Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Chemical Education

Compounding Selection Rules in Quantum Mechanics

Kenneth R. Brownstein, K. S. Capelle

Published Jul 1, 1999• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The selection rule for matrix elements, <n j |αβ| n k >, of a product of operators, αβ, can be obtained by compounding the selection rules for the matrix elements <n j |α| n k > and <n s |β| n k > of the individual operators through intermediate states | n s . We point out that a naive application of this technique may lead to misleading results due to nonexistent intermediate "ghost" states.

DOI
10.1021/ed076p992

Related papers

Iterative method for evaluating the matrix representation of the generators in the unitary-group approach

A. Lev, M. Schlesinger, R. D. Kent

An iterative method is presented for the evaluation of the matrix representation of the group generators in the unitary-group approach to many-electron systems. The method yields, in addition, closed-form expressions and selection rules for nonvanishing matrix elements. Generator products (two-body operators) are treated by a scalar-product method.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1984•3 citations

Some matrix calculations

John P. Killingbeck

The original version of matrix mechanics is little used in applications nowadays. In that early theory position, momentum and other quantities were represented by infinite matrices, whereas many modern applications of quantum mechanics represent such observables as operators. Infinite matrices are unwieldy to use and have some disturbing properties, e.g. they do not obey the associative rule. By far the most commonly appearing matrix in quantum mechanics is the matrix of the energy operator as set up in some finite basis of trial functions. The procedure has been used for perturbed oscillator problems; the recurrence relation approach is particularly simple when the matrix has only one non-zero element beyond the diagonal element in each row. It seems to the author that there are still many hybrid methods which need investigation.

CRC Press eBooks•Jan 18, 2018•0 citations

From single-particle states ton-particle states

Yoel Tikochinsky

With the use of Feynman's laws for combining quantum-mechanical amplitudes, expressions for the n-particle states in terms of the single-particle states (for noninteracting particles) are derived rather than postulated. The usual direct-product form for distinguishable particles and the symmetric (antisymmetric) combination of direct products for identical particles emerge as the only forms consistent with the quantum-mechanical laws for compounding amplitudes.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1988•6 citations

What Squaring Erases

Parker Emmerson (Yaohushuason)

The phenomenological-velocity radical αlsin β= L+κ L−/κ, with κ= 1−v2/c2, is usually analysed by squaring, which yields a v-free compatibility constraint and the conclusion that the equation says nothing about v. That conclusion holds only for the squared equation. Working on the principal branch, we show that the product of principal roots equals ε L+L− with a branch factor ε∈{±1}that depends on the signs of L± and on whether |v|<cor |v|>c, and that squaring erases it. On the solution locus, ε reduces to sgn(lα) for |v|<c and to +1 for |v|>c, giving a selection rule: solutions with |v|<c require sin β >0, solutions with |v|>c require sgn(lα) = sgn sin β, and for β ∈[0,π] the |v|>cregime is admitted if and only if lα>0. The light cone |v|= c is simultaneously the branch discontinuity, the locus where L−/κ is undefined, and the value returned by symbolic solvers. On the locus, εis a nonseparable function of sgn(lα) and the velocity regime: the Z/2 parity obstruction of a maximally CHSH-violating sign table, produced here by a branch cut with no probability. Its definedness locus coincides pointwise with a setting-dependent acceptance map under which Bell-local responses carry −cos(a−b) exactly on accepted data with unbiased marginals; what the model relinquishes is the settings-independence of the trial set, not locality, and we state the protocol under which the mechanism predicts no violation and is thereby refutable. Transporting the asymmetric decoration into an operator setting yields E=−cos(a−b+ 2ϑ(v)) with S = 2√2 |cos 2ϑ|. Keywords: principal branch; square-root identity; Riemann surface; Lorentz factor; light cone; phenomenological velocity; selection rule; Bell–CHSH; computer algebra.

•Sep 18, 2026•0 citations

Extra selection rules

Nigel B. Backhouse

The recognition of antiunitary symmetry in a quantum mechanical system is considered in relation to selection rules. It is shown that the interaction of unitary symmetry and the anti-invariance of matrix elements under antiunitary operators can produce extra selection rules in magnetic systems. The criteria obtained for the occurrence of these additional selection rules are presented in the form of group character tests, and in a special case provide an application for the symmetrized and antisymmetrized squares of group representations.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Jan 1, 1974•4 citations

Superposition of states and the structure of quantum logics

Platon C. Deliyannis

A derivation of the classical Hilbert space model of quantum theory is given (including superselection rules) based (i) on various axioms on the behavior of events and (ii) an explicit formula for the superposition of two pure states in terms of transition probabilities.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 1976•7 citations
The selection rule for matrix elements, <n j |αβ| n k >, of a product of operators, αβ, can be obtained by compounding the selection rules for the matrix elements <n j |α| n k > and <n s |β| n k > of the individual operators through intermediate states | n s . We point out that a naive application of this technique may lead to misleading results due to nonexistent intermediate "ghost" states.
The original version of matrix mechanics is little used in applications nowadays. In that early theory position, momentum and other quantities were represented by infinite matrices, whereas many modern applications of quantum mechanics represent such observables as operators. Infinite matrices are unwieldy to use and have some disturbing properties, e.g. they do not obey the associative rule. By far the most commonly appearing matrix in quantum mechanics is the matrix of the energy operator as set up in some finite basis of trial functions. The procedure has been used for perturbed oscillator problems; the recurrence relation approach is particularly simple when the matrix has only one non-zero element beyond the diagonal element in each row. It seems to the author that there are still many hybrid methods which need investigation.
The phenomenological-velocity radical αlsin β= L+κ L−/κ, with κ= 1−v2/c2, is usually analysed by squaring, which yields a v-free compatibility constraint and the conclusion that the equation says nothing about v. That conclusion holds only for the squared equation. Working on the principal branch, we show that the product of principal roots equals ε L+L− with a branch factor ε∈{±1}that depends on the signs of L± and on whether |v|<cor |v|>c, and that squaring erases it. On the solution locus, ε reduces to sgn(lα) for |v|<c and to +1 for |v|>c, giving a selection rule: solutions with |v|<c require sin β >0, solutions with |v|>c require sgn(lα) = sgn sin β, and for β ∈[0,π] the |v|>cregime is admitted if and only if lα>0. The light cone |v|= c is simultaneously the branch discontinuity, the locus where L−/κ is undefined, and the value returned by symbolic solvers. On the locus, εis a nonseparable function of sgn(lα) and the velocity regime: the Z/2 parity obstruction of a maximally CHSH-violating sign table, produced here by a branch cut with no probability. Its definedness locus coincides pointwise with a setting-dependent acceptance map under which Bell-local responses carry −cos(a−b) exactly on accepted data with unbiased marginals; what the model relinquishes is the settings-independence of the trial set, not locality, and we state the protocol under which the mechanism predicts no violation and is thereby refutable. Transporting the asymmetric decoration into an operator setting yields E=−cos(a−b+ 2ϑ(v)) with S = 2√2 |cos 2ϑ|. Keywords: principal branch; square-root identity; Riemann surface; Lorentz factor; light cone; phenomenological velocity; selection rule; Bell–CHSH; computer algebra.
The recognition of antiunitary symmetry in a quantum mechanical system is considered in relation to selection rules. It is shown that the interaction of unitary symmetry and the anti-invariance of matrix elements under antiunitary operators can produce extra selection rules in magnetic systems. The criteria obtained for the occurrence of these additional selection rules are presented in the form of group character tests, and in a special case provide an application for the symmetrized and antisymmetrized squares of group representations.