We analytically calculate the ground state pairing symmetry and excitation spectra of two holes doped into the half-filled $t\ensuremath{-}{t}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{-}{t}^{\ensuremath{''}}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{z}$ model in the strong-coupling limit $({J}_{z}⪢\ensuremath{\mid}t\ensuremath{\mid},\ensuremath{\mid}{t}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{\mid},\ensuremath{\mid}{t}^{\ensuremath{''}}\ensuremath{\mid})$. In leading order, this reduces to the ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{-}{t}^{\ensuremath{''}}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{z}$ model, where there are regions of d-wave, s-wave, and (degenerate) p-wave symmetry. We find that the $t\ensuremath{-}{J}_{z}$ model maps in lowest order onto the ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{-}{t}^{\ensuremath{''}}\ensuremath{-}{J}_{z}$ model on the boundary between d and p symmetry, with a flat lower band in the pair excitation spectrum. In higher order, d-wave symmetry is selected from the lower pair band. However, we observe that the addition of the appropriate ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}<0$ and/or ${t}^{\ensuremath{''}}>0$, the signs of ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ and ${t}^{\ensuremath{''}}$ found in the hole-doped cuprates, could drive the hole-pair symmetry to p-wave symmetry, implying the possibility of competition between p-wave and d-wave pair ground states. (An added ${t}^{\ensuremath{'}}>0$ and/or ${t}^{\ensuremath{''}}<0$ generally tend to promote d-wave symmetry.) We perturbatively construct an extended quasipair for the $t\ensuremath{-}{J}_{z}$ model. In leading order, there are contributions from sites at a distance of 2 lattice spacings apart; however, contributions from sites two lattice spacings apart, also of the same order, vanish identically. Finally, we compare our approach with analytic calculations for a $2\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}2$ plaquette and with existing numerical work, and discuss possible relevance to the physical parameter regime.
Using finite-temperature determinantal quantum Monte Carlo calculations, we find that the dominant pairing symmetries in the standard Hubbard model on the honeycomb lattice depend on the electron filling. When the electron density $\ensuremath{\rho}$ is larger than around 0.25, the dominant pairing symmetry is the d+id-wave; when the electron density is low enough ($\ensuremath{\rho}\ensuremath{\lesssim}0.25$), the dominant pairing symmetry is the p+ip wave. For two electron densities $\ensuremath{\rho}=0.1$ and $\ensuremath{\rho}=0.4$, where the dominant pairing symmetries are p+ip wave and d+id wave separately, we study the effect of two types of hopping inhomogeneities (the plaquette and the quasi-1D hopping inhomogeneities) on the pairing symmetries. For $\ensuremath{\rho}=0.1$, the plaquette hopping inhomogeneity drives the dominant p+ip-wave pairing symmetry into the d+id-wave; while the quasi-1D hopping inhomogeneity almost does not affect the p+ip wave, and arises the f wave, causing the coexistence of p+ip-wave and f-wave pairing. For $\ensuremath{\rho}=0.4$, both the plaquette and the quasi-1D hopping inhomogeneities destroy the d+id-wave pairing symmetry, without causing other pairing symmetry. Our results suggest that the effect of hopping inhomogeneity on the pairing symmetries is robust and depends on the electron filling. This finding may be useful for the design of artificial graphene superconductors with different kinds of pairing, especially for the realization of the d+id-wave, p+ip-wave, or f-wave superconductors at low filling.
Charge Conjugation and Pairing in a model Cu5O4 Cluster
Highly-symmetric three-band Hubbard Cu-O clusters have peculiar properties when the hole number is such that they admit W=0 hole pairs. These are two-hole eigenstates of the on-site Hubbard repulsion with eigenvalue 0, get bound by correlation effects when dressed by the interaction with the background, and cause superconducting flux quantization. We study the Cu5O4 cluster by exact diagonalization and show that bound electron pairs of 1% B2 symmetry are obtained at an appropriate filling, and quantize flux like the hole pairs. The basic mechanism for pairing in this model is the second-order exchange diagram, and an approximate charge conjugation symmetry holds between electron and hole pairs. Further, the flux quantization property requires that the W=0 pairs of d symmetry have s symmetry couterparts, still with W=0; the former are due to a spin fluctuation, while the latter arise from a charge fluctuation mechanism. The simultaneous existence of both is an essential property of our model and is required for any model of superconducting d pairs.