fundamental principle governing their transport which transcends particle statistics.